Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Lacksie · 07/11/2026 17:10

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 17:05

Oh, and while you may need to understand exactly what trans experience is to understand how you will accomodate trans people, you don't need to understand that to rule out some of the ways you won't accomodate trans people, because you can do that based on other factors like how it impacts other people.

An analogy would be - society very much has to solve (or maybe just morally should solve) some of the problems that are arising from increasing wealth inequality. It's an extremely complex prolem with many stakeholders and different views and indeed ideologies. We may never solve it.

However, in the meantime society has nevertheless pretty much agreed that one way we don't solve it is to give everyone carte blanche to take someone else's stuff if they strongly believe their need is greater. Neither have we let on the table the possibility of reducing the number of poor people by reducing the number of people rather than their poverty. We have, despite the complexity and moral components of the problem, desote not knowing how we will solve it, somehow amazingly been able to rule out some ways we won't.

So yes, one absolutely can say No to treating male bodies people "as if" they were female when it comes to language ("woman, girl, her, she, female" etc), law, culture, single sex spaces, opportunities and protections etc simply based on the unreasonableness of that demand's consequences for female people.

There's absolutely no reason to put off treating female people fairly until one decides what society will or will not extend to trans people, and frankly it's utterly fucking shockingly sexist not to see that.

You keep saying ‘fair to female people’ as if that settled anything. Three problems. First, most of what you list isn’t zero-sum: calling a trans woman ‘she’ doesn’t un-call anyone else ‘she’, and protecting trans people from discrimination doesn’t unprotect women. Second, ‘female people’ don’t speak with one voice — plenty of women don’t see trans women’s inclusion as unfair to them, so ‘fair to women’ here means ‘fair by your reckoning’, and you’re calling the women who disagree sexist. Third, fairness between groups depends on who’s in them. ‘Fairness to women requires excluding trans women’ assumes trans women aren’t among the people fairness is owed to, which already assumed the conclusion you are supposed to be justifying.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 17:11

What's that old phrase - "there's none so blind as those who will not see"?

Or was it "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it" - though of course many things could be substitiuted for salary here.

Though personally, I think given the thread topic, "Did ye, aye?" has a certain satisfying fitness.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 17:11

MyAmpleSheep · 07/11/2026 17:05

There's no gatekeeping to being trans. So obviously some arseholes will and do adopt it only because they're arseholes and not because they have any kind of gender dysphoria or other internal distress.

Any accomodation for trans-identifying people has to manage the fact that at least some - and quite a lot of the most vocal trans-identifying people are trans-because-they're-arseholes-and-claiming-to-be-trans-is-a-great-way-to-inconvenience-everyone-else-with-being-an-arsehole.

That's a given, before we discuss what accommodations we should all make for people claiming a trans identity.

Any accomodation for trans-identifying people has to manage the fact that at least some - and quite a lot of the most vocal trans-identifying people are trans-because-they're-arseholes-and-claiming-to-be-trans-is-a-great-way-to-inconvenience-everyone-else-with-being-an-arsehole.

This is such a bizarre thing to believe. Why would there be a mass of people pretending to be trans? What do you think it would gain them? Why do you believe this?

MrsOvertonsWindow · 07/11/2026 17:12

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 16:51

Eh?
I didn’t say every trans person is lovely and genuine - trans people are all individuals like anyone else; some people are lovely, some are arseholes. And so what?
The dismissal and anger towards trans people as a group/ category rests on a false account of what being trans itself is — that to be trans itself is to engage in fakery, pretence, sexism and entitlement. That’s a claim about the category, not a character reference for each member. Some gay people are lovely, others are liars; it tells you nothing about what being gay is, and whether we should criminalise homosexuality or not.

We absolutely need to have an accurate understanding of what trans experience is in order to have a reasonable conversation about how to accommodate trans people as a group in society.

Edited

Sadly Lacks, as you point out, this is what transgenderism is:
"that to be trans itself is to engage in fakery, pretence, sexism and entitlement".

It's absolutely fundamental to transactivists that they dismiss the rights of others (especially women and children), create bodily facsimiles of the opposite sex,, insist that anyone challenging, exposing, even noticing the facsimile is a bigot to be dismissed as transphobic.

I've not idea what it is that motivates you to spend so many hours on here trying to persuade mostly women to abandon standing up for the rights of women and the need to safeguard the young. Only you can know the answer to that.

But you'll never persuade posters that children should be abandoned to the born in the wrong body lobby. That mentally vulnerable young women should mutilate their bodies having been indoctrinated online by the trans mob

By all means keep sharing your word salads. Just pointing out that resposnible ethical adults will never agree with you.

murasaki · 07/11/2026 17:13

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 17:10

You keep saying ‘fair to female people’ as if that settled anything. Three problems. First, most of what you list isn’t zero-sum: calling a trans woman ‘she’ doesn’t un-call anyone else ‘she’, and protecting trans people from discrimination doesn’t unprotect women. Second, ‘female people’ don’t speak with one voice — plenty of women don’t see trans women’s inclusion as unfair to them, so ‘fair to women’ here means ‘fair by your reckoning’, and you’re calling the women who disagree sexist. Third, fairness between groups depends on who’s in them. ‘Fairness to women requires excluding trans women’ assumes trans women aren’t among the people fairness is owed to, which already assumed the conclusion you are supposed to be justifying.

It absolutely does mean that 'she' doesn't refer to women, so it is uncalling women 'she' as you put it. As they are men. Why can't we have a word that doesn't include men?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 17:15

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 17:10

You keep saying ‘fair to female people’ as if that settled anything. Three problems. First, most of what you list isn’t zero-sum: calling a trans woman ‘she’ doesn’t un-call anyone else ‘she’, and protecting trans people from discrimination doesn’t unprotect women. Second, ‘female people’ don’t speak with one voice — plenty of women don’t see trans women’s inclusion as unfair to them, so ‘fair to women’ here means ‘fair by your reckoning’, and you’re calling the women who disagree sexist. Third, fairness between groups depends on who’s in them. ‘Fairness to women requires excluding trans women’ assumes trans women aren’t among the people fairness is owed to, which already assumed the conclusion you are supposed to be justifying.

I've replied to you on these exact points many times before. You have never yet been able to argue against them, only dissemble and deny.

Experience tells me that spending time going round that loop with you again is is not a good use of my time.

However, if you genuinely have trouble remembering what has previously been said to you, please feel free to use the advanced search

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 17:20

“First, most of what you list isn’t zero-sum: calling a trans woman ‘she’ doesn’t un-call anyone else ‘she’, and protecting trans people from discrimination doesn’t unprotect women.”

This thread highlights that falsity of this claim.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 17:22

For anyone else, the logical fallacy being deployed against women here is the assumption that the only possible way to be "fair" to a male person who claims to believe himself a female person is to treat said male bodied person "as if" he is female when it comes to language ("woman, girl, her, she, female" etc), law, culture, single sex spaces, opportunities and protections etc.

As my original post made clear to anyone reading it with an open mind, there are surely many ways this man can be accomdated. There's no reason to fixate on the one that requires changing wholesale our understanding of female in law, culture and society, literally no longer having a word for half of humanity, unless one has an agenda beyond the stated one of accomodating in a fair and compassionate way whatever this mystery of a "trans experience" is.

Catiette · 07/11/2026 17:23

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 17:07

I'm so sorry I just don't follow your posts I'm afraid.

OK, no worries - back to the essence of them.

  1. Given some trans-identifying males' perception of themselves as female...

a) How can potentially life-saving sex-disaggregated clinical trials be ethically and meaningfully administered (acknowledging the potential for small numbers of males to significantly distort results, especially in smaller trials)?

b) How can a doctor (for example) administer drugs such as ambien or morphine, or appropriate sex-specific treatment if required, to

i) an unconscious patient?

ii) someone with Dr Upton's self-perception?

  1. Does a female patient have the right to request a female-only clinician in line with her perception of what "female" means?

  2. If your answer to the above is yes, how can this right be reconciled with a trans-identifying male medic's own right to perceive himself as female, in practical terms, while acknowledging the issues posters outline above (eg. visually impaired / mentally disabled etc. patients)?

  3. How, in the light of the above, can we consistently and ethically distinguish between those instances in which self-perception does override objective reality, and those in which it doesn't?

  4. Is your response to 5) a sufficiently strong argument to outweigh other groups' corresponding arguments that their own (and they would say, equally valid!) self-perception should outweigh current social contracts and legal processes? (For examples, see my bulletted list above, in the original version of these questions).

This is a lot because these are complex issues. However, as I know you engage in some detail with these threads and are also very clear indeed in your views on these issues, I hope you can devote a few summarising sentences or so to explain each to us.

Thanks in advance.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 17:23

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 17:20

“First, most of what you list isn’t zero-sum: calling a trans woman ‘she’ doesn’t un-call anyone else ‘she’, and protecting trans people from discrimination doesn’t unprotect women.”

This thread highlights that falsity of this claim.

💯

Or to look at it another way - "we don't have to make it a zero sum game that takes from female people to give to male, we just want to"

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 07/11/2026 17:24

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 18:43

I see you want to continue the personal insults, so this will be the last of your posts that I read or respond to.

we agree on more than you think. Biological mechanisms exist, they have observable effects, female people exist and will go on existing, and all of that can be named. Nobody here has denied any of it, so it doesn't need defending.

What I don't accept is the step you keep skipping: that those mechanisms sort people cleanly into two kinds, and that 'woman' is simply the name for one of them. That's a classification, not an observation — you've already had to retreat from 'produces gametes' to 'mechanisms of biological sex' to keep it standing. And in practice 'woman' has never been applied by checking any of those mechanisms. It's applied by recognition — how someone lives, how they're seen, how they're treated. That's how you've been called a woman every day of your life, and nobody checked your gametes and few your genitals. Trans women are called women in exactly that way by the people who know them.

"The existing language of sex" is your framing, not a fact. The word has always been the language of recognition. And 'have your own word' isn't the neutral offer you try to make it sound like. If everyone else is a woman and trans women get a different word, the different word exists to mark them out. That's the exclusion, restated politely.

Edited

Trans women are called women in exactly that way by the people who know them.

That is not a universal truth by a long stretch. Even many of the people who do call them women do so because they are shamed and coerced into doing so. Those of us who don't accept this new usage don't call them women at all.

murasaki · 07/11/2026 17:25

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 17:23

💯

Or to look at it another way - "we don't have to make it a zero sum game that takes from female people to give to male, we just want to"

Edited

And then posters get arsey when we call them male. Which is odd, given i can see why men would argue for this, but am constantly baffled as to why any woman would.

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 17:34

Catiette · 07/11/2026 17:23

OK, no worries - back to the essence of them.

  1. Given some trans-identifying males' perception of themselves as female...

a) How can potentially life-saving sex-disaggregated clinical trials be ethically and meaningfully administered (acknowledging the potential for small numbers of males to significantly distort results, especially in smaller trials)?

b) How can a doctor (for example) administer drugs such as ambien or morphine, or appropriate sex-specific treatment if required, to

i) an unconscious patient?

ii) someone with Dr Upton's self-perception?

  1. Does a female patient have the right to request a female-only clinician in line with her perception of what "female" means?

  2. If your answer to the above is yes, how can this right be reconciled with a trans-identifying male medic's own right to perceive himself as female, in practical terms, while acknowledging the issues posters outline above (eg. visually impaired / mentally disabled etc. patients)?

  3. How, in the light of the above, can we consistently and ethically distinguish between those instances in which self-perception does override objective reality, and those in which it doesn't?

  4. Is your response to 5) a sufficiently strong argument to outweigh other groups' corresponding arguments that their own (and they would say, equally valid!) self-perception should outweigh current social contracts and legal processes? (For examples, see my bulletted list above, in the original version of these questions).

This is a lot because these are complex issues. However, as I know you engage in some detail with these threads and are also very clear indeed in your views on these issues, I hope you can devote a few summarising sentences or so to explain each to us.

Thanks in advance.

Edited

Lacksie has trouble answering single sentence questions, with just a simple point. Such as:

In terms of Dr Upton, what is your cognitive process from looking at a man to arguing on the internet that you think he is a woman?

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 17:37

“Second, ‘female people’ don’t speak with one voice — plenty of women don’t see trans women’s inclusion as unfair to them, so ‘fair to women’ here means ‘fair by your reckoning’, and you’re calling the women who disagree sexist.”

When it comes to access to a collective group (ie female ) single sex access of a publicly accessed provision , the bar for consent is I am afraid set at the lowest level of acceptance. Meaning if one female person who will be potentially accessing that provision says they don’t accept a male person being there, that is the decision. Consent by a majority of a group doesn’t over ride the rejection of the people who don’t consent. In safeguarding, when safeguarding matters and it is a publicly accessed provision, that consent is not democratically over ridden. That is the antithesis to consent.

Catiette · 07/11/2026 17:39

Catiette · 07/11/2026 17:23

OK, no worries - back to the essence of them.

  1. Given some trans-identifying males' perception of themselves as female...

a) How can potentially life-saving sex-disaggregated clinical trials be ethically and meaningfully administered (acknowledging the potential for small numbers of males to significantly distort results, especially in smaller trials)?

b) How can a doctor (for example) administer drugs such as ambien or morphine, or appropriate sex-specific treatment if required, to

i) an unconscious patient?

ii) someone with Dr Upton's self-perception?

  1. Does a female patient have the right to request a female-only clinician in line with her perception of what "female" means?

  2. If your answer to the above is yes, how can this right be reconciled with a trans-identifying male medic's own right to perceive himself as female, in practical terms, while acknowledging the issues posters outline above (eg. visually impaired / mentally disabled etc. patients)?

  3. How, in the light of the above, can we consistently and ethically distinguish between those instances in which self-perception does override objective reality, and those in which it doesn't?

  4. Is your response to 5) a sufficiently strong argument to outweigh other groups' corresponding arguments that their own (and they would say, equally valid!) self-perception should outweigh current social contracts and legal processes? (For examples, see my bulletted list above, in the original version of these questions).

This is a lot because these are complex issues. However, as I know you engage in some detail with these threads and are also very clear indeed in your views on these issues, I hope you can devote a few summarising sentences or so to explain each to us.

Thanks in advance.

Edited

I was just thinking it may help to add...

If the above is too much, feel free to adapt each question to a quick Y/N instead (eg. for Q1, Can potentially life-saving... etc., and for Q3, Can these rights be reconciled... etc.). Maybe then you could explain just two or three of the more difficult ones more fully to justify the Y/N.

Also, note that MN sent the numbering a bit awry, in that Q5 should refer to "your response to Q4".

All should now be crystal clear!

I persist because I really do think addressing these would really help you to help us to understand your POV and reasoning, Lacksie.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/11/2026 17:41

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 16:51

In another life, I sometimes needed to write pretentious bollocks for my job.

One soon learns to avoid ever committing to any concrete interpretation because that could be challenged and one might have to back up said bollocks, which given it was bollcoks was not always going to be doable.

I discovered one of the absolute best strategies to avoid concrete meaning was always insisting I was interrogating (a great cutural-bollocks word) the space between terms that might have teasingly appeared to be what the bollocks was trying to get it. Literally always able to be in a place there's no clear way to express simply by defining my space as a place between the words.

An infinite recursion of "no, it's not that; no, not quite that; no, almost and close to that but yet not exactly that". Always implying that my analysis was just a little bit smarter, more subtle than whatever meaning anyone attempted to pin on it, but also that it was almost in reach and definitely, definitely worth someone's while to spend time on.

Was great fun actually.

Of course, I knew what I was doing.

I'm not sure why that should spring to mind on this thread, but there you go.

Maybe it's because I've been working with AI a lot this week and I'm recognising that same will-o-the-wisp, just one more step pattern there as well. They really do knowingly code those things to be addictive I think - once we start paying for token use, obviously better to have a model that almost gets you there but has just one more thing to clarify first than one that delivers first time.

Or maybe it's for some other reason this springs to mind after all those years. After all, who can even guess at the unknowability of the human mind, or at anyone else's motivations and reasons?

Edited

I got an A in an a level drama exam at school when I was asked how I would stage a play - I said I would leave the stage totally bare (I waffled a lot more than this but this was the entire thrust of my argument) “to symbolise the futility of man’s struggle against the sea.” I’m wise to waffle that adds up to nothing 😂

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 17:41

MrsOvertonsWindow · 07/11/2026 17:12

Sadly Lacks, as you point out, this is what transgenderism is:
"that to be trans itself is to engage in fakery, pretence, sexism and entitlement".

It's absolutely fundamental to transactivists that they dismiss the rights of others (especially women and children), create bodily facsimiles of the opposite sex,, insist that anyone challenging, exposing, even noticing the facsimile is a bigot to be dismissed as transphobic.

I've not idea what it is that motivates you to spend so many hours on here trying to persuade mostly women to abandon standing up for the rights of women and the need to safeguard the young. Only you can know the answer to that.

But you'll never persuade posters that children should be abandoned to the born in the wrong body lobby. That mentally vulnerable young women should mutilate their bodies having been indoctrinated online by the trans mob

By all means keep sharing your word salads. Just pointing out that resposnible ethical adults will never agree with you.

Edited

Sadly Lacks, as you point out, this is what transgenderism is:
"that to be trans itself is to engage in fakery, pretence, sexism and entitlement".

It's really awful that you believe this and promote it on the internet . It's just sheer prejudice through and through.

Catiette · 07/11/2026 17:42

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/11/2026 17:41

I got an A in an a level drama exam at school when I was asked how I would stage a play - I said I would leave the stage totally bare (I waffled a lot more than this but this was the entire thrust of my argument) “to symbolise the futility of man’s struggle against the sea.” I’m wise to waffle that adds up to nothing 😂

Speaking of... Canute comes to mind in a number of ways in this thread!

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 17:48

Catiette · 07/11/2026 17:23

OK, no worries - back to the essence of them.

  1. Given some trans-identifying males' perception of themselves as female...

a) How can potentially life-saving sex-disaggregated clinical trials be ethically and meaningfully administered (acknowledging the potential for small numbers of males to significantly distort results, especially in smaller trials)?

b) How can a doctor (for example) administer drugs such as ambien or morphine, or appropriate sex-specific treatment if required, to

i) an unconscious patient?

ii) someone with Dr Upton's self-perception?

  1. Does a female patient have the right to request a female-only clinician in line with her perception of what "female" means?

  2. If your answer to the above is yes, how can this right be reconciled with a trans-identifying male medic's own right to perceive himself as female, in practical terms, while acknowledging the issues posters outline above (eg. visually impaired / mentally disabled etc. patients)?

  3. How, in the light of the above, can we consistently and ethically distinguish between those instances in which self-perception does override objective reality, and those in which it doesn't?

  4. Is your response to 5) a sufficiently strong argument to outweigh other groups' corresponding arguments that their own (and they would say, equally valid!) self-perception should outweigh current social contracts and legal processes? (For examples, see my bulletted list above, in the original version of these questions).

This is a lot because these are complex issues. However, as I know you engage in some detail with these threads and are also very clear indeed in your views on these issues, I hope you can devote a few summarising sentences or so to explain each to us.

Thanks in advance.

Edited
  1. a) I don't understand the question, what has some people being trans got to do with how we measure sex in clinical trials?
b) i) I don't understand the question. ii) I don't understand the question.
  1. Absolutely. A patient has the right to request to be treated by a different doctor for any reason. DU also emphasised this in her testimony. Requesting a female doctor is totally valid, and for some people female means registered female at birth.
  1. The two can be reconciled, people just need to make their wishes clear, appreciating that people may have different understandings of certain contested terminologies.
  1. I don't understand the question.
  1. I don't understand the question.
Lacksie · 07/11/2026 17:49

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 17:37

“Second, ‘female people’ don’t speak with one voice — plenty of women don’t see trans women’s inclusion as unfair to them, so ‘fair to women’ here means ‘fair by your reckoning’, and you’re calling the women who disagree sexist.”

When it comes to access to a collective group (ie female ) single sex access of a publicly accessed provision , the bar for consent is I am afraid set at the lowest level of acceptance. Meaning if one female person who will be potentially accessing that provision says they don’t accept a male person being there, that is the decision. Consent by a majority of a group doesn’t over ride the rejection of the people who don’t consent. In safeguarding, when safeguarding matters and it is a publicly accessed provision, that consent is not democratically over ridden. That is the antithesis to consent.

It's got nothing whatsoever to do with "consent". It's about balancing competing needs/ interests/ wants in a public space.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 17:50

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 17:48

  1. a) I don't understand the question, what has some people being trans got to do with how we measure sex in clinical trials?
b) i) I don't understand the question. ii) I don't understand the question.
  1. Absolutely. A patient has the right to request to be treated by a different doctor for any reason. DU also emphasised this in her testimony. Requesting a female doctor is totally valid, and for some people female means registered female at birth.
  1. The two can be reconciled, people just need to make their wishes clear, appreciating that people may have different understandings of certain contested terminologies.
  1. I don't understand the question.
  1. I don't understand the question.

sorry the numbering got messed up

Catiette · 07/11/2026 17:53

Thank you.

Regarding the responses, I find 3) interesting. Could you suggest the words such a female patient should use to guard against misunderstanding, being distressingly put on the spot, or being accused of transphobia? Please assume disability and vulnerability, so we're maximising the inclusivity of your response. It would be very interesting to see what you suggest. (Not to mention invaluable to posters who are genuinely anxious about this to the point of, in the case of a minority, I can quite easily believe actually being put off seeking treatment).

Regarding the ones you don't understand, frankly, I'm not entirely convinced by this. You could have a go, at least, or propose what you think I may mean. The quality of your arguments are head and shoulders above the usually visitor arguing for the kind of trans "rights" posters here may find potentially problematic (eg. self-identification as female as a medic), so unless you're relying disproportionately on AI, I'm confident that you can get the gist - or at the least respond, instead of a phrase that closes down engagement, with a question that would help me to move you towards greater understanding.

Catiette · 07/11/2026 17:53

No worries, MN hates numbering I find.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 17:53

I'd love to know how the belief that a man's mind can make him for any practical purpose more like a "woman" than a man could be construed in way that is not sexist 😂

Sadly I have no expectation whatsoever of anyone managing to provide this explanation. Assert it, sure. But actually show how it can be true? Nope. Not without changing the terms of the question to deflect it away from the impact on female people to some other definition that's easier to argue

MrsOvertonsWindow · 07/11/2026 18:02

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 17:41

Sadly Lacks, as you point out, this is what transgenderism is:
"that to be trans itself is to engage in fakery, pretence, sexism and entitlement".

It's really awful that you believe this and promote it on the internet . It's just sheer prejudice through and through.

Nope. It's reality.
People are entitled to live their lives via unreality, falsehoods and fantasy. What we do in our private lives is up to us as long as we don't harm others.

What they're not entitled to do is to upend society, remove safeguarding from others (especially children) and try to impose their false distorted views on society.

You are trying to persuade others to accept an incoherent ideology, a fantasy that causes massive harm to the young and mentally vulnerable.

The Russell Brand case (and countless others) demonstrates what happens when society celebrates those promoting their own sexual needs and egos. When women are seen as disposable with no right to consent. Where the safety of children is disposable,

No more.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread