Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
MyAmpleSheep · 07/11/2026 15:30

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 07/11/2026 15:25

I agree with you. I do have one thing niggling me. Isn't it at least arguable that an employer providing changing rooms and toilets etc is providing a service to their employees? Is this point clarified in the EA2010 or elsewhere?

Section 29 EA2010 kicks off with:

A person (a “service-provider”) concerned with the provision of a service to the public or a section of the public (for payment or not) must not discriminate...

So you can be a service provider to your employees, but if you're not providing a service to the public or a section of the public (employers, by providing changing rooms to their employees, are not) then you are not bound by section 29.

CassOle · 07/11/2026 15:34

Heggettypeg · 07/11/2026 13:42

By yourself, in a vacuum, you could have an inbuilt instinctive feeling of being other than you seem. But you can only understand that feeling in terms of known possibilities, which is already not the feeling itself, but interpretation of the feeling in the light of your experience of the outside world. This is still the case even when the interpretation is not a conscious process of deliberate thought.

Imagine a mule that is conscious of self. It has grown up with its donkey mother. But it feels, instinctively, not-donkey. One day it sees a horse. It "recognises" itself as a horse because that's the only not-donkey equine the world has offered it. (Or, if it's a precise and cautious sort of mule, it might recognise itself as not-really-horse- either, and hold off from giving a label to its feeling yet. )

If it opts for "horse', and insists on that, it will run into trouble with other people, who can see perfectly well that it isn't what they would call a horse. Its feeling of not-donkey is perfectly real and valid. But its inference and expectations based on the feeling are not.

It's a Hinny in your example.
Mules have a horse mother and a donkey father.

(Now that I have been a terrible pedant, I shall run away from this thread again).

MyAmpleSheep · 07/11/2026 15:35

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 14:08

How we should treat, accommodate trans people is a separate question I agree.

But we can't possibly begin to have a reasonable conversation about that when people don't understand the basics of what being trans is. So much of the dismissal and anger towards trans people rests on assumptions that trans people are "fake" "pretending" "sexist" "entitled". This is all so very very very wrong, and it's a consequence of people not actually understanding trans experience and what it is.

Are you seriously suggesting that not a single person who claims to be trans-gender is fake, pretending, sexist or entitled? Not one?

I suggest a significant proportion are all of those, and the majority at least one.

Why is it a prerequisite for us to agree all people claiming a trans identity are without exception lovely and genuine before we can discuss how society should accomodate them?

I think the way society accomodates trans people, whatever it should be, should not incentivise people with bad intentions falsely to claim a trans identity the better to further their nefarious goals by giving them privileges that nobody else gets.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 07/11/2026 15:47

alcovecupboards · 02/11/2026 22:54

As I've already said - yes they do. None of that has anything to do with the fact that Sandie Peggie is a vile bigot. Even vile bigots are entitled to single sex spaces - but I wouldn't want her anywhere near me or my family.

"Vile" is rapidly losing its power, it's overused so much.

As for Sandie Peggie, I do criticise her behaviour several years ago when she posted the picture (which I have seen posted far more often by TRAs being "vile" towards SP) of ten unpleasant jokes. Even if she was posting it to say how shocking such jokes are, it would be better not to spread them, wouldn't you agree?

On the other hand, are people not allowed to learn and grow? If SP's behaviour was once poor, that says little about how she is now. She may have struggled with her daughter's coming out; many parents have found that adjustment difficult, and SP seems actually a model of how to handle it, based on the current relationships in her family.

I have often noticed that those who are free with the word "bigot" don't seem to possess a mirror.

Catiette · 07/11/2026 16:17

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 07/11/2026 15:47

"Vile" is rapidly losing its power, it's overused so much.

As for Sandie Peggie, I do criticise her behaviour several years ago when she posted the picture (which I have seen posted far more often by TRAs being "vile" towards SP) of ten unpleasant jokes. Even if she was posting it to say how shocking such jokes are, it would be better not to spread them, wouldn't you agree?

On the other hand, are people not allowed to learn and grow? If SP's behaviour was once poor, that says little about how she is now. She may have struggled with her daughter's coming out; many parents have found that adjustment difficult, and SP seems actually a model of how to handle it, based on the current relationships in her family.

I have often noticed that those who are free with the word "bigot" don't seem to possess a mirror.

I don't know about losing its power.

