Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Would Joan Collins have transitioned as a teenager?

111 replies

Neversofaraway · 20/11/2026 20:22

https://www.thetimes.com/article/2b532778-04c9-4179-a2c3-f2a807c0a9ff?shareToken=467145f8b3db82824e20f63dc1235e45

I first heard Joan Collins on WH some years ago saying that she wanted to be a boy when she was a teenager and here she is repeating it in today's Times.
Like many of us she didn't fancy becoming an adult women.

Would she have been transitioned under today's regime?

Verifying Device

https://www.thetimes.com/article/2b532778-04c9-4179-a2c3-f2a807c0a9ff?shareToken=467145f8b3db82824e20f63dc1235e45

OP posts:
Schylla · Yesterday 09:19

MoistVonL · Yesterday 09:12

Schylla claims everything they don't like has been "debunked", when its only been "debunked" by TRA mouthpieces.

They've even rolled out the No True Scotsman with "those trans identifying kids who desisted aren't trans".

Cope A+.

borntobequiet · Yesterday 09:19

Yup.

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 09:21

borntobequiet · Yesterday 09:19

I see we’re getting to the condescending and belittling phase.

Oh absolutely. Nowhere else to go really.
Arguments are full of holes and contradictions, as is the whole trans ideology and gender theory.

HousePlantEmergency · Yesterday 09:23

Oh no. Women's opinions are "breathtaking" again.
You might want to bold or italicise that going forward.

MoistVonL · Yesterday 09:23

Schylla · Yesterday 09:15

Oh please. The current cultural zeitgeist is saturated with trans demonisation & dehumanisation. The idea that children who are gender non conforming in the least not being bullied is a particularly ludicrous one.

Honestly, how low can you go to diminish this obvious prevalent harm?
The shamelessness is breathtaking.

Bollocks. In the wider world, maybe.
In high school and university, it's positively feted. I've watched it happen. I swear this country will have no young lesbians left if this gender identity nonsense doesn't end soon.

Tavistock practitioners said it themselves - transing the gay away.

Imdunfer · Yesterday 09:24

TransParentlyAnnoyed · Yesterday 01:13

Nope. Being trans has nothing to do with clothes.

My son is trans. He wears skirts quite often. Played with a wide variety of toys as a kid - his brother's stuff, and My Little Ponies. Barbies. He liked JoJo Bows, ballet and all manner of girly stuff.

Being trans isn't cosplay. It's not about appearance or wanting what boys have.

It's about knowing you already are a boy, whatever your body shape. However you look, and whatever hobbies you enjoy.

Although in your case as a non binary mother who likes boys there might have been a bit more going on than just that.

OldCrone · Yesterday 09:26

Schylla · Yesterday 09:17

No. Reread the thread you are totally confused.

So what you're saying is that most children who claim a trans identity aren't really trans. The ones who are will persist after puberty, and the ones who aren't will desist.

The problem for the gender clinics who want to medicalise the trutrans children is that they've admitted that there's no way of telling which children will persist after puberty and which will desist.

DeanElderberry · Yesterday 09:29

When I was starting to think about all this - five years ago, ten maybe? I was reminded of the girl at secondary school who until at least 13 'was' a pony. Trotted, neighed, tossed her head, ate slices of apple. Reverted to human in the classroom, back to pony afterwards. The someone on a discussion board I was on said they were at school with a girl who 'was' a guinea pig, similar behavior pattern. But it later emerged that guinea pig girl had suffered serious sexual abuse, and that in the good old 1970s way the adults decided the best thing was to not make a fuss,

Children suddenly deciding they 'are' something they are not is a alarm signal and should be treated as such.

I fear also that in some cases I've seen - pony girl, a family I've known since way before the trans Id member was born, a neighbour - there can be an element of codependency in the relationship, and that is bad for all involved including the supporters.

Imdunfer · Yesterday 09:33

I have absolutely no doubt that the neurodivergent tomboy me who refused to go to school because I was afraid of growing up would have been sucked into the trans support on the internet and taken to the Tavistock faster than a rat up a drainpipe by my narcissistic mother who would simply have adored the attention she would have got for having a trans child.

Thank heavens it didn't exist at the time.

I will now sit back and wait for the trans activists to tell me that I don't know my own lived experience.

Mumoftwoteenagers · Yesterday 09:33

importantupdate · Yesterday 08:47

I don’t know, but I know for sure I would have, and my sister too.

It’s probably the reason I’m very much against gender bollocks now.

I used to practice peeing standing up in the bath, shove socks down my pants…every time we went on holiday when I was a kid I’d introduce myself as a boy to any kids I met. I cried so much when my dm made me start wearing a bra and used to take it off in the toilets and hide it in my bag. If I’d had the option of a breast binder I’d have been all over that!

How do you feel about being female as an adult? Do you have biological children? Did you breastfeed them?

I wasn’t as committed as you but I did find puberty horrendous and terrifying. At 13 I would have taken any “out” I could. By my 15th birthday I was actually pretty happy with myself, my body and being female. But it does scare me just how much damage I could have done in those 2 years had the option been open to me.

Mumoftwoteenagers · Yesterday 09:39

OldCrone · Yesterday 09:26

So what you're saying is that most children who claim a trans identity aren't really trans. The ones who are will persist after puberty, and the ones who aren't will desist.

The problem for the gender clinics who want to medicalise the trutrans children is that they've admitted that there's no way of telling which children will persist after puberty and which will desist.

Even if no medical choices are made it is still problematic. If Lucy, aged 13, announces she is now Luke and everyone is terribly supportive and proud of her and tells her how brave she is. Then it is very hard for Luke, now aged 15, to suddenly say “Actually I think I’ll go back to being boring old ordinary Lucy now. Not special after all.’

idontknowhowtodreamyourdreams · Yesterday 09:42

Schylla · Yesterday 08:12

The difference being you never said 'I am a boy' rather 'you want to be one'.

Big difference.

Actually at the time I did say I was a boy. But thanks for thinking you know more about my experience of this than me. You get that if a child is abused and traumatised it is totally unsurprising that they would hate their body and decide it would be better if it was something else, right? Ffs.

Perenelle · Yesterday 09:42

Schylla · Yesterday 08:52

If it were just about (social) gender and not about (physical) sex, why should the treatment be to change ones body?

Sex traits are also gendered traits. Natal females aren't getting breast enhancements in droves to accentuate their reproductive abilities. They are doing so because it aligns with their personal conception of ideal womanhood. In other words its about gender not sex.

Exactly, just as any performance of stereotypes does not influence let alone change ones sex.

You can ever only be an approximation to the other sex. You will however be reminded every day of your physical reality.

That’s why it is so important that trans men still have access to female health care and vice versa.

The conflation of gender and sex is just obfuscation.

Mommydearest40 · Yesterday 09:44

Schylla · Yesterday 09:11

I can’t imagine a young woman having the confidence to do that now.

My dude, have you been living under a rock? Try telling a young woman today they look hot & watch how fast they call the cops! 😂

What a very male response

Imdunfer · Yesterday 09:47

Schylla · Yesterday 08:12

The difference being you never said 'I am a boy' rather 'you want to be one'.

Big difference.

This is not correct.

In a world where a girl knows that there are no circumstances where she can ever be a boy, which was the world we lived in at the time, the most likely thing for her to say would have been "I want to be a boy".

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 09:49

Schylla · Yesterday 08:10

There's no guarantee that therapy would work to sort out all of a kid's mental health issues, but it should be tried and definitely before anything else is tried.

Depends on the circumstances. If the context is adults, we don't typically require mental health assessments for those that don't raise that they have have mental distress & request medical bodily enhancements. If its minors the protocol is generally supposed to be explorative & holistic.

Can you even give any examples of where transing children has worked?

Seriously? There are no trans adults who say they 'knew' when they were children? Many trans adults claim just that most famously Caitlin Jenner.

Why do we never see them among the trans activists?

You know all trans activists do you?

still have huge mental health issues

Making a person's life easier from mental distress doesn't necessarily mean it will be eradicated particularly since there is so much social resistance & discrimination that remains. Being 'different', bullied & rejected for one's entire life has its intractable consequences.

clearly know that they are actually gay males on some leve

Data?

Or are you suggesting that kids should be immediately transed with no therapy or mental health assessment beforehand?

As I said, an exploration of motivations & holistic options that isn't coerced & is patient centred is ideal & with WPATH guidelines.

