Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 12:02

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:57

It is proven science.

How do you know? You don't have the lived experience of a male person who thinks he's a female person so you are not allowed to comment on the science right? According to your own logic that is..

Edited

More philosophising.

Great job. Keep going. You do more to discredit your self identified spokesperson role than any of us here.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 12:03

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 12:00

DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality, and it’s the reality from which she answered the question

Of course he doesn't think he is female.

Nobody think he is female.

She does. She's a trans woman, that is her reality. I appreciate this is hard for you to imagine or understand because it's not an experience you can personally relate to.

MyAmpleSheep · 07/11/2026 12:04

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:52

Just like no other person should be able to discredit any other person’s claim to be transgender.

Also this. Your entire philosophy is founded on the premise that we can and must discredit another person's claim to be female!!!

Only the men. The ones who aren’t female. Because female isn’t a feeling in a man’s head.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 12:06

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 12:02

More philosophising.

Great job. Keep going. You do more to discredit your self identified spokesperson role than any of us here.

Not a spokesperson. Just someone who understands the science.

StealthTroublemaker · 07/11/2026 12:06

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:57

It is proven science.

How do you know? You don't have the lived experience of a male person who thinks he's a female person so you are not allowed to comment on the science right? According to your own logic that is..

Edited

But if sex is sooooo complicated as you have pointed out (repeatedly) 🙄🙄🙄. How does this male person come to think he is female? What criteria is he using to determine he is not male? All he has is his idea of what a female “should” be, but that is different for everyone according to you as it just relies on inner feelings. So in your opinion, how are you defining female in such a way that a male person can believe he is one?

MyAmpleSheep · 07/11/2026 12:07

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 12:03

She does. She's a trans woman, that is her reality. I appreciate this is hard for you to imagine or understand because it's not an experience you can personally relate to.

If his reality is that he’s female and honestly, really and truly can’t see that he isn’t, I submit that’s disqualifying for evidence-based careers like medicine.

StealthTroublemaker · 07/11/2026 12:07

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 12:06

Not a spokesperson. Just someone who understands the science.

But you don’t though. You are using philosophy instead of science. Which ok technically is a science, but not in the way you are representing it.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 07/11/2026 12:08

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:55

and who possesses the capacity to be pregnant

Oh dear.

😅
That's the uncomfortable one isn't it Lacks?

While you rush around here tilting at windmills, facts and biology carry on unchanged. Only women gestate and birth babies - no matter how much mooing is done about "trans demands".
As a result society will continue to return to safeguarding the vulnerable, recognising sex as binary and dismissing those seeking to foist their delusionary thinking on others.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 12:09

StealthTroublemaker · 07/11/2026 12:06

But if sex is sooooo complicated as you have pointed out (repeatedly) 🙄🙄🙄. How does this male person come to think he is female? What criteria is he using to determine he is not male? All he has is his idea of what a female “should” be, but that is different for everyone according to you as it just relies on inner feelings. So in your opinion, how are you defining female in such a way that a male person can believe he is one?

We've been through this, there's no "criteria" its not a reasoned judgement based on comparing one's experience against a set of criteria.

Body recognition doesn't work like that - it's a pre-reflective, non-conceptual type of cognition that stands entirely apart from conscious knowing.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 12:14

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 12:06

Not a spokesperson. Just someone who understands the science.

No. If you ‘understood’ the science you would be able to articulate clearly without it being reliant on circular logic and subjective reality being treated as being material reality.

You don’t have ‘science’ to support your arguments.

Oh. Sorry. ‘Science’ of course is a destabilised term that also can mean anything anyone wants it to mean. Therefore you can confidently make a claim using your own definitions and
the majority of people will be left wondering what the fuck you mean.

Discussion is meaningless in these instances.

StealthTroublemaker · 07/11/2026 12:14

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 12:09

We've been through this, there's no "criteria" its not a reasoned judgement based on comparing one's experience against a set of criteria.

Body recognition doesn't work like that - it's a pre-reflective, non-conceptual type of cognition that stands entirely apart from conscious knowing.

Nah mate. You’re talking gubbins now. So according to you, female is whatever anyone thinks it is? So there are no sex classes? Just “human”. No worries. In that case, you’ve just erased transpeople. Well done!! If female and male mean nothing, transpeople cannot transition can they? Seems a bit transphobic to me but you do you boo.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 12:17

This discussion is about consent and it is very enlightening to see how the use of language which has been said to be not negatively impacted has led to consent discussions being now about meanings of common use reference terms to be able to even understand whether consent is given or not.

As has been said by several posters over the past weeks regarding this situation with Upton, these discussions point to a major weakness in safeguarding principles.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 12:21

If someone walks into my home and tells me it's their home now, it may because they are a criminal breaking in, or because they mistakenly think I stole it from them and they are simply righting that wrong, or because they have a very genuine perception that it is and always has been their home and that I have always been happy to share it with them.

These diferences are very important to their experience, and possibly even legal defense.

However, it is still my home. And neither my right to my home, nor society's ability to put protections and laws in place to prevent breakign and entering, home invasion, cuckooing or squatting, are contingent on first understanding all the various reasons one person may demand the home of another, nor on whether some of the people so doing have the genuine perception their demand is justified.

It's very telling that all the concern is towards making sure we properly understand something before we are allowed to consider the impact on other people and none towards the experiences and self knowledge of the other people being utilised during this holding pattern.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 12:21

MyAmpleSheep · 07/11/2026 12:07

If his reality is that he’s female and honestly, really and truly can’t see that he isn’t, I submit that’s disqualifying for evidence-based careers like medicine.

Edited

I would agree.

If a person cannot differentiate their subjective reality from material reality (when there is no material reality as a base to that subjective reality) and has no personal understanding that their personal subjective reality should not be that one that female patients have to understand to communicate clearly, I would suggest that practicising as a medical provider is not appropriate.

Totallygripped · 07/11/2026 12:25

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 12:09

We've been through this, there's no "criteria" its not a reasoned judgement based on comparing one's experience against a set of criteria.

Body recognition doesn't work like that - it's a pre-reflective, non-conceptual type of cognition that stands entirely apart from conscious knowing.

I see we're moving on from theory of mind to philosophy of mind.

Catiette · 07/11/2026 12:28

As I understand it, Lacksie's saying the following:

A) Material reality is complex for two reasons: a) there will always be exceptions to common rules and patterns, and b) we can only ever experience it through individual human consciousness and perception.

B) On this basis, defining objective meaning is, in the case of sex and female consent in a medical context, fundamentally impossible, and associated safeguarding rules collapse under the weight of this complexity.

Where I think this all falls down is in Lacksie's extrapolation of B) from A). After all, this philosophy of indefinable complexity and the paramouncy of subjective reality is applicable to pretty much everything! So what I've not yet seen from Lacksie or others is anything approaching a convincing assessment of why it should be applied in this case, and not in other cases.

For example, Lacksie says:

"The pp's hypothetical depends on the assumption that everyone has the same understanding of these terms - male and female - as she does: what they mean and how they should be applied. But they don't. That's the entire point... DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality..."

This is explicit and emphatic. Could Lacksie explain then, in the light of this,

  1. How clinical trials exploring how best to preserve life and health on a global scale with necessary reference to sex difference can be ethically and meaningfully administered?

  2. How a doctor should (for example) administer drugs such as ambien or morphine, or appropriate sex-specific treatment if required, to a) an unconscious patient or b) someone with Dr Upton's self-perception?

Next, if Lacksie feels that the objective reality of biological sex does indeed supercede self-perception in these contexts, I'd ask,

  1. How does one consistently and ethically distinguish between those instances in which self-perception does override objective reality, and those in which it doesn't?

  2. How does one present a sufficiently strong argument for these exceptions?

For example, Lacksie's clear that the sheet complexity of determining an objective reality (A) above) renders female patients' right to request and receive (given availability) a female clinician impossible to meet, or, at the least, effectively moot.

How, then, can this argument be made sufficiently strongly such that it unambiguously overrides the arguments others would certainly make for their own self-perception to be paramount at the expense of others? Consider, as examples:

  • a white supremicist
  • someone clinically depressed (the assisted dying debate)
  • a parent convinced their child has ADHD and is entitled to accommodations in examinations despite the commonly accepted (but ever-evolving!) assessment demonstrating otherwise
  • an egregious example of workplace disability discrimination nevertheless being dragged through the courts at immeasurable personal expense because the employer contests it
  • fantasists etc. etc. etc.
  • an infinity of others - take your well-chosen pick!

It will have to be a damn strong argument to counter-act these cases, especially in the light of the answers I find it hard to imagine not being given to 1) and 2), for which I can find no equivalent in scope and import in my above examples.

Lacksie? Alcove?

There was no acknowledgement to my last lengthy post on your side. Understandable in a busy, fast-moving thread, but I'd appreciate a direct and honest response to this one.

Edited to clarify lettering and numbering!

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 12:29

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 12:03

She does. She's a trans woman, that is her reality. I appreciate this is hard for you to imagine or understand because it's not an experience you can personally relate to.

Then he needs a psychiatrist, not acess to vulnerable incapacitated women

MyAmpleSheep · 07/11/2026 12:30

@Lacksie I’ve asked this before, but why should someone’s internal reality that they’re really and truly the opposite sex to their body be taken more seriously than their honest and true internal understanding that they are Cleopatra?

On what basis do you distinguish the two scenarios?

Catiette · 07/11/2026 12:40

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 12:09

We've been through this, there's no "criteria" its not a reasoned judgement based on comparing one's experience against a set of criteria.

Body recognition doesn't work like that - it's a pre-reflective, non-conceptual type of cognition that stands entirely apart from conscious knowing.

Body recognition doesn't work like that - it's a pre-reflective, non-conceptual type of cognition that stands entirely apart from conscious knowing.

Bloody hell, who'd be a medical professional in this litigiously (and literally!) lethal context?

But still - please do respond to my post above. My painstaking letters and numbers are to aid a direct response.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 12:42

Catiette · 07/11/2026 12:28

As I understand it, Lacksie's saying the following:

A) Material reality is complex for two reasons: a) there will always be exceptions to common rules and patterns, and b) we can only ever experience it through individual human consciousness and perception.

B) On this basis, defining objective meaning is, in the case of sex and female consent in a medical context, fundamentally impossible, and associated safeguarding rules collapse under the weight of this complexity.

Where I think this all falls down is in Lacksie's extrapolation of B) from A). After all, this philosophy of indefinable complexity and the paramouncy of subjective reality is applicable to pretty much everything! So what I've not yet seen from Lacksie or others is anything approaching a convincing assessment of why it should be applied in this case, and not in other cases.

For example, Lacksie says:

"The pp's hypothetical depends on the assumption that everyone has the same understanding of these terms - male and female - as she does: what they mean and how they should be applied. But they don't. That's the entire point... DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality..."

This is explicit and emphatic. Could Lacksie explain then, in the light of this,

  1. How clinical trials exploring how best to preserve life and health on a global scale with necessary reference to sex difference can be ethically and meaningfully administered?

  2. How a doctor should (for example) administer drugs such as ambien or morphine, or appropriate sex-specific treatment if required, to a) an unconscious patient or b) someone with Dr Upton's self-perception?

Next, if Lacksie feels that the objective reality of biological sex does indeed supercede self-perception in these contexts, I'd ask,

  1. How does one consistently and ethically distinguish between those instances in which self-perception does override objective reality, and those in which it doesn't?

  2. How does one present a sufficiently strong argument for these exceptions?

For example, Lacksie's clear that the sheet complexity of determining an objective reality (A) above) renders female patients' right to request and receive (given availability) a female clinician impossible to meet, or, at the least, effectively moot.

How, then, can this argument be made sufficiently strongly such that it unambiguously overrides the arguments others would certainly make for their own self-perception to be paramount at the expense of others? Consider, as examples:

  • a white supremicist
  • someone clinically depressed (the assisted dying debate)
  • a parent convinced their child has ADHD and is entitled to accommodations in examinations despite the commonly accepted (but ever-evolving!) assessment demonstrating otherwise
  • an egregious example of workplace disability discrimination nevertheless being dragged through the courts at immeasurable personal expense because the employer contests it
  • fantasists etc. etc. etc.
  • an infinity of others - take your well-chosen pick!

It will have to be a damn strong argument to counter-act these cases, especially in the light of the answers I find it hard to imagine not being given to 1) and 2), for which I can find no equivalent in scope and import in my above examples.

Lacksie? Alcove?

There was no acknowledgement to my last lengthy post on your side. Understandable in a busy, fast-moving thread, but I'd appreciate a direct and honest response to this one.

Edited to clarify lettering and numbering!

Edited

Excellent post, thank you.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 13:11

Catiette · 07/11/2026 12:28

As I understand it, Lacksie's saying the following:

A) Material reality is complex for two reasons: a) there will always be exceptions to common rules and patterns, and b) we can only ever experience it through individual human consciousness and perception.

B) On this basis, defining objective meaning is, in the case of sex and female consent in a medical context, fundamentally impossible, and associated safeguarding rules collapse under the weight of this complexity.

Where I think this all falls down is in Lacksie's extrapolation of B) from A). After all, this philosophy of indefinable complexity and the paramouncy of subjective reality is applicable to pretty much everything! So what I've not yet seen from Lacksie or others is anything approaching a convincing assessment of why it should be applied in this case, and not in other cases.

For example, Lacksie says:

"The pp's hypothetical depends on the assumption that everyone has the same understanding of these terms - male and female - as she does: what they mean and how they should be applied. But they don't. That's the entire point... DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality..."

This is explicit and emphatic. Could Lacksie explain then, in the light of this,

  1. How clinical trials exploring how best to preserve life and health on a global scale with necessary reference to sex difference can be ethically and meaningfully administered?

  2. How a doctor should (for example) administer drugs such as ambien or morphine, or appropriate sex-specific treatment if required, to a) an unconscious patient or b) someone with Dr Upton's self-perception?

Next, if Lacksie feels that the objective reality of biological sex does indeed supercede self-perception in these contexts, I'd ask,

  1. How does one consistently and ethically distinguish between those instances in which self-perception does override objective reality, and those in which it doesn't?

  2. How does one present a sufficiently strong argument for these exceptions?

For example, Lacksie's clear that the sheet complexity of determining an objective reality (A) above) renders female patients' right to request and receive (given availability) a female clinician impossible to meet, or, at the least, effectively moot.

How, then, can this argument be made sufficiently strongly such that it unambiguously overrides the arguments others would certainly make for their own self-perception to be paramount at the expense of others? Consider, as examples:

  • a white supremicist
  • someone clinically depressed (the assisted dying debate)
  • a parent convinced their child has ADHD and is entitled to accommodations in examinations despite the commonly accepted (but ever-evolving!) assessment demonstrating otherwise
  • an egregious example of workplace disability discrimination nevertheless being dragged through the courts at immeasurable personal expense because the employer contests it
  • fantasists etc. etc. etc.
  • an infinity of others - take your well-chosen pick!

It will have to be a damn strong argument to counter-act these cases, especially in the light of the answers I find it hard to imagine not being given to 1) and 2), for which I can find no equivalent in scope and import in my above examples.

Lacksie? Alcove?

There was no acknowledgement to my last lengthy post on your side. Understandable in a busy, fast-moving thread, but I'd appreciate a direct and honest response to this one.

Edited to clarify lettering and numbering!

Edited

It's hard to answer these posts, because you attribute so much that I haven't said.
I have never argued anything resembling this:

"defining objective meaning is, in the case of sex and female consent in a medical context, fundamentally impossible, and associated safeguarding rules collapse under the weight of this complexity"

What makes you think I have?

MyAmpleSheep · 07/11/2026 13:16

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 13:11

It's hard to answer these posts, because you attribute so much that I haven't said.
I have never argued anything resembling this:

"defining objective meaning is, in the case of sex and female consent in a medical context, fundamentally impossible, and associated safeguarding rules collapse under the weight of this complexity"

What makes you think I have?

Many people are trying to do their best to put a sound logical structure behind your posts. You have a habit of making “hit-and-run” points. You don’t thresh out anything you say, you don’t fill any of the obvious gaps, you don’t appear to make any good-faith effort to avoid ambiguity. And when anyone else does any of those things for you, you simply say “that’s not what I said at all, what makes you think it is?”

Your style of engagement is light years beyond plain slippery and evasive.

ScrollingLeaves · 07/11/2026 13:18

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 13:11

It's hard to answer these posts, because you attribute so much that I haven't said.
I have never argued anything resembling this:

"defining objective meaning is, in the case of sex and female consent in a medical context, fundamentally impossible, and associated safeguarding rules collapse under the weight of this complexity"

What makes you think I have?

What you are missing is the implications of what you have said. Maybe that is too vague a word. ‘The consequences’ of what you say, if what you say were taken as the rule, might be clearer.

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 13:20

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 13:11

It's hard to answer these posts, because you attribute so much that I haven't said.
I have never argued anything resembling this:

"defining objective meaning is, in the case of sex and female consent in a medical context, fundamentally impossible, and associated safeguarding rules collapse under the weight of this complexity"

What makes you think I have?

You have said Dr Upton thinks he is a female.

What makes you think this?

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 07/11/2026 13:29

alcovecupboards · 02/11/2026 15:52

Of course it is. She's a vile bigot and has been shown as such. She has done nothing but harm sensible gender criticals in this country by becoming the face of a movement when she's been so openly racist and homophobic.

Here is the vile bigot being vilely bigoted:

Edited because the photo I tried to show, of SP hugging Jennifer Melle, hasn't displayed. Or I've misunderstood how inserting pictures works.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread