Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Women would have to give explicit consent for sex under rape law review

90 replies

Transperson · Yesterday 01:45

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/20/women-explicit-consent-sex-under-rape-law-review/

'Women could be required to explicitly consent to sex for it to be legal under reforms to be considered by the Law Commission.The commission is to launch a review of consent laws that will examine recent legal reforms in Canada and Australia, in which sexual activity requires a definitive “yes”.

Under current law in England and Wales, a defendant can be acquitted if a jury finds they held a “reasonable belief” that the other person consented, meaning cases can often hinge on whether a woman said “no”.Any change would amount to the biggest overhaul of sexual offence laws in England and Wales for two decades.This week, Joanne Young, who was raped and sexually assaulted by strangers after being drugged by her husband, called for a review of consent laws “as a priority”.'

This seems great :))

OP posts:
Helleofabore · Yesterday 17:29

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 17:14

having no choice isn’t true consent

I absolutely agree.
I would add having an uninformed choice is also not true consent.

Giving consent when important information has not been disclosed by another party that needs that consent is an act of coercion.

Transperson · Yesterday 17:30

Grammarnut · Yesterday 16:49

Selling the holes in your body for someone else to use is not work. It is not the same as being a sales assistant or a teacher or a doctor or anything else. Prostituted women are paid to let men rape them. Do not dignify this obscenity by suggesting it is work. Oh, and go away. Mind, you have revealed yourself good and proper.

Edited

Only because it has social stigma and some people not understand it, doesn't give anyone the right to dismiss it and take away bodily autonomy.

A job exists to make money. Some people enjoy sex and do it professionally, it's not that complicated.

OP posts:
GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 17:31

I hope the Law Commission considers all scenarios. Could be a groundbreaking review if so.

Helleofabore · Yesterday 17:31

Yes. Being paid to allow someone to use your body for sex is not work.

And ‘sex work is work’ is nothing but an empty platitude from someone who doesn’t understand power dynamics, coercion and consent.

Helleofabore · Yesterday 17:32

Gosh. Lots of myths about prostitution coming out now.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 17:33

They enjoy it.

Now I'm humming Roy Orbison.

BackToLurk · Yesterday 17:34

Transperson · Yesterday 17:30

Only because it has social stigma and some people not understand it, doesn't give anyone the right to dismiss it and take away bodily autonomy.

A job exists to make money. Some people enjoy sex and do it professionally, it's not that complicated.

Edited

Nah. If a man’s daughter was a hairdresser he’d happily pay her to cut his hair. He’s highly unlikely to be quite so cavalier about paying his ‘sex worker’ daughter for a blow job. Not ‘just a job like any other’.

Tears0fTheMushroom · Yesterday 17:36

Transperson · Yesterday 01:45

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/20/women-explicit-consent-sex-under-rape-law-review/

'Women could be required to explicitly consent to sex for it to be legal under reforms to be considered by the Law Commission.The commission is to launch a review of consent laws that will examine recent legal reforms in Canada and Australia, in which sexual activity requires a definitive “yes”.

Under current law in England and Wales, a defendant can be acquitted if a jury finds they held a “reasonable belief” that the other person consented, meaning cases can often hinge on whether a woman said “no”.Any change would amount to the biggest overhaul of sexual offence laws in England and Wales for two decades.This week, Joanne Young, who was raped and sexually assaulted by strangers after being drugged by her husband, called for a review of consent laws “as a priority”.'

This seems great :))

Really? You agree that consent matters? YOU?

Women would have to give explicit consent for sex under rape law review
GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 17:38

I support Joanne Young 💜

Tears0fTheMushroom · Yesterday 17:50

Helleofabore · Yesterday 15:32

It could be part of performative feministing.

It's outright trolling. TP is well aware of this board's opinions about his purported behaviour around gaining meaningful consent.

Tears0fTheMushroom · Yesterday 17:55

Transperson · Yesterday 16:22

Sex work is work. Anyone should have the bodily autonomy to do as they wish with their body. No one should be coerced or trafficked to be a sex worker - that is already a crime.

We shouldn't punish women that do this as a line of work.

Outlawing it would just make it underground which would mean plenty of people will lose the ability to go to the police if they are attacked or other offences against them.

Anyone shocked that this is TPs opinion on prostitution?

Consent really means absolutely nothing to you, does it?

Tears0fTheMushroom · Yesterday 17:57

Transperson · Yesterday 16:42

Plenty of people agree with me, only because you don't doesn't mean I'm doing anything wrong.

Nobody decent agrees with you. That rapists and punters do is not the flex you think it is.

Grammarnut · Yesterday 18:04

Needaboost · Yesterday 17:01

The problem here is that prostitution is a necessity because apparently men are entitled to sex, even if it means paying for it. Outlawing it won’t help anyone, but understanding that paying for sex means having sex with a probably vulnerable woman who has no other choice. On paper it’s consensual - but having no choice isn’t true consent, it’s giving in.

