Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Conversion therapy bill should not stop ‘healthy and challenging family conversations’ Children's tsar

482 replies

IwantToRetire · 12/11/2026 21:21

Dame Rachel de Souza told The Telegraph that the Government’s legislation to outlaw conversion therapy must not “impact healthy and challenging family conversations”.

Dame Rachel said that while she supported the aims of the bill, she was keen to see that it did not impinge on conversations within the family.

“I know young people face abuse and coercion because of their sexuality or gender, and I support the Government’s aim to ban harmful practices,” she said.

“This is complex and sensitive legislation, and for the bill to be effective, it is important it doesn’t impact healthy and challenging family conversations and aligns with existing measures in place to protect children from cruelty.”

Full article https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/12/trans-conversion-law-must-not-silence-parents-children/

And at https://archive.is/QWfdH

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Thehorticulturalhussie · Yesterday 19:20

borntobequiet · Yesterday 19:06

Gel, surely.

No. Francesca Feathering-Tampons identifies as a Gal. But they are indeed the Surrey branch of the family. You must have been in the same year as Helen Letitia Loosebox.

Tears0fTheMushroom · Yesterday 19:27

Thehorticulturalhussie · Yesterday 19:20

No. Francesca Feathering-Tampons identifies as a Gal. But they are indeed the Surrey branch of the family. You must have been in the same year as Helen Letitia Loosebox.

This reminds me of Phoebe in friends declaring her college sorority was Thigh-Beta-Tampon

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · Yesterday 19:36

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 09:38

I hear all that, and am not without sympathy. I've treated a few trans as a manual therapist and spoken to others, and not once have had negative feelings, only if and when the conversation has strayed onto wider social ramifications.
Can you imagine an alternative timeline, where pressure groups for trans acknowledged people could not change sex, but we're hugely uncomfortable, and that society would help them in providing third spaces re toilets and changing facilities, sports would provide opportunities in open categories.
That medicalisation of teens was one step too far, but psychological provision would be ramped up to help the new cohort.
And that cancel culture had never been imposed via No Debate.
I genuinely believe the same consensus as was developed over same sex marriage could have been cultivated, much less invaluable social capital trashed.
But no, any dissent or debate was stifled in that cauldron of 2015-2022, trans rights were radicalised to access of men into women's sports and prisons, even medicalisation of trans IDing teens was obscured and made non transparent, and the results came in. Polls all this decade progressively worse and worse for trans policy acceptance, scandals at Tavistock and WPATH, weaponised propagandists like Mermaids given free rein in schools, those schools being willfully untruthful with parents (Dorothy Stringer the biggest example atm).
Yes, a whole different tolerant future could have transpired if debate had been allowed and mantras like men can become women, and promoting of medicalising of teens etc, had been discouraged.
Now? In the UK at least it's a total zero sum game.
I'll always be genuinely civil and understanding of trans IDd individuals, until biological men insist on using women's toilets, be in women's sports and prisons, and they happily promote medicalisation of teens.
Attempts at Self ID law in Scotland was bad enough, but now this Conversion Practices Bill is a step too far, now we're taking the whole zero sum game realm right into the heart of the most sensitive spaces of all, family relationships, teachers doctors therapists with individual children.
That's beyond a step too far.

Attempts at Self ID law in Scotland was bad enough, but now this Conversion Practices Bill is a step too far, now we're taking the whole zero sum game realm right into the heart of the most sensitive spaces of all, family relationships, teachers doctors therapists with individual children.

And it is noticeable and rather sinister that it is threads about children, parental responsibility and safeguarding, as this one was meant to be, that are guaranteed to attract adult trans-identified men intent on disrupting, centring themselves, diverting the conversation and portraying the very women who would protect children as deluded, bullying and morally deficient.

Shedmistress · Yesterday 19:42

Can you imagine if any woman kept going onto male dominated forums wailing 'what about me, little me, vulnerable me' for days on end. She would be told to catch herself on/a version of that which we cannot say as it upsets the blokes.

They remind me of one of my cats who pitifully wails so much as I am literally opening his food that he sounds as if he is actually dying.
He isnt of course, 10 seconds later he is snorting the food down like a trooper.

Transperson · Yesterday 19:52

CassOle · Yesterday 17:00

You are male and have every right to use a male single-sex space. If you don't want to do this, then you are back to having to plan properly so that unisex spaces are available for you. What you should never do is use a female single-sex space, as you are not female. Behave in a decent manner and do not use something that is not for you.

The EHRC guidance is not aimed at individuals, you don't have authority over this.

Transperson · Yesterday 19:53

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · Yesterday 19:36

Attempts at Self ID law in Scotland was bad enough, but now this Conversion Practices Bill is a step too far, now we're taking the whole zero sum game realm right into the heart of the most sensitive spaces of all, family relationships, teachers doctors therapists with individual children.

