Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

A question for anyone who is not a teacher

122 replies

EBWhite · Yesterday 09:56

I’m a teacher and have resigned after years at the chalk face. Many of my colleagues are desperate to get out and a lot of the new recruits don’t last beyond the first couple of years. It’s also harder than ever to secure your first post. Everywhere I look, teachers are unhappy but maybe that’s because I’m unhappy. I’ve joined the Facebook groups about leaving the profession and look at the data from teacher tapp that shows deep dissatisfaction.

So my question is this- if you have a teacher in your family or as a close friend, are they ok in their job? Are they happy? I think my opinion is skewed because the only opinions I see are from people who feel the way I do. Are there a quiet majority getting on happily and enjoying the role as I used to. What do the teachers in your lives have to say about school?

OP posts:
RPRegionalPosh · Yesterday 16:20

EBWhite · Yesterday 09:56

I’m a teacher and have resigned after years at the chalk face. Many of my colleagues are desperate to get out and a lot of the new recruits don’t last beyond the first couple of years. It’s also harder than ever to secure your first post. Everywhere I look, teachers are unhappy but maybe that’s because I’m unhappy. I’ve joined the Facebook groups about leaving the profession and look at the data from teacher tapp that shows deep dissatisfaction.

So my question is this- if you have a teacher in your family or as a close friend, are they ok in their job? Are they happy? I think my opinion is skewed because the only opinions I see are from people who feel the way I do. Are there a quiet majority getting on happily and enjoying the role as I used to. What do the teachers in your lives have to say about school?

I have a close friend who is in a senior teaching role in a very deprived area, work is hard but she enjoys it. She was approached to go and work at a local private school and said no. My aunt has been a teacher for years and about 5/6 years ago started additional training as she didn't enjoy the management route and was a bit sick of what she called the exam factory, so now works in alternative provision/boarding school for those with additional needs, mainly autism, still teaching and enjoys it

brunettemic · Yesterday 16:36

DH is teacher and loves teaching and being in the classroom. His school is a very good one and they don’t treat the staff that well and just care about whatever the results are. He’s massively appreciative of the things he gets that others simply don’t like 13 weeks off (he’s been in it for 24 years I think so doesn’t need to spend much of it working) and whilst he likes to moan about big his pension contributions are he also gets how good his pension is.

He knows people that have left and definitely considers it. Two of his friends have left and work for HMRC and I think quite a few people in our area go there.

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · Yesterday 16:46

Yes, my cousin is a secondary school teacher and she loves it. However, she did a pretty high level, stressful and demanding job before career changing into teaching around 10-15 years ago, so I think her benchmark is slightly different from that of the average teacher. She doesn't seem to get overly stressed by it.

Another cousin is a teacher in a very deprived primary school and absolutely loves it. Her sister is a headteacher in a similar school. The headteacher has said that it's very stressful and upsetting to deal with the difficult safeguarding stuff but she wouldn't ever want to do anything different.

We also have close family friends in which both halves of the couple are primary teachers and have been for 25+ years. Both of them are very happy, and their young adult son is about to follow in their footsteps.

I think there are certainly stresses involved, and there are probably differences between schools. It clearly isn't the right career for everyone. But there are certainly still teachers out there who love what they do.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

mugglewump · Yesterday 16:47

TraitorOrFaithful · Yesterday 11:53

@EBWhite can you explain why it's harder now to find your first post but also that lots of teachers are leaving? I find that hard to understand?

I think it might be something to do with falling roll. Lots of schools near me are going from two form entry to one form entry or even combining classes (eg one KS1 class from previously two year 1 and two year 2 classes). Also, whilst ECTs are cheaper in terms of pay, they also need additional support/training and their mentor needs time out of class too, so they are more expensive and more time consuming to employ than someone who has passed their initial stage.

mugglewump · Yesterday 16:54

Supply teacher here. I left full time permanent teaching 10 years ago - initially planning to return to having my own class in a year or so. However, I have never felt the urge to go back to the 60 hours a week of stress and unattainable targets that come with teaching - especially if you are in a school with Ofsted looming (expectations for marking, displays, progress rates and presentation of books is so high pre-Ofsted).

Moreover, with budget cuts in real terms, there is less TA support than ever, yet SEND needs are rising exponentially. It's an impossible mix.

Yes, there are people out there who still love teaching, but most hate the paperwork, politics and expectations.

fiorentina · Yesterday 16:59

I’m friends or related to a few.

One has left and now has her own education related business. Others have stayed and are relatively ok with the role but one moved schools to a more supportive environment environment having been in a depressing private school with financial challenges.

I know it can be long hours and many frustrations with budgets, parents and lack of support but other jobs aren’t always much better sadly.

Iamnofool · Yesterday 17:03

I’m a retired teacher. I struggled in several posts and would have looked for something different but I got a job in an independent grammar school and loved it. Worked there 20+ years until retirement. It was hard work. Long hours, challenging parents ( “ We pay your salary, why aren’t you predicting an A*?”) But most of the pupils wanted to be there and learn. Towards the end the admin became burdensome. I wouldn’t become a teacher now.

LoafofSellotape · Yesterday 17:15

ItalianoSl · Yesterday 16:09

I presume they are either using some of their pension or have another source of income, because I don't think you can support yourself/home on a Tesco delivery drive or library wage.

I don't ask them about their income ,they were clearly happy to take a drop on earnings for the sake of their mental health.

BearSoFair · Yesterday 17:15

My sister has been a teacher for 20+ years, still passionate about her subject and wants to help her students acheive the best they can, but she doesn't have the same love of the job she had a few years ago. She's hoping to retire by 2030.

ItalianoSl · Yesterday 17:21

LoafofSellotape · Yesterday 17:15

I don't ask them about their income ,they were clearly happy to take a drop on earnings for the sake of their mental health.

Fair enough.
I'm sure we'd all be happy to improve our well being, but many people do not have the choice if they rely on their income.
This is why so many people are trapped in jobs/professions they don't enjoy.

Wooflewaffle · Yesterday 17:24

My mum - lifelong primary teacher / headteacher, was broken by a brutal inspection, retired early.

My sister - didn’t even make it through her first PGCE placement before realising she hated it.

DH - secondary teacher, burnout last year and only works part time, no exam classes, now.

moonraker0 · Yesterday 17:32

ItalianoSl · Yesterday 16:09

I presume they are either using some of their pension or have another source of income, because I don't think you can support yourself/home on a Tesco delivery drive or library wage.

Do you think everyone who works in a supermarket lives in a cardboard box? Of course people can support themselves in this type of job, thousands already do.

Cuwins · Yesterday 17:38

My sister loves it but she does teach in quite a
unique special school setting so probably not generally representative of teachers

EllaPaella · Yesterday 17:41

I have a few teachers in my friendship circle. No, they are not happy. Close to burnout, often working in quite toxic environments, two of them are being actively bullied my the head teacher (something that other teacher friends have experienced as well in the past). They find it stressful and extremely demanding. I wouldn’t want to do their job for all the tea in China. I have a lot of empathy for anyone in the teaching profession.

PoliteSquid · Yesterday 17:53

TraitorOrFaithful · Yesterday 11:53

@EBWhite can you explain why it's harder now to find your first post but also that lots of teachers are leaving? I find that hard to understand?

Because schools/Trusts can’t afford to recruit qualified teachers.

I work in the head office of a MAT and we are asking Principal and Heads to really really consider if they actually need to recruit into vacant posts. The result is a lot of non specialists teaching subjects they don’t know because theoretically a teacher should be able to teach anything!

it’s utter bollocks and I don’t want to be part of it any more. Nor do I want to return to the classroom!!

CleverKitten · Yesterday 17:54

One of my best friends is a teacher, she is on her knees with exhaustion and stress. She worked as a teaching assistant for 16 years and then did her training. She thought she had a good idea what she was getting into but said it’s 10 times harder than she expected.

SirChenjins · Yesterday 17:57

Mixed, like any job - some love it, some think it's ok, some hate it.

There are no shortages of people wanting to train as teachers, and the salary (up here) is pretty good, esp for someone just a few years out of uni, so people aren't leaving in droves.

AnneElliott · Yesterday 18:01

My SIL is a primary teacher and my niece (other side of the family) is head of politics at a secondary school. Both are very happy - supportive SLT and good atmosphere.

Delphiniumandlupins · Yesterday 18:03

I know two primary school teachers who are both unhappy and looking to leave (one after 20 years). They have large numbers of children needing additional support and little support available. They feel undermined by parents, (often by) senior management and worn down by external policies that change frequently and don't help teaching.

I also know a secondary head of science in a private school who is pretty happy. Still lots of overtime and bureaucracy but she's not trying to quit.

bababamama · Yesterday 18:08

My friend is a teacher and loves it still, his wife isn’t a teacher and he sees how hard she works for half the pay he earns plus anti social shifts, she gets less holidays of course too. I’m not saying teaching isn’t hard, BUT so are most jobs, it’s called work, not leisure for a reason. I work hard, deal with the public in difficult situations (talking about suicidal, in debt, no food, other illnesses or just plain lonely) it isn’t easy either, and like teachers I end up working many more hours than people realise. But I do like my job, it’s not easy sometimes though.

i know of two teachers who quit and within 2 years returned (one supply, one contract) because the outside world was just as crap

LittleGreenDuck · Yesterday 18:09

My best friend is a teacher, primary level. She left a few years ago to pursue a “dream” own business that she’d been hankering after for a while. Lasted two years and went back to teaching. She’s very honest that she loves the long holidays.

Alohaaaaa · Yesterday 18:11

My dad was a teacher. He retired at 60 even though he could have continued working health wise much longer in a less demanding job. He taught in a London comprehensible secondary and left because the kids had no respect for teachers and he could not control the classroom anymore at all. He had been a well respected and popular teacher in his prime.

fridaynightzzz · Yesterday 18:12

I think primary/secondary is a big difference. A lot of secondary school teachers are still doing what they enjoy, especially if you have good pastoral support.
@PoliteSquidone of the reasons for teachers being unhappy is having to teach outside of their specialty- which will get worse with these new practical GCSEs I’m sure.

Primary school teaching seems to have been totally ruined so I can understand why they are unhappy.

CaptainCalm · Yesterday 18:12

I know one ex teacher, state primary, she stopped to become a tutor and is really enjoying it. She wasn’t unhappy but they didn’t renew her contract and she decided she’d use this as an opportunity to do something else.

The two current teachers I know are happy. One stepped back from a Head of role to just teach again, and is 4 days a week. She is state secondary.

The other is a male, he is now in a Head of role at a large private school and is very happy. His children attend the same school and they live onsite in a lovely house provided by the school.

MerryAquaKoala · Yesterday 18:13

The ones I know who work at private schools are happy.