Which is why criminalising pimps and the men who buy prostitutes is much better than criminalising the prostitutes. It might get it home to entitled men that buying sex is noxious if it meant they were heavily fined or had their pictures all over the internet as creeps.

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 18:10

Grammarnut · Yesterday 18:04

Which is why criminalising pimps and the men who buy prostitutes is much better than criminalising the prostitutes. It might get it home to entitled men that buying sex is noxious if it meant they were heavily fined or had their pictures all over the internet as creeps.

The young women I've worked with who ended up in prostitution were without exception abused as children, were neglected, lived in poverty and were abused by their pimps and the men who used them for sex. They were of school age.

Yet men fantasise about "happy hookers" and body autonomy - very far from the realities of those young women's lives.

So fucking offensive.

Grammarnut · Yesterday 18:13

Transperson · Yesterday 17:30

Only because it has social stigma and some people not understand it, doesn't give anyone the right to dismiss it and take away bodily autonomy.

A job exists to make money. Some people enjoy sex and do it professionally, it's not that complicated.

Edited

No, it's not that complicated. There is not much bodily autonomy if you have to let men rape you for money to feed your DC, pay the rent and keep the heating on in winter. None at all, in fact.
Prostituted women who have escaped this hell will tell exactly how it was and what psychological and physical damage it does. It's not a job, it's exploitation by entitled men who think it is ok to pay to commit rape.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 18:35

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 18:10

The young women I've worked with who ended up in prostitution were without exception abused as children, were neglected, lived in poverty and were abused by their pimps and the men who used them for sex. They were of school age.

Yet men fantasise about "happy hookers" and body autonomy - very far from the realities of those young women's lives.

So fucking offensive.

This. Plus drug addiction and lifelong psychological and physical scars.

But hey, it's a job, right? Just complain to HR if something goes wrong.

Baafboard · Yesterday 19:03

Transperson · Yesterday 17:30

Only because it has social stigma and some people not understand it, doesn't give anyone the right to dismiss it and take away bodily autonomy.

A job exists to make money. Some people enjoy sex and do it professionally, it's not that complicated.

Edited

Did you really type that with a straight face?

Transperson · Yesterday 19:13

Grammarnut · Yesterday 18:04

Which is why criminalising pimps and the men who buy prostitutes is much better than criminalising the prostitutes. It might get it home to entitled men that buying sex is noxious if it meant they were heavily fined or had their pictures all over the internet as creeps.

Trafficking & pimping is already illegal.

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · Yesterday 20:14

If sex work is work, then anyone on job seekers would eventually be expected to apply for jobs as a prostitute.

Sex work is not work. If sex work ever becomes work, it will be because we truly have entered the dystopian era of society.

Transperson · Yesterday 20:18

Ponderingwindow · Yesterday 20:14

If sex work is work, then anyone on job seekers would eventually be expected to apply for jobs as a prostitute.

Sex work is not work. If sex work ever becomes work, it will be because we truly have entered the dystopian era of society.

If I decided I wanted to do sex work, how does it hurt you or anyone else?

I'm not expecting for it to be forced upon others.

OP posts:
GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 21:34

Always this response " what's it to you"

We live in a society. Some of us care about others. If you do not, why should anyone care what you want.

Transperson · Yesterday 21:47

Needaboost · Yesterday 17:01

The problem here is that prostitution is a necessity because apparently men are entitled to sex, even if it means paying for it. Outlawing it won’t help anyone, but understanding that paying for sex means having sex with a probably vulnerable woman who has no other choice. On paper it’s consensual - but having no choice isn’t true consent, it’s giving in.

I agree that there is a systematic failure in terms of not supporting people enough and putting them in situations where they are desperate for money, those people should be supported better.

No one should feel like they have to resort to sex work.

OP posts:
Transperson · Yesterday 21:53

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 21:34

Always this response " what's it to you"

We live in a society. Some of us care about others. If you do not, why should anyone care what you want.

I care about sex workers, I don't want to take their income and I don't want to make people who want to do it stop.

I respect their bodily autonomy and also don't want to make the ones that do it out of desperation in a worse situation.

OP posts:
SorcererGaheris · Yesterday 22:00

Grammarnut · Yesterday 16:49

Selling the holes in your body for someone else to use is not work. It is not the same as being a sales assistant or a teacher or a doctor or anything else. Prostituted women are paid to let men rape them. Do not dignify this obscenity by suggesting it is work. Oh, and go away. Mind, you have revealed yourself good and proper.

Edited

@Grammarnut

It does align with some of the definitions of work.

One of the definitions is "fulfill duties regularly for wages or salary". Prostitutes are fulfilling sexual duties for wages.

Another definition is to perform or carry through a task requiring sustained effort. Prostitution fits that.

Another definition is "to exert oneself physically or mentally" - there is a level of physical exertion in a number of sex acts. * *

Sotiredimightreallydie · Yesterday 22:09

One second.

A man who had told us he is fine with sexually assaulting and raping women (which having sex and sexual activity whilst pretending to be the wrong sex is), is trying to pretend he's a feminist when it comes to other consent issues.

Ok...

Swipe left for the next trending thread