Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 18:05

@Catiette

While you write very well and very clearly, it seems one poster has a specific problem with your writing style.

Perhaps you could run it through an AI tool and ask it to rephrase for that poster the same concepts and questions in the most simple, widely understandable way possible?

Of course the poster may still struggle, but at least it would clarify whether (to abuse an ol tech support phrase) the comprehension gap is due to some flaw in your writing style, or an issue between that poster's screen and chair.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:05

Catiette · 07/11/2026 17:53

Thank you.

Regarding the responses, I find 3) interesting. Could you suggest the words such a female patient should use to guard against misunderstanding, being distressingly put on the spot, or being accused of transphobia? Please assume disability and vulnerability, so we're maximising the inclusivity of your response. It would be very interesting to see what you suggest. (Not to mention invaluable to posters who are genuinely anxious about this to the point of, in the case of a minority, I can quite easily believe actually being put off seeking treatment).

Regarding the ones you don't understand, frankly, I'm not entirely convinced by this. You could have a go, at least, or propose what you think I may mean. The quality of your arguments are head and shoulders above the usually visitor arguing for the kind of trans "rights" posters here may find potentially problematic (eg. self-identification as female as a medic), so unless you're relying disproportionately on AI, I'm confident that you can get the gist - or at the least respond, instead of a phrase that closes down engagement, with a question that would help me to move you towards greater understanding.

Edited

Well they might be accused of transphobia, but they shouldn't be, and DU was clear about that herself. A patient has the right to be treated by a doctor she feels comfortable with.

To be honest, I don't really think this hypothetical scenario is actually an issue in practice - how many complaints have their been of this nature in the NHS? It would be interested to review and see. I'm not aware of any.

The only reason we are debating it, is because people were furious with what DU said on the stand under questioning, and have used that to entirely misrepresent her as a doctor - suggesting that she is the sort of Dr that would violate women's consent. There is no evidence for this and this isn't what DU meant when she responded to those questions.

Regarding your other questions, the first couple seem to contain an assumption, that a) birth sex is always a useful/ the most relevant proxy in health contexts (it often is, but sometimes it isn't) and b) that birth sex can't be recorded if we recognise gender. Neither of these assumptions hold.

Question 4 is framed in terms of a contrast between 'self-perception' and 'objective reality' and suggesting that one needs to override the other. I reject this framing - both the contrast between "self perception" and "objective reality" and the idea that they are mutually exclusive or opposing. Both are real, and both can exist and be acknowledged at the same time.

The last question I can't make sense of - what does this mean "that their own (and they would say, equally valid!) self-perception should outweigh current social contracts and legal processes?"

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 07/11/2026 18:08

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 12:36

Go on, give it a go… we are all ears!

Oi! I'm not an ear.

...but that is the level of linguistic obfuscation genderism often resorts to, the deliberate misunderstanding or manipulation of words to mean s0mething other than their plain meaning in context.

Totallygripped · 07/11/2026 18:13

I too am perplexed by the proposition that calling a transwoman "she" does not uncall anyone else "she". I suppose I could insist on being referred to as a cisgender woman but I might anticipate a pile on of...oh, let me think ..."vile bigot transphobe"? Lacksie's reading is no doubt loftier than Reddit. Oh the complaints about "period pains" and observations on the topic of dilator size post surgery that a vagina is capable of accommodating a full term baby. Maybe don't try that one at home.

Veilsofmorning · 07/11/2026 18:17

“This isn't what DU meant when she responded to those questions.”

How can you possibly know what someone else was actually thinking - beyond your own inference? Bit of a big claim to be a mind reader? You might believe he didn’t mean it but you can’t know it, unless you are a mind reader. Perhaps you should read the AI answers more carefully before you post them?
Probably will get no answer- or not a straight one anyway.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 07/11/2026 18:23

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:42

Sure and that's the very limited relevance I was referring to.

The reason it's of very limited relevance is that recognition of self as human (or not) is entirely different (in terms of causes/mechanisms/ consequences) from recognition of self as male and female. One tells you almost nothing about the other

You put great store by 'recognition of self as male and female'. The (sometimes relevant and necessary 'recognition of someone else as male or female'? Not so much. Why?

Catiette · 07/11/2026 18:25

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:05

Well they might be accused of transphobia, but they shouldn't be, and DU was clear about that herself. A patient has the right to be treated by a doctor she feels comfortable with.

To be honest, I don't really think this hypothetical scenario is actually an issue in practice - how many complaints have their been of this nature in the NHS? It would be interested to review and see. I'm not aware of any.

The only reason we are debating it, is because people were furious with what DU said on the stand under questioning, and have used that to entirely misrepresent her as a doctor - suggesting that she is the sort of Dr that would violate women's consent. There is no evidence for this and this isn't what DU meant when she responded to those questions.

Regarding your other questions, the first couple seem to contain an assumption, that a) birth sex is always a useful/ the most relevant proxy in health contexts (it often is, but sometimes it isn't) and b) that birth sex can't be recorded if we recognise gender. Neither of these assumptions hold.

Question 4 is framed in terms of a contrast between 'self-perception' and 'objective reality' and suggesting that one needs to override the other. I reject this framing - both the contrast between "self perception" and "objective reality" and the idea that they are mutually exclusive or opposing. Both are real, and both can exist and be acknowledged at the same time.

The last question I can't make sense of - what does this mean "that their own (and they would say, equally valid!) self-perception should outweigh current social contracts and legal processes?"

Well they might be accused of transphobia...

This is why I'm keen to hear the exact words you would recommend. To have this from someone with your views would be interesting indeed, and something of a public service. Could you suggest something?

To be honest, I don't really think this hypothetical scenario is actually an issue in practice - how many complaints have their been of this nature in the NHS? It would be interested to review and see. I'm not aware of any.

The only reason we are debating it, is because people were furious with what DU said on the stand under questioning, and have used that to entirely misrepresent her as a doctor - suggesting that she is the sort of Dr that would violate women's consent. There is no evidence for this and this isn't what DU meant when she responded to those questions.

I have no doubt that everyone here with whom you're debating feels it's a worthwhile question. A recent Mumsnetter's own audit showed that "our" understanding of what a female is conflicts with recent NHS policy on a national scale. And so many of us have asked for female clinicians. This is emphatically not hypothetical in that sense at least. I also find your argument that it's hypothetical on the basis that it's what many posters here think and worry about (ie. it's "in their minds") inconsistent with your previous focus on the importance and validity of thought and perception in shaping human reality.

Regarding your other questions, the first couple seem to contain an assumption, that a) birth sex is always a useful/ the most relevant proxy in health contexts (it often is, but sometimes it isn't)

I addressed this in my earlier lenghty post (which also went unanswered). If you're a member, you can search - just look for the earliest (I think?) massive post from me. If not, I can paste it again if we're quick before the thread ends, and you can even put it through AI as Rhino suggests if helpful.

and b) that birth sex can't be recorded if we recognise gender.

I'm confused by this one, as I've not said it and don't think I believe it.

Question 4 is framed in terms of a contrast between 'self-perception' and 'objective reality' and suggesting that one needs to override the other. I reject this framing - both the contrast between "self perception" and "objective reality" and the idea that they are mutually exclusive or opposing. Both are real, and both can exist and be acknowledged at the same time.

Of course one doesn't "need to override" the other or the two to be "mutually exclusive" (unless we get into seriously abstract philosophising about the nature of meaning itself!)

For someone like me, so obviously concerned about the practical (in the self-evident friction between the two in some contexts), this would be an illogical position to take. Suggesting I do is either a misunderstanding or a strawman enabling evasion of the central question. This question is what to do in the many other situations when they do rub up against each other. I even provide a list of examples of these to keep us tethered to the concrete and the practical (eg. white supremacism, clinical depression, ADHD diagnosis and something else I've forgotten).

