Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

A question for anyone who is not a teacher

122 replies

EBWhite · Yesterday 09:56

I’m a teacher and have resigned after years at the chalk face. Many of my colleagues are desperate to get out and a lot of the new recruits don’t last beyond the first couple of years. It’s also harder than ever to secure your first post. Everywhere I look, teachers are unhappy but maybe that’s because I’m unhappy. I’ve joined the Facebook groups about leaving the profession and look at the data from teacher tapp that shows deep dissatisfaction.

So my question is this- if you have a teacher in your family or as a close friend, are they ok in their job? Are they happy? I think my opinion is skewed because the only opinions I see are from people who feel the way I do. Are there a quiet majority getting on happily and enjoying the role as I used to. What do the teachers in your lives have to say about school?

OP posts:
FirmSnake · Yesterday 12:59

blythet · Yesterday 12:53

why is it so hard to get a job as a new teacher with so many leaving?

Falling birth rates. There's fewer children to teach. My kids school was two form entry, now it's single form entry for yr1 and below. That's several teaching jobs going over the next few years in one school alone.

Scarecrowsweeding · Yesterday 12:59

My husband is a teacher. He loves it but it is SO high pressure. Lots of his colleagues are overwhelmed to the point of tears regularly.

I know that OFSTED was recently revamped in the wake of the suicide of a headteacher after a negative report but the new system takes absolutely none of the pressure off. They phone on a Monday and are in the next day. So for months of their lives teachers have the potential threat of an inspection clouding every weekend. It’s terrible for mental health.

Fifthtimelucky · Yesterday 13:00

One of my daughters is a teacher and so is her fiancé. They are still relatively new (she’s in her 5th year and he is in his 3rd) and they both love it.

They are at the same school (11-18 comprehensive) which has an effective SLT and seems a very happy place for staff and pupils. This is the first school either of them has taught in (except while training) and they both feel that they have landed on their feet and been very lucky.

I have a good friend who teaches in an 11-16 comprehensive in another part of the country. There is a newish headteacher who is trying to turn things round, but is having an uphill battle. Pupil behaviour, and parental engagement are appalling (police are called regularly) and many of the teachers seem to have given up. Friend is often told by pupils that she is the only teacher who ever enforces rules eg around use of mobile phones.

She is 60 and went part time this year, but on the whole still enjoys it.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

CheesesForUsMeeses · Yesterday 13:00

FirmSnake · Yesterday 12:59

Falling birth rates. There's fewer children to teach. My kids school was two form entry, now it's single form entry for yr1 and below. That's several teaching jobs going over the next few years in one school alone.

Probably a good thing that so many appear to hate it and are leaving then, there aren’t enough jobs for them all anyway!

Talkingtomyhouseplants · Yesterday 13:10

Ex teacher here for reasons you probably don’t need to try too hard to imagine. My brother is a history teacher at a secondary school in a nice area - he loves it.

BlueSpottyLeopard · Yesterday 13:13

My brother is a teacher in primary school. He is headteacher two days and class teacher 3 days. He’s happy in his job. He said he is very disciplined and never brings work home as that is a slippery slope. His working day is around 8am to 5pm.

EBWhite · Yesterday 13:16

BigSmoking · Yesterday 12:50

I am not sure why you are asking the question OP? If your straw poll shows enough happy teacher experience, might you look for another job? And it really is a very subjective straw poll!

FWIW my SIL is a teacher after a job in business; she loves it - she is a bit of a comedian and is popular with the kids. She especially loves the pastoral side and has taken on more in this area. My dad was a teacher and had a love-hate relationship with it for years (loved kids, hated paperwork), but his experience is a bit out of date. My friend's daughter also retrained as a primary teacher after a city job - works in a deprived area, loves it, feels that she is doing something worthwhile. I know two people who didn't survive their NQT years, but I would say their motivations for retraining as teachers were probably not right.

I don't think there is much special about how teachers view their jobs compared to people I know working in private or public sector. Some live to work, some work to live. Teachers don't stick out in any way as far as I can see.

I’m asking because I’m interested in different opinions. I suspected I was in a bit of a negative echo chamber with the places I was looking to engage with people on this topic. I would have thought there would be fewer people with positive stories. It’s encouraging to see lots of people who still love the job. I think I could see myself working in a school again but perhaps in a different role. As everyone says here, the kids are the best part of it. I’m also considering school adjacent roles perhaps for the local authority or a specialist setting.

OP posts:
fridaynightzzz · Yesterday 13:23

I don’t work there now but I did work in HR/recruitment for a trust. I’d say most of the staff were happy in their job.
One teacher did leave when she loved her job but the underlying pressure was effecting her mental health. She did want to come back to it one day.
2 left because they were unhappy but returned because they couldn’t make the same kind of money elsewhere. We are in an area of low employment and declining industry and there isn’t the kind of jobs around matching their SLT wages.

Id say most of the teachers who were unhappy were PE teachers who hadn’t moved onto management. But I can guess 20+ years of PE lessons in the cold/rain might do that.

ArtieChoke · Yesterday 13:24

My friend youngest lasted a year as a teacher after 3 at university

they now work at a university

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 13:25

I know four retired teachers, and all but one took early retirement. I suppose that says something about how they view the profession. The one who lasted till state retirement age was working part time at a private school.

Seagulldancing · Yesterday 13:28

All the teachers I have known, in 3 countries and across 30 years, all complain equally about their jobs. Its a hard job and people who fell into it seems to struggle the most.
But school rolls are falling, a primary school near me is likely to close or merge with another one next Sept. So all the people who seem to hate teaching will have a way out soon.

FireEater · Yesterday 13:29

My sister is a primary teacher and enjoys her job. She had a very difficult period at one school which practically broke her and almost brought her to quitting the profession but is very happy in her current school. It has as a fantastic head teacher which I suspect helps massively.
My sister seems to have a good work life balance - she works hard but rarely works evenings or weekends unless reports are due. She does a fair bit of hobbies during the week and weekend and has decent social life at weekend.

Works a small amount of holidays - such as a couple of days at start and end of summer holidays.

She's been doing the job 18 years

sausageth · Yesterday 13:31

I'm a supply TA. Most of the teachers I've worked with either want to leave or are generally struggling but put on a brace face.

MajorProcrastination · Yesterday 14:08

not a teacher. teacher friends/family:

  • 1 loved primary teaching, gained ALNCo responsibilities & extra pay, loved the school's ethos & approach, but budget pressure from LA meant job cuts and shuffle which led to more pressure, stress & less pay (as less reponsibility) with smaller staff but growing level of need. last year and a bit has had huge chunks of time off work sick
  • 1 loved primary teaching, took less reponsibility for a role in a school with great ethos and approach as they recognised they needed to learn how they do things. a family/health situation means they've had to take big chunks off on sick leave
  • 1 who loved teaching & working with children but was pressured into more senior roles and responsibility with less time with the children doing the bits she loved, retired & now wishes she'd stuck to her guns and honed her classroom skills rather than admin & management
  • several who love teaching & learning & working with children & the way their school does things but has been made miserable, stressed, bullied, anxious, scared by awful parents (eg physical threats, verbal aggression, lies told to police, whatsapp & social media hate campaigns against them etc)
  • a couple who love their jobs at SLT & headships but who have been pressured to leave by inadequate budgets from the LA (v high ALN needs so many many many who need 1:1 but there's no money for that, the extra funding received goes nowhere near paying for an additional adult in an LSA role for 39 weeks a year, nowhere near - SLT & heads feel that they need to self sacrifice to make way for cheaper leadership and because they feel there's nowhere left to go, there's nothing else to cut from the budget)
  • 1 who likes teaching but has forced herself onto a leadership pathway for financial reasons because of her husband's ill health
  • 1 who's fairly new into secondary teaching as a career change post 40 and is really enthusiastic about it but she's a pretty positive person and has had many diffferent careers
  • 1 who's fairly new into secondary teaching post 40 after being a SAHM for about 13 years, from talking with her I feel she's got what I'd see as a pretty old fashioned view of teaching and learning but it fits well with the curriculum in England and her training & school
  • 1 who did post 16 PGCE, managed to get an LSA role and was enjoying especially the ALN work, and was pursuing further training in that area but had to leave when they were inflexible about her return to work after maternity and she now works at an organisation supporting learning disabled adults
  • 1 who was an amazing primary teacher who took on a lot of community focused work and made a huge difference with a lot of families and was on a very cool leadership journey. LA changed how they funded that stream of work (which the new person let fizzle to shit and got diluted across a wider range of schools where the need wasn't so high), she went on mat leave and after brief part time stint left to be a SAHM.
  • 1 who teaches in a very specialist setting with teenagers who loves it, they're valued in post, it's a place of real innovation and responsiveness to the needs of the young people attendin, they've also been supported to do a Phd so there's huge commitment there in their own professional learning and development.

From my perspective, as a friend or family member, I can see it depends on the individual, the school's curriculum and values, how they're valued and supported. From my perspective as a governor, it's hugely linked with the inadequate funding received from our local authority, and what they receive from Welsh Government and so on. The visions, values, ethos, expertise, heart, innovation is all there but the money isn't and that's what's letting the whole system down. We're losing really special and important knowledge and understanding and passion because the money isn't there to pay the staff structures that we need to be as amazing as it can be. Parents are another major area of concern for me.

I've been told by numerous people through life in different situations that I should've pursued teaching as a career. I would've loved the pension and the pay. I would've loved the interaction with the children. I would've loved the curiosity and interaction and making a difference. But I can see all the frustrations too. And I love the sector I actually work in!

Lacyboo · Yesterday 14:14

I know a head teacher and a teacher, both primary level but not same school. Both of them are heavy cocaine users. I have no idea how they function in the job but i understand the pressures of the job that lead them to being users

ItalianoSl · Yesterday 14:16

Lacyboo · Yesterday 14:14

I know a head teacher and a teacher, both primary level but not same school. Both of them are heavy cocaine users. I have no idea how they function in the job but i understand the pressures of the job that lead them to being users

Are you saying teaching drove them to cocaine?
Most people with work-place stress do not start taking cocaine as a way to cope.

ItalianoSl · Yesterday 14:18

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 13:25

I know four retired teachers, and all but one took early retirement. I suppose that says something about how they view the profession. The one who lasted till state retirement age was working part time at a private school.

Or that (especially if they had been in the profession a long time) their pension enabled them to retire early?

EBWhite · Yesterday 15:13

@MajorProcrastination thank you for sharing your perspective. I share the frustration of your friends in leadership. I’m following the SEND reforms with particular interest as I feel we are at crisis point in schools. However, lots of teachers seem to not be feeling this pressure or can’t have the level of need that some of us do in our classrooms. it’s heartening to hear lots of positive stories on here.

When I started teaching we had a supportive local authority, support from other schools, Education action zones, sure start centres, a guaranteed TA in each class, space in specialist provision for children who were working significantly below key stage standards. If the funding and support had kept pace I do wonder if there would be so many parents pushing for EHCPs.

OP posts:
MajorProcrastination · Yesterday 15:26

EBWhite · Yesterday 15:13

@MajorProcrastination thank you for sharing your perspective. I share the frustration of your friends in leadership. I’m following the SEND reforms with particular interest as I feel we are at crisis point in schools. However, lots of teachers seem to not be feeling this pressure or can’t have the level of need that some of us do in our classrooms. it’s heartening to hear lots of positive stories on here.

When I started teaching we had a supportive local authority, support from other schools, Education action zones, sure start centres, a guaranteed TA in each class, space in specialist provision for children who were working significantly below key stage standards. If the funding and support had kept pace I do wonder if there would be so many parents pushing for EHCPs.

Yep, I think our problem is that 1 LSA just isn't enough either. In some classes we have 3 children who need 1:1 support. They're just not getting linked up with specialist provision as quickly as in the past. I think also we've got a reputation locally for doing things well so parents opt to come to us. There's so much more I want to say but it's all too specific.

It's so sad, we've got some good eggs in the LA but in recent years some of the decisions made and the approaches taken by some very bad eggs at the LA have been really damaging. As a governor, I also feel a huge sense of responsibility for the wellbeing of our staff team.

It varies between schools I know - one of my teacher mates has 1 child with an IDP in the whole school, we have around 70 each year. This only came up because she was talking about the pressures of being an ALNCo and I was sympathising thinking of ours but we've got a whole different scale (she has half the number of children at her school but it's still a huge difference).

jonesonscam · Yesterday 15:43

I was one, I wasn’t happy really. I have another one in my family. They are deeply unhappy but feel trapped.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · Yesterday 15:45

I left teaching in August 2022 and have never been happier.

My sister always enjoyed the job of actually teaching the children but hated everything else. She quit this summer and is now doing her masters.

LoafofSellotape · Yesterday 15:49

I know 4 teachers, all have done at least 25 + years and couldn't stand another minute. 2 retired early,one now works for Tesco delivery and the other works in a library.

CherryKerry · Yesterday 15:49

Family member has been a Biology teacher in state school for over 10 years. (Female, late 30s).

The physical assaults and unjustified complaints from parents are tipping her over the edge now. She's working out her exit strategy as she's had enough.

ItalianoSl · Yesterday 16:09

LoafofSellotape · Yesterday 15:49

I know 4 teachers, all have done at least 25 + years and couldn't stand another minute. 2 retired early,one now works for Tesco delivery and the other works in a library.

I presume they are either using some of their pension or have another source of income, because I don't think you can support yourself/home on a Tesco delivery drive or library wage.

Boomer55 · Yesterday 16:16

My grandson started teaching in a rural place 2 years ago. He loved it at first. He had lots of special needs kids, (age 6 class) but he had a TA to help him.

This school has now got shot of their TAs, it's too much for him, so my grandson is coming back to a London suburb, as our local schools are more adequately staffed.