Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Women would have to give explicit consent for sex under rape law review

90 replies

Transperson · Yesterday 01:45

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/20/women-explicit-consent-sex-under-rape-law-review/

'Women could be required to explicitly consent to sex for it to be legal under reforms to be considered by the Law Commission.The commission is to launch a review of consent laws that will examine recent legal reforms in Canada and Australia, in which sexual activity requires a definitive “yes”.

Under current law in England and Wales, a defendant can be acquitted if a jury finds they held a “reasonable belief” that the other person consented, meaning cases can often hinge on whether a woman said “no”.Any change would amount to the biggest overhaul of sexual offence laws in England and Wales for two decades.This week, Joanne Young, who was raped and sexually assaulted by strangers after being drugged by her husband, called for a review of consent laws “as a priority”.'

This seems great :))

OP posts:
mamakoukla · Yesterday 01:52

Any person, of any sex and/or gender, should have to give explicit consent

OldUserNewNameNow · Yesterday 01:55

Wow! This would be amazing! What a brilliant moment in history it would be.

IwantToRetire · Yesterday 02:30

I am not opposed to it, but this has come up not in relation to an interaction between a man and a woman who know each other, but because the scum bags who have just been sentenced for rape said because the husband said his wife had consented that meant she had.

This has never been true. This "defence" has never been true, and is another example of how barristers etc., in court cases will use any sort of slur on behalf of the men they represent. Just as happened in the Brand case.

So you would hope that 2 adults in or thinking of having a relationship would do this, but does not deal with the situation of the recent court cases of a man arranging for other men to come and rape his wife.

Wouldn't put it past the type of slimy male shit of the husband ito put together some written statement claiming it was from his wife saying she gave consent to any man her husband invited to have "sex" with her, ie rape her, had her consent.

IwantToRetire · Yesterday 02:48

Then, and I am only being this negative because it is about expecting men to behave with respect towards women, there was the whole gross situation with Assange when accused of rape in Sweden said it couldn't be rape as the women concerned had agreed to sex. But that had been the night before, not the following morning.

Helleofabore · Yesterday 04:36

It is great that explicit consent will need to be sought.

I hope for many clear and open discussions in parliament about it.

Helleofabore · Yesterday 04:41

Any law about explicit consent will then need to include full disclosure of a person’s sex category with no obfuscating philosophical belief. And information given clearly in ways that the majority of people will receive an accurate interpretation of that message.

I remember lesbian women posting on MN about how they never consented to sex with a male person, yet were so terrified of additional physical harm of them rejecting that male person they submitted. And could never disclose their trauma to their social group for fear of ostracisation from that social group. It was horrifying to read.

Coerced consent is not consent.

And non-disclosure of such a significant fact should be clearly stated in law as consent not being achieved.

Seems timely to post this :

https://www.cps.gov.uk/cps/news/prosecutors-publish-updated-deception-sex-guidance

Central to the update, the guidance makes clear:

“In line with the law on consent – charges will depend on whether a victim was aware of the person’s birth sex and therefore consented to sexual activity by choice. The suspect must also have reasonably believed consent had been given.

“It also clarifies that a suspect may deceive a complainant as to their birth sex if they choose not to disclose their sex or trans identity. It also clarifies there is no expectation for a complainant to confirm the sex of the defendant prior to sexual activity.*

Prosecutors publish updated ‘deception as to sex’ guidance | The Crown Prosecution Service

https://www.cps.gov.uk/cps/news/prosecutors-publish-updated-deception-sex-guidance

evelynevelyn · Yesterday 05:17

Does anyone know how this works in other countries?

Because the range of cases where it practically would make a difference seems quite narrow.

Consent can still be given by actions (not just words). So a jury will now have to decide “were her actions consent” rather than “did he reasonably believe she had consented”.

There can’t be that many cases where a defendant’s case is that his belief in her consent was neither based on actions nor on words.

Rightsraptor · Yesterday 05:40

You may remember the government consultation on marriage which closed a few weeks ago. It was proposing to end the legal requirement for the bride to speak at her wedding, ending a bride signifying her consent by words. Because some cultures/religious don't require the bride to speak.

And here we are, requiring actual, specific consent for sex. How do these fit together?

I'm also puzzled how it would work in practice. It's unlikely there'd be any witnesses and even if there were, they'd come down on one side (the man's). It'd still be 'he said she said'.

Ponderingwindow · Yesterday 05:48

I agree there should be an enthusiastic yes. However, it still comes down to one person’s word against another’s in many cases. I don’t see how changing the law makes convictions easier.

Imnobody4 · Yesterday 10:42

Rightsraptor · Yesterday 05:40

You may remember the government consultation on marriage which closed a few weeks ago. It was proposing to end the legal requirement for the bride to speak at her wedding, ending a bride signifying her consent by words. Because some cultures/religious don't require the bride to speak.

And here we are, requiring actual, specific consent for sex. How do these fit together?

I'm also puzzled how it would work in practice. It's unlikely there'd be any witnesses and even if there were, they'd come down on one side (the man's). It'd still be 'he said she said'.

I agree. I can't see that it would make much difference in the conduct of rape trials but the silence of the bride is a real danger to women.

Transperson · Yesterday 11:31

Rightsraptor · Yesterday 05:40

You may remember the government consultation on marriage which closed a few weeks ago. It was proposing to end the legal requirement for the bride to speak at her wedding, ending a bride signifying her consent by words. Because some cultures/religious don't require the bride to speak.

And here we are, requiring actual, specific consent for sex. How do these fit together?

I'm also puzzled how it would work in practice. It's unlikely there'd be any witnesses and even if there were, they'd come down on one side (the man's). It'd still be 'he said she said'.

Conceptually I think the spirit is to by law the a lack of a no isn't a yes. Enthusiastic consent matters and it will give more power to people over their agency. It would give them more opportunities to go to the police and report the incident.

Although we all know how only 2% of all sexual assault reports end up in a conviction.

Maybe we should change the law to make it easier to convict?

OP posts:
Imnobody4 · Yesterday 11:47

This is from the CPS guidance. I'm not sure how else it could be written.

www.cps.gov.uk/sites/default/files/documents/publications/what_is_consent_v2.pdf

Consent is defined by section 74 Sexual Offences Act 2003.
Someone consents to vaginal, anal or oral penetration only if s/he agrees by choice to that penetration and has the freedom and capacity to make that choice.
Consent to sexual activity may be given to one sort of sexual activity but not another, e.g.to vaginal but not anal sex or penetration with conditions, such as
wearing a condom. Consent can be withdrawn at any time during sexual activity and each time activity occurs.
In investigating the suspect, it must be established what steps, if any, the suspect took to obtain the complainant’s consent and the prosecution must prove
that the suspect did not have a reasonable belief that the complainant was consenting.

Irishlinen · Yesterday 11:56

I think this would make sense and tbh I thought it was already the law. I however agree with an earlier post which made the point that at the end of the day it often ends up being one person's word against another. In the cases of rape when the accused does not know the victim and is a random attack it is easier to convict or where violence is clearly used, in cases where the defendant has had a consensual relationship at times or there has been a relationship etc with the defendant it makes a conviction harder that is why the context and circumstances are important. The burden of proof has to be on the prosecution.

Helleofabore · Yesterday 11:56

Imnobody4 · Yesterday 11:47

This is from the CPS guidance. I'm not sure how else it could be written.

www.cps.gov.uk/sites/default/files/documents/publications/what_is_consent_v2.pdf

Consent is defined by section 74 Sexual Offences Act 2003.
Someone consents to vaginal, anal or oral penetration only if s/he agrees by choice to that penetration and has the freedom and capacity to make that choice.
Consent to sexual activity may be given to one sort of sexual activity but not another, e.g.to vaginal but not anal sex or penetration with conditions, such as
wearing a condom. Consent can be withdrawn at any time during sexual activity and each time activity occurs.
In investigating the suspect, it must be established what steps, if any, the suspect took to obtain the complainant’s consent and the prosecution must prove
that the suspect did not have a reasonable belief that the complainant was consenting.

The issue as we have seen here on FWR for the past months is that if someone has their own personalised understanding of ‘consent’, how then can true consent be achieved?

If groups of male people has established their own group understanding of consent that is not true consent, but they believe it is and are told by people within the group that it is consent, then there is going to be confusion.

I am in support for some very blunt and clear guidance being given and widely published. Tailored to each group if needed.

When language has become so meaningless as it has become now, communication is unreliable and consent is going to be very hard to achieve in some cases if each group believes the onus is on someone else to ask the right questions in the right way.

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 12:14

Ponderingwindow · Yesterday 05:48

I agree there should be an enthusiastic yes. However, it still comes down to one person’s word against another’s in many cases. I don’t see how changing the law makes convictions easier.

Yes - rape is rarely a "witnessed crime"

The bigger picture is that we live in a society where the misogynistic demands of men have been able to persuade many that the sex crimes of voyeurism and indecent exposure no longer matter. These are both gateway crimes to further sex offending. School girls are instructed they have no right to consent to the presence of random males when they undress in school changing rooms (see the Brighton Dorothy Stringe school).
Mixed sex changing facilities in public sports / swimming facilities have led who a tsunami of crimes of covert photographing / voyeurism against women & girls -see WRN Red Flag campaign
https://www.womensrights.network/post/red-flag-campaign

And the media have been complicit in promoting the wishes of porn soaked, sexually incontinent men both in politics (see the conversion practices bill and the chilling impact on adults wanting to safeguard children) and the stream of men both in (and outside) the public eye appearing in court charged with sex offences.

Until the power that porn soaked men have in society is successfully challenged, too many women and girls will continue to be told that they have no right to object or say no to the demands of disordered males.

Whether tinkering with the consent issue will work I'm not sure. But the context of discussions about consent are founded on how society treats the two sexes. Are women and girls allowed to say no to male demands or not? Until the trend that tells women they have no right to speak out is reversed, too many women are being schooled into keeping silent.

And catastrophically, too many men get the message that they are entitled to access women's bodies in any way they choose.

Red Flag Campaign | Women's Rights Network | UK

Millions of women and children will be heading to swimming pools and leisure centres over the summer blissfully unaware of the dangers they face from sexual predators seeking victims in mixed-sex changing rooms.

https://www.womensrights.network/post/red-flag-campaign

Imnobody4 · Yesterday 12:21

I think porn is the big one that needs tackling.The depiction of rape is illegal in pre internet law but anything goes on line.
Misogyny has been turbo charged. I must admit Jess Philips being involved doesn't fill me with confidence that anything useful will come out of it.

Helleofabore · Yesterday 12:40

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 12:14

Yes - rape is rarely a "witnessed crime"

The bigger picture is that we live in a society where the misogynistic demands of men have been able to persuade many that the sex crimes of voyeurism and indecent exposure no longer matter. These are both gateway crimes to further sex offending. School girls are instructed they have no right to consent to the presence of random males when they undress in school changing rooms (see the Brighton Dorothy Stringe school).
Mixed sex changing facilities in public sports / swimming facilities have led who a tsunami of crimes of covert photographing / voyeurism against women & girls -see WRN Red Flag campaign
https://www.womensrights.network/post/red-flag-campaign

And the media have been complicit in promoting the wishes of porn soaked, sexually incontinent men both in politics (see the conversion practices bill and the chilling impact on adults wanting to safeguard children) and the stream of men both in (and outside) the public eye appearing in court charged with sex offences.

Until the power that porn soaked men have in society is successfully challenged, too many women and girls will continue to be told that they have no right to object or say no to the demands of disordered males.

Whether tinkering with the consent issue will work I'm not sure. But the context of discussions about consent are founded on how society treats the two sexes. Are women and girls allowed to say no to male demands or not? Until the trend that tells women they have no right to speak out is reversed, too many women are being schooled into keeping silent.

And catastrophically, too many men get the message that they are entitled to access women's bodies in any way they choose.

I agree.

Until consent has been defined with clarity that cannot be obfuscated by philosophical belief, changes to laws are going to be less valuable.

And until the wider population understands with greater depth what consent is and how consent has been eroded even before it really has reached a level of useful understanding in the first place, the changes will just cause confusion.

We cannot teach our girls and women consent about sex when they are so confused about boundaries and consent for other aspects in life, because the messaging will be confused. It really is time for the wider discussion on consent as well as focusing on consent for sex acts.

Grammarnut · Yesterday 12:42

Imnobody4 · Yesterday 10:42

I agree. I can't see that it would make much difference in the conduct of rape trials but the silence of the bride is a real danger to women.

Whatever the culture if the marriage takes place in the UK then the bride must give spoken consent. Live somewhere else if this does not sit well with you.

Needaboost · Yesterday 12:45

I have two boys, and in discussions about girls (they’re both attracted to women not men, we’ve had that discussion too!), I’ve always reiterated that unless they receive a “yes” then they don’t touch them. My oldest asked me about kissing, and I still said that he should check it’s ok if he’s the one initiating. I also explained that a girl/woman who is drinking or doing drugs can’t consent - we’ve talked about situations when they witness things that they feel is inappropriate and how to handle protecting a girl if necessary (and themselves).
It should be absolutely commonplace that “yes” is required before any sexual activity. The amount of times I had sex without wanting to because I felt unsure or pressured is ridiculous, and I really want boys to be brought up understanding what consent is.

Needaboost · Yesterday 12:48

Helleofabore · Yesterday 12:40

I agree.

Until consent has been defined with clarity that cannot be obfuscated by philosophical belief, changes to laws are going to be less valuable.

And until the wider population understands with greater depth what consent is and how consent has been eroded even before it really has reached a level of useful understanding in the first place, the changes will just cause confusion.

We cannot teach our girls and women consent about sex when they are so confused about boundaries and consent for other aspects in life, because the messaging will be confused. It really is time for the wider discussion on consent as well as focusing on consent for sex acts.

Absolutely. I used to be quite active within a radical feminist group, and there were frequent discussions around prostitution and whether a woman in the sex industry is truly consenting. It needs to be clear and straightforward so that women know how to place a boundary, and men and boys know when they have consent.

Needaboost · Yesterday 12:53

Sorry, I just wanted to add something to this: regarding consent within a relationship or with nuanced context, if a woman doesn’t clearly say yes then it’s not consent. However, coercion is an enormous issue within relationships and often power, control and threats can be used to elicit a “yes” in circumstances where the woman feels she has no other choice.
It will never be black or white because consent is so hard to prove - but having the word “yes” to be a clear sign of consent is a good start to laying the boundaries down.

MontyMadness99 · Yesterday 12:57

Needaboost · Yesterday 12:45

I have two boys, and in discussions about girls (they’re both attracted to women not men, we’ve had that discussion too!), I’ve always reiterated that unless they receive a “yes” then they don’t touch them. My oldest asked me about kissing, and I still said that he should check it’s ok if he’s the one initiating. I also explained that a girl/woman who is drinking or doing drugs can’t consent - we’ve talked about situations when they witness things that they feel is inappropriate and how to handle protecting a girl if necessary (and themselves).
It should be absolutely commonplace that “yes” is required before any sexual activity. The amount of times I had sex without wanting to because I felt unsure or pressured is ridiculous, and I really want boys to be brought up understanding what consent is.

Yep, did the same. My son was a teenager when the Oxford 5 were on trial and the fear of being falsely accused impacted him greatly. Thankfully, with conversations we addressed it from both sides. Additionally, talked about the violence they might encounter from men, usually fuelled by drink.

Whereas with my daughters it was about personal safety, drink safety (spiking), taxi safety, where to walk, where to go/who to speak to/who to trust if you feel unsafe (including driving), etc. from men.

Imnobody4 · Yesterday 13:18

Grammarnut · Yesterday 12:42

Whatever the culture if the marriage takes place in the UK then the bride must give spoken consent. Live somewhere else if this does not sit well with you.

That's a bit aggressive. I'm referring to a recent consultation on wedding law called Tying the Knot. I don't want to derail. I could say educate yourself.

Grammarnut · Yesterday 13:42

Imnobody4 · Yesterday 13:18

That's a bit aggressive. I'm referring to a recent consultation on wedding law called Tying the Knot. I don't want to derail. I could say educate yourself.

Don't say 'educate yourself' it is patronising. You don't know what I know about other cultures. Nevertheless, in law a bride should have to give spoken consent. It fits in with having to have explicit consent to sex, because that is what she is consenting to.

Grammarnut · Yesterday 13:45

Needaboost · Yesterday 12:48

Absolutely. I used to be quite active within a radical feminist group, and there were frequent discussions around prostitution and whether a woman in the sex industry is truly consenting. It needs to be clear and straightforward so that women know how to place a boundary, and men and boys know when they have consent.

Prostituted women are not consenting. They are receiving money to be raped. Most will feel this even if they don't think they can say it.