It never ceases to astonish me that the posters on here who seem most likely to condemn the person not the behaviour, or to throw around quite extreme and distressing accusations like this, are those who most explicitly claim to be morally superior and on the side of right. The irony of it packs a punch every time.

In the early days of my terfism, as I was weighing the different sides of the argument and testing every thought from every possible angle, this way of thinking and behaving went a long way to confirming to me that all was not well in the state of genderism. I continue to find it disturbing even now.

Your post above - setting the old favourites "vile" and "bigot" against 8 lines of reflection which acknowledge several different ways of thinking about it - is not unrepresentative of the overall trend seen here and, in my limited experience, on Reddit and Twitter.

Really, there are (I hope!) very few people who are out and out nasty or fundamentally irredeemable. There are reams who are prejudiced, though, whether or not the'll admit it - and we're all flawed to a greater or lesser degree.

To see someone like Sandie - possibly prejudiced, definitely flawed, basically human - reduced to "vile" and "bigot" with such unreflective certainty always chills me.

To similarly see the honest acknowledgement that some proportion of trans-identifying males are likely taking advantage presented as bigotry reinforces the irony.

It's a consistent positioning of one group on the side of the do-no-wrong angels, and the other as anathema, on the basis of their politics/beliefs - the very definition of what's being accused (and, much as I hate to do the genocide thing, it's far closer to the root of so many 20th-century horrors than a considered - if often emotive and sometimes upsetting - discussion of a conflict of rights can be).

It's why more considered discussions here are so often misrepresented as "all trans people" this and "all trans people" that: defensive, indefensible DARVO. (It's also why I think we need to word discussions here very carefully, to guard against that misrepresentation).

No. I think "vile" and "bigot" retain their power, in that they serve as important indicators to me and, I suspect, many others, of on which side most danger really lies in this debate.

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 16:19

10 Spout a load of incoherent shite
20 Answer questions with 'what, who, where' or say 'I'm sorry you don't understand, try educating yourself'
30 Wait for the VERY FUCKING SIMPLE questions that we know you can't answer to move out of sight on the thread
40 GOTO 10

Every time.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 07/11/2026 16:47

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 09:59

Trans is a word that means fake?

Maybe 'mock' would be more appropriate.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 16:51

MyAmpleSheep · 07/11/2026 15:35

Are you seriously suggesting that not a single person who claims to be trans-gender is fake, pretending, sexist or entitled? Not one?

I suggest a significant proportion are all of those, and the majority at least one.

Why is it a prerequisite for us to agree all people claiming a trans identity are without exception lovely and genuine before we can discuss how society should accomodate them?

I think the way society accomodates trans people, whatever it should be, should not incentivise people with bad intentions falsely to claim a trans identity the better to further their nefarious goals by giving them privileges that nobody else gets.

Edited

Eh?
I didn’t say every trans person is lovely and genuine - trans people are all individuals like anyone else; some people are lovely, some are arseholes. And so what?
The dismissal and anger towards trans people as a group/ category rests on a false account of what being trans itself is — that to be trans itself is to engage in fakery, pretence, sexism and entitlement. That’s a claim about the category, not a character reference for each member. Some gay people are lovely, others are liars; it tells you nothing about what being gay is, and whether we should criminalise homosexuality or not.

We absolutely need to have an accurate understanding of what trans experience is in order to have a reasonable conversation about how to accommodate trans people as a group in society.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 16:51

In another life, I sometimes needed to write pretentious bollocks for my job.

One soon learns to avoid ever committing to any concrete interpretation because that could be challenged and one might have to back up said bollocks, which given it was bollcoks was not always going to be doable.

I discovered one of the absolute best strategies to avoid concrete meaning was always insisting I was interrogating (a great cutural-bollocks word) the space between terms that might have teasingly appeared to be what the bollocks was trying to get it. Literally always able to be in a place there's no clear way to express simply by defining my space as a place between the words.

An infinite recursion of "no, it's not that; no, not quite that; no, almost and close to that but yet not exactly that". Always implying that my analysis was just a little bit smarter, more subtle than whatever meaning anyone attempted to pin on it, but also that it was almost in reach and definitely, definitely worth someone's while to spend time on.

Was great fun actually.

Of course, I knew what I was doing.

I'm not sure why that should spring to mind on this thread, but there you go.

