Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

A question for anyone who is not a teacher

122 replies

EBWhite · Yesterday 09:56

I’m a teacher and have resigned after years at the chalk face. Many of my colleagues are desperate to get out and a lot of the new recruits don’t last beyond the first couple of years. It’s also harder than ever to secure your first post. Everywhere I look, teachers are unhappy but maybe that’s because I’m unhappy. I’ve joined the Facebook groups about leaving the profession and look at the data from teacher tapp that shows deep dissatisfaction.

So my question is this- if you have a teacher in your family or as a close friend, are they ok in their job? Are they happy? I think my opinion is skewed because the only opinions I see are from people who feel the way I do. Are there a quiet majority getting on happily and enjoying the role as I used to. What do the teachers in your lives have to say about school?

OP posts:
Echobelly · Yesterday 10:04

I know a teacher and a former one. The current teacher seems happy in her job, has been at the same school for many years. Maybe finding the right place makes a big difference. The other taught in private schools sort of as a job of last resort when he couldn't settle on anything and did it for 10+ years, but it never felt like his heart was in it. He now does 1:1 care work with adults with additional needs I think

TheeNotoriousPIG · Yesterday 10:59

I am no longer a teacher. Nor is my sibling. We both left within the first two years. I don't know what my sibling would say, but I have always maintained that the students are lovely (bar, perhaps, the odd one, let's be honest!), but it is the adults around them who make life difficult, and that there is too much pressure that sucks the joy out of teaching.

HeartBreakClub · Yesterday 11:01

my sister is a teacher and she enjoys her job

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

EBWhite · Yesterday 11:22

TheeNotoriousPIG · Yesterday 10:59

I am no longer a teacher. Nor is my sibling. We both left within the first two years. I don't know what my sibling would say, but I have always maintained that the students are lovely (bar, perhaps, the odd one, let's be honest!), but it is the adults around them who make life difficult, and that there is too much pressure that sucks the joy out of teaching.

Can I ask what you both do now?

OP posts:
SaraHoliday · Yesterday 11:29

I know 2 ex-Teachers.

One had re-trained as a Teacher as a second career (after being a Nurse!). She said Nursing wasn't what she thought it would be so thought she would try Teaching as it fitted in with her children to work term-time only. Absolutely hated it. She is now a stay at home Mum.

The other one progressed to be a 'Head of Department' but said the extra salary did not equate to the additional responsibility and workload. She now works from home teaching other teachers virtually.

TheeNotoriousPIG · Yesterday 11:31

EBWhite · Yesterday 11:22

Can I ask what you both do now?

My sibling went back into the sports industry, and is now a nutritionist (I think). I work in farming. I have found quite a surprising number of ex-teachers are in the smallholding/farming world. It seems to be agreed that the less people, the better!

WhatNoRaisins · Yesterday 11:34

I have teacher friends. They do find parts of the role genuinely rewarding and overall love working with the children. It's also obvious even just to an observer that they are under a large amount of pressure. I've also noticed even just from doing school runs how demanding parents can be to the school staff.

waxcrayon · Yesterday 11:35

DD teaches in an FE college, usually young people with significant learning needs, small groups and she has a lot of freedom to teach how she wants but covering the GCSE syllabus. She loves her job and has no interest in teaching in mainstream schools.

Saturdaysfairies · Yesterday 11:36

Teachers around me has the same joy over their job as the people I know in NHS, retail, the social worker, police officer - you name it...

Snorlaxo · Yesterday 11:36

My sister is a teacher and left to work overseas where she’s much happier.

FlowersInPots · Yesterday 11:39

DH is a teacher in a primary school. Enjoys the actual teaching and time in a classroom, hates the politics in the background. He’s also 50/50 on dealing with parents as they seem to be either great or awful and nothing in between.

Anneleesa · Yesterday 11:40

Actually I only know happy teachers. One is a job-share Reception teacher, one is a maths secondary school teacher, one is a science secondary teacher, one is a primary SEN coordinator (part time).

But my dd who is now 16 and absolutely incredible with young kids wanted to be a teacher and ultimately a primary HT.

But all her teachers - including the happy ones - have told her “don’t do it, do anything else.”

It has been so overwhelmingly negative from the teachers - some of whom were aghast when she mentions her career ambitions - that she has changed her mind and is now focusing on a “soft option” - medicine!

Anneleesa · Yesterday 11:41

Oh I also know a TA in a rural community, she’s doing ok. Not exactly happy but head above water

Askandyforcompo · Yesterday 11:42

My friend was a teacher. She moaned constantly about it for 15 years! She left last year and has never been happier

angelcake20 · Yesterday 11:45

I left teaching a couple of years ago. My colleagues were not terribly happy but only one (of about 10 in the department) was actively trying to leave. I know of a couple of happy primary teachers who are in a well supported school. In spite of my experience and advice, my DD is currently doing a PGCE and, although her placement school is terrible, is enjoying it.

PissedOffNeighbour22 · Yesterday 11:48

My brother is a teacher. He complains and seems to think he works long hours but he works nowhere near the hours that me and my DH do for less money.

He’s in a secondary school so obviously has more behavioural issues to deal with than a primary and it’s inner city so a bit rough and very diverse. I can see why he would get a bit stressed out with it. On the whole he seems to enjoy the job though.

He made head of department 2yrs after qualifying so that boosted his enjoyment of the job.

edited to add I know 2 other teachers who quit early in their careers. Just didn’t suit the job and chose other careers instead with no regrets.

villadicance · Yesterday 11:48

I know a 5 teachers, one ECT who is a bit stressed, the others classroom teachers, one assistant head who are all pretty happy.

No question there are some unhappy teachers but I do think there is a bit of an echo chamber as well

EatenTooMuchChocolateAgain · Yesterday 11:50

I know a secondary teacher who is very unhappy and has been for several years. Says she spends most time dealing with behaviour issues and children with SEND whose needs are too severe for mainstream. She’s very close to leaving.

villadicance · Yesterday 11:50

Anneleesa · Yesterday 11:40

Actually I only know happy teachers. One is a job-share Reception teacher, one is a maths secondary school teacher, one is a science secondary teacher, one is a primary SEN coordinator (part time).

But my dd who is now 16 and absolutely incredible with young kids wanted to be a teacher and ultimately a primary HT.

But all her teachers - including the happy ones - have told her “don’t do it, do anything else.”

It has been so overwhelmingly negative from the teachers - some of whom were aghast when she mentions her career ambitions - that she has changed her mind and is now focusing on a “soft option” - medicine!

Has she talked to any doctors? The ones I know are far more miserable than the teachers, they just talk about it less

Merrow · Yesterday 11:51

I know 4 teachers, although one is thinking of leaving the profession:

  • 1 is gunning for headmaster's job, really driven and ambitious, loves teaching and intentionally has only worked in private schools.
  • 1 was head of year (I think? Head of something), quit because they hated it, then realised it wasn't actually teaching they disliked but all the extra stuff and is now moderately happy as a classroom teacher
  • 1 is a primary school teacher and is very happy in their current role with a supportive head teacher, but hasn't been as happy in previous jobs
  • 1 is currently on maternity leave and I doesn't intend to return to teaching and will instead return to HR (their previous job before teaching) because the work-life balance is better for the salary
TraitorOrFaithful · Yesterday 11:52

I know one teacher who is due to retire at the end of this academic year and is counting the days. The other teachers I know seem to be happy. They moan about their jobs a bit but no more than anyone else.

annonymousse · Yesterday 11:53

My daughter and her husband are both teachers. One in public school and one in state school. Both very burnt out but feel trapped as they can't afford to retrain for anything else. They worked abroad for a few years and would love to take off again but they have school aged children now and so it's not so easy.

TraitorOrFaithful · Yesterday 11:53

@EBWhite can you explain why it's harder now to find your first post but also that lots of teachers are leaving? I find that hard to understand?

MaeshoweDragon · Yesterday 11:56

DD24 is a Biology teacher - Y9 up - at a private day/boarding school. She absolutely loves it. She is in her second year of teaching, so not yet jaded and worn down,

just full of enthusiasm - especially for A level teaching since (as she says) the kids have actively chosen to study it, and most need a good grade for medicine etc, so are invested in doing well.

JuliaAgrippina · Yesterday 11:57

Anneleesa · Yesterday 11:40

Actually I only know happy teachers. One is a job-share Reception teacher, one is a maths secondary school teacher, one is a science secondary teacher, one is a primary SEN coordinator (part time).

But my dd who is now 16 and absolutely incredible with young kids wanted to be a teacher and ultimately a primary HT.

But all her teachers - including the happy ones - have told her “don’t do it, do anything else.”

It has been so overwhelmingly negative from the teachers - some of whom were aghast when she mentions her career ambitions - that she has changed her mind and is now focusing on a “soft option” - medicine!

DD1 friend just graduated like here was like that - always wanted to be a teacher but everyone in profession told her don't. She's now on zero hours contract with council and trying to get into media work.

Only I I know now a HT - went to uni with him - has been for a while and seems really happy though long hours.

Did summer school with a teacher decade ago she'd moved to a private girls school she was vile about the kids and depeiterly trying to retain out the job.

DH in HE and was getting really down just after covid to point it was affecting home life but change in uni and he back to enjoying it despie politics still being a thing -- he more protected by his higher ups at new uni and support staff are helpful - and it makes a massive difference.

Swipe left for the next trending thread