Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Conversion therapy bill should not stop ‘healthy and challenging family conversations’ Children's tsar

482 replies

IwantToRetire · 12/11/2026 21:21

Dame Rachel de Souza told The Telegraph that the Government’s legislation to outlaw conversion therapy must not “impact healthy and challenging family conversations”.

Dame Rachel said that while she supported the aims of the bill, she was keen to see that it did not impinge on conversations within the family.

“I know young people face abuse and coercion because of their sexuality or gender, and I support the Government’s aim to ban harmful practices,” she said.

“This is complex and sensitive legislation, and for the bill to be effective, it is important it doesn’t impact healthy and challenging family conversations and aligns with existing measures in place to protect children from cruelty.”

Full article https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/12/trans-conversion-law-must-not-silence-parents-children/

And at https://archive.is/QWfdH

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 09:43

polypostlurker · Yesterday 07:28

I met Dylan Scholinski at a book reading/signing when I was living in the US. At the time she was going by Daphne and was gender nonconforming. Afterward, I read their book and believe no one should ever be treated that way.

Parents are not always the supportive people they believe they are. My father was the first person I heard say this in my life.

Edited

So, in your opinion - based on an example from another country, not the UK - parents in the UK should be punished by law if they are unpleasant to their child who doesn't dress in stereotypical ways? Perhaps Scholinski's parents' negative attitude to their daughter not wanting to wear dresses is what made her think she's a man? As has been said before, transing is the actual conversion therapy and that's what children and young people need protecting from. We need to get the message across that it's ok not to want to dress like a stereotype, that it's ok to be a girl who likes girls or a boy who likes boys.

You never even explain what the bad treatment allegedly meted out by Scholinski's parents towards their daughter was. How are we meant to know what you're talking about when you give vague anecdotes from outside the UK?

I just looked Scholinski up - she looks just like a woman with a bit of face fluff, of the type some women have naturally. She probably gets "misgendered" as a woman all the time. Because she is a woman.

Perenelle · Yesterday 10:07

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 09:38

I hear all that, and am not without sympathy. I've treated a few trans as a manual therapist and spoken to others, and not once have had negative feelings, only if and when the conversation has strayed onto wider social ramifications.
Can you imagine an alternative timeline, where pressure groups for trans acknowledged people could not change sex, but we're hugely uncomfortable, and that society would help them in providing third spaces re toilets and changing facilities, sports would provide opportunities in open categories.
That medicalisation of teens was one step too far, but psychological provision would be ramped up to help the new cohort.
And that cancel culture had never been imposed via No Debate.
I genuinely believe the same consensus as was developed over same sex marriage could have been cultivated, much less invaluable social capital trashed.
But no, any dissent or debate was stifled in that cauldron of 2015-2022, trans rights were radicalised to access of men into women's sports and prisons, even medicalisation of trans IDing teens was obscured and made non transparent, and the results came in. Polls all this decade progressively worse and worse for trans policy acceptance, scandals at Tavistock and WPATH, weaponised propagandists like Mermaids given free rein in schools, those schools being willfully untruthful with parents (Dorothy Stringer the biggest example atm).
Yes, a whole different tolerant future could have transpired if debate had been allowed and mantras like men can become women, and promoting of medicalising of teens etc, had been discouraged.
Now? In the UK at least it's a total zero sum game.
I'll always be genuinely civil and understanding of trans IDd individuals, until biological men insist on using women's toilets, be in women's sports and prisons, and they happily promote medicalisation of teens.
Attempts at Self ID law in Scotland was bad enough, but now this Conversion Practices Bill is a step too far, now we're taking the whole zero sum game realm right into the heart of the most sensitive spaces of all, family relationships, teachers doctors therapists with individual children.
That's beyond a step too far.

Yes, a whole different tolerant future could have transpired if debate had been allowed and mantras like men can become women, and promoting of medicalising of teens etc, had been discouraged.

That is such an important point.

The trans movement alienated so many people through their totalitarian demands, harmful behaviour and distortion of reality and language. Very much to the detriment of truly distressed persons for whom a more diverse concept of "gender expression" while staying rooted in physical reality would have been helpful.

Also, they might have underestimated that women, especially when threatened, tend to fight hard for what is dear to them, be it their rights or the safety of their children.

Thehorticulturalhussie · Yesterday 11:04

Shedmistress · 16/11/2026 21:27

I think someone on the pop has slurred into a 'voice to text' app or something this evening.

Anyway...as it happens...
I'm a 'Gender Non-Conforming Woman' and have never, not once, even with shaved head, jeans, DMs and black tshirt on, from the ages of 16 through to 59, never once been 'challenged' in female facilities.

This again is a rarity brought on by men in female spaces and being used as a 'gotcha' by the same men who think/have fever dreams that we women have 'girlie' chats in toilets and have pyjama parties on the weekly.

I do think that you have a point there. I have looked at some excited trans Reddit posts about using the Ladies and have read comments along the lines of 'We had a really nice chat, I gave her a Tampax and she showed me how to feather my eye liner'

Just no. There is NO Sisterhood Of The Water Closet.

CassOle · Yesterday 12:26

Transperson · 16/11/2026 22:54

Again when they are available and safe I use them, often at restaurants, pubs, shopping centres, etc they simplify don't exist.

Then use the mens, or go to a different pub/restaurant/shopping centre that does have unisex facilities. As I said, plan better.

CassOle · Yesterday 12:34

Transperson · 16/11/2026 23:07

Don't I have the right to use the toilet without fear of being assaulted?

I think that a campaign to ensure that men who identify as trans and have feminised their body can safely use the mens loos would be a good idea.

I think you should be able to use the mens loos without fear of being assaulted. There are men who identify as trans who already do this.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 12:53

she showed me how to feather my eye liner

Oh God, is this something I should know about for next time I'm queueing in the loos at Victoria station?

TheKeatingFive · Yesterday 12:57

If men are genuinely assaulting other men, in the men’s facilities, why is nothing being done to tackle this appalling behaviour?

Why is there radio silence about that, but instead all this pressure on women to give up their spaces?

Shedmistress · Yesterday 12:59

CassOle · Yesterday 12:26

Then use the mens, or go to a different pub/restaurant/shopping centre that does have unisex facilities. As I said, plan better.

When I worked in London I did everything feasibly possible to avoid using the toilets at St Pancras or on the train home. Indeed I don't think in the last 5 years before covid happened that I used the train loo once. I did have to use St Pancras very occasionally, mainly if the trains were delayed and I wanted to avoid using the train ones.

As women, we absolutely plan things. Men just never think about any of this.

Thehorticulturalhussie · Yesterday 13:04

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 12:53

she showed me how to feather my eye liner

Oh God, is this something I should know about for next time I'm queueing in the loos at Victoria station?

Well yes obviously you should, it's what ordinary women always do in public toilets, for hours on end, while acting as a pop up dispenser of sanitary products.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 13:08

Thehorticulturalhussie · Yesterday 13:04

Well yes obviously you should, it's what ordinary women always do in public toilets, for hours on end, while acting as a pop up dispenser of sanitary products.

My need for sanitary products is lost in the mists of history, and with the layout of the loos at Victoria I'm too busy looking around to see where a cubicle has become free to dispense cosmetic tips (even if I had any).

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 13:32

TheKeatingFive · Yesterday 12:57

If men are genuinely assaulting other men, in the men’s facilities, why is nothing being done to tackle this appalling behaviour?

Why is there radio silence about that, but instead all this pressure on women to give up their spaces?

Another million dollar question

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 13:36

Thehorticulturalhussie · Yesterday 11:04

I do think that you have a point there. I have looked at some excited trans Reddit posts about using the Ladies and have read comments along the lines of 'We had a really nice chat, I gave her a Tampax and she showed me how to feather my eye liner'

Just no. There is NO Sisterhood Of The Water Closet.

Oh god I initially thought the (imaginary) woman was using the tampon to feather her eye-liner 😂

Anyway, all the cool chicks use reuseables now. Period pants and mooncups. No opportunity or need to ask any stranger for a tampon (which doesn't happen in real life anyway)

Thehorticulturalhussie · Yesterday 13:52

Oh god I initially thought the (imaginary) woman was using the tampon to feather her eye-liner
Sorry, I can see why you thought that!
The Feathering Tampons - the band names just keep emerging don't they?

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 14:08

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 12:53

she showed me how to feather my eye liner

Oh God, is this something I should know about for next time I'm queueing in the loos at Victoria station?

"feather" and "eyeliner" do not compute for me... 😁

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 14:08

Peachesonbeaches · Yesterday 08:07

There’s no need for hate. You can be GC and not be a bully, rude and degrading to trans people. Gross

You are rather demonstrating why the bill is a problem.

Sex is often relevant and it is not 'bullying' to refer to somebody's sex when it is relevant.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 14:20

Peachesonbeaches · Yesterday 09:00

What about trans men? The tumble weed in the wind on here….i bet you that poster wouldn’t be so cruel to a woman who identified as a man and remind her over and over that she’s a woman. I mean, maybe they would, but it would seem cruel and unnecessary for someone already distressed about their gender. So why is it ok to say it to the man? Because he’s a man and therefore fair game? I just don’t think like that. And no, I don’t feel the need to be “kind and compliant” because I’m a woman. I treat all people with kindness and respect, regardless of their gender, until they give me a reason not to. I also treat people as individuals, and don’t assume all their motivations are the same. Also, no one decides to be trans because they think it’s a trend! What an unbelievably stupid way to think (Bar some teen girls maybe identifying as non-binary for a limited period of time). To actually identify as trans, to want to permanently disfigure your body, to want to deliberately make yourself a social outcast, to voluntarily, massively limit your options for romantic partners and a happy future, just because you think it’s trendy is absolutely ridiculous. It goes much, much deeper than that. These backwards, small-minded attitudes scare me and remind me of the attitudes I encountered when I came out as a young lesbian, “she’s just doing it to try and be cool”. Do you know how frustrating, invalidating and isolating it felt to hear that? That’s what trans people must feel today. Or let’s go back a couple more decades and anyone who came out as gay then was considered mentally ill…it’s shockingly similar to what’s happening now with trans people - “they must be mentally ill”. Completely disregarding that they may have very powerful internal feelings about their gender that they can’t control, just like gay people do about who they’re attracted to. Just cos you don’t understand it, doesn’t mean it’s not real

i bet you that poster wouldn’t be so cruel to a woman who identified as a man and remind her over and over that she’s a woman.

I cannot deny that this is a feminist board and so posters are more likely to sympathise with women. However, you can't talk about feminism without talking about sex, so yes, it is likely that anyone posting about subjects that relate to their sex on this board is likely to have their sex referred to repeatedly.

Caveat Emptor really.

If you post on AIBU, you are also likely to be told whether you are being reasonable, and the dog owner's board tends to focus on dogs.

Or let’s go back a couple more decades and anyone who came out as gay then was considered mentally ill…it’s shockingly similar to what’s happening now with trans people - “they must be mentally ill”.

No, there isn't much similarity.

On the one hand Gender dysphoria is a diagnosis in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders and it is not possible to change sex.

On the other it is clearly possible to be sexually and/or romantically attracted to people of the same sex.

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 14:35

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 12:53

she showed me how to feather my eye liner

Oh God, is this something I should know about for next time I'm queueing in the loos at Victoria station?

What’s feathery eyeliner? Is it another “proper woman” thing that I don’t know about? Humph.

Transperson · Yesterday 16:37

CassOle · Yesterday 12:34

I think that a campaign to ensure that men who identify as trans and have feminised their body can safely use the mens loos would be a good idea.

I think you should be able to use the mens loos without fear of being assaulted. There are men who identify as trans who already do this.

No why would I use the mens? I deserve dignity and privacy, without getting harassed or fear of being assaulted.

And if men didn't assault, I wouldn't disrespect myself because I don't see myself as a man.

CassOle · Yesterday 17:00

You are male and have every right to use a male single-sex space. If you don't want to do this, then you are back to having to plan properly so that unisex spaces are available for you. What you should never do is use a female single-sex space, as you are not female. Behave in a decent manner and do not use something that is not for you.

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 17:05

Transperson · Yesterday 16:37

No why would I use the mens? I deserve dignity and privacy, without getting harassed or fear of being assaulted.

And if men didn't assault, I wouldn't disrespect myself because I don't see myself as a man.

have you tried going to specsavers? New glasses might help….

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 17:11

Transperson · Yesterday 16:37

No why would I use the mens? I deserve dignity and privacy, without getting harassed or fear of being assaulted.

And if men didn't assault, I wouldn't disrespect myself because I don't see myself as a man.

You deserve to be able to use the correct toilet for your sex without harassment, and you can also argue for alternative provision.

You do not have the right to use provision for people of the opposite sex.

Sotiredimightreallydie · Yesterday 17:11

Transperson · Yesterday 16:37

No why would I use the mens? I deserve dignity and privacy, without getting harassed or fear of being assaulted.

And if men didn't assault, I wouldn't disrespect myself because I don't see myself as a man.

Ah, so the sole arbiter of everything is what is going on privately in your head is it?

Don't you see that it's ridiculous.

If you don't see yourself as an adult is it ok for you to go the primary school?
If you see yourself as ill should we use a hospital bed in you?
If a murderer saw himself as innocent should he be allowed to walk free?

Facts don't just fall away because they don't fit how you see your place in the world. That would be ridiculous.

You go in the men's because you are a man. You struggling

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 19:03

Thehorticulturalhussie · Yesterday 13:52

Oh god I initially thought the (imaginary) woman was using the tampon to feather her eye-liner
Sorry, I can see why you thought that!
The Feathering Tampons - the band names just keep emerging don't they?

Are they related to the Surrey Feathering-Tampons? I think I went to school with the eldest gal.

borntobequiet · Yesterday 19:06

Gel, surely.