Stop spreading the nasty lie that children are born in the wrong body.

That be more your misguided 'interpretation'. Gender & sex aren't the same thing.

Here's Jazz Jennings talking, under hypnotherapy, about how he doesn't think his family wants him because he's gay.

Perhaps all kids who have been encouraged to think they are "trans" should have hypnotherapy.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/0fNWgwG60gY?si=tGmjQi2YDzFbH28a&t=142

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 09:53

HousePlantEmergency · Yesterday 09:23

Oh no. Women's opinions are "breathtaking" again.
You might want to bold or italicise that going forward.

It's all such sexist, misogynistic drivel isn't it?
i can't be arsed - he's so tedious.

Perenelle · Yesterday 10:07

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 08:45

I would just like to add, for all the tiresome trans activists, we do know that sex is not ”gender”. Very clearly in fact.

It is the gender theory believers that are very keen on blurring the difference between the two, to the point of claiming that sex is so complex it cannot possibly be determined or observed, and must therefore be replaced with “gender”.

However, the word “gender” is used in a number of ways, and I do not yet have a single explanation of what trans believers mean by the word - none of them can tell me, and every one that I have interacted with gives a different answer, or (even more importantly) uses the word “gender” to mean something different in one sentence followed by the next in order to obfuscate arguments.

It is used:

  1. a euphemism and synonym for sex
  2. the social expectations that we put on people of either sex
  3. ”expression” or presentation in the clothes/style associated with one sex or the other.
  4. Some sort of inner gender essence that somehow means you are really the opposite sex (only possessed by trans identified people).

Given that we all agree that sex is distinct from gender:

  1. why do activists want access to spaces that are separated by sex for physical reasons of female vulnerability?
  2. why do activists want change the sex marker on their birth certificates?
  3. why do plenty of trans women claim to have changed sex rather than gender?

Agree, it is all so wishy-washy.

At the end of the day, even the intense feeling of being a boy, does not make one. Even if girls try to bend their body to their will, if they perform every male stereotype perfectly and everyone makes sure to affirm their feelings, they still remain female.

And I think it is harmful to pretend otherwise with linguistic contortions.

BackToLurk · Yesterday 10:08

Imdunfer · Yesterday 09:24

Although in your case as a non binary mother who likes boys there might have been a bit more going on than just that.

..and who struggled when their girl was interested in 'girly' things.

Schylla · Yesterday 10:36

idontknowhowtodreamyourdreams · Yesterday 09:42

Actually at the time I did say I was a boy. But thanks for thinking you know more about my experience of this than me. You get that if a child is abused and traumatised it is totally unsurprising that they would hate their body and decide it would be better if it was something else, right? Ffs.

That's not what you said in your post which was you "wanted to be a boy".

Schylla · Yesterday 10:38

Mommydearest40 · Yesterday 09:44

What a very male response

What a very gendered response!

I'm female btw. 😂

OldCrone · Yesterday 10:39

Schylla · Yesterday 10:36

That's not what you said in your post which was you "wanted to be a boy".

You're not doing yourself any favours by suggesting you know more about other people's lived experience than they know themselves.

DaintyBlueLark · Yesterday 10:40

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 07:03

I never wanted to be a boy but I was very much a tomboy and grew up to be a lesbian. I tried weeing standing up through a toilet roll a couple of times, just to see what it was like, but that's about it for any interest in what it's like to be a boy.

I did the toilet roll thing too. I was very disappointed when it went soggy 😁

Schylla · Yesterday 10:40

OldCrone · Yesterday 10:39

You're not doing yourself any favours by suggesting you know more about other people's lived experience than they know themselves.

Confused again. I simply quoted the commenter.

WhitePicketCrypt · Yesterday 10:40

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 09:49

Here's Jazz Jennings talking, under hypnotherapy, about how he doesn't think his family wants him because he's gay.

Perhaps all kids who have been encouraged to think they are "trans" should have hypnotherapy.

Oh poor Jazz. It’s always been painfully obvious that his family couldn’t cope with their effeminate son who was pretty obviously going to be gay and they chose to encourage delusion and mutilation instead.
I’m expecting a documentary about this in the future and maybe some law suits, this should never have been allowed to happen.