Maybe it's because I've been working with AI a lot this week and I'm recognising that same will-o-the-wisp, just one more step pattern there as well. They really do knowingly code those things to be addictive I think - once we start paying for token use, obviously better to have a model that almost gets you there but has just one more thing to clarify first than one that delivers first time.

Or maybe it's for some other reason this springs to mind after all those years. After all, who can even guess at the unknowability of the human mind, or at anyone else's motivations and reasons?

Catiette · 07/11/2026 16:54

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 16:51

Eh?
I didn’t say every trans person is lovely and genuine - trans people are all individuals like anyone else; some people are lovely, some are arseholes. And so what?
The dismissal and anger towards trans people as a group/ category rests on a false account of what being trans itself is — that to be trans itself is to engage in fakery, pretence, sexism and entitlement. That’s a claim about the category, not a character reference for each member. Some gay people are lovely, others are liars; it tells you nothing about what being gay is, and whether we should criminalise homosexuality or not.

We absolutely need to have an accurate understanding of what trans experience is in order to have a reasonable conversation about how to accommodate trans people as a group in society.

Edited

Just to make sure people don't think Shedmistress had a point in her rather cynical numbered list a few posts up, Lacksie... Did you have any response to my questions (or any clarification, with ref. to my bulletted quotes from you, as to where I misunderstood you in it)?

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 16:56

Catiette · 07/11/2026 16:54

Just to make sure people don't think Shedmistress had a point in her rather cynical numbered list a few posts up, Lacksie... Did you have any response to my questions (or any clarification, with ref. to my bulletted quotes from you, as to where I misunderstood you in it)?

No I told you, I don't understand what your questions are. You attributed statements to me that have nothing to do with what I said and then demanded I justify them. How am I supposed to respond to that? When I asked for clarity you declined to provide it.

Catiette · 07/11/2026 16:57

Catiette · 07/11/2026 13:31

The quotation I cite in the post to which you're responding, and the context in which you wrote it.

If that doesn't mean what I "attribute", I'd be interested to hear why, and I'd be happy to reswponse.

That will then enable use to explore the questions in my post and address any suspicions of your seeking to evade direct answers to these.

Is this where I "declined" to clarify?

Catiette · 07/11/2026 16:57

Catiette · 07/11/2026 14:07

NB. In the below, please note my various citations from your posts could be applied to various of my attributions in relation to them.

So.

My understanding of what you say (bold), with reference to your own words (italics).

A) Material reality is complex for two reasons:

a) there will always be exceptions to common rules and patterns

  • It is proven science.
  • They have to know their relevant physiological / medical history. Sex is a proxy- it's a useful proxy much of the time, and sometimes it's not. Many people define biological sex in terms of chromosomes.
  • Are women with CAIS allowed to be doctors?
  • The characteristics of the body are separate from the recognition/ observation of them...The second can’t be reduced to the first, it's reductive and false to pretend it can.

b) we can only ever experience it through individual human consciousness and perception.

  • The pp's hypothetical depends on the assumption that everyone has the same understanding of these terms - male and female - as she does: what they mean and how they should be applied. But they don't. That's the entire point.
  • Theory of mind my dear, theory of mind. DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality.
  • Body recognition doesn't work like that - it's a pre-reflective, non-conceptual type of cognition that stands entirely apart from conscious knowing
  • I understand that your definition of ‘female’ excludes trans women. Many people don’t share that definition.

B) On this basis, defining objective meaning is, in the case of sex and female consent in a medical context, fundamentally impossible, and associated safeguarding rules collapse under the weight of this complexity.

  • Your entire philosophy is founded on the premise that we can and must discredit another person's claim to be female!!!
  • I don't 'believe they should be able to identify into the opposite sex category', I understand that the reality of their experience is that they do.
  • She was saying that, to her, a request for a female doctor wouldn’t automatically mean the patient was refusing her. DU... is not required to disclose her own medical history to patients.

...if [and I implicitly assume she will] Lacksie feels that the objective reality of biological sex does indeed supercede self-perception in these contexts [ administering drugs and/or treatment in contexts in which self-perception of sex conflicts with perceived sex, or can't be shared]...

  • Just someone who understands the science.
  • Interpreting the words "woman" and "female" expansively to include rare minority variations, does not imply that language, law or medicine for female people at large will collapse.
  • What is putting people in ACTUAL DANGER is the string of repressive reforms

Or was it here? 🤔

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 16:58

Catiette · 07/11/2026 16:57

Is this where I "declined" to clarify?

No. I responded to this post where you said you'd ben interested in hearing why. I said why what? And you declined to clarify. I don't know what your question is.

Catiette · 07/11/2026 16:58

If those don't suffice, do feel free to clarify, er, your request for clarity and I'll, er, clarify again! 😅

Catiette · 07/11/2026 16:59

Ah, I see. You're thinking of the question singular. Here are the questions plural to which I'm referring which preceded this. Hang on...

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 16:59

Catiette · 07/11/2026 16:58

If those don't suffice, do feel free to clarify, er, your request for clarity and I'll, er, clarify again! 😅

What is it that you want me to answer?

Catiette · 07/11/2026 17:00

Catiette · 07/11/2026 12:28

As I understand it, Lacksie's saying the following:

A) Material reality is complex for two reasons: a) there will always be exceptions to common rules and patterns, and b) we can only ever experience it through individual human consciousness and perception.

B) On this basis, defining objective meaning is, in the case of sex and female consent in a medical context, fundamentally impossible, and associated safeguarding rules collapse under the weight of this complexity.

Where I think this all falls down is in Lacksie's extrapolation of B) from A). After all, this philosophy of indefinable complexity and the paramouncy of subjective reality is applicable to pretty much everything! So what I've not yet seen from Lacksie or others is anything approaching a convincing assessment of why it should be applied in this case, and not in other cases.

For example, Lacksie says:

"The pp's hypothetical depends on the assumption that everyone has the same understanding of these terms - male and female - as she does: what they mean and how they should be applied. But they don't. That's the entire point... DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality..."

This is explicit and emphatic. Could Lacksie explain then, in the light of this,

  1. How clinical trials exploring how best to preserve life and health on a global scale with necessary reference to sex difference can be ethically and meaningfully administered?

  2. How a doctor should (for example) administer drugs such as ambien or morphine, or appropriate sex-specific treatment if required, to a) an unconscious patient or b) someone with Dr Upton's self-perception?

Next, if Lacksie feels that the objective reality of biological sex does indeed supercede self-perception in these contexts, I'd ask,

  1. How does one consistently and ethically distinguish between those instances in which self-perception does override objective reality, and those in which it doesn't?

  2. How does one present a sufficiently strong argument for these exceptions?

For example, Lacksie's clear that the sheet complexity of determining an objective reality (A) above) renders female patients' right to request and receive (given availability) a female clinician impossible to meet, or, at the least, effectively moot.

How, then, can this argument be made sufficiently strongly such that it unambiguously overrides the arguments others would certainly make for their own self-perception to be paramount at the expense of others? Consider, as examples:

  • a white supremicist
  • someone clinically depressed (the assisted dying debate)
  • a parent convinced their child has ADHD and is entitled to accommodations in examinations despite the commonly accepted (but ever-evolving!) assessment demonstrating otherwise
  • an egregious example of workplace disability discrimination nevertheless being dragged through the courts at immeasurable personal expense because the employer contests it
  • fantasists etc. etc. etc.
  • an infinity of others - take your well-chosen pick!

It will have to be a damn strong argument to counter-act these cases, especially in the light of the answers I find it hard to imagine not being given to 1) and 2), for which I can find no equivalent in scope and import in my above examples.

Lacksie? Alcove?

There was no acknowledgement to my last lengthy post on your side. Understandable in a busy, fast-moving thread, but I'd appreciate a direct and honest response to this one.

Edited to clarify lettering and numbering!

Edited

This one.

Again, do clarify what you need if this isn't enough. I'm on and off again but will try to respond.

Catiette · 07/11/2026 17:01

For clarity (😉) the questions are those labelled 1, 2, 3 and 4. Answering them offers ample scope to address any misunderstandings on my part, too.

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 17:01

Catiette · 07/11/2026 16:54

Just to make sure people don't think Shedmistress had a point in her rather cynical numbered list a few posts up, Lacksie... Did you have any response to my questions (or any clarification, with ref. to my bulletted quotes from you, as to where I misunderstood you in it)?

Or my most recent one which is:

In terms of Dr Upton, what is your, Lacksie's, cognitive process from looking at a man to arguing on the internet that you think he is a woman?

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 17:01

Catiette · 07/11/2026 17:00

This one.

Again, do clarify what you need if this isn't enough. I'm on and off again but will try to respond.

I have already responded to this.

I never said these things:

"A) Material reality is complex for two reasons: a) there will always be exceptions to common rules and patterns, and b) we can only ever experience it through individual human consciousness and perception.
B) On this basis, defining objective meaning is, in the case of sex and female consent in a medical context, fundamentally impossible, and associated safeguarding rules collapse under the weight of this complexity."

What you have attributed to me is incoherent and I don't know what you mean by it or why you think I said it. I also don't understand your questions that follow from this misattribution either.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 17:05

Oh, and while you may need to understand exactly what trans experience is to understand how you will accomodate trans people, you don't need to understand that to rule out some of the ways you won't accomodate trans people, because you can do that based on other factors like how it impacts other people.

An analogy would be - society very much has to solve (or maybe just morally should solve) some of the problems that are arising from increasing wealth inequality. It's an extremely complex prolem with many stakeholders and different views and indeed ideologies. We may never solve it.

However, in the meantime society has nevertheless pretty much agreed that one way we don't solve it is to give everyone carte blanche to take someone else's stuff if they strongly believe their need is greater. Neither have we let on the table the possibility of reducing the number of poor people by reducing the number of people rather than their poverty. We have, despite the complexity and moral components of the problem, desote not knowing how we will solve it, somehow amazingly been able to rule out some ways we won't.

So yes, one absolutely can say No to treating male bodies people "as if" they were female when it comes to language ("woman, girl, her, she, female" etc), law, culture, single sex spaces, opportunities and protections etc simply based on the unreasonableness of that demand's consequences for female people.

There's absolutely no reason to put off treating female people fairly until one decides what society will or will not extend to trans people, and frankly it's utterly fucking shockingly sexist not to see that.

Catiette · 07/11/2026 17:05

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 17:01

I have already responded to this.

I never said these things:

"A) Material reality is complex for two reasons: a) there will always be exceptions to common rules and patterns, and b) we can only ever experience it through individual human consciousness and perception.
B) On this basis, defining objective meaning is, in the case of sex and female consent in a medical context, fundamentally impossible, and associated safeguarding rules collapse under the weight of this complexity."

What you have attributed to me is incoherent and I don't know what you mean by it or why you think I said it. I also don't understand your questions that follow from this misattribution either.

Edited

I've responded to the "why you think I said it" (and thereby, implicitly, the "what you mean") above in massive bullet-pointed detail. From recent posts, I'm not yet sure if you saw that.

If that doesn't suffice, I also note immediately above that you don't need to agree with or engage with the misattributions to answer the questions, and that answering the questions is a great way to address the misattributions in any case!

Or maybe you mean I should rephrase the questions themselves, in which case I'm happy to do so.

I can't say fairer than that, guv!

MyAmpleSheep · 07/11/2026 17:05

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 16:51

Eh?
I didn’t say every trans person is lovely and genuine - trans people are all individuals like anyone else; some people are lovely, some are arseholes. And so what?
The dismissal and anger towards trans people as a group/ category rests on a false account of what being trans itself is — that to be trans itself is to engage in fakery, pretence, sexism and entitlement. That’s a claim about the category, not a character reference for each member. Some gay people are lovely, others are liars; it tells you nothing about what being gay is, and whether we should criminalise homosexuality or not.

We absolutely need to have an accurate understanding of what trans experience is in order to have a reasonable conversation about how to accommodate trans people as a group in society.

Edited

There's no gatekeeping to being trans. So obviously some arseholes will and do adopt it only because they're arseholes and not because they have any kind of gender dysphoria or other internal distress.

Any accomodation for trans-identifying people has to manage the fact that at least some - and quite a lot of the most vocal trans-identifying people are trans-because-they're-arseholes-and-claiming-to-be-trans-is-a-great-way-to-inconvenience-everyone-else-with-being-an-arsehole.

That's a given, before we discuss what accommodations we should all make for people claiming a trans identity.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 17:07

Catiette · 07/11/2026 17:05

I've responded to the "why you think I said it" (and thereby, implicitly, the "what you mean") above in massive bullet-pointed detail. From recent posts, I'm not yet sure if you saw that.

If that doesn't suffice, I also note immediately above that you don't need to agree with or engage with the misattributions to answer the questions, and that answering the questions is a great way to address the misattributions in any case!

Or maybe you mean I should rephrase the questions themselves, in which case I'm happy to do so.

I can't say fairer than that, guv!

I'm so sorry I just don't follow your posts I'm afraid.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread