Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Conversion therapy bill should not stop ‘healthy and challenging family conversations’ Children's tsar

481 replies

IwantToRetire · 12/11/2026 21:21

Dame Rachel de Souza told The Telegraph that the Government’s legislation to outlaw conversion therapy must not “impact healthy and challenging family conversations”.

Dame Rachel said that while she supported the aims of the bill, she was keen to see that it did not impinge on conversations within the family.

“I know young people face abuse and coercion because of their sexuality or gender, and I support the Government’s aim to ban harmful practices,” she said.

“This is complex and sensitive legislation, and for the bill to be effective, it is important it doesn’t impact healthy and challenging family conversations and aligns with existing measures in place to protect children from cruelty.”

Full article https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/12/trans-conversion-law-must-not-silence-parents-children/

And at https://archive.is/QWfdH

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:54

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 07:53

So you are posting on this thread because…?

I was unaware this was only a thread for lawyers and legislative experts. I'll say my goodbyes. byeee

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 07:56

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:52

Personally? I don't know enough to answer. It is between the child, their parents and potentially, medical team (due to the health concerns).

Edited

It’s more that you seem to have absolutely no interest in understanding the subject of the thread.

BlueLegume · Yesterday 07:57

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:52

Personally? I don't know enough to answer. It is between the child, their parents and potentially, medical team (due to the health concerns).

Edited

Surely as an adult, and presumably a parent, you do not legal or medical training to know what good parenting looks like without going into pseudo intellectual verbal gymnastics?

You must see that the proposed bill is full of holes that could see good parents be criminalised.

TheKeatingFive · Yesterday 08:00

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:52

Personally? I don't know enough to answer. It is between the child, their parents and potentially, medical team (due to the health concerns).

Edited

Quite. So surely you understand that this kind of ambiguity is deeply worrying for a loving parent who is trying to do the best by their child in the long term?

TheKeatingFive · Yesterday 08:00

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:54

I was unaware this was only a thread for lawyers and legislative experts. I'll say my goodbyes. byeee

Well someone has realised they are out of their depth

Peachesonbeaches · Yesterday 08:07

BunnyBunbunbun · 13/11/2026 10:57

And what does the bill say about telling a man such as yourself that he's a man?

That's the whole problem, isn't it? It's all extremely vague and unclear, both just what this bill wants to penalise and what penalties it would impose.

I doubt many people would agree that it should be made a crime to tell a man, such as yourself, that he's a man and not a woman.

You're a man. All transwomen are men.

There’s no need for hate. You can be GC and not be a bully, rude and degrading to trans people. Gross

Shedmistress · Yesterday 08:07

This bill could criminalise anyone, parent, teacher, therapist, doctor, employer, even as pointed out yesterday a judge asking questions in court.

All anyone has to say is 'people are asking me questions about gender' and boom. Could end up in losing your kids, your job, your business and jail time.

Shedmistress · Yesterday 08:08

Peachesonbeaches · Yesterday 08:07

There’s no need for hate. You can be GC and not be a bully, rude and degrading to trans people. Gross

Calling a man a man is not hate.

Hope that helps.

borntobequiet · Yesterday 08:15

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:21

Most people don't feel compelled to perform algebra everytime a sex, gender or pronoun is used.

Most people never used to until this abuse of language was inflicted on them by gender identarians.

Shedmistress · Yesterday 08:27

borntobequiet · Yesterday 08:15

Most people never used to until this abuse of language was inflicted on them by gender identarians.

It is also why I personally try and use men for men, and women for women. No algebra needed.

Unless you are a man pretending to be a woman pretending to be a man pretending to be a woman to try and get some sort of 'gotcha', in which case...

Confused South By Southwest GIF by Arena Live Chat
FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 08:31

Peachesonbeaches · Yesterday 08:07

There’s no need for hate. You can be GC and not be a bully, rude and degrading to trans people. Gross

This is how women are silenced.

By making it socially unacceptable to say clearly why men claiming they are women are not in fact the same thing as women.

By refusing to hear us until we can arrange our entirely reasonable and wonan-focussed points into language that doesn't make then men who are trampling over our rights, language and social existence feel bad about themselves.

By forcing us into language so convoluted our points become unclear.

Eventually, women realise they have to choose between being "kind" and being Feminist, because the "kindness" itself is part of the structure that keeps us trapped.

Peachesonbeaches · Yesterday 08:34

Shedmistress · Yesterday 08:08

Calling a man a man is not hate.

Hope that helps.

If it’s done with the intent to deliberately cause emotional pain then it is hate and bullying. That poster knows very well that this man finds his biological reality distressing and identifies as a woman. To keep reminding him over and over that he is a man is cruel and nasty. Whether it is true or not. I honestly don’t know how some people on here have the energy to keep hating trans people and arguing about it. It’s so boring. A tiny proportion of society wants to present themselves as the other sex. God, it’s really not that big a deal. I bet most of you never even have one meaningful encounter with a trans person in your life. All this hate for a group of people you’ve never even met. It’s ridiculous. Live and let live, life is way too short. Children are dying in Gaza every single day, FFS there are bigger issues in the world! No parent is ever going to end up in prison because they tell their child that changing sex isn’t possible. Let’s stop scaremongering and be reasonable 🙄

TheKeatingFive · Yesterday 08:37

Peachesonbeaches · Yesterday 08:34

If it’s done with the intent to deliberately cause emotional pain then it is hate and bullying. That poster knows very well that this man finds his biological reality distressing and identifies as a woman. To keep reminding him over and over that he is a man is cruel and nasty. Whether it is true or not. I honestly don’t know how some people on here have the energy to keep hating trans people and arguing about it. It’s so boring. A tiny proportion of society wants to present themselves as the other sex. God, it’s really not that big a deal. I bet most of you never even have one meaningful encounter with a trans person in your life. All this hate for a group of people you’ve never even met. It’s ridiculous. Live and let live, life is way too short. Children are dying in Gaza every single day, FFS there are bigger issues in the world! No parent is ever going to end up in prison because they tell their child that changing sex isn’t possible. Let’s stop scaremongering and be reasonable 🙄

Who decides on what the ‘intent’ is?

But what you don’t understand here, is that clear language is necessary in order to protect women’s rights.

I’m not going to call a man a woman because a) that’s not true and b) it creates confusion where there should be clarity.

That's not ‘hate’ it’s just basic common sense.

BlueLegume · Yesterday 08:44

Peachesonbeaches · Yesterday 08:34

If it’s done with the intent to deliberately cause emotional pain then it is hate and bullying. That poster knows very well that this man finds his biological reality distressing and identifies as a woman. To keep reminding him over and over that he is a man is cruel and nasty. Whether it is true or not. I honestly don’t know how some people on here have the energy to keep hating trans people and arguing about it. It’s so boring. A tiny proportion of society wants to present themselves as the other sex. God, it’s really not that big a deal. I bet most of you never even have one meaningful encounter with a trans person in your life. All this hate for a group of people you’ve never even met. It’s ridiculous. Live and let live, life is way too short. Children are dying in Gaza every single day, FFS there are bigger issues in the world! No parent is ever going to end up in prison because they tell their child that changing sex isn’t possible. Let’s stop scaremongering and be reasonable 🙄

Why only mention Gaza? Children are dying all over the world but somehow the Palestine/Gaza card trumps all other atrocities. It seems trans rights (still not clear what these rights are?) and Palestine go hand in hand.

To suggest we have not had any meaningful interactions with trans people is disingenuous. I have worked with several men who have decided to present as women. All union reps, all very overblown sense of self, all pretty mediocre men who then ensured if anyone misgendered them they would complain about it.

In one case we were merging two companies and this would have seen redundancy. Man identifying as a woman was up against an absolutely fantastic member of staff - female. They both did the same role in each of the separate companies but with the merge re there was only to be one role.

Man identifying as a woman worked for a trans organisation as an advisor to government so was very well up on his rights. He essentially went into management and told them he would sue them and bring the company down if he didn’t get the role telling them he would say he had been overlooked because he was trans. Management didn’t have a clue if he could or would do this but they cow towed and he got the job. This was in 2013. Now retired from that role he went onto writing policy and advising the Civil Service.

sanluca · Yesterday 08:47

Peachesonbeaches · Yesterday 08:34

If it’s done with the intent to deliberately cause emotional pain then it is hate and bullying. That poster knows very well that this man finds his biological reality distressing and identifies as a woman. To keep reminding him over and over that he is a man is cruel and nasty. Whether it is true or not. I honestly don’t know how some people on here have the energy to keep hating trans people and arguing about it. It’s so boring. A tiny proportion of society wants to present themselves as the other sex. God, it’s really not that big a deal. I bet most of you never even have one meaningful encounter with a trans person in your life. All this hate for a group of people you’ve never even met. It’s ridiculous. Live and let live, life is way too short. Children are dying in Gaza every single day, FFS there are bigger issues in the world! No parent is ever going to end up in prison because they tell their child that changing sex isn’t possible. Let’s stop scaremongering and be reasonable 🙄

But he is one. Asking him to leave a woman's changing room as he is a man or telling him he can't play on the womens team because he is a man isn't hate. Having a law that makes it impossible to say those things makes even the Bananarama accusation unnecessary. It is not what you said but how you said it. Now you will no longer even be allowed to say it.

A man is a man until the day he dies. Even transwomen.

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 08:55

Hillary Cass opposes draft bill:

The author of the independent review into gender identity services for young people says she doesn't support the current draft bill banning conversion practices - having previously welcomed it.
Baroness Cass said the current wording of the bill risked "serious unintended consequences" for parents of children suffering gender distress, or medical professionals working in that area.

ttps://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6m25vd2yxgdo

Shedmistress · Yesterday 08:58

Peachesonbeaches · Yesterday 08:34

If it’s done with the intent to deliberately cause emotional pain then it is hate and bullying. That poster knows very well that this man finds his biological reality distressing and identifies as a woman. To keep reminding him over and over that he is a man is cruel and nasty. Whether it is true or not. I honestly don’t know how some people on here have the energy to keep hating trans people and arguing about it. It’s so boring. A tiny proportion of society wants to present themselves as the other sex. God, it’s really not that big a deal. I bet most of you never even have one meaningful encounter with a trans person in your life. All this hate for a group of people you’ve never even met. It’s ridiculous. Live and let live, life is way too short. Children are dying in Gaza every single day, FFS there are bigger issues in the world! No parent is ever going to end up in prison because they tell their child that changing sex isn’t possible. Let’s stop scaremongering and be reasonable 🙄

Then maybe he needs some therapy.

By all means reach out to him to offer some. Whoever he is.

Peachesonbeaches · Yesterday 09:00

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 08:31

This is how women are silenced.

By making it socially unacceptable to say clearly why men claiming they are women are not in fact the same thing as women.

By refusing to hear us until we can arrange our entirely reasonable and wonan-focussed points into language that doesn't make then men who are trampling over our rights, language and social existence feel bad about themselves.

By forcing us into language so convoluted our points become unclear.

Eventually, women realise they have to choose between being "kind" and being Feminist, because the "kindness" itself is part of the structure that keeps us trapped.

What about trans men? The tumble weed in the wind on here….i bet you that poster wouldn’t be so cruel to a woman who identified as a man and remind her over and over that she’s a woman. I mean, maybe they would, but it would seem cruel and unnecessary for someone already distressed about their gender. So why is it ok to say it to the man? Because he’s a man and therefore fair game? I just don’t think like that. And no, I don’t feel the need to be “kind and compliant” because I’m a woman. I treat all people with kindness and respect, regardless of their gender, until they give me a reason not to. I also treat people as individuals, and don’t assume all their motivations are the same. Also, no one decides to be trans because they think it’s a trend! What an unbelievably stupid way to think (Bar some teen girls maybe identifying as non-binary for a limited period of time). To actually identify as trans, to want to permanently disfigure your body, to want to deliberately make yourself a social outcast, to voluntarily, massively limit your options for romantic partners and a happy future, just because you think it’s trendy is absolutely ridiculous. It goes much, much deeper than that. These backwards, small-minded attitudes scare me and remind me of the attitudes I encountered when I came out as a young lesbian, “she’s just doing it to try and be cool”. Do you know how frustrating, invalidating and isolating it felt to hear that? That’s what trans people must feel today. Or let’s go back a couple more decades and anyone who came out as gay then was considered mentally ill…it’s shockingly similar to what’s happening now with trans people - “they must be mentally ill”. Completely disregarding that they may have very powerful internal feelings about their gender that they can’t control, just like gay people do about who they’re attracted to. Just cos you don’t understand it, doesn’t mean it’s not real

Pingponghavoc · Yesterday 09:16

This bill will harm girls more than anyone.

Adult men always make themselves the victim, but in reality they are more likely to be laughed at when they wear women's clothes than anything else.

Its the young girls who are put on PB and are waiting for mastectomies who are truly harmed.

We are standing in the way of parents and therapists trying to protect these girls, so that adult men can make it all about them.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 09:18

Peachesonbeaches · Yesterday 09:00

What about trans men? The tumble weed in the wind on here….i bet you that poster wouldn’t be so cruel to a woman who identified as a man and remind her over and over that she’s a woman. I mean, maybe they would, but it would seem cruel and unnecessary for someone already distressed about their gender. So why is it ok to say it to the man? Because he’s a man and therefore fair game? I just don’t think like that. And no, I don’t feel the need to be “kind and compliant” because I’m a woman. I treat all people with kindness and respect, regardless of their gender, until they give me a reason not to. I also treat people as individuals, and don’t assume all their motivations are the same. Also, no one decides to be trans because they think it’s a trend! What an unbelievably stupid way to think (Bar some teen girls maybe identifying as non-binary for a limited period of time). To actually identify as trans, to want to permanently disfigure your body, to want to deliberately make yourself a social outcast, to voluntarily, massively limit your options for romantic partners and a happy future, just because you think it’s trendy is absolutely ridiculous. It goes much, much deeper than that. These backwards, small-minded attitudes scare me and remind me of the attitudes I encountered when I came out as a young lesbian, “she’s just doing it to try and be cool”. Do you know how frustrating, invalidating and isolating it felt to hear that? That’s what trans people must feel today. Or let’s go back a couple more decades and anyone who came out as gay then was considered mentally ill…it’s shockingly similar to what’s happening now with trans people - “they must be mentally ill”. Completely disregarding that they may have very powerful internal feelings about their gender that they can’t control, just like gay people do about who they’re attracted to. Just cos you don’t understand it, doesn’t mean it’s not real

  1. Try paragraphs. It's a grown up look.
  2. Everything you said has been raised and spoken about thousands of times on this board already.

An adolescent diatribe of rehashed Reddit dogma isn't worth Gender Critical Feminists getting out of bed for these days. We are so far ahead of where you are now it's laughable.

Use advanced search, find out what people are actually saying here - yes, even about transmen - and then you'll be ready to have a sensible and civilised conversation. We'll be here.

Shedmistress · Yesterday 09:18

Peachesonbeaches · Yesterday 09:00

What about trans men? The tumble weed in the wind on here….i bet you that poster wouldn’t be so cruel to a woman who identified as a man and remind her over and over that she’s a woman. I mean, maybe they would, but it would seem cruel and unnecessary for someone already distressed about their gender. So why is it ok to say it to the man? Because he’s a man and therefore fair game? I just don’t think like that. And no, I don’t feel the need to be “kind and compliant” because I’m a woman. I treat all people with kindness and respect, regardless of their gender, until they give me a reason not to. I also treat people as individuals, and don’t assume all their motivations are the same. Also, no one decides to be trans because they think it’s a trend! What an unbelievably stupid way to think (Bar some teen girls maybe identifying as non-binary for a limited period of time). To actually identify as trans, to want to permanently disfigure your body, to want to deliberately make yourself a social outcast, to voluntarily, massively limit your options for romantic partners and a happy future, just because you think it’s trendy is absolutely ridiculous. It goes much, much deeper than that. These backwards, small-minded attitudes scare me and remind me of the attitudes I encountered when I came out as a young lesbian, “she’s just doing it to try and be cool”. Do you know how frustrating, invalidating and isolating it felt to hear that? That’s what trans people must feel today. Or let’s go back a couple more decades and anyone who came out as gay then was considered mentally ill…it’s shockingly similar to what’s happening now with trans people - “they must be mentally ill”. Completely disregarding that they may have very powerful internal feelings about their gender that they can’t control, just like gay people do about who they’re attracted to. Just cos you don’t understand it, doesn’t mean it’s not real

Stop co-opting gay history.

And yes if you knew anything about anything, you'd know that one of the running doctors jokes at the Tavistock was there would be no gay kids left after they'd transed them all. Go figure.

The first teens that were the guinea pigs for 'puberty blockers' were girls whose parents did not want butch lesbian daughters. Go educate yourself.

And yes, women who think they are men are women. Thing is, they are not much of a threat to women, what with being women. The biggest threat they are is to themselves, with the lack of estrogen that they need for strong bodies, and the increase in testosterone which their bodies are unable to process or cope with. Practicing eugenics on lesbians and gender non-conforming girls is disgusting. Do better.

MarieDeGournay · Yesterday 09:21

Peachesonbeaches · Yesterday 08:34

If it’s done with the intent to deliberately cause emotional pain then it is hate and bullying. That poster knows very well that this man finds his biological reality distressing and identifies as a woman. To keep reminding him over and over that he is a man is cruel and nasty. Whether it is true or not. I honestly don’t know how some people on here have the energy to keep hating trans people and arguing about it. It’s so boring. A tiny proportion of society wants to present themselves as the other sex. God, it’s really not that big a deal. I bet most of you never even have one meaningful encounter with a trans person in your life. All this hate for a group of people you’ve never even met. It’s ridiculous. Live and let live, life is way too short. Children are dying in Gaza every single day, FFS there are bigger issues in the world! No parent is ever going to end up in prison because they tell their child that changing sex isn’t possible. Let’s stop scaremongering and be reasonable 🙄

A tiny proportion of society wants to present themselves as the other sex. God, it’s really not that big a deal.

If that was true, you'd have a good point.
However, it is a big deal: that tiny proportion of society has had disproportionate influence over many areas of everyday life.

Two of the most obvious are language, where the established meaning of words have been artificially altered, so 'woman' can now also mean 'some men', and the law, where that tiny proportion's decision to 'present themselves as the other sex' was inexplicably the subject of a law and the invention of a legal fiction, with a certificate to back it up, the GRC - as you say, FFS there are bigger issues.'.

The media, medicine, building design, education, all have been impacted by the noisy, sometimes unsanitary [remember all those bottles of urine?], frequently aggressive and occasionally violent behaviour of the tiny proportion and their supporters.

Maybe it's easy to minimise it as you are trying to do if you are not personally negatively impacted by it, in the way that women - a very big proportion of society - have been.

TheKeatingFive · Yesterday 09:25

Peachesonbeaches · Yesterday 09:00

What about trans men? The tumble weed in the wind on here….i bet you that poster wouldn’t be so cruel to a woman who identified as a man and remind her over and over that she’s a woman. I mean, maybe they would, but it would seem cruel and unnecessary for someone already distressed about their gender. So why is it ok to say it to the man? Because he’s a man and therefore fair game? I just don’t think like that. And no, I don’t feel the need to be “kind and compliant” because I’m a woman. I treat all people with kindness and respect, regardless of their gender, until they give me a reason not to. I also treat people as individuals, and don’t assume all their motivations are the same. Also, no one decides to be trans because they think it’s a trend! What an unbelievably stupid way to think (Bar some teen girls maybe identifying as non-binary for a limited period of time). To actually identify as trans, to want to permanently disfigure your body, to want to deliberately make yourself a social outcast, to voluntarily, massively limit your options for romantic partners and a happy future, just because you think it’s trendy is absolutely ridiculous. It goes much, much deeper than that. These backwards, small-minded attitudes scare me and remind me of the attitudes I encountered when I came out as a young lesbian, “she’s just doing it to try and be cool”. Do you know how frustrating, invalidating and isolating it felt to hear that? That’s what trans people must feel today. Or let’s go back a couple more decades and anyone who came out as gay then was considered mentally ill…it’s shockingly similar to what’s happening now with trans people - “they must be mentally ill”. Completely disregarding that they may have very powerful internal feelings about their gender that they can’t control, just like gay people do about who they’re attracted to. Just cos you don’t understand it, doesn’t mean it’s not real

Anyone who cannot deal with the reality of their biological sex needs serious therapy. Not everyone else reframing everything they know about reality in some misguided attempt to ‘be kind’.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 09:38

Peachesonbeaches · Yesterday 09:00

What about trans men? The tumble weed in the wind on here….i bet you that poster wouldn’t be so cruel to a woman who identified as a man and remind her over and over that she’s a woman. I mean, maybe they would, but it would seem cruel and unnecessary for someone already distressed about their gender. So why is it ok to say it to the man? Because he’s a man and therefore fair game? I just don’t think like that. And no, I don’t feel the need to be “kind and compliant” because I’m a woman. I treat all people with kindness and respect, regardless of their gender, until they give me a reason not to. I also treat people as individuals, and don’t assume all their motivations are the same. Also, no one decides to be trans because they think it’s a trend! What an unbelievably stupid way to think (Bar some teen girls maybe identifying as non-binary for a limited period of time). To actually identify as trans, to want to permanently disfigure your body, to want to deliberately make yourself a social outcast, to voluntarily, massively limit your options for romantic partners and a happy future, just because you think it’s trendy is absolutely ridiculous. It goes much, much deeper than that. These backwards, small-minded attitudes scare me and remind me of the attitudes I encountered when I came out as a young lesbian, “she’s just doing it to try and be cool”. Do you know how frustrating, invalidating and isolating it felt to hear that? That’s what trans people must feel today. Or let’s go back a couple more decades and anyone who came out as gay then was considered mentally ill…it’s shockingly similar to what’s happening now with trans people - “they must be mentally ill”. Completely disregarding that they may have very powerful internal feelings about their gender that they can’t control, just like gay people do about who they’re attracted to. Just cos you don’t understand it, doesn’t mean it’s not real

I hear all that, and am not without sympathy. I've treated a few trans as a manual therapist and spoken to others, and not once have had negative feelings, only if and when the conversation has strayed onto wider social ramifications.
Can you imagine an alternative timeline, where pressure groups for trans acknowledged people could not change sex, but we're hugely uncomfortable, and that society would help them in providing third spaces re toilets and changing facilities, sports would provide opportunities in open categories.
That medicalisation of teens was one step too far, but psychological provision would be ramped up to help the new cohort.
And that cancel culture had never been imposed via No Debate.
I genuinely believe the same consensus as was developed over same sex marriage could have been cultivated, much less invaluable social capital trashed.
But no, any dissent or debate was stifled in that cauldron of 2015-2022, trans rights were radicalised to access of men into women's sports and prisons, even medicalisation of trans IDing teens was obscured and made non transparent, and the results came in. Polls all this decade progressively worse and worse for trans policy acceptance, scandals at Tavistock and WPATH, weaponised propagandists like Mermaids given free rein in schools, those schools being willfully untruthful with parents (Dorothy Stringer the biggest example atm).
Yes, a whole different tolerant future could have transpired if debate had been allowed and mantras like men can become women, and promoting of medicalising of teens etc, had been discouraged.
Now? In the UK at least it's a total zero sum game.
I'll always be genuinely civil and understanding of trans IDd individuals, until biological men insist on using women's toilets, be in women's sports and prisons, and they happily promote medicalisation of teens.
Attempts at Self ID law in Scotland was bad enough, but now this Conversion Practices Bill is a step too far, now we're taking the whole zero sum game realm right into the heart of the most sensitive spaces of all, family relationships, teachers doctors therapists with individual children.
That's beyond a step too far.