Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Women would have to give explicit consent for sex under rape law review

90 replies

Transperson · Yesterday 01:45

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/20/women-explicit-consent-sex-under-rape-law-review/

'Women could be required to explicitly consent to sex for it to be legal under reforms to be considered by the Law Commission.The commission is to launch a review of consent laws that will examine recent legal reforms in Canada and Australia, in which sexual activity requires a definitive “yes”.

Under current law in England and Wales, a defendant can be acquitted if a jury finds they held a “reasonable belief” that the other person consented, meaning cases can often hinge on whether a woman said “no”.Any change would amount to the biggest overhaul of sexual offence laws in England and Wales for two decades.This week, Joanne Young, who was raped and sexually assaulted by strangers after being drugged by her husband, called for a review of consent laws “as a priority”.'

This seems great :))

OP posts:
Needaboost · Yesterday 13:48

Imnobody4 · Yesterday 13:18

That's a bit aggressive. I'm referring to a recent consultation on wedding law called Tying the Knot. I don't want to derail. I could say educate yourself.

I’m married to a Middle Eastern man and I’ve lived in his culture/country and also in the UK. Things that are perfectly “normal” in his country seem extremely questionable to me as someone who grew up in the UK.
They marry girls as young as 14, and many times without her consent, it’s just an expectation within a family agreement. Sex is seen as an entitlement to men, and as a means to pregnancy for women. Married men have sex with other women and sometimes men outside of marriage and it’s seen as acceptable. Consent isn’t really a thing, particularly within very conservative communities.
Many people of our generation have started marrying other cultures and moving away, so things are starting to change. But what this poster alludes to is an issue in the UK. For some men who may have been bright up in a culture similar to my husbands, the concept of a woman consenting to marriage and sex is alien. Id agree that there should be one rule and that’s that. And if there are cultures in the UK who have different values, then society needs to find a way through integration, education and policy to start to change them to align with consent laws in the UK.

Littlebitpsycho · Yesterday 14:14

Needaboost · Yesterday 12:53

Sorry, I just wanted to add something to this: regarding consent within a relationship or with nuanced context, if a woman doesn’t clearly say yes then it’s not consent. However, coercion is an enormous issue within relationships and often power, control and threats can be used to elicit a “yes” in circumstances where the woman feels she has no other choice.
It will never be black or white because consent is so hard to prove - but having the word “yes” to be a clear sign of consent is a good start to laying the boundaries down.

@Needaboost genuine question as I'm a little confused about what these possible new rules would mean.

Does this genuinely mean that EVERY time my partner and I have sex he needs to specifically say 'do you want to have sex' and I have to say 'yes'

It just sounds bizarre to me in a relationship context. I'm all for it in a first-time scenario 'can I kiss you' 'are you sure this is okay/that you want to' etc

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 14:29

I'm sorry, what? Am I reading this right?

"This seems great" writes the OP, who has clearly stated he wouldn't necessarily disclose his real sex to a potential sexual partner.

How is that gaining genuine consent?

Helleofabore · Yesterday 15:02

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 14:29

I'm sorry, what? Am I reading this right?

"This seems great" writes the OP, who has clearly stated he wouldn't necessarily disclose his real sex to a potential sexual partner.

How is that gaining genuine consent?

It comes across as somewhat tone deaf considering what this OP has written in the past couple of weeks.

TempestTost · Yesterday 15:11

Ponderingwindow · Yesterday 05:48

I agree there should be an enthusiastic yes. However, it still comes down to one person’s word against another’s in many cases. I don’t see how changing the law makes convictions easier.

I don't think anyone else gets a say in whether I need to be enthusiastic about anything I do.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 15:15

Helleofabore · Yesterday 15:02

It comes across as somewhat tone deaf considering what this OP has written in the past couple of weeks.

You couldn't make it up. There may be posters on this thread who are not aware TP has said he would not disclose his birth sex to potential sexual partners. Which means those partners are being denied the option of giving full consent to a sexual act.

Yet he starts a post about consent? It's taking the piss, honestly.

FKAT · Yesterday 15:23

I am skeptical about all this marginal new legislation proposed whenever a high profile sexual assault or rape hits the headlines. As if it was the lack of clarity around the law that was causing men to rape and assault women.
In the Young case, consent given by the husband on behalf of his unconscious wife is not the smoking gun. It is just a distraction about the relative length of the man's sentence. We are supposed to feel sad that a man who went to a stranger's house to have sex with an unknown unconscious woman might get a slightly longer sentence because he didn't realise that consent couldn't be by proxy. FML what a laughable take. Does no-one realise that this proposal is to protect MEN not women?

All of these law changes are designed to get women wasting their time running after increasingly niche points of the law instead of doing what we should be doing - campaigning for medical and chemical castration, mandatory life sentences and death penalty - not because that is what we want to end up but because we have to draw a far tougher line in the sand than we are if we are to get ANY change.

TempestTost · Yesterday 15:24

Littlebitpsycho · Yesterday 14:14

@Needaboost genuine question as I'm a little confused about what these possible new rules would mean.

Does this genuinely mean that EVERY time my partner and I have sex he needs to specifically say 'do you want to have sex' and I have to say 'yes'

It just sounds bizarre to me in a relationship context. I'm all for it in a first-time scenario 'can I kiss you' 'are you sure this is okay/that you want to' etc

Yeah I feel like this mainly sense to people who are in shorter term situations.

Insofar as you can consent non-verbally. Well that's the same problem we have now. What is consent, what isn't.

JuliaMaesa · Yesterday 15:29

So the guy has the signed document.

You get to it.

Then you decide to stop. But he now has your signed consent and thus a defence to unconsensual sex.

what then ?

Helleofabore · Yesterday 15:32

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 15:15

You couldn't make it up. There may be posters on this thread who are not aware TP has said he would not disclose his birth sex to potential sexual partners. Which means those partners are being denied the option of giving full consent to a sexual act.

Yet he starts a post about consent? It's taking the piss, honestly.

It could be part of performative feministing.

FKAT · Yesterday 15:37

Helleofabore · Yesterday 11:56

The issue as we have seen here on FWR for the past months is that if someone has their own personalised understanding of ‘consent’, how then can true consent be achieved?

If groups of male people has established their own group understanding of consent that is not true consent, but they believe it is and are told by people within the group that it is consent, then there is going to be confusion.

I am in support for some very blunt and clear guidance being given and widely published. Tailored to each group if needed.

When language has become so meaningless as it has become now, communication is unreliable and consent is going to be very hard to achieve in some cases if each group believes the onus is on someone else to ask the right questions in the right way.

This is where we are at as a society, where we have to change the law on rape so it doesn't unfairly criminalise men who go to strangers' houses for sex with unconscious women where those women have given their consent.

napody · Yesterday 15:41

Ponderingwindow · Yesterday 05:48

I agree there should be an enthusiastic yes. However, it still comes down to one person’s word against another’s in many cases. I don’t see how changing the law makes convictions easier.

But it should put an end to the disgusting rhetoric from defence barristers that she should have screamed, fought etc.

It puts the onus on the man. To avoid whataboutery and to ensure same sex couples are covered I'd even be in favour of an explicit specification that the partner needs to seek a yes before penetrating their partner. Including vaginally, orally, anally and with an object. Enthusiastic consent before entry.

napody · Yesterday 15:44

FKAT · Yesterday 15:23

I am skeptical about all this marginal new legislation proposed whenever a high profile sexual assault or rape hits the headlines. As if it was the lack of clarity around the law that was causing men to rape and assault women.
In the Young case, consent given by the husband on behalf of his unconscious wife is not the smoking gun. It is just a distraction about the relative length of the man's sentence. We are supposed to feel sad that a man who went to a stranger's house to have sex with an unknown unconscious woman might get a slightly longer sentence because he didn't realise that consent couldn't be by proxy. FML what a laughable take. Does no-one realise that this proposal is to protect MEN not women?

All of these law changes are designed to get women wasting their time running after increasingly niche points of the law instead of doing what we should be doing - campaigning for medical and chemical castration, mandatory life sentences and death penalty - not because that is what we want to end up but because we have to draw a far tougher line in the sand than we are if we are to get ANY change.

Having said that I do agree with most of this! I do think it's irrelevant to the Young case. It's more about addressing rape myths that just will not die. Although striking defence barristers off for using them in court might be a more direct route to that.

Transperson · Yesterday 16:22

Grammarnut · Yesterday 13:45

Prostituted women are not consenting. They are receiving money to be raped. Most will feel this even if they don't think they can say it.

Sex work is work. Anyone should have the bodily autonomy to do as they wish with their body. No one should be coerced or trafficked to be a sex worker - that is already a crime.

We shouldn't punish women that do this as a line of work.

Outlawing it would just make it underground which would mean plenty of people will lose the ability to go to the police if they are attacked or other offences against them.

OP posts:
Transperson · Yesterday 16:29

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 14:29

I'm sorry, what? Am I reading this right?

"This seems great" writes the OP, who has clearly stated he wouldn't necessarily disclose his real sex to a potential sexual partner.

How is that gaining genuine consent?

You really do hate when someone lives in a different country, with different laws, and has a different opinion and moral framework than you.

This kind of stuff screams the vibe of "you should follow my region and no one"

OP posts:
GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 16:37

0/10 for relevance

Transperson · Yesterday 16:42

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 16:37

0/10 for relevance

Plenty of people agree with me, only because you don't doesn't mean I'm doing anything wrong.

OP posts:
MarieDeGournay · Yesterday 16:43

Transperson Outlawing it would just make it underground which would mean plenty of people will lose the ability to go to the police if they are attacked or other offences against them.

Criminalising the buyers of sexual services, and the pimps and traffickers who keep the industry going and-- crucially - properly enforcing the law, addresses the issue you raise. Illegality changes sides.

Transperson · Yesterday 16:45

MarieDeGournay · Yesterday 16:43

Transperson Outlawing it would just make it underground which would mean plenty of people will lose the ability to go to the police if they are attacked or other offences against them.

Criminalising the buyers of sexual services, and the pimps and traffickers who keep the industry going and-- crucially - properly enforcing the law, addresses the issue you raise. Illegality changes sides.

Still doesn't work, it means that sex workers will lose money and if they get attacked they still can't go to the police because people might avoid going to the sex worker because of that.

Like, you don't want to take their bodily autonomy by telling them that what they or their customers do is wrong or immoral.

OP posts:
Grammarnut · Yesterday 16:49

Transperson · Yesterday 16:22

Sex work is work. Anyone should have the bodily autonomy to do as they wish with their body. No one should be coerced or trafficked to be a sex worker - that is already a crime.

We shouldn't punish women that do this as a line of work.

Outlawing it would just make it underground which would mean plenty of people will lose the ability to go to the police if they are attacked or other offences against them.

Selling the holes in your body for someone else to use is not work. It is not the same as being a sales assistant or a teacher or a doctor or anything else. Prostituted women are paid to let men rape them. Do not dignify this obscenity by suggesting it is work. Oh, and go away. Mind, you have revealed yourself good and proper.

Needaboost · Yesterday 16:55

Littlebitpsycho · Yesterday 14:14

@Needaboost genuine question as I'm a little confused about what these possible new rules would mean.

Does this genuinely mean that EVERY time my partner and I have sex he needs to specifically say 'do you want to have sex' and I have to say 'yes'

It just sounds bizarre to me in a relationship context. I'm all for it in a first-time scenario 'can I kiss you' 'are you sure this is okay/that you want to' etc

As I said, it’s not at all black and white, and within a committed relationship with no evidence of coercive control or abuse, then I’d presume each person within the relationship feels secure and trusting enough to get on with it. I don’t expect you’re going to be accusing him of rape if you’re in an equally loving and consensual relationship.
But if let’s say I’m a young woman in an abusive relationship where I’m threatened or bullied regularly and coerced into sex when I don’t want it, then the word “yes” becomes pertinent.
The whole premise behind this is that consent should be easy to understand. Men (for the sake of argument) should be able to have the respect and intelligent judgement to understand when a woman is clearly consenting to sex. The problem is that they don’t. Thankfully the lines are becoming less blurred now and women are being given the tools to be able to clearly say: yes I want, or no I don’t, so that men understand without having to rely on their judgement.

Needaboost · Yesterday 16:58

Grammarnut · Yesterday 13:45

Prostituted women are not consenting. They are receiving money to be raped. Most will feel this even if they don't think they can say it.

I absolutely agree with you. Which is why just saying yes isn’t the solution. It’s a good start for learning boundaries though.

Needaboost · Yesterday 17:01

Transperson · Yesterday 16:45

Still doesn't work, it means that sex workers will lose money and if they get attacked they still can't go to the police because people might avoid going to the sex worker because of that.

Like, you don't want to take their bodily autonomy by telling them that what they or their customers do is wrong or immoral.

The problem here is that prostitution is a necessity because apparently men are entitled to sex, even if it means paying for it. Outlawing it won’t help anyone, but understanding that paying for sex means having sex with a probably vulnerable woman who has no other choice. On paper it’s consensual - but having no choice isn’t true consent, it’s giving in.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 17:14

having no choice isn’t true consent

I absolutely agree.
I would add having an uninformed choice is also not true consent.

BackToLurk · Yesterday 17:26

Helleofabore · Yesterday 15:02

It comes across as somewhat tone deaf considering what this OP has written in the past couple of weeks.

Or deliberately provocative.

Swipe left for the next trending thread