Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 18:47

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/11/2026 18:45

Non zero chance of that happening, it would be a great power play, except now he’d definitely be staying in the men’s, thanks to KPSS and FWS.

In the UK yes, thankfully. But any other country and he'd be straight in. After all, long hair and v necks.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/11/2026 18:48

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 18:47

In the UK yes, thankfully. But any other country and he'd be straight in. After all, long hair and v necks.

Absolutely.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:48

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 18:44

What if they are liars and predators?

If Russell Brand said 'I'm a lady' are you for him being put in a female prison?

I think Russel Brand is a rapist. I'm not usually one for the politics of revenge but I was very happy to see him convicted, because I believe that trial and that conviction are so important for women. These are the issues that actually matter for women's equality, consent, protection from violence etc.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 18:48

Ah, and I see we are also again ignoring that a trans identity is not simply "this is who I am", but also "and that means I am like you whether you agree with that or not".

The first I have no issues wth, It is the second that IMO violates the stated principle that people’s own accounts of who they are and how they experience themselves should carry greater weight than someone else’s external assessment of them

It's the difference between Sally Smith saying she wants to be called Starchild Smith because that suits her better, and Sally Smith saying she wants to be called Sally Jones because she believes her true self is the Jones' daughter not the Smiths, and then demanding the Jones give her a bedroom in their house. The Jones get a say here as well.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/11/2026 18:49

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:48

I think Russel Brand is a rapist. I'm not usually one for the politics of revenge but I was very happy to see him convicted, because I believe that trial and that conviction are so important for women. These are the issues that actually matter for women's equality, consent, protection from violence etc.

If he said he was a woman tomorrow and demanded she/her pronouns, you’d accept it, wouldn’t you?

Catiette · 07/11/2026 18:51

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:42

I think people’s own accounts of who they are and how they experience themselves should carry greater weight than someone else’s external assessment of them. This isn’t a principle I reserve for this particular issue; it’s one I apply generally. I think there’s something fundamentally wrong with presuming to tell another person who they are. And I think it becomes intolerable when someone tells you, “This is the reality of my experience,” and your response is effectively, “No, it isn’t. You’re a fake/ pretending.” Or "well you must be deluded because that doesn't fit how I like to classify things in boxes".

I think people’s own accounts of who they are and how they experience themselves should carry greater weight than someone else’s external assessment of them. This isn’t a principle I reserve for this particular issue; it’s one I apply generally. I think there’s something fundamentally wrong with presuming to tell another person who they are. And I think it becomes intolerable when someone tells you, “This is the reality of my experience,” and your response is effectively, “No, it isn’t. You’re a fake/ pretending.”

OK, sod it. I didn't want to torture people with the below again - am worried I'm dominating the thread a bit, so scrolling on by recommended if you feel that way! - but the presumption of ethical superiority on this basis is so facile it drives me up the wall.

This is my earlier post on this kind of thing, Lacksie. It is wordy - I get a bit verbose when exercised about something (am working on it), so feel free to AI it for a shortened version.

Coming to this late, I'm aware, but this and the fact/opinion debate got me thinking.

So if it's a matter of "competing interests in a shared space" (which I agree it is, though I'd say "boundaries" form a part of the competing interests), then the next step's got to be to assess the relative merits of the opposing sides. And this means opinions, but... opinions are founded on facts. An opinion untethered from any material foundation, just floating free, can be such a dangerous thing.
Take the always-popular analogy of racial segregation, teetering precariously on the unfounded conviction that certain races are fundamentally inferior (intellectually, ethically, physically even). The friction of any empty construct like racism rubs up against the evidence - facts - of reality to generate a furious heat that's reflected in the ideological energy of its supporters. You'll always be frustrated trying to balance an impossible equation - and the harder you fight, the harder reality will fight back. If we take a positive view of the overall march of human history in this sense, the scales of justice tend to steady and rebalance over time. Black people, gay people and women aren't inferior, and reality won't support the narrative that they are.

But reality itself can change to obscure or expose a lie of inferiority. The mass casualties or WW1 and 2 created the necessity of a female workforce. The pill enabled the continuation and consolidation of women's success in the public sphere. The internet, on the other hand, has enabled the proliferation of degrading narratives previously confined to dusty top shelves.

Meanwhile, meaning-making shifts, too, often in reactive pendulum shifts - the Enlightenment segued into the Romantics... It feels ironic that we're leaving reason behind again right now, at the height of our scientific knowledge, but maybe that also makes a kind of sick sense. We've reached a point of sufficient privilege that we - in the affluent West, at least - are sufficiently cosseted from the limitations of our physical reality (we have food and shelter, and our bodies can be managed and mitigated to a greater degree than even before) that we at last have the time, space and freedom to choose to (believe we can) construct reality itself: post-modernism rulz OK. And why wouldn't we want to construct reality, after all? Consciousness - meaning-making - is what makes us human.

The truth, though, is that whatever we do or say, or think or believe, there will always remain an undeniable concrete reality that can't be changed, and it will always be a frightening one. We're all dying, women are physically weaker, the universe is hostile and indifferent. We can't change these facts, we can only pretend to. And the paradox is that the harder we pretend, the harder reality will bite back, and the more vulnerable to it we'll be. Global warming - the product of the mass delusion that we can keep living as comfortably as we are. Mass communication, reassuring us that we're connected even as we drift further apart. And, most cruelly of all, the more tech we have, the more vulnerable we are to escapist avoidance and physical catastrophe - ancient subsistence farmers would be far better equipped to face what's probably coming than humanity is now.

And that's where I see the difference between the respective pulls of the sex- and gender- based arguments. One is absolutely, indisputably concrete, while the other, while very real in a way - perception is everything in a sense; where would humans be without their own construction of reality? - must inevitably give way to the other. The pendulum swings back, the scales rebalance, and physical reality reasserts itself over the lie, however appealing that lie may be.

The tragedy is that a comforting narrative - of ass-kicking female superheroes, or TWAW, does better if it's less aggressively asserted, as it doesn't then generate the same strength of inevitable opposing force. Social constructs can rub along together quite nicely with minimal friction as long as they don't cut into each other, like the appropriately violent Progress flag chevron into gay and lesbian rights. This is complex, too - the MRA argument that, "You asked for equality, and you got it!" is a distortion of it, as the push and pull of gendered power dynamics continue. But when trans ideology seeks to cut up reality itself...?

Maslow had it down, really. The solid foundation of his pyramid of needs will always be there - the demands of our physical reality. Everything else built on top of it is precariously reliant on what's below.

So yes, I think sex supersedes gender. Regardless which way the winds of social constructs blow, the reality of facts, evidence, necessity, scale, and the laws of physics will endure.

Single sex spaces may be a construct, but whereas racial segregation is the product of empty prejudice, single-sex spaces acknowledge something true and necessary and entirely distinct from warped value judgements (at least outside the frightened noise of the manosphere).

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 18:53

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:48

I think Russel Brand is a rapist. I'm not usually one for the politics of revenge but I was very happy to see him convicted, because I believe that trial and that conviction are so important for women. These are the issues that actually matter for women's equality, consent, protection from violence etc.

But if his theory of mind makes him open his mouth and say he was a woman you'd be on here calling him she/her and doing everything you could to get him into female spaces.

You either know he is a man or you don't, otherwise you are gatekeeping.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:54

Veilsofmorning · 07/11/2026 18:46

That’s your interpretation and belief- you still can’t know it. My interpretation at the time (and now) and in the context at that time was and still is, different to yours, but no less valid, arguably more so perhaps, because made at the time. You are not a mind reader, so your interpretation will be biased by what you want to believe, but you can still only believe, not know. Neither can I, and perhaps I’m biased as well, but you can’t claim that you know for certain what he meant, especially relying on written text where several layers of meaning are absent.

Again.

What DU said when questioned was several things:

That patient consent is of the utmost importance.

That a patient can request a different doctor for any reason at all; that is entirely legitimate and must be respected.

That she would always respect a patient’s wishes if they said they were uncomfortable being treated by her.

That if a patient requested a female doctor, she wouldn’t automatically assume they meant they didn’t want to be treated by a trans woman.

That she is not required to disclose her own medical history to patients.

People are furious about the fourth one, and that is where theory of mind comes in — the capacity to grasp that other people’s beliefs and perspectives differ from your own. I understand that your definition of ‘female’ excludes trans women. Many people don’t share that definition. DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality, and it’s the reality from which she answered the question
She wasn’t saying it’s fine to treat a patient without consent or against their wishes. She was saying that, to her, a request for a female doctor wouldn’t automatically mean the patient was refusing her — and that if the patient made clear they were, she would step aside. Nobody gets treated against their wishes under what she described. The disagreement isn’t about consent. It’s about what a request for a female doctor means — and that’s a definitional argument.

No patient has ever accused DU of treating them without consent. There has been no finding of misconduct against her of any kind.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 18:55

“how many complaints have their been of this nature in the NHS? It would be interested to review and see. I'm not aware of any.”

Considering the public abuse women and girls get from making a complaint of this nature, why would you put women in the situation?

Plus again, if a female feels they had no choice but to accept a male person, they are not likely to complain. I know a woman in Australia who is not about to complain when she had a male person arrive after being very clear she asked for a female health care provider for an intimate procedure. Her CPTSD was triggered and she will never make that complaint

But sure, dismiss it as an issue because female people will not likely complain. That looks like victim blaming behaviour to me.

Women concerned and worried = no complaints = no issues.

Thanks again for showing how much female people are centred in your belief.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:57

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 18:53

But if his theory of mind makes him open his mouth and say he was a woman you'd be on here calling him she/her and doing everything you could to get him into female spaces.

You either know he is a man or you don't, otherwise you are gatekeeping.

This is such a stupid argument.
Russell Brand is not trans and trans people are not responsible for his crimes. It's a totally red herring.

Furthermore; If Russell brand claimed tomorrow is was autistic (or any other condition) and therefore had to have special accommodations in prison I'd call bullshit.
Not because autism isn't real, or that I'm "gatekeeping autism". My DD is autistic.

Coatsoff42 · 07/11/2026 18:57

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/11/2026 18:39

This is nonsense. He said, under oath, that he felt entitled to treat a patient who had asked for a female doctor. He is not female, and whatever self interested guff he comes out with, he knows that full well. “Theory of mind” my arse.

Yes I think he was asked ‘if a female patient asked for a female doctor would you go and treat them’ and he said ‘yes.’
Consent my arse, him turning up and expecting the sick and vulnerable patient who has been clear enough from the outset to then have to go through an HR nightmare to get a female doctor.

Totallygripped · 07/11/2026 18:59

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:44

I'm calling DU "she" because I believe that when I refer to someone else, I should use language that is respectful to that person and compatible with their dignity and express wishes of how to be addressed.

Im using "their" for the patients , as there is no specific individual patient being referred to, but patients in general as a group.

How was your post about how Sandie Peggie's legal proceedings are being funded compatible with that respectful approach? "That nurse". Because nurses should stick to their "station"?

Catiette · 07/11/2026 19:00

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:54

Again.

What DU said when questioned was several things:

That patient consent is of the utmost importance.

That a patient can request a different doctor for any reason at all; that is entirely legitimate and must be respected.

That she would always respect a patient’s wishes if they said they were uncomfortable being treated by her.

That if a patient requested a female doctor, she wouldn’t automatically assume they meant they didn’t want to be treated by a trans woman.

That she is not required to disclose her own medical history to patients.

People are furious about the fourth one, and that is where theory of mind comes in — the capacity to grasp that other people’s beliefs and perspectives differ from your own. I understand that your definition of ‘female’ excludes trans women. Many people don’t share that definition. DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality, and it’s the reality from which she answered the question
She wasn’t saying it’s fine to treat a patient without consent or against their wishes. She was saying that, to her, a request for a female doctor wouldn’t automatically mean the patient was refusing her — and that if the patient made clear they were, she would step aside. Nobody gets treated against their wishes under what she described. The disagreement isn’t about consent. It’s about what a request for a female doctor means — and that’s a definitional argument.

No patient has ever accused DU of treating them without consent. There has been no finding of misconduct against her of any kind.

That she would always respect a patient’s wishes if they said they were uncomfortable being treated by her.

But also that, to "say" this, they would have to overturn their own perception of reality and language, to adopt their doctor's. Regardless of theirs being the more common. Ignoring the power dynamics inherent in the situation. Disregarding that they may not even have the knowledge or language necessary to do this.

What does that say for Dr Upton's "theory of mind", Lacksie? For your own?

Yes, there's a clash of rights, here, I can acknowledge that, to some degree.

Why do you come down on the side of the treating clinician with the access to the knowledge and vocabulary to mitigate this conflict of rights, rather than the possible victim of abuse (not unlikely) seeking potentially life-saving treatment (not unlikely), who may not even have access to the understanding you say is necessary to make this request? Whose own experience of the world may be automatically subsumed into the doctor's against their consent and potentially without their knowledge as a result?

That judgement call demonstrates your belief in the primacy of one way of seeing the world over another. Of one individual over another. In a, to me, quite damningly revealing context.

And that's the conflict you've still not addressed.

That's what really interests me here. I'm still not clear on how you justify this with reference to the conflict of interest here, the different circumstances of those involved (as I outline above) and the potential of this attitude to degrade important social contracts in other areas.

As Rhinos(? sorry - phone call and no time to check) says upthread, it feels (something like) theory of mind for me but not for thee.

ScrollingLeaves · 07/11/2026 19:05

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:54

Again.

What DU said when questioned was several things:

That patient consent is of the utmost importance.

That a patient can request a different doctor for any reason at all; that is entirely legitimate and must be respected.

That she would always respect a patient’s wishes if they said they were uncomfortable being treated by her.

That if a patient requested a female doctor, she wouldn’t automatically assume they meant they didn’t want to be treated by a trans woman.

That she is not required to disclose her own medical history to patients.

People are furious about the fourth one, and that is where theory of mind comes in — the capacity to grasp that other people’s beliefs and perspectives differ from your own. I understand that your definition of ‘female’ excludes trans women. Many people don’t share that definition. DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality, and it’s the reality from which she answered the question
She wasn’t saying it’s fine to treat a patient without consent or against their wishes. She was saying that, to her, a request for a female doctor wouldn’t automatically mean the patient was refusing her — and that if the patient made clear they were, she would step aside. Nobody gets treated against their wishes under what she described. The disagreement isn’t about consent. It’s about what a request for a female doctor means — and that’s a definitional argument.

No patient has ever accused DU of treating them without consent. There has been no finding of misconduct against her of any kind.

It would either be coercing the patient to spell out that they did not want “her” which would feel very uncomfortable for the patient because,

a. the patient could feel it might be construed as rude and a personal attack on Dr U.
b. the patient might feel it could lead to a black mark against them ( the patient) and lead to lesser treatment or consideration.

or, if by any chance the weak vulnerable patient did not realise Dr U was a male by birth, but they had previously asked for female only care, then the patient would be being gaslighted by Dr U and the hospital.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 19:05

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:54

Again.

What DU said when questioned was several things:

That patient consent is of the utmost importance.

That a patient can request a different doctor for any reason at all; that is entirely legitimate and must be respected.

That she would always respect a patient’s wishes if they said they were uncomfortable being treated by her.

That if a patient requested a female doctor, she wouldn’t automatically assume they meant they didn’t want to be treated by a trans woman.

That she is not required to disclose her own medical history to patients.

People are furious about the fourth one, and that is where theory of mind comes in — the capacity to grasp that other people’s beliefs and perspectives differ from your own. I understand that your definition of ‘female’ excludes trans women. Many people don’t share that definition. DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality, and it’s the reality from which she answered the question
She wasn’t saying it’s fine to treat a patient without consent or against their wishes. She was saying that, to her, a request for a female doctor wouldn’t automatically mean the patient was refusing her — and that if the patient made clear they were, she would step aside. Nobody gets treated against their wishes under what she described. The disagreement isn’t about consent. It’s about what a request for a female doctor means — and that’s a definitional argument.

No patient has ever accused DU of treating them without consent. There has been no finding of misconduct against her of any kind.

This.

Coatsoff42 · 07/11/2026 19:05

The world has plenty of people who’s self perception is crazy, and its generally not an issue until they run around with a machete or drive a van over someone. There’s a limit to accepting someone’s self perception as being accurate. Even that they think they are hilariously funny is clearly not true half the time. Lacksie, you must tie yourself in knots going along with the nonsense people believe about themselves.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 19:06

ScrollingLeaves · 07/11/2026 19:05

It would either be coercing the patient to spell out that they did not want “her” which would feel very uncomfortable for the patient because,

a. the patient could feel it might be construed as rude and a personal attack on Dr U.
b. the patient might feel it could lead to a black mark against them ( the patient) and lead to lesser treatment or consideration.

or, if by any chance the weak vulnerable patient did not realise Dr U was a male by birth, but they had previously asked for female only care, then the patient would be being gaslighted by Dr U and the hospital.

But also that, to "say" this, they would have to overturn their own perception of reality and language, to adopt their doctor's

No! She's saying that you can't assume that's what the patient would mean either. You are assuming that because it's how you feel, but other people have different perspectives and realities.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 19:09

Sorry I quoted the wrong poster

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 19:09

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 18:53

But if his theory of mind makes him open his mouth and say he was a woman you'd be on here calling him she/her and doing everything you could to get him into female spaces.

You either know he is a man or you don't, otherwise you are gatekeeping.

Sorry to be pedantic, it's not his theory of mind there. Theory of mind is a posh phrase for realising that other people's knowledge and perception can be different from ones own and being able to think about what they know and might therefore be expected to think or do.

The canonical example is to have something on the table in front of an adult and child, have the adult leave the room and put the thing in a box, then ask the child "If I asked [the adult] where the thing is now, what would they say?"

On the table -> Child has developed a theory of mind. They can think what the adult would be aware of and conclude the adult would say the table even though it's different knowledge to that of the child

In the box - > Child has not yet developed a theory of mind. They don't understand the adult has a separate consciousness and awareness to themselves.

So, the relevent theory of mind here is (a) Lacksie's, who would accept that RB might believe he is female because of some perception in his mind even though she knows he is not, or (b) everyone else's, who could recognise that RB may for his own reasons be claiming a female identity despite knowing he is not female because he knows they know they can't see inside his head. (Higher order theories of mind - "If I know that you know that I know that you know, then..." - are correlated with high IQ BTW)

Oh darn, I guess that also include's RB's theory of mind that allows him to claim he feels a certain way and that others cannot verify or disprove it. So @Shedmistress you were right all along! But I like this post so I'm posting it anyway 😂

Fun fact - Theory of Mind is a prerequisite to being able to lie.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 19:10

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 17:49

It's got nothing whatsoever to do with "consent". It's about balancing competing needs/ interests/ wants in a public space.

And there you show you really don’t understand safeguarding principles again.

Why are those provisions segregated by sex at all if safeguarding principles are not at the very core of the decision?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 19:12

So, amid all the waffle, has anyone yet explained why a male doctor's self image means female nurses have to undress in front of him?

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 19:13

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 19:10

And there you show you really don’t understand safeguarding principles again.

Why are those provisions segregated by sex at all if safeguarding principles are not at the very core of the decision?

Why are you conflating "consent" and "safeguarding".
Also, no , I don't accept your premise that this conversation is about "safeguarding ".

Veilsofmorning · 07/11/2026 19:13

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 19:06

But also that, to "say" this, they would have to overturn their own perception of reality and language, to adopt their doctor's

No! She's saying that you can't assume that's what the patient would mean either. You are assuming that because it's how you feel, but other people have different perspectives and realities.

Which is exactly what you won’t admit in other posts - really Lacksie, you’re slipping even more than before

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 19:16

There was an old man who said "God
Must find it exceedingly odd
That a doctor from Fife
Spends so much of his life
Insisting he's of female bod"

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 19:20

Anyone reading ‘they might be accused of transphobia but they shouldn’t’ and think of Claire Dimyon and Teresa Steele and think, there is some ignorance being shown with that statement.

https://archive.ph/AiK

And consent is an essential part of safeguarding. It is indeed an important part of the discussion. rather ignorant to deny it.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread