Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Would Joan Collins have transitioned as a teenager?

111 replies

Neversofaraway · 20/11/2026 20:22

https://www.thetimes.com/article/2b532778-04c9-4179-a2c3-f2a807c0a9ff?shareToken=467145f8b3db82824e20f63dc1235e45

I first heard Joan Collins on WH some years ago saying that she wanted to be a boy when she was a teenager and here she is repeating it in today's Times.
Like many of us she didn't fancy becoming an adult women.

Would she have been transitioned under today's regime?

Verifying Device

https://www.thetimes.com/article/2b532778-04c9-4179-a2c3-f2a807c0a9ff?shareToken=467145f8b3db82824e20f63dc1235e45

OP posts:
BunkBedsArePeopleShelves · Yesterday 10:42

Cobrakainerd · 20/11/2026 21:13

I think there's a lot of women who 60s/70s/80s were the stereotypical Tomboy. I certainly was. Joan probably fell into that category. Girls don't seem to have that option these days, but get pigeon holed into the trans shite.

Exactly this. Feminism and progress used to be about widening the definitions, that girls (and boys) could do pretty much anything, be anything, look like anything.
Now a little boys who likes dolls and nail varnish is told be must actually be a girl. It's so reductive.

OldCrone · Yesterday 10:48

Schylla · Yesterday 10:40

Confused again. I simply quoted the commenter.

I don't often comment on other posters' grammar, syntax, spelling or writing style, but I often have to read your posts several times, and then give up , having decided that since you can't be bothered to express yourself clearly, I'm not going to waste my time trying to understand what you mean.

For you to then make hair splitting comments about another poster's posts, and insist they meant something other than what they actually did mean, and later clarified, is just astonishing (but not altogether surprising from you).

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 10:55

Schylla · Yesterday 10:38

What a very gendered response!

I'm female btw. 😂

Oh but what does female even mean?

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 10:57

BunkBedsArePeopleShelves · Yesterday 10:42

Exactly this. Feminism and progress used to be about widening the definitions, that girls (and boys) could do pretty much anything, be anything, look like anything.
Now a little boys who likes dolls and nail varnish is told be must actually be a girl. It's so reductive.

It really is.

And you have a great user name!

idontknowhowtodreamyourdreams · Yesterday 11:51

Schylla · Yesterday 10:36

That's not what you said in your post which was you "wanted to be a boy".

@Schylla when you are 14 and have been groomed by a man in his 30s who has had sex with you and is now requiring you to have sex with other men, the difference is utterly academic.

I was there, I remember to this day exactly how I felt.

Do you really want to argue the toss with someone who has groomed and raped as a child and tell them how they felt?

How fucking dare you tell me otherwise. You are idiotic, at best.

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 12:24

idontknowhowtodreamyourdreams · Yesterday 11:51

@Schylla when you are 14 and have been groomed by a man in his 30s who has had sex with you and is now requiring you to have sex with other men, the difference is utterly academic.

I was there, I remember to this day exactly how I felt.

Do you really want to argue the toss with someone who has groomed and raped as a child and tell them how they felt?

How fucking dare you tell me otherwise. You are idiotic, at best.

I'm so sorry Idontknow. Flowers

I'd seriously recommend avoiding the posters who are only here to goad and sneer. They offer nothing to the general discourse and have no insight into, or understanding of, the lives of women and girls.

It's just a form of nasty entertainment to them.

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 12:29

In my teens I didn't much fancy being an adult woman either. All it seemed to entail was endless housework, cooking, cleaning, doing what men told you to do, having to 'submit' to your husband, and not being allowed any agency in career choices. Nurse, hairdresser, typist (or the heady heights of secretary), sewing machinist, shop assistant, that was pretty much what women did. Until you got married and had babies, then you had to stop work anyway and become a housewife.

I didn't want to be trapped like that.

idontknowhowtodreamyourdreams · Yesterday 12:33

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 12:24

I'm so sorry Idontknow. Flowers

I'd seriously recommend avoiding the posters who are only here to goad and sneer. They offer nothing to the general discourse and have no insight into, or understanding of, the lives of women and girls.

It's just a form of nasty entertainment to them.

@MrsOvertonsWindow Thank you. You are correct! Normally I wouldn’t rise to it. I do however feel v strongly about gender ideology and trans issues, not just because of my own personal history, but as a feminist and parent.

The internal contradictions of it all astonishes me.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Yesterday 13:58

Schylla · Yesterday 08:12

The difference being you never said 'I am a boy' rather 'you want to be one'.

Big difference.

I did, frequently, say "I am a boy". I wore my brothers' cast-off clothes; the only skirt I ever wore was school uniform. I was generally thought to be a boy by adults who did not know me (in shops, on trains, on buses).

The "big difference" was that in the forties and fifties mutilating your body to try to become what you were not was not an option open to a child, and I grew out of the delusion.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · Yesterday 14:11

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · Yesterday 07:09

Your child is female. This can't be changed. Your job as a parent is not to go along with a delusion. If your child has come to believe that she is male when she manifestly isn't, she needs skilled professional help to unpick what has made her feel that way and to reassure her that being a woman will be fine.

He's an ardent feminist who's under constant scrutiny from violent cis men. No medical transition as yet.

My job as a parent is to listen to, respect, learn from and protect my child.

Neither of us needs lectures on how we're meant to behave cheers.

Your inability to respect his identity is your problem, not his.

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 14:16

idontknowhowtodreamyourdreams · Yesterday 12:33

@MrsOvertonsWindow Thank you. You are correct! Normally I wouldn’t rise to it. I do however feel v strongly about gender ideology and trans issues, not just because of my own personal history, but as a feminist and parent.

The internal contradictions of it all astonishes me.

I know. For me it's being a parent (as well as a lifetime working with so many vulnerable children) that makes me reel in horror at the distorted, misogynistic guff that some men drop onto this board. It's hard not to be enraged and it's right that they're sometimes confronted with the grim reality of what they're trying to impose on women.

I just get concerned at the emotional wear on women who challenge all this crap, so often from men "playing with" posters on this board. But I also know it's not up to me to "police" women on here so do need to resist the temptaion 😀

New posts on this thread. Refresh page