Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Conversion therapy bill should not stop ‘healthy and challenging family conversations’ Children's tsar

486 replies

IwantToRetire · 12/11/2026 21:21

Dame Rachel de Souza told The Telegraph that the Government’s legislation to outlaw conversion therapy must not “impact healthy and challenging family conversations”.

Dame Rachel said that while she supported the aims of the bill, she was keen to see that it did not impinge on conversations within the family.

“I know young people face abuse and coercion because of their sexuality or gender, and I support the Government’s aim to ban harmful practices,” she said.

“This is complex and sensitive legislation, and for the bill to be effective, it is important it doesn’t impact healthy and challenging family conversations and aligns with existing measures in place to protect children from cruelty.”

Full article https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/12/trans-conversion-law-must-not-silence-parents-children/

And at https://archive.is/QWfdH

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
BlueLegume · Yesterday 07:09

polypostlurker · Yesterday 06:36

Exactly, I do not have any edit ability on this account. I would have removed the 'very...' bit had I had the ability to edit.

Edited to add: I am dumb. I neglected to check the three dot options on my post. Now I know.

Additionally edited to add: I have forgotten how to use mumsnet in the time since I deleted my old account.

Edited

@polypostlurker you can clearly see that @Shedmistress has NOT edited the post. I fit had been edited it would state it had been edited. Only the person posting can edit their own posts so I am not sure what you are talking about.

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:11

BlueLegume · Yesterday 07:09

@polypostlurker you can clearly see that @Shedmistress has NOT edited the post. I fit had been edited it would state it had been edited. Only the person posting can edit their own posts so I am not sure what you are talking about.

Thank you. I don't know how to more clearly state that I was talking about me editing my own post. I did not remember to click on the three dot thing on the upper right of my post, and didn't see any obvious edit mechanism. So I was under the belief that I could not edit my own post and would have had I had the ability to edit.

Shedmistress · Yesterday 07:12

polypostlurker · Yesterday 06:59

My original post said "People I've met were very vocal in calling me a slut, a whore, a cow, a dyke, a slut, a man-hater.... but no one, ever, until I posted on mumsnet had ever called me a man."

I typed in the family relationships afterward and didn't check to see if it made sense in the context of everything. My family and friends are wonderful, thanks.

Most actual women would be upset about being called those things, not use them as 'evidence' that people really and truly think they are female.

And I've been called a man before. Once, when the person was not looking at me he took two tickets from my hands and said 'thank you sir, take the door to your left'.

And guess what...nothing happened. No rage. No ranting. No threats. No endless posts on Mumsnet.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 07:13

polypostlurker · Yesterday 06:21

Gender critical people have this need to believe that everyone I've met over more than the last four decades is deathly afraid of a 5'4" slight woman. People I've met were very vocal in calling me a daughter, a sister, a niece, a wife, a mother... And fewer had strong feelings about calling me a slut, a whore, a cow, a dyke, a slut, a man-hater.... but no one, ever, until I posted on mumsnet had ever called me a man.

I guess no one on Mumsnet has met you in real life so the only reason someone called you a man is because of something you wrote that gave that impression.

We get it, you are actually a woman. Unlike Transperson, who is a man.

This thread is about the conversion practices bill, by the way.

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:15

Shedmistress · Yesterday 07:12

Most actual women would be upset about being called those things, not use them as 'evidence' that people really and truly think they are female.

And I've been called a man before. Once, when the person was not looking at me he took two tickets from my hands and said 'thank you sir, take the door to your left'.

And guess what...nothing happened. No rage. No ranting. No threats. No endless posts on Mumsnet.

They are spoken by supposedly frightened people against a woman.

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:17

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 07:13

I guess no one on Mumsnet has met you in real life so the only reason someone called you a man is because of something you wrote that gave that impression.

We get it, you are actually a woman. Unlike Transperson, who is a man.

This thread is about the conversion practices bill, by the way.

Conversion practises must be stopped. One can hope that the day will arrive when they will be illegal.

Shedmistress · Yesterday 07:19

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:15

They are spoken by supposedly frightened people against a woman.

When woman can mean man or woman nobody has any idea what you are banging on about.

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:21

Shedmistress · Yesterday 07:19

When woman can mean man or woman nobody has any idea what you are banging on about.

Most people don't feel compelled to perform algebra everytime a sex, gender or pronoun is used.

Shedmistress · Yesterday 07:21

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:17

Conversion practises must be stopped. One can hope that the day will arrive when they will be illegal.

They already are.

BlueLegume · Yesterday 07:21

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:17

Conversion practises must be stopped. One can hope that the day will arrive when they will be illegal.

You know they are illegal? You are aware @polypostlurker that this new draft bill is a Trojan horse? It is wrapped up in pretty ribbons but ultimately it does not distinguish between adults and children. Thus so if a child tells a parent at aged 8 they think they are the opposite sex and said parent does good parenting and explains that is not possible and seeks therapy for their confused child, if the child then tells a teacher what the parent has done the teacher could report the parent to the police and could be criminalised for trying to ‘convert’ there child into believing they cannot change sex.

Much of this is driven by the TQIA+ community who as yet have not let us know what the + is.

What is your view on that?

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:28

BlueLegume · Yesterday 07:21

You know they are illegal? You are aware @polypostlurker that this new draft bill is a Trojan horse? It is wrapped up in pretty ribbons but ultimately it does not distinguish between adults and children. Thus so if a child tells a parent at aged 8 they think they are the opposite sex and said parent does good parenting and explains that is not possible and seeks therapy for their confused child, if the child then tells a teacher what the parent has done the teacher could report the parent to the police and could be criminalised for trying to ‘convert’ there child into believing they cannot change sex.

Much of this is driven by the TQIA+ community who as yet have not let us know what the + is.

What is your view on that?

Edited

I met Dylan Scholinski at a book reading/signing when I was living in the US. At the time she was going by Daphne and was gender nonconforming. Afterward, I read their book and believe no one should ever be treated that way.

Parents are not always the supportive people they believe they are. My father was the first person I heard say this in my life.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 07:30

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:17

Conversion practises must be stopped. One can hope that the day will arrive when they will be illegal.

Can you give an example of "conversion practices" being practiced in the UK today? The only ones I can think of in recent times was when the Tavistock gender clinic was transing gay teens to make them straight. Which conversion practices are you thinking of? With real-life examples, please, and what punishments you think there should be.

The bill in its current form has just taken a big blow as Hilary Cass has withdrawn support from it because she was deceived as to what it contained and believes it will have chilling effects.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 07:31

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:28

I met Dylan Scholinski at a book reading/signing when I was living in the US. At the time she was going by Daphne and was gender nonconforming. Afterward, I read their book and believe no one should ever be treated that way.

Parents are not always the supportive people they believe they are. My father was the first person I heard say this in my life.

Edited

I don’t know who Dylan Scholinski is but this thread is discussing U.K. law.

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:36

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 07:30

Can you give an example of "conversion practices" being practiced in the UK today? The only ones I can think of in recent times was when the Tavistock gender clinic was transing gay teens to make them straight. Which conversion practices are you thinking of? With real-life examples, please, and what punishments you think there should be.

The bill in its current form has just taken a big blow as Hilary Cass has withdrawn support from it because she was deceived as to what it contained and believes it will have chilling effects.

I believe 'conversion practises' can be as subtle as removing a child from friends and technology, through punative treatments to discourage behaviour, to requiring visits to a psychologist-cult deprogrammer...or in extreme examples, sending a child to a 'camp' overseas.

The Ex-gay movement in the USA had a whole industry operating in the 1980s.

I hadn't heard the latest about Baroness Cass. Is the tap running warm water this week? Last week she was supporting the puberty blocker trial...

BlueLegume · Yesterday 07:39

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:28

I met Dylan Scholinski at a book reading/signing when I was living in the US. At the time she was going by Daphne and was gender nonconforming. Afterward, I read their book and believe no one should ever be treated that way.

Parents are not always the supportive people they believe they are. My father was the first person I heard say this in my life.

Edited

Did you read my actual post or did you simply seize the opportunity to slip in a sad anecdote?

So by your logic in my example of an 8 year old telling you they think they are the opposite sex you would take their hand and set them off on puberty blocker and x sex hormones without exploring the fact they may be confused and there may be other factors to consider?

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:40

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 07:31

I don’t know who Dylan Scholinski is but this thread is discussing U.K. law.

Many countries have passed anti-conversion practises law in recent years. I would guess it is all interrelated and not only a U.K. thing. I especially don't believe it is being nurtured within the Brazil-esque (film, not country) law and social reform thing the country has going on.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 07:41

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:36

I believe 'conversion practises' can be as subtle as removing a child from friends and technology, through punative treatments to discourage behaviour, to requiring visits to a psychologist-cult deprogrammer...or in extreme examples, sending a child to a 'camp' overseas.

The Ex-gay movement in the USA had a whole industry operating in the 1980s.

I hadn't heard the latest about Baroness Cass. Is the tap running warm water this week? Last week she was supporting the puberty blocker trial...

The Ex-gay movement in the USA had a whole industry operating in the 1980s.

And if you live in America in the 1980s you should certainly do something about that.

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 07:42

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 07:13

I guess no one on Mumsnet has met you in real life so the only reason someone called you a man is because of something you wrote that gave that impression.

We get it, you are actually a woman. Unlike Transperson, who is a man.

This thread is about the conversion practices bill, by the way.

Plot twist. This poster is also a man…. Like transperson.

BlueLegume · Yesterday 07:43

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:36

I believe 'conversion practises' can be as subtle as removing a child from friends and technology, through punative treatments to discourage behaviour, to requiring visits to a psychologist-cult deprogrammer...or in extreme examples, sending a child to a 'camp' overseas.

The Ex-gay movement in the USA had a whole industry operating in the 1980s.

I hadn't heard the latest about Baroness Cass. Is the tap running warm water this week? Last week she was supporting the puberty blocker trial...

As a parent you have a duty to be a good parent. If your kid is playing GTA and it is impacting their life negatively then removing the game is good parenting not conversion therapy. Like wise if they are in with a bad friendship group that is making them unhappy. Good parenting is caring enough to find an alternative so their problems with said group are resolved.

Next you will be telling us that if we don’t let them eat whatever they want we are being cruel. The Bill is full of holes and the grifter MPs promoting it such as Olivia Bailey use faux innocence when faced with the reality of people such as Dennis Kavanagh.

TheKeatingFive · Yesterday 07:46

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:36

I believe 'conversion practises' can be as subtle as removing a child from friends and technology, through punative treatments to discourage behaviour, to requiring visits to a psychologist-cult deprogrammer...or in extreme examples, sending a child to a 'camp' overseas.

The Ex-gay movement in the USA had a whole industry operating in the 1980s.

I hadn't heard the latest about Baroness Cass. Is the tap running warm water this week? Last week she was supporting the puberty blocker trial...

Removing a child from malign influences and technology can also be exemplary parenting.

Wherein lies the issue.

The bill opens the door for ordinary, sensible parenting decisions to be criminalised.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 07:46

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:40

Many countries have passed anti-conversion practises law in recent years. I would guess it is all interrelated and not only a U.K. thing. I especially don't believe it is being nurtured within the Brazil-esque (film, not country) law and social reform thing the country has going on.

I would guess it is all interrelated

That is not how legislation works.

Different countries have different existing legislation. What do you think the proposed legislation would render criminal that isn’t already criminal?

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:48

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 07:46

I would guess it is all interrelated

That is not how legislation works.

Different countries have different existing legislation. What do you think the proposed legislation would render criminal that isn’t already criminal?

I am not a lawyer, nor am I a legislative expert. I don't honestly know.

TheKeatingFive · Yesterday 07:48

@polypostlurkercan you answer the question posed earlier?

If a girl in her early teens decided she was ‘really a boy’ and requested a binder, and her parents refused to get that for her on health grounds - would you consider that to be ‘conversion practice’?

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:52

TheKeatingFive · Yesterday 07:48

@polypostlurkercan you answer the question posed earlier?

If a girl in her early teens decided she was ‘really a boy’ and requested a binder, and her parents refused to get that for her on health grounds - would you consider that to be ‘conversion practice’?

Personally? I don't know enough to answer. It is between the child, their parents and potentially, medical team (due to the health concerns).

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 07:53

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:48

I am not a lawyer, nor am I a legislative expert. I don't honestly know.

So you are posting on this thread because…?