The last question I can't make sense of - what does this mean "that their own (and they would say, equally valid!) self-perception should outweigh current social contracts and legal processes?"

It's in reference to that list of bracketted examples I give immediately above.

If you're saying, as you appear to be, that Dr Upton's self-perception of himself as female should be upheld to the degree that there's an acknowledged risk that a vulnerable woman seeking urgent treatment "might be accused of transphobia"... then how do you justify that potential harm as justified, while also holding back the tide of people who would duly argue that, therefore, their self-perception should similarly be upheld, and the corresponding harms resulting from that would be similarly justified?

Editing after posting in case I fall off the end of the thread!

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:26

Veilsofmorning · 07/11/2026 18:17

“This isn't what DU meant when she responded to those questions.”

How can you possibly know what someone else was actually thinking - beyond your own inference? Bit of a big claim to be a mind reader? You might believe he didn’t mean it but you can’t know it, unless you are a mind reader. Perhaps you should read the AI answers more carefully before you post them?
Probably will get no answer- or not a straight one anyway.

Because what she meant is clear from what she actually said. It's being entirely misrepresented.

Coatsoff42 · 07/11/2026 18:27

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:26

Because what she meant is clear from what she actually said. It's being entirely misrepresented.

It was clear at the time and it was shocking. It’s not being misrepresented at all.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:30

Catiette · 07/11/2026 18:25

Well they might be accused of transphobia...

This is why I'm keen to hear the exact words you would recommend. To have this from someone with your views would be interesting indeed, and something of a public service. Could you suggest something?

To be honest, I don't really think this hypothetical scenario is actually an issue in practice - how many complaints have their been of this nature in the NHS? It would be interested to review and see. I'm not aware of any.

The only reason we are debating it, is because people were furious with what DU said on the stand under questioning, and have used that to entirely misrepresent her as a doctor - suggesting that she is the sort of Dr that would violate women's consent. There is no evidence for this and this isn't what DU meant when she responded to those questions.

I have no doubt that everyone here with whom you're debating feels it's a worthwhile question. A recent Mumsnetter's own audit showed that "our" understanding of what a female is conflicts with recent NHS policy on a national scale. And so many of us have asked for female clinicians. This is emphatically not hypothetical in that sense at least. I also find your argument that it's hypothetical on the basis that it's what many posters here think and worry about (ie. it's "in their minds") inconsistent with your previous focus on the importance and validity of thought and perception in shaping human reality.

Regarding your other questions, the first couple seem to contain an assumption, that a) birth sex is always a useful/ the most relevant proxy in health contexts (it often is, but sometimes it isn't)

I addressed this in my earlier lenghty post (which also went unanswered). If you're a member, you can search - just look for the earliest (I think?) massive post from me. If not, I can paste it again if we're quick before the thread ends, and you can even put it through AI as Rhino suggests if helpful.

and b) that birth sex can't be recorded if we recognise gender.

I'm confused by this one, as I've not said it and don't think I believe it.

Question 4 is framed in terms of a contrast between 'self-perception' and 'objective reality' and suggesting that one needs to override the other. I reject this framing - both the contrast between "self perception" and "objective reality" and the idea that they are mutually exclusive or opposing. Both are real, and both can exist and be acknowledged at the same time.

Of course one doesn't "need to override" the other or the two to be "mutually exclusive" (unless we get into seriously abstract philosophising about the nature of meaning itself!)

For someone like me, so obviously concerned about the practical (in the self-evident friction between the two in some contexts), this would be an illogical position to take. Suggesting I do is either a misunderstanding or a strawman enabling evasion of the central question. This question is what to do in the many other situations when they do rub up against each other. I even provide a list of examples of these to keep us tethered to the concrete and the practical (eg. white supremacism, clinical depression, ADHD diagnosis and something else I've forgotten).

The last question I can't make sense of - what does this mean "that their own (and they would say, equally valid!) self-perception should outweigh current social contracts and legal processes?"

It's in reference to that list of bracketted examples I give immediately above.

If you're saying, as you appear to be, that Dr Upton's self-perception of himself as female should be upheld to the degree that there's an acknowledged risk that a vulnerable woman seeking urgent treatment "might be accused of transphobia"... then how do you justify that potential harm as justified, while also holding back the tide of people who would duly argue that, therefore, their self-perception should similarly be upheld, and the corresponding harms resulting from that would be similarly justified?

Editing after posting in case I fall off the end of the thread!

Edited

The words are easy- female at birth (add registered, assigned, observed as preferred for even more precision) ; cisgender woman; female doctor please and I'm not comfortable with a trans woman.
Loads of possibilities.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:35

Coatsoff42 · 07/11/2026 18:27

It was clear at the time and it was shocking. It’s not being misrepresented at all.

It's absolutely being misrepresented- to imply that DU thinks it's ok to treat a patient against their consent, when she repeatedly stated that patient consent is paramount and she would never treat a patient without that consent.
It was only shocking to those who lack theory of mind

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/11/2026 18:39

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:35

It's absolutely being misrepresented- to imply that DU thinks it's ok to treat a patient against their consent, when she repeatedly stated that patient consent is paramount and she would never treat a patient without that consent.
It was only shocking to those who lack theory of mind

This is nonsense. He said, under oath, that he felt entitled to treat a patient who had asked for a female doctor. He is not female, and whatever self interested guff he comes out with, he knows that full well. “Theory of mind” my arse.

Catiette · 07/11/2026 18:39

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:30

The words are easy- female at birth (add registered, assigned, observed as preferred for even more precision) ; cisgender woman; female doctor please and I'm not comfortable with a trans woman.
Loads of possibilities.

Edited

Female doctor - self-evidently inadequate (the whole point of our discussion).

Cisgender, registered, assigned & observed as - not understood by a significant proportion of the vulnerable patients I ask you to consider, with many not even aware of or understanding that their understanding of female is being forced into obsolescence in certain contexts, and alternative terminology required.

Female at birth - ditto.

In addition, this doesn't take into account the associated complexities or current paperwork, privacy law and NHS record-keeping as I understand it, not to mention activist capture (are you over here? I'm sure other posters with more knowledge on that front can clarify).

None of this is "easy". If it were, there wouldn't be an issue. All your suggestions present problems and straight-up exclude people existing outside your own frame of reference - your own "perception", in a sense.

If theirs does indeed have equal validity, that leaves us with a problem, as they no longer have the language necessary to express their understanding and needs, without capitulation to your own framing of reality.

I see that as very far from inclusive indeed.

And all that's on top of your acknowledgement that, even assuming clear mutual understanding, there's still scope for accusations of transphobia.

Houston, we still have a major inclusion problem for many disabled individuals here, speakers of English as a second language, the very young and very old, the mentally disabled and the mentally vulnerable.

Totallygripped · 07/11/2026 18:39

Coatsoff42 · 07/11/2026 18:27

It was clear at the time and it was shocking. It’s not being misrepresented at all.

That is my recollection too.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/11/2026 18:40

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:30

The words are easy- female at birth (add registered, assigned, observed as preferred for even more precision) ; cisgender woman; female doctor please and I'm not comfortable with a trans woman.
Loads of possibilities.

Edited

How about “an actual woman, not a man pretending to be one” “a female doctor, not a cosplaying man”.

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 18:41

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:35

It's absolutely being misrepresented- to imply that DU thinks it's ok to treat a patient against their consent, when she repeatedly stated that patient consent is paramount and she would never treat a patient without that consent.
It was only shocking to those who lack theory of mind

Why are you calling him 'she'? And the female patient 'their'?

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:42

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 07/11/2026 18:23

You put great store by 'recognition of self as male and female'. The (sometimes relevant and necessary 'recognition of someone else as male or female'? Not so much. Why?

I think people’s own accounts of who they are and how they experience themselves should carry greater weight than someone else’s external assessment of them. This isn’t a principle I reserve for this particular issue; it’s one I apply generally. I think there’s something fundamentally wrong with presuming to tell another person who they are. And I think it becomes intolerable when someone tells you, “This is the reality of my experience,” and your response is effectively, “No, it isn’t. You’re a fake/ pretending.” Or "well you must be deluded because that doesn't fit how I like to classify things in boxes".

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 18:42

Oh, are we back to "anyone who doesn't think the same as me must have no theory of mind" as opposed to just, y'know, either:

  1. understanding perfectly well how someone is thinking but based on their own intelligence, experience and knowledge concluding that person is mistaken, or
  2. understanding perfectly well how what someone is saying but based on their own intelligence, experience and knowledge concluding that person is lying?

It very much seems to be a case of "Theory of Mind for me, but not for thee...."

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 18:44

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:42

I think people’s own accounts of who they are and how they experience themselves should carry greater weight than someone else’s external assessment of them. This isn’t a principle I reserve for this particular issue; it’s one I apply generally. I think there’s something fundamentally wrong with presuming to tell another person who they are. And I think it becomes intolerable when someone tells you, “This is the reality of my experience,” and your response is effectively, “No, it isn’t. You’re a fake/ pretending.” Or "well you must be deluded because that doesn't fit how I like to classify things in boxes".

What if they are liars and predators?

If Russell Brand said 'I'm a lady' are you for him being put in a female prison?

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:44

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 18:41

Why are you calling him 'she'? And the female patient 'their'?

I'm calling DU "she" because I believe that when I refer to someone else, I should use language that is respectful to that person and compatible with their dignity and express wishes of how to be addressed.

Im using "their" for the patients , as there is no specific individual patient being referred to, but patients in general as a group.

MyAmpleSheep · 07/11/2026 18:45

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 17:11

Any accomodation for trans-identifying people has to manage the fact that at least some - and quite a lot of the most vocal trans-identifying people are trans-because-they're-arseholes-and-claiming-to-be-trans-is-a-great-way-to-inconvenience-everyone-else-with-being-an-arsehole.

This is such a bizarre thing to believe. Why would there be a mass of people pretending to be trans? What do you think it would gain them? Why do you believe this?

What do you think it would gain them?

Access to women's changing rooms, toilets, sports, rape counselling and prisons, for a start.

Once we've taken the illegitimate access to those things away, let's see who's left.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/11/2026 18:45

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 18:44

What if they are liars and predators?

If Russell Brand said 'I'm a lady' are you for him being put in a female prison?

Non zero chance of that happening, it would be a great power play, except now he’d definitely be staying in the men’s, thanks to KPSS and FWS.

Veilsofmorning · 07/11/2026 18:46

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:26

Because what she meant is clear from what she actually said. It's being entirely misrepresented.

That’s your interpretation and belief- you still can’t know it. My interpretation at the time (and now) and in the context at that time was and still is, different to yours, but no less valid, arguably more so perhaps, because made at the time. You are not a mind reader, so your interpretation will be biased by what you want to believe, but you can still only believe, not know. Neither can I, and perhaps I’m biased as well, but you can’t claim that you know for certain what he meant, especially relying on written text where several layers of meaning are absent.

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 18:46

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 18:44

I'm calling DU "she" because I believe that when I refer to someone else, I should use language that is respectful to that person and compatible with their dignity and express wishes of how to be addressed.

Im using "their" for the patients , as there is no specific individual patient being referred to, but patients in general as a group.

Men, really do have a vice like grip on people eh?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/11/2026 18:47

I watched him say it, and it was very clear what he meant.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.