And it is noticeable and rather sinister that it is threads about children, parental responsibility and safeguarding, as this one was meant to be, that are guaranteed to attract adult trans-identified men intent on disrupting, centring themselves, diverting the conversation and portraying the very women who would protect children as deluded, bullying and morally deficient.

I'm glad I live in Scotland, many more human rights here compared to England.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 19:57

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · Yesterday 19:36

Attempts at Self ID law in Scotland was bad enough, but now this Conversion Practices Bill is a step too far, now we're taking the whole zero sum game realm right into the heart of the most sensitive spaces of all, family relationships, teachers doctors therapists with individual children.

And it is noticeable and rather sinister that it is threads about children, parental responsibility and safeguarding, as this one was meant to be, that are guaranteed to attract adult trans-identified men intent on disrupting, centring themselves, diverting the conversation and portraying the very women who would protect children as deluded, bullying and morally deficient.

Well said

It's so noticeable

CassOle · Yesterday 20:01

Transperson · Yesterday 19:52

The EHRC guidance is not aimed at individuals, you don't have authority over this.

You should step up and take responsibility for your actions. You should follow the law because that is what decent people do.

Transperson · Yesterday 20:09

CassOle · Yesterday 20:01

You should step up and take responsibility for your actions. You should follow the law because that is what decent people do.

I am not breaking the law, I am not a service provider. And if I was I would have provided gender neutral toilets.

CassOle · Yesterday 20:15

You know that as a male, you should not use single-sex spaces for female people. The fact that you are arguing the toss really speaks volumes, and not in a good way.

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 20:19

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · Yesterday 19:36

Attempts at Self ID law in Scotland was bad enough, but now this Conversion Practices Bill is a step too far, now we're taking the whole zero sum game realm right into the heart of the most sensitive spaces of all, family relationships, teachers doctors therapists with individual children.

And it is noticeable and rather sinister that it is threads about children, parental responsibility and safeguarding, as this one was meant to be, that are guaranteed to attract adult trans-identified men intent on disrupting, centring themselves, diverting the conversation and portraying the very women who would protect children as deluded, bullying and morally deficient.

Indeed. Along with the interminable use of I, me and my.
Fortunately the women on here are outward looking and focus on the safety and wellbeing of others, safeguarding children from age inappropriate notions about sex change and worry about the impact of the terminally self obsessed on society - including this dangerous bill that is meant to be the focus of this thread.

Fortunately a quick read demonstrates who is solely self interested as opposed to those concerned for others.

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 21:12

Transperson · Yesterday 19:53

I'm glad I live in Scotland, many more human rights here compared to England.

But don’t men have a lower life expectancy in Scotland? Surely you’d be worried about that.

Transperson · Yesterday 21:28

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 21:12

But don’t men have a lower life expectancy in Scotland? Surely you’d be worried about that.

I mean I am not really aware of that but would make sense? Scotland has a much bigger drinking and drug culture. But I don't actually know anything about the cause or correlation, or even if what you say is true.

JanesLittleGirl · Yesterday 21:31

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 21:12

But don’t men have a lower life expectancy in Scotland? Surely you’d be worried about that.

The poor life expectancy of men is just one of many human rights that are available in Scotland but not in England. Everyone in Scotland has a lower life expectancy than in England. The rate of drug-related deaths is far higher in Scotland than it is in England. Educational outcomes in Scotland are lower than they are in England. I have probably missed a few other human rights that Scots get but I'm sure that @Transpersonwill fill in the gaps.

Transperson · Yesterday 21:46

JanesLittleGirl · Yesterday 21:31

The poor life expectancy of men is just one of many human rights that are available in Scotland but not in England. Everyone in Scotland has a lower life expectancy than in England. The rate of drug-related deaths is far higher in Scotland than it is in England. Educational outcomes in Scotland are lower than they are in England. I have probably missed a few other human rights that Scots get but I'm sure that @Transpersonwill fill in the gaps.

None of thesw reflect on laws regarding human rights in Scotland.

Those are problems but they relate to poverty more than anything else?

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 21:50

Transperson · Yesterday 21:46

None of thesw reflect on laws regarding human rights in Scotland.

Those are problems but they relate to poverty more than anything else?

So what human rights do people have in Scotland that they don’t have in England?

Transperson · Yesterday 22:01

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 21:50

So what human rights do people have in Scotland that they don’t have in England?

Glad you asked,

Here is a a detailed analysis
http://wrap.warwick.ac.uk/165742

Tldr is Scotland has different laws and they are much more progressive, there was a time Scotland was ahead of human rights and a leading country in it.

England didn't like that and did their damn best to undermine Scottish progress.

JanesLittleGirl · Yesterday 22:33

Transperson · Yesterday 22:01

Glad you asked,

Here is a a detailed analysis
http://wrap.warwick.ac.uk/165742

Tldr is Scotland has different laws and they are much more progressive, there was a time Scotland was ahead of human rights and a leading country in it.

England didn't like that and did their damn best to undermine Scottish progress.

Did you actually read the download rather than just the abstract. The actual report shows that the Scottish government commitment to extended human rights owes at least as much to a desire to be seen as different to England as it does to drive a societal advancement in human rights and, where there has been enactment of high-level human rights legislation, this hasn't resulted in any actual introduction of additional rights. I would struggle to use this paper as evidence that there is any tangible difference in human rights between Scotland and England.

While the paper is somewhat pro Scotland, it is more anti UK conservative and clearly suggests that those activities that ScotGov has undertaken are far more performative than practical.

Transperson · Yesterday 22:39

JanesLittleGirl · Yesterday 22:33

Did you actually read the download rather than just the abstract. The actual report shows that the Scottish government commitment to extended human rights owes at least as much to a desire to be seen as different to England as it does to drive a societal advancement in human rights and, where there has been enactment of high-level human rights legislation, this hasn't resulted in any actual introduction of additional rights. I would struggle to use this paper as evidence that there is any tangible difference in human rights between Scotland and England.

While the paper is somewhat pro Scotland, it is more anti UK conservative and clearly suggests that those activities that ScotGov has undertaken are far more performative than practical.

What are you on about? They praise Scotland for the steads they took for human rights. I have read it.

Transperson · Yesterday 22:41

Transperson · Yesterday 22:39

What are you on about? They praise Scotland for the steads they took for human rights. I have read it.

One example out of pages and pages about this:

"Scotland has introduced policies that seek to ensure human rights play a vital rolein strategic decisions at the highest levels of devolved government. In 2013, forexample, the Scottish Government launched its National Action Plan for HumanRights (SNAP), in keeping with international best practice. Human Rights ActionPlans seek to ensure ‘that areas of social policy such as education, health, poverty,and social security are framed through the lens of human rights and that variousnational policies are in line with human rights-based approaches to development’(Chalabi, 2018). SNAP, therefore, represented a commitment from a variety ofsectors, including government, civil society and public authorities, to apply ahuman rights based approach within governance and decision-making."

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 22:58

Transperson · Yesterday 22:41

One example out of pages and pages about this:

"Scotland has introduced policies that seek to ensure human rights play a vital rolein strategic decisions at the highest levels of devolved government. In 2013, forexample, the Scottish Government launched its National Action Plan for HumanRights (SNAP), in keeping with international best practice. Human Rights ActionPlans seek to ensure ‘that areas of social policy such as education, health, poverty,and social security are framed through the lens of human rights and that variousnational policies are in line with human rights-based approaches to development’(Chalabi, 2018). SNAP, therefore, represented a commitment from a variety ofsectors, including government, civil society and public authorities, to apply ahuman rights based approach within governance and decision-making."

And yet even in this bastion of rights, a man can never be a woman. Apparently biology does not respect borders.

Transperson · Yesterday 23:01

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 22:58

And yet even in this bastion of rights, a man can never be a woman. Apparently biology does not respect borders.

For social purposes it is definitely changeable.

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 23:04

Transperson · Yesterday 23:01

For social purposes it is definitely changeable.

Nope. You are wrong. You could not be wronger if you tried. You are the wrongest anyone has ever been. Ever. In the history of wrongness.

JanesLittleGirl · Yesterday 23:06

Transperson · Yesterday 22:41

One example out of pages and pages about this:

"Scotland has introduced policies that seek to ensure human rights play a vital rolein strategic decisions at the highest levels of devolved government. In 2013, forexample, the Scottish Government launched its National Action Plan for HumanRights (SNAP), in keeping with international best practice. Human Rights ActionPlans seek to ensure ‘that areas of social policy such as education, health, poverty,and social security are framed through the lens of human rights and that variousnational policies are in line with human rights-based approaches to development’(Chalabi, 2018). SNAP, therefore, represented a commitment from a variety ofsectors, including government, civil society and public authorities, to apply ahuman rights based approach within governance and decision-making."

Lets have a look at what the paper has to say about SNAP.

Whilst initiatives such as SNAP have not necessarily been as effective as originally
intended, in part due to under-funding by the Scottish Government, its launch at
least demonstrated a government taking active steps towards putting human rights
at the heart of policy-making and practice. And in the 2019 evaluation of SNAP,
it is acknowledged that ‘growing support from the First Minister and the Scottish
Parliament generally for Human Rights has been notable in recent years’ (Ferrie,
2019: 61). The realisation of measures, such as national action plans for human
rights, is harder to achieve than the commitment is to make, but Scotland is taking
those initial steps, attempting to navigate through the complicated maze of human
rights compliance and implementation."

Somewhat less than a ringing endorsement isn't it and, as ever with ScotGov, no actual delivery.

Transperson · Yesterday 23:07

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 23:04

Nope. You are wrong. You could not be wronger if you tried. You are the wrongest anyone has ever been. Ever. In the history of wrongness.

Edited

i can't even respond to the immaturity displayed here. Any articulation of ideas?