Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think support from the Job Center should be for everyone?

158 replies

Frequency · 25/03/2024 13:43

I had my appointment for contributions-based JSA today. I had a list of questions about support/help that would assist me in getting back into work quicker.

I was pretty much told their services are not for me and other professionals or people who have been previously successful. Their services only cover people who lack basic skills.

None of what I asked about was available to me or anyone else using their services.

I asked for;

Assistance towards paying for driving lessons as we have a lack of jobs available locally and poor public transport. Even this was only a money-off voucher with certain providers or meant having to travel to a government-approved driving school I would have taken the support.

Local or remote training that would lead to a professional certification or government certificate to verify I had the skills covered by the course - I was thinking of things like Cisco/Juniper/Solar Winds etc. They only offer functional skills. They have the government-funded skills courses on top of this but these are not run by the JC and they have no information on them.

Professional CV writing services to make sure I am using the right keywords to get through the AI scanner/past HR. They offer support with CVs but it is basic such as support with SPAG and how to use a word processor.

I understand the budget is limited but surely spending towards some of these things for people on a low-income or looking for employment would reduce the benefits bill in the long-run?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CuteOrangeElephant · 30/03/2024 19:06

@Frequency I just did my AWS Solution Architect Associate, which is quite broad. If I was in your position I would start with either SysOps Administrator Associate or Developer Associate.

I used the Stephane Maarek courses on Udemy to prepare. I am going to do Developer next. I am also interested in Kubernetes.

mrsjg · 28/03/2024 06:23

Back in the early 90's I worked out of town and wanted a job in the town where I lived. I would frequently visit the job centre on my lunch break to see what was available. Asked about a job and was told they couldn't help me as I was already employed, they were only there to help unemployed people find jobs.

SpringBunnies · 28/03/2024 06:11

If you are interviewing for your next role, having real experience is more important than a cert but no experience. Have a look how you can gain experience in devops, site reliability engineering. (That’s what the PP @imansre nickname means. Unsure if you know the acronym).

Kubernetes is specific for docker application deployment. I’m not sure if your NHS role will give exposure to that? But look out for any automation opportunities. Things like ansible, chef, puppet. Or monitoring. But really keep an eye out for learning opportunities.

ILJ28 · 28/03/2024 02:34

Frequency · 27/03/2024 21:44

No, it was pure web development I was/am interested in. I have very limited exposure to AWS but I reckon I could learn that relatively easily.

This has all been really helpful.

This is what I wanted from the JC. When I try to talk to family about my career I get shut down straight away with "We don't know what you are talking about, leave us alone."

DH used to let me talk at him until I figured things out for myself.

New plan;

Take the job with the NHS which does seem to be more sysadmin funnily enough, despite me not really having a great deal of experience in that area.

Get AWS cert followed by Kubernetes and try to push NHS for some exposure to Dev Ops.

And pass my driving test obvs.

I will also do the software course which is a foundation degree with the option to go on to do a full degree but as I said that is more from interest than anything else. We have no TV. I relax on an evening by doing Udemy courses Grin

And don’t forget looking for that moped! Will give you confidence AND independence while you’re learning to drive… then sell (or give to DD) once you e passed your test 😉

456pickupsticks · 27/03/2024 21:45

Yes, there should be far more services available.

I went into the job centre near my parent's house when I was 18 on a university break, looking for a job for the 3 month break (having had a part time job at uni).
They outright said they couldn't help me if I was in full time education, and they didn't have a board or anything with adverts, and my best bet was just looking on google or going round locally with CVs, but they wouldn't take any to give to anyone looking for employees.

The definitely aren't actual job centres - more like 'benefit hubs'.

Frequency · 27/03/2024 21:44

No, it was pure web development I was/am interested in. I have very limited exposure to AWS but I reckon I could learn that relatively easily.

This has all been really helpful.

This is what I wanted from the JC. When I try to talk to family about my career I get shut down straight away with "We don't know what you are talking about, leave us alone."

DH used to let me talk at him until I figured things out for myself.

New plan;

Take the job with the NHS which does seem to be more sysadmin funnily enough, despite me not really having a great deal of experience in that area.

Get AWS cert followed by Kubernetes and try to push NHS for some exposure to Dev Ops.

And pass my driving test obvs.

I will also do the software course which is a foundation degree with the option to go on to do a full degree but as I said that is more from interest than anything else. We have no TV. I relax on an evening by doing Udemy courses Grin

OP posts:
imansre · 27/03/2024 21:29

Frequency · 27/03/2024 21:11

Thanks @SpringBunnies

Web Dev or application development is more what I am interested in rather than network automation or Dev Ops but an in is an in and getting a role in Dev Ops would be a step closer.

AWS and Kubernetes certs are now top of my list, alongside the software course. Maybe I will do CCNA after those if I still have not got any closer to where I want to be.

@SpringBunnies is right (our setups are very similar btw! Well at my current company anyway).

OP, I'm not sure what your previous background was. But pure 'web development/ 'software engineering' is saturated. Not only is the former the entry point for practically everybody and their grandmothers, thanks to the media hype + bootcamps. But, the skillsets are different. You'd need to know things like unit tests, integration tests, design patterns, API design, exception handling etc a lot of these are learnt on the job. They are an art.

There are jobs like mine (see username) which are software engineering roles that also require a strong infrastructure background but again, 'modern' infrastructure like that I and PP have been talking about, related to those DevOps roles.

I think you can make the jump if you were previously a strong software dev. But your current skillset IMO is more valuable. having done both application development is more popular, but easier to master for most CRUD applications IMO compared to infrastructure. Of course, if you're writing code for high performance such as algorithmic trading, it's a different story.

Almostwelsh · 27/03/2024 21:20

Idk why so many people are laughing about the driving lessons. I was unemployed 30 years ago and they certainly did offer driving courses then in my area ( And HGV courses - if you pass a HGV test you don't need to take a separate car test).

If you've not encountered the job centre recently I can see how you'd be perplexed, they have deliberately made things harder for people in recent years.

Frequency · 27/03/2024 21:11

Thanks @SpringBunnies

Web Dev or application development is more what I am interested in rather than network automation or Dev Ops but an in is an in and getting a role in Dev Ops would be a step closer.

AWS and Kubernetes certs are now top of my list, alongside the software course. Maybe I will do CCNA after those if I still have not got any closer to where I want to be.

OP posts:
SpringBunnies · 27/03/2024 20:59

I mean software skills as a sysadmin no certification.

SpringBunnies · 27/03/2024 20:59

I agree with your background you don’t need a software certification. I think you need it for being a sysadmin, not a software developer. You need to think about DevOps type automation. I work as a developer but I know my SA colleagues use CI/CD and IoC to build on premise VMs. We are hybrid on premise and public cloud. We have kubernetes cluster on premise installed on Linux VM. We are also on AWS. There is definitely a demand for good sysadmin to do DevOps. I would imagine you can use that background to gain a foothold in?

For application development, you also need very solid kubernetes and AWS knowledge nowadays. We write all our infrastructure using either terraform or CDK. If your application doesn’t work, the SA team won’t help unless we can demonstrate it is an infrastructure problem. Maybe other places hire from bootcamps. But our hires are either experienced developers or graduates. We have had degree apprentices but I have only worked with one and it’s very rare.

Frequency · 27/03/2024 20:19

An AWS or Kubernetes certification would allow you to pivot.

@imansre I will look into getting one of these in case this happens again. Thank you.

Re: CCNA, can I pick your brain? I've been told it's not needed as it is entry-level and I have networking experience but my former employer wanted me to study towards it. I need to practice/speed up on the subnetting questions but apart from that I was ready to do the exam. Would that be worth paying for or not since I already have experience?

The software course is as much for interest as anything else. I would love to work in software but I also just really enjoy it as a hobby. I know you don't need certifications, only a portfolio but I don't feel like I'm ready to start applying to jobs yet. I am almost ready but not quite there. The structured learning of an actual course vs the self-teaching I have been doing would help prepare me quicker.

OP posts:
imansre · 27/03/2024 20:10

Frequency · 27/03/2024 16:39

I knew the benefits system was archaic and unfair but, like the people in 2008, I genuinely believed the job center itself was there to support people and help them find work.

But that's correct. They are there to help people find work. Any work. Not just work that meets their very high standards which, in your case, is fully remote.

Seriously OP you're not unemployable. And you already have an offer. The skillset for your job is usually 'traditional' companies that have significant on-prem infrastructure, these also tend to be hybrid rather than remote. Even for those 'remote', the market is bad, many are cutting back and returning to hybrid.

Don't waste your time on software courses - it's not required. Certifications could help but in your case, the problem is simply your target jobs.
Do you have any experience with DevOps, public cloud or containerisation at all? There are more of these remote jobs. Your current skillset seems old-school sysadmin. An AWS or Kubernetes certification would allow you to pivot.

Happy to share more information if you DM me. Always pleased to meet another woman in a very technical role. There are very few of us especially in infrastructure.

@EBearhug Personally I found those 'women in tech' events crap. 90% of the attendees were others looking to 'break in'. The ones there from the company just give generic advice, they don't give you an in.
I also signed up to one of those 'mentorship' programs, specified wanting help with technical leadership, a technical career path and they gave me... a saleswoman who had no idea what Linux or a command line even was.

If they really wanted to help me they'd have given me a principal engineer, of whatever gender, to advise.

Frequency · 27/03/2024 19:51

aodirjjd · 27/03/2024 18:34

But op don’t you see you’ve proven everyone’s point? You’ve got a job with 0 extra cost to tax payer. Driving lessons professional cv writing etc would have been wasted on you.

I only finished my last job 9 days ago and only applied for JSA yesterday so I don't think I would have gotten far enough along in the process to get any taxpayer money if it was an option.

I see your point but I was both lucky and willing to take a massive pay cut to avoid being unemployed. I had bonus points for being female as a pp said and H was working there when he passed away suddenly so if they recognised my name from him that would also have worked in my favour. A 50+ white male would not have had the same luck but would still deserve support in finding something.

OP posts:
aodirjjd · 27/03/2024 18:34

Frequency · 27/03/2024 16:39

I knew the benefits system was archaic and unfair but, like the people in 2008, I genuinely believed the job center itself was there to support people and help them find work.

But op don’t you see you’ve proven everyone’s point? You’ve got a job with 0 extra cost to tax payer. Driving lessons professional cv writing etc would have been wasted on you.

EBearhug · 27/03/2024 17:30

I'm not sure how I feel about driving a van given that I feel like death is imminent when driving a small car but I am determined I will not let driving beat me.

I feel safer in a van - it's higher up, so more visibility, and they're usually a better spec than my small car. Not that I've driven one in ages, but I have hired one a handful of times in the past for various reasons.

Frequency · 27/03/2024 16:39

I knew the benefits system was archaic and unfair but, like the people in 2008, I genuinely believed the job center itself was there to support people and help them find work.

OP posts:
Mrbumpssmile · 27/03/2024 16:31

As others have pointed out, Jobcentres aren't there to support people: they're there to punish and scare people.

I remember reading, back in the 2008 crisis, with astonishment and then bemusement, all those interviews in the Guardian and Independent with well-off, middle class people who'd been made redundant and were outraged at being treated like criminals by the DWP. It was news, to them, that the Jobcentre wasn't a friendly support service.

Mrbumpssmile · 27/03/2024 16:22

BelleDingle · 25/03/2024 13:51

pay for driving lessons?😂

Well, obviously the government should be providing adequate public transport and measures to cut private car use, but considering they're doing the opposite then yes, they do have a duty to provide alternatives to the transport services they've taken away, especially if they want people to be able to travel to jobs!

Frequency · 27/03/2024 16:17

I have a job offer.

It's a lot less money than I was on but it is in town after the two weeks' initial training.

I can still do the part-time software course and work toward that for the long term.

I interviewed for it last week but had not expected to hear anything because the job interview was 3 minutes long and consisted of asking me if I could drive and telling me I would need to drive a van if I passed my test. I'm not sure how I feel about driving a van given that I feel like death is imminent when driving a small car but I am determined I will not let driving beat me.

It also gives me enough evening/weekend time to pick up some extra hours in my friend's shop to top up my wage if needed.

It's only a temporary contract but it gives me some breathing space at least. And it is for the NHS so getting my foot in the door can only be a good thing.

@ButterflyTulips Try LinkedIn for remote work. They advertise quite a lot of remote admin/customer service roles but the competition for them is ridiculous.

OP posts:
aodirjjd · 27/03/2024 15:19

ButterflyTulips · 27/03/2024 13:18

I've been looking at CS jobs but I thought there was amove back towards having days in the office?

I dont live near a major city (or I would have applied for the coventry/ exam based ones) so a truly wfh job would make more available to me.

If the job doesn’t say it’s wfh then it’s not. Most depts are in 2 or 3 days a week. I wouldn’t risk taking a job that would be a crazy commute because I only see it going up.

ButterflyTulips · 27/03/2024 13:18

I've been looking at CS jobs but I thought there was amove back towards having days in the office?

I dont live near a major city (or I would have applied for the coventry/ exam based ones) so a truly wfh job would make more available to me.

Pireck · 27/03/2024 11:29

Honestly just apply for a remote job in the civil service. There's quite a few of them, you might have to occasionally visit a city but they'll pay expenses etc. There are virtually no jobs in the North East, that aren't public sector at least. There's just no economy up there as no businesses base themselves there and all the money people earn there gets funnelled straight back down south when they pay for stuff from big businesses etc.

Frequency · 27/03/2024 11:24

But - I've also been invited to a couple of events for women wanting to work in tech, with organisations like AWS. This was through LinkedIn, so make sure you're using it well enough

I'm finding this. I've just been invited to one for Solar Winds, which I have signed up for. Cisco is good for this too. And as I said, I have the software course starting on the 2nd.

I'm not getting interviews, although, in fairness, I've only been applying for positions for a month or so. I'm just not used to applying and not hearing back, Usually when I want a new job I apply to a handful, get 2-3 interviews, and have 1-2 jobs to pick from. In the interviews I have had the feedback is I am overqualified and would get bored/they feel I'd be using the position as a stop-gap until I find something better or they don't think I can reliably commute and have hired someone who lives closer/can drive.

There's not even that much I can apply to, atm. Even looking at retail etc there is nothing about locally.

@Ginmonkeyagain I am learning to drive as I've said several times throughout the thread. I am also willing to relocate if I find a job that would make relocation financially viable.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread