Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Women would have to give explicit consent for sex under rape law review

90 replies

Transperson · Yesterday 01:45

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/20/women-explicit-consent-sex-under-rape-law-review/

'Women could be required to explicitly consent to sex for it to be legal under reforms to be considered by the Law Commission.The commission is to launch a review of consent laws that will examine recent legal reforms in Canada and Australia, in which sexual activity requires a definitive “yes”.

Under current law in England and Wales, a defendant can be acquitted if a jury finds they held a “reasonable belief” that the other person consented, meaning cases can often hinge on whether a woman said “no”.Any change would amount to the biggest overhaul of sexual offence laws in England and Wales for two decades.This week, Joanne Young, who was raped and sexually assaulted by strangers after being drugged by her husband, called for a review of consent laws “as a priority”.'

This seems great :))

OP posts:
Grammarnut · Yesterday 22:09

SorcererGaheris · Yesterday 22:00

@Grammarnut

It does align with some of the definitions of work.

One of the definitions is "fulfill duties regularly for wages or salary". Prostitutes are fulfilling sexual duties for wages.

Another definition is to perform or carry through a task requiring sustained effort. Prostitution fits that.

Another definition is "to exert oneself physically or mentally" - there is a level of physical exertion in a number of sex acts. * *

Semantics. Prostitution is not work it is these things: rape, rape, rape, degradation, rape, rape. Paid for rape.
Also you are fitting the facts to an argument that does not match them in the least. Indeed, the last, that physical effort is required, is laughable.

SorcererGaheris · Yesterday 22:15

Grammarnut · Yesterday 22:09

Semantics. Prostitution is not work it is these things: rape, rape, rape, degradation, rape, rape. Paid for rape.
Also you are fitting the facts to an argument that does not match them in the least. Indeed, the last, that physical effort is required, is laughable.

Edited

@Grammarnut

Well, yes, it's semantics, because it's discussing definitions and meaning. If how something is defined is being discussed or debated, then semantics is an important part of that, surely?

I'm pointing out that society as a whole defines 'work in several ways, and prostitution aligns with some of them. So while you can choose not to define it as work, other people can choose to define it as a work if that is how they see it.

I would view oral sex as requiring some small physical effort. The physical effort need not be vast, it can be minimal. But sex is a physical act, so the effort is physical.

sawdustformypony · Yesterday 23:47

JuliaMaesa · Yesterday 15:29

So the guy has the signed document.

You get to it.

Then you decide to stop. But he now has your signed consent and thus a defence to unconsensual sex.

what then ?

Doesn’t the signature need to be witnessed by an independent adult? Both parties to the sexual act will need to sign the agreement document. The agreement will expressly define those sexual act (and possibly positions) for which consent is given. There’s probably going to have to be some app for this.

Yes, if you are going to stop then you will need another signed consent agreement. The same witness will suffice, I’d have thought.

SorcererGaheris · Yesterday 23:58

sawdustformypony · Yesterday 23:47

Doesn’t the signature need to be witnessed by an independent adult? Both parties to the sexual act will need to sign the agreement document. The agreement will expressly define those sexual act (and possibly positions) for which consent is given. There’s probably going to have to be some app for this.

Yes, if you are going to stop then you will need another signed consent agreement. The same witness will suffice, I’d have thought.

@sawdustformypony

Wouldn't that make any form of consensual sex unreasonably convoluted (and not practically possible in many situations?)

sawdustformypony · Today 00:05

SorcererGaheris · Yesterday 23:58

@sawdustformypony

Wouldn't that make any form of consensual sex unreasonably convoluted (and not practically possible in many situations?)

Oh yes, but it does solve the “he said/she said” issue. If a sexual act was proven without the required documentation, at least one of the participants will be looking at a custodial sentence.

Transperson · Today 00:11

sawdustformypony · Today 00:05

Oh yes, but it does solve the “he said/she said” issue. If a sexual act was proven without the required documentation, at least one of the participants will be looking at a custodial sentence.

Consent is always withdrawable though

OP posts:
SorcererGaheris · Today 00:16

sawdustformypony · Today 00:05

Oh yes, but it does solve the “he said/she said” issue. If a sexual act was proven without the required documentation, at least one of the participants will be looking at a custodial sentence.

@sawdustformypony

Yes, it definitely solves that. I just doubt that any law would be implemented in the specific way you suggest, given the huge inconvenience it would cause to people trying to have consensual sex.

sawdustformypony · Today 00:20

Furthermore, a person under the influence of drink or drugs cannot provide consent - no matter how enthusiastically (fairly sure I saw this in the thread). Therefore if they are, the witness should decline to provide a signature, until such time that all are sober.

Transperson · Today 00:24

sawdustformypony · Today 00:20

Furthermore, a person under the influence of drink or drugs cannot provide consent - no matter how enthusiastically (fairly sure I saw this in the thread). Therefore if they are, the witness should decline to provide a signature, until such time that all are sober.

How about some kind of time stamped record from each person? Before and after.

What about coercion though? A "yes" doesn't mean it's consensual.

OP posts:
sawdustformypony · Today 00:27

SorcererGaheris · Today 00:16

@sawdustformypony

Yes, it definitely solves that. I just doubt that any law would be implemented in the specific way you suggest, given the huge inconvenience it would cause to people trying to have consensual sex.

I dare say the Law Commission will find some way of ensuring ‘explicit consent’ is both obtained and verifiable.

SorcererGaheris · Today 00:30

sawdustformypony · Today 00:20

Furthermore, a person under the influence of drink or drugs cannot provide consent - no matter how enthusiastically (fairly sure I saw this in the thread). Therefore if they are, the witness should decline to provide a signature, until such time that all are sober.

@sawdustformypony

"Furthermore, a person under the influence of drink or drugs cannot provide consent"

I don't think that's currently part of the law, though. There's a threshold at which a person under the influence of drink or drugs could be argued to be incapable of giving consent, but simply being under the influence is not, in the law, grounds for being incapable of consent.

I wouldn't want the law on that changed. I've consented to sexual acts whilst being pretty drunk. Not conscious or semi-conscious, perfectly capable of deciding what I wanted to do. I wouldn't want the government telling me I don't have the right to consent to sex just because I've had some alcohol.

sawdustformypony · Today 00:34

Transperson · Today 00:24

How about some kind of time stamped record from each person? Before and after.

What about coercion though? A "yes" doesn't mean it's consensual.

This is the role of the witness, in fact it may be better to think of them as a certificate provider, in the same as one gets with lasting powers of attorney. Both parties would be interviewed in separate rooms to ensure proper explicit consent is achieved without any influence of the other party. If something is worth doing it is worth doing properly

sawdustformypony · Today 00:42

SorcererGaheris · Today 00:30

@sawdustformypony

"Furthermore, a person under the influence of drink or drugs cannot provide consent"

I don't think that's currently part of the law, though. There's a threshold at which a person under the influence of drink or drugs could be argued to be incapable of giving consent, but simply being under the influence is not, in the law, grounds for being incapable of consent.

I wouldn't want the law on that changed. I've consented to sexual acts whilst being pretty drunk. Not conscious or semi-conscious, perfectly capable of deciding what I wanted to do. I wouldn't want the government telling me I don't have the right to consent to sex just because I've had some alcohol.

Then you will need to take that up with @Needaboost in their post at 12:45 yesterday. Nobody thereafter seemed to object to this advice to her sons.

Transperson · Today 00:48

sawdustformypony · Today 00:34

This is the role of the witness, in fact it may be better to think of them as a certificate provider, in the same as one gets with lasting powers of attorney. Both parties would be interviewed in separate rooms to ensure proper explicit consent is achieved without any influence of the other party. If something is worth doing it is worth doing properly

Maybe this can be done digitally with some regular in person check ups & discussions?

To make sure consent is present and make this more feasible?

OP posts:
SorcererGaheris · Today 00:48

sawdustformypony · Today 00:42

Then you will need to take that up with @Needaboost in their post at 12:45 yesterday. Nobody thereafter seemed to object to this advice to her sons.

@sawdustformypony

I haven't read their post. Maybe I'll take a look.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread