Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Conversion therapy bill should not stop ‘healthy and challenging family conversations’ Children's tsar

486 replies

IwantToRetire · 12/11/2026 21:21

Dame Rachel de Souza told The Telegraph that the Government’s legislation to outlaw conversion therapy must not “impact healthy and challenging family conversations”.

Dame Rachel said that while she supported the aims of the bill, she was keen to see that it did not impinge on conversations within the family.

“I know young people face abuse and coercion because of their sexuality or gender, and I support the Government’s aim to ban harmful practices,” she said.

“This is complex and sensitive legislation, and for the bill to be effective, it is important it doesn’t impact healthy and challenging family conversations and aligns with existing measures in place to protect children from cruelty.”

Full article https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/12/trans-conversion-law-must-not-silence-parents-children/

And at https://archive.is/QWfdH

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 23:09

JanesLittleGirl · Yesterday 23:06

Lets have a look at what the paper has to say about SNAP.

Whilst initiatives such as SNAP have not necessarily been as effective as originally
intended, in part due to under-funding by the Scottish Government, its launch at
least demonstrated a government taking active steps towards putting human rights
at the heart of policy-making and practice. And in the 2019 evaluation of SNAP,
it is acknowledged that ‘growing support from the First Minister and the Scottish
Parliament generally for Human Rights has been notable in recent years’ (Ferrie,
2019: 61). The realisation of measures, such as national action plans for human
rights, is harder to achieve than the commitment is to make, but Scotland is taking
those initial steps, attempting to navigate through the complicated maze of human
rights compliance and implementation."

Somewhat less than a ringing endorsement isn't it and, as ever with ScotGov, no actual delivery.

Scotgov are worse than the Royal Mail for delivering. I mean, even the GLP have a better record of results. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Transperson · Yesterday 23:10

JanesLittleGirl · Yesterday 23:06

Lets have a look at what the paper has to say about SNAP.

Whilst initiatives such as SNAP have not necessarily been as effective as originally
intended, in part due to under-funding by the Scottish Government, its launch at
least demonstrated a government taking active steps towards putting human rights
at the heart of policy-making and practice. And in the 2019 evaluation of SNAP,
it is acknowledged that ‘growing support from the First Minister and the Scottish
Parliament generally for Human Rights has been notable in recent years’ (Ferrie,
2019: 61). The realisation of measures, such as national action plans for human
rights, is harder to achieve than the commitment is to make, but Scotland is taking
those initial steps, attempting to navigate through the complicated maze of human
rights compliance and implementation."

Somewhat less than a ringing endorsement isn't it and, as ever with ScotGov, no actual delivery.

Have you read the conclusion? It's definitely very positive on Scottish attitudes to law and human rights.

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 23:12

Transperson · Yesterday 23:10

Have you read the conclusion? It's definitely very positive on Scottish attitudes to law and human rights.

Are you using the actual meaning of positive or is this another word you’re er…. Expanding the meaning of? Like when you claimed to be female cos hormones gave you breasts 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 23:14

Transperson · Yesterday 23:10

Have you read the conclusion? It's definitely very positive on Scottish attitudes to law and human rights.

Showing your naivity now. If it wasn't already apparent.

JanesLittleGirl · Yesterday 23:18

Transperson · Yesterday 23:10

Have you read the conclusion? It's definitely very positive on Scottish attitudes to law and human rights.

Yes, I have read the conclusion. It's positive but doesn't point to any demonstrable differences in human rights legislation between Scotland and England.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 23:21

Transperson · Yesterday 23:01

For social purposes it is definitely changeable.

Ah. So in the times when we apply social constructs on top of the sex of the body, those social constructs are arbitrarily appplied to one sec or the other and are therefore changeable.

I agree. We call that stuff sexism.

Which is why Gender Critical Feminists generally disapprove of it.

Not, to be clear, that we approve of the constructs but not the changing - what we disapprove of is society applying these arbitrary social constructs on top of sex in the first place.

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · Yesterday 23:53

Transperson · Yesterday 20:09

I am not breaking the law, I am not a service provider. And if I was I would have provided gender neutral toilets.

Are you absolutely 100% sure that you would not be breaking the law?

If you are wrong it could mean 3 months in nick in a men's prison:
www.cps.gov.uk/prosecution-guidance/trespass-and-nuisance-land

Conversion therapy bill should not stop ‘healthy and challenging family conversations’ Children's tsar
Conversion therapy bill should not stop ‘healthy and challenging family conversations’ Children's tsar
Transperson · Today 00:43

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · Yesterday 23:53

Are you absolutely 100% sure that you would not be breaking the law?

If you are wrong it could mean 3 months in nick in a men's prison:
www.cps.gov.uk/prosecution-guidance/trespass-and-nuisance-land

Lmao trespassing isn't criminal unless one is being asked to leave from the permises and they refuse.

I never had someone challenge me let alone have the owners or someone authorised by the owners ask me to leave.

BlueLegume · Today 07:19

Transperson · Today 00:43

Lmao trespassing isn't criminal unless one is being asked to leave from the permises and they refuse.

I never had someone challenge me let alone have the owners or someone authorised by the owners ask me to leave.

Do you know what thread title you are actually commenting on? Or is this just another way for you to pass time @Transperson

All you do is talk about yourself and nitpick silly points that do nothing other than show you for the chauvinist you are. Just because ‘no one’ has ever asked you to leave somewhere does not mean people were comfortable with your presence. You seem to think it is your ‘right’ to impose your ‘gender identity’ on people and their rights mean nothing.

To quote from another thread …..

When one group’s ‘rights’ require another group to surrender privacy, fairness, or conscience, the conflict is no longer about equality. It is about power.”

Start your own thread.

borntobequiet · Today 08:39

Transperson · Yesterday 22:41

One example out of pages and pages about this:

"Scotland has introduced policies that seek to ensure human rights play a vital rolein strategic decisions at the highest levels of devolved government. In 2013, forexample, the Scottish Government launched its National Action Plan for HumanRights (SNAP), in keeping with international best practice. Human Rights ActionPlans seek to ensure ‘that areas of social policy such as education, health, poverty,and social security are framed through the lens of human rights and that variousnational policies are in line with human rights-based approaches to development’(Chalabi, 2018). SNAP, therefore, represented a commitment from a variety ofsectors, including government, civil society and public authorities, to apply ahuman rights based approach within governance and decision-making."

Gosh, an Action Plan, how effective.

nicepotoftea · Today 08:49

Transperson · Yesterday 23:01

For social purposes it is definitely changeable.

It really isn't.

Where are all the campaigns for a handicap system so that women who identify as men can take part in competitive men's sport?

Where are all the women claiming that because they sometimes wear trousers they should be accepted on dating apps for gay men?

Transperson · Today 13:22

nicepotoftea · Today 08:49

It really isn't.

Where are all the campaigns for a handicap system so that women who identify as men can take part in competitive men's sport?

Where are all the women claiming that because they sometimes wear trousers they should be accepted on dating apps for gay men?

For sports it's more complicated and isn't a one to one comparison. Id rather we focus on more relevant points

We both know that changing what you wear isn't enough to change your precieved sex, HRT does affect your secondary sex characteristics.

nicepotoftea · Today 13:29

Transperson · Today 13:22

For sports it's more complicated and isn't a one to one comparison. Id rather we focus on more relevant points

We both know that changing what you wear isn't enough to change your precieved sex, HRT does affect your secondary sex characteristics.

If it's the taking part and not the winning that matters, why wouldn't a handicap system be the perfect answer?

Id rather we focus on more relevant points

Relevant to what? The subject of the thread? Or does it get boring when people aren't discussing men's rights?

Shedmistress · Today 13:32

I think the reason they deliberately spell words wrong to annoy people reading is the same reason that these men will just keep on using female spaces, they know the effects and that is all part of the delight.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 13:35

Shedmistress · Today 13:32

I think the reason they deliberately spell words wrong to annoy people reading is the same reason that these men will just keep on using female spaces, they know the effects and that is all part of the delight.

Like spelling "woman" M-A-L-E

Transperson · Today 13:37

Shedmistress · Today 13:32

I think the reason they deliberately spell words wrong to annoy people reading is the same reason that these men will just keep on using female spaces, they know the effects and that is all part of the delight.

That's a funny concept, that I am not actually dyslexic for the sake of influencing language.

Unfortunately im dyslexic.

Transperson · Today 13:38

nicepotoftea · Today 13:29

If it's the taking part and not the winning that matters, why wouldn't a handicap system be the perfect answer?

Id rather we focus on more relevant points

Relevant to what? The subject of the thread? Or does it get boring when people aren't discussing men's rights?

I replied originally in the context of the thread.

Don't derail the thread and then be upset I'm responding.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 13:40

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 13:35

Like spelling "woman" M-A-L-E

😂

nicepotoftea · Today 13:43

Transperson · Today 13:38

I replied originally in the context of the thread.

Don't derail the thread and then be upset I'm responding.

Apologies. I must have missed the point you made that was relevant.

Transperson · Today 13:44

nicepotoftea · Today 13:43

Apologies. I must have missed the point you made that was relevant.

Nws

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · Today 17:00

Transperson · Today 00:43

Lmao trespassing isn't criminal unless one is being asked to leave from the permises and they refuse.

I never had someone challenge me let alone have the owners or someone authorised by the owners ask me to leave.

I never had someone challenge me let alone have the owners or someone authorised by the owners ask me to leave.

There's always a first time.

Employers and Service Providers have got rather twitchy about being taken to court for being in breach of the EA2010, which is why so many private sector companies have been quick off the mark to change their policies and ban men from women's single-sex spaces. Public sector bodies have dragged their heels but are following suit.

There have been several cases of men being banned from entering whole town centres because they kept going into Ladies Toilets. Nice photos of the creeps in the local press too.

Up to you if you still want to annoy and intimidate women but your brain is stuck in 2016. It's 2026 now and things have changed.

Remember, up to 3 months in a men's prison if you have misjudged the risk you are taking.

Miss Piggy Waiting GIF by Muppet Wiki
Transperson · Today 17:01

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · Today 17:00

I never had someone challenge me let alone have the owners or someone authorised by the owners ask me to leave.

There's always a first time.

Employers and Service Providers have got rather twitchy about being taken to court for being in breach of the EA2010, which is why so many private sector companies have been quick off the mark to change their policies and ban men from women's single-sex spaces. Public sector bodies have dragged their heels but are following suit.

There have been several cases of men being banned from entering whole town centres because they kept going into Ladies Toilets. Nice photos of the creeps in the local press too.

Up to you if you still want to annoy and intimidate women but your brain is stuck in 2016. It's 2026 now and things have changed.

Remember, up to 3 months in a men's prison if you have misjudged the risk you are taking.

Shall we find out? I am waiting.

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · Today 17:04

Transperson · Today 17:01

Shall we find out? I am waiting.

You need to set a date, time and place and give enough notice for us to call the cops. About a week ahead should be enough time.

Transperson · Today 17:07

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · Today 17:04

You need to set a date, time and place and give enough notice for us to call the cops. About a week ahead should be enough time.

Nah, because you can always tell right?
How many more years since the SCJ do you think?

Been a year and a half so far. No issues.

Transperson · Today 17:08

Transperson · Today 13:38

I replied originally in the context of the thread.

Don't derail the thread and then be upset I'm responding.

Actually might be fun to test this, I'll give you a date and an hour long time frame, if you know it's me then I'll wait for the pigs with you 😌