Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Catiette · 07/11/2026 13:31

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 13:11

It's hard to answer these posts, because you attribute so much that I haven't said.
I have never argued anything resembling this:

"defining objective meaning is, in the case of sex and female consent in a medical context, fundamentally impossible, and associated safeguarding rules collapse under the weight of this complexity"

What makes you think I have?

The quotation I cite in the post to which you're responding, and the context in which you wrote it.

If that doesn't mean what I "attribute", I'd be interested to hear why, and I'd be happy to reswponse.

That will then enable use to explore the questions in my post and address any suspicions of your seeking to evade direct answers to these.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 13:31

MyAmpleSheep · 07/11/2026 13:16

Many people are trying to do their best to put a sound logical structure behind your posts. You have a habit of making “hit-and-run” points. You don’t thresh out anything you say, you don’t fill any of the obvious gaps, you don’t appear to make any good-faith effort to avoid ambiguity. And when anyone else does any of those things for you, you simply say “that’s not what I said at all, what makes you think it is?”

Your style of engagement is light years beyond plain slippery and evasive.

Edited

That's a grossly unfair characterisation. But I'm not here to defend myself.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 13:32

Catiette · 07/11/2026 13:31

The quotation I cite in the post to which you're responding, and the context in which you wrote it.

If that doesn't mean what I "attribute", I'd be interested to hear why, and I'd be happy to reswponse.

That will then enable use to explore the questions in my post and address any suspicions of your seeking to evade direct answers to these.

Why what?

Heggettypeg · 07/11/2026 13:42

By yourself, in a vacuum, you could have an inbuilt instinctive feeling of being other than you seem. But you can only understand that feeling in terms of known possibilities, which is already not the feeling itself, but interpretation of the feeling in the light of your experience of the outside world. This is still the case even when the interpretation is not a conscious process of deliberate thought.

Imagine a mule that is conscious of self. It has grown up with its donkey mother. But it feels, instinctively, not-donkey. One day it sees a horse. It "recognises" itself as a horse because that's the only not-donkey equine the world has offered it. (Or, if it's a precise and cautious sort of mule, it might recognise itself as not-really-horse- either, and hold off from giving a label to its feeling yet. )

If it opts for "horse', and insists on that, it will run into trouble with other people, who can see perfectly well that it isn't what they would call a horse. Its feeling of not-donkey is perfectly real and valid. But its inference and expectations based on the feeling are not.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 13:43

Pattern matching.

It's how humans are able to abstract and conceptualise.

Language.

It's how humans are able to share meaning and understanding.

This thread is a great demonstration of both.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 13:52

Heggettypeg · 07/11/2026 13:42

By yourself, in a vacuum, you could have an inbuilt instinctive feeling of being other than you seem. But you can only understand that feeling in terms of known possibilities, which is already not the feeling itself, but interpretation of the feeling in the light of your experience of the outside world. This is still the case even when the interpretation is not a conscious process of deliberate thought.

Imagine a mule that is conscious of self. It has grown up with its donkey mother. But it feels, instinctively, not-donkey. One day it sees a horse. It "recognises" itself as a horse because that's the only not-donkey equine the world has offered it. (Or, if it's a precise and cautious sort of mule, it might recognise itself as not-really-horse- either, and hold off from giving a label to its feeling yet. )

If it opts for "horse', and insists on that, it will run into trouble with other people, who can see perfectly well that it isn't what they would call a horse. Its feeling of not-donkey is perfectly real and valid. But its inference and expectations based on the feeling are not.

By yourself, in a vacuum, you could have an inbuilt instinctive feeling of being other than you seem. But you can only understand that feeling in terms of known possibilities, which is already not the feeling itself, but interpretation of the feeling in the light of your experience of the outside world.

That's not quite right- we need language and categories/
concepts to be able explain, articulate and reason about our experience, but it doesn't follow that our cognitive experience (eg of sense of the body) is produced by that learned knowledge (of language / concepts). in fact we know from neuroscience that it isn't- the sense of the body can come apart from the knowledge / perception of it in really surprising ways that demonstrates the two are distinct.

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 13:55

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 13:52

By yourself, in a vacuum, you could have an inbuilt instinctive feeling of being other than you seem. But you can only understand that feeling in terms of known possibilities, which is already not the feeling itself, but interpretation of the feeling in the light of your experience of the outside world.

That's not quite right- we need language and categories/
concepts to be able explain, articulate and reason about our experience, but it doesn't follow that our cognitive experience (eg of sense of the body) is produced by that learned knowledge (of language / concepts). in fact we know from neuroscience that it isn't- the sense of the body can come apart from the knowledge / perception of it in really surprising ways that demonstrates the two are distinct.

In terms of Dr Upton, what is your cognitive process from looking at a man to arguing on the internet that you think he is a woman?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 14:00

None of which is relevant to why people with objectively, observablely, not-in-any-way-biologically-exceptional male bodies should ever be treated as interchangeable socially, culturally or legally with people with female bodies in any setting, medical or otherwise, where a distinction between men and women, male and female, boys and girls, is being made.

Intellectually onanistic flimflam is fine in the privacy of ones own study, but when it escapes into how one treats other people in the real world, that's a problem.

Catiette · 07/11/2026 14:07

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 13:11

It's hard to answer these posts, because you attribute so much that I haven't said.
I have never argued anything resembling this:

"defining objective meaning is, in the case of sex and female consent in a medical context, fundamentally impossible, and associated safeguarding rules collapse under the weight of this complexity"

What makes you think I have?

NB. In the below, please note my various citations from your posts could be applied to various of my attributions in relation to them.

So.

My understanding of what you say (bold), with reference to your own words (italics).

A) Material reality is complex for two reasons:

a) there will always be exceptions to common rules and patterns

  • It is proven science.
  • They have to know their relevant physiological / medical history. Sex is a proxy- it's a useful proxy much of the time, and sometimes it's not. Many people define biological sex in terms of chromosomes.
  • Are women with CAIS allowed to be doctors?
  • The characteristics of the body are separate from the recognition/ observation of them...The second can’t be reduced to the first, it's reductive and false to pretend it can.

b) we can only ever experience it through individual human consciousness and perception.

  • The pp's hypothetical depends on the assumption that everyone has the same understanding of these terms - male and female - as she does: what they mean and how they should be applied. But they don't. That's the entire point.
  • Theory of mind my dear, theory of mind. DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality.
  • Body recognition doesn't work like that - it's a pre-reflective, non-conceptual type of cognition that stands entirely apart from conscious knowing
  • I understand that your definition of ‘female’ excludes trans women. Many people don’t share that definition.

B) On this basis, defining objective meaning is, in the case of sex and female consent in a medical context, fundamentally impossible, and associated safeguarding rules collapse under the weight of this complexity.

  • Your entire philosophy is founded on the premise that we can and must discredit another person's claim to be female!!!
  • I don't 'believe they should be able to identify into the opposite sex category', I understand that the reality of their experience is that they do.
  • She was saying that, to her, a request for a female doctor wouldn’t automatically mean the patient was refusing her. DU... is not required to disclose her own medical history to patients.

...if [and I implicitly assume she will] Lacksie feels that the objective reality of biological sex does indeed supercede self-perception in these contexts [ administering drugs and/or treatment in contexts in which self-perception of sex conflicts with perceived sex, or can't be shared]...

  • Just someone who understands the science.
  • Interpreting the words "woman" and "female" expansively to include rare minority variations, does not imply that language, law or medicine for female people at large will collapse.
  • What is putting people in ACTUAL DANGER is the string of repressive reforms
Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 14:07

The essence of this thread is about consent. And when we ask direct questions, such as below, the deflection is obvious.

“Do you believe that a female patient can give consent that is with full knowledge and no coercion if a male doctor (who they expect to understand the difference between male and female humans and who they trust would act ethically and that they have to trust to treat them) presented themselves as being the female doctor that they requested?

It is a yes or no question. Do you believe they can give consent based on this scenario or not?”

I think we can now make the observation that those who deflect from making a clear answer are likely to realise what their answer would contradict any claim about centring female people.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 14:08

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 14:00

None of which is relevant to why people with objectively, observablely, not-in-any-way-biologically-exceptional male bodies should ever be treated as interchangeable socially, culturally or legally with people with female bodies in any setting, medical or otherwise, where a distinction between men and women, male and female, boys and girls, is being made.

Intellectually onanistic flimflam is fine in the privacy of ones own study, but when it escapes into how one treats other people in the real world, that's a problem.

How we should treat, accommodate trans people is a separate question I agree.

But we can't possibly begin to have a reasonable conversation about that when people don't understand the basics of what being trans is. So much of the dismissal and anger towards trans people rests on assumptions that trans people are "fake" "pretending" "sexist" "entitled". This is all so very very very wrong, and it's a consequence of people not actually understanding trans experience and what it is.

Catiette · 07/11/2026 14:09

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 13:32

Why what?

Come on, now. There's no ambiguity there, which does lead me to wonder if the issue is, as Alcove is so fond of suggesting (and I really try to resist doing, as I find it so rude) of comprehension. I'm still rather inclined to think it's evasion, but am trying to reserve judgement as I await a reply to my lettered/numbered questions.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 14:11

Also LOL that the poster arguing so passionately, if incoherently, on this thread for the right of an individual's self perception to override the perception of that individual by everyone else is also the poster that on another thread refused to carry on replying to me because of my solipsism 😂

You couldn't make it up, could you? The double standards are so clear it must require a very special type of recognition not to see it.

Catiette · 07/11/2026 14:13

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 14:08

How we should treat, accommodate trans people is a separate question I agree.

But we can't possibly begin to have a reasonable conversation about that when people don't understand the basics of what being trans is. So much of the dismissal and anger towards trans people rests on assumptions that trans people are "fake" "pretending" "sexist" "entitled". This is all so very very very wrong, and it's a consequence of people not actually understanding trans experience and what it is.

To follow on from the above, it's interesting to see where you deflect and where you engage.

I know my questions are tricky, but surely that's an argument for seizing the opportunity to demonstrate the courage of your convictions? By all means include in your answer where I misunderstood or wrongly attributed to you something you don't believe. My bullets above lay the groundwork for this, and your thorough engagement with the thread suggests you have the time. I'll drop in and out, and others will be interested in your thoughts on them, too.

Looking forward to hearing more.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 14:16

Also LOL at a reply to my post that demonstrated the exact issue the post was highlighting 😂

No, we don't have to adopt a specific and ideologically prescribed set of words, nor even understand the causes of soneone claiming a trans identity, to focus on what it is fair and reasonable to expect of other people.

Or even just to say "no".

StealthTroublemaker · 07/11/2026 14:19

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 14:08

How we should treat, accommodate trans people is a separate question I agree.

But we can't possibly begin to have a reasonable conversation about that when people don't understand the basics of what being trans is. So much of the dismissal and anger towards trans people rests on assumptions that trans people are "fake" "pretending" "sexist" "entitled". This is all so very very very wrong, and it's a consequence of people not actually understanding trans experience and what it is.

But then you could say that men claiming to be female is a consequence of not actually understanding female experience and what it is couldn’t you? If all they base their “femaleness” on is a concept in their head, then they are not female. The only criteria to be a “transwoman” is to be male, so as humans cannot change sex, a male can never be female, or feel female, or know anything about being a female, whatever weird concepts you use to try to make people think they can be. This may make you sad. Personally, I don’t care.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 14:25

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 14:00

None of which is relevant to why people with objectively, observablely, not-in-any-way-biologically-exceptional male bodies should ever be treated as interchangeable socially, culturally or legally with people with female bodies in any setting, medical or otherwise, where a distinction between men and women, male and female, boys and girls, is being made.

Intellectually onanistic flimflam is fine in the privacy of ones own study, but when it escapes into how one treats other people in the real world, that's a problem.

“onanistic”

A new word for me.

Catiette · 07/11/2026 14:30

Intellectually onanistic flimflam - a t-shirt-worthy phrase if ever there was one. Probably belongs on the same clothing rack as the Focauldian Grievance Gerbils motif (or whatever it was).

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 14:30

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 13:52

By yourself, in a vacuum, you could have an inbuilt instinctive feeling of being other than you seem. But you can only understand that feeling in terms of known possibilities, which is already not the feeling itself, but interpretation of the feeling in the light of your experience of the outside world.

That's not quite right- we need language and categories/
concepts to be able explain, articulate and reason about our experience, but it doesn't follow that our cognitive experience (eg of sense of the body) is produced by that learned knowledge (of language / concepts). in fact we know from neuroscience that it isn't- the sense of the body can come apart from the knowledge / perception of it in really surprising ways that demonstrates the two are distinct.

And it continues to always come down to law and policy has to be based on common use language that has no weaknesses that allow the very opposite of what the policy and law states to happen.

Hence we keep circling back to language needs to be clear with no ambiguity to enable safeguarding protections to be enacted.

All this philosophising is again meaningless in the aim to establish whether consent can be given by a female patient who either does not have full information or is feeling coerced in any way when they give consent.

There is so much sparpling happening as a distraction from this issue at hand.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 14:37

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 14:16

Also LOL at a reply to my post that demonstrated the exact issue the post was highlighting 😂

No, we don't have to adopt a specific and ideologically prescribed set of words, nor even understand the causes of soneone claiming a trans identity, to focus on what it is fair and reasonable to expect of other people.

Or even just to say "no".

Hey, Flirts!

We do in a separate reality realm. Because remember any reference word can mean anything anyone wants it to mean in that one moment. So, one person saying something is true and they claim the authority of knowledge to back up that claim means it must be true in that person’s subjective view meaning they can never to told they are spreading misinformation or that they are wrong.

Because in an alternate reality in that person’s subjective belief they are correct. Therefore no laws that someone says have been broken cannot be broken if someone’s subjective reality belief is shown to support their action follows the law based on their personal reference definitions.

This is the stage we are at.

Yet it will be denied because that too will be philosophised away.

Catiette · 07/11/2026 14:41

This philosophising away itself is an apt metaphor for the whole thing, really, given Lacksie's suggestion that I've in some way misattributed what they meant/intended even as others find my summary pretty synonymous with what they've written.

An explanation of my misattributions, clarifying where I misunderstood their initial comments, would help.

And an answer to my questions would clarify so much.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 14:51

Catiette · 07/11/2026 14:41

This philosophising away itself is an apt metaphor for the whole thing, really, given Lacksie's suggestion that I've in some way misattributed what they meant/intended even as others find my summary pretty synonymous with what they've written.

An explanation of my misattributions, clarifying where I misunderstood their initial comments, would help.

And an answer to my questions would clarify so much.

As you say catiette, it is a demonstration of the issues around consent that have been raised.

I remember spending hours going back and forth with the poster where I and numerous other posters explained, some in significant detail, the harms of destabilised language around reference terms for female people and the direct examples of those harms in action. Only to be told with utmost authority and confidence that there had been no negative impact of female people at all regarding language.

And here we are months on with a very clear demonstration on those harms.

But apparently, nothing to see here. Let’s just theorise it all away. Both philosophical theory and neurological theory.

All still theory. Yet all still apparently material reality despite not evidence at all.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 14:54

In a world of destabilised language where a term referencing only two states of being can mean both states at the same time to some people, the very word ‘no’ is also meaningless.

Because a person can believe that ‘no’ has a personal meaning of yes and that is considered acceptable for the application of policy and law around consent.

LinearALinearB · 07/11/2026 14:55

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 14:25

“onanistic”

A new word for me.

Oh, I could have guessed that one because I once had to look up the Danish word 'onanere' to make sense of a news article in the local rag. The story was about a man arrested at the train station for doing the onanere- ing in public. Glad it's come in handy (no pun intended) twice now!

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 07/11/2026 15:25

Talkinpeace · 02/11/2026 22:16

The RCN let Sandie Peggie down
by not highlighting at the very outset that NHS Fife was in breach of H&S1992

Theo Upton should never have been allowed into the female changing space
regardless of his identity that day

Under the EA2010, service providers are required to provide gender neutral solutions
but as both Upton and Peggie were employees
the Supreme Court Ruling in all its layers
never applied to them

the RCN were negligent from the utter outset in standing up for their member in Scotland
and for the members in Darlington

I agree with you. I do have one thing niggling me. Isn't it at least arguable that an employer providing changing rooms and toilets etc is providing a service to their employees? Is this point clarified in the EA2010 or elsewhere?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread