Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Would Joan Collins have transitioned as a teenager?

111 replies

Neversofaraway · 20/11/2026 20:22

https://www.thetimes.com/article/2b532778-04c9-4179-a2c3-f2a807c0a9ff?shareToken=467145f8b3db82824e20f63dc1235e45

I first heard Joan Collins on WH some years ago saying that she wanted to be a boy when she was a teenager and here she is repeating it in today's Times.
Like many of us she didn't fancy becoming an adult women.

Would she have been transitioned under today's regime?

Verifying Device

https://www.thetimes.com/article/2b532778-04c9-4179-a2c3-f2a807c0a9ff?shareToken=467145f8b3db82824e20f63dc1235e45

OP posts:
testmatchspecial · 20/11/2026 22:36

Thanks for sharing that article OP. It’s interesting to hear that from JC when you’ve only known her as an uber-glamorous woman. Also bleak that she thinks things are getting worse, given what she’s lived through.

Heggettypeg · 20/11/2026 22:39

Schylla · 20/11/2026 21:22

Its not as if there isn't an option to be a masculine coded female or 'butch' woman to exist. In fact the social cost is substantially lower.

The problem is that actual social cost and anticipated social cost can be two different things.

Any girl who doesn't find it easy, or even possible, to perform conventional femininity knows from her own experience that being a woman will be difficult. Conforming will be a struggle and may attract derision for failure; but doing what comes naturally to her will annoy the conformists and bring her a different lot of problems; and either way she'll get shit just for being female. So she knows already that being a butch woman will come with a cost.

But if she expects that medication and surgery will let her pass as a man to the wider world, and expects that the people she hangs out with who knows her history will believe and behave as though gender matters and sex doesn't, she might well anticipate that the problems of being female will simply disappear when she identifies as a man. That she'll have a social circle of male friends (and lovers, if she considers herself a gay man) who treat her as a man and an equal, not a sex object. I've seen disappointed posts on Reddit on the lines of "I thought my boyfriend saw me as a man, but it's become clear he doesn't really", so I think some people are overly optimistic about what transitioning will achieve socially. And there have been a couple of awful rape cases where it seems the victim had counted on being protected by passing, or on their identification as a man being respected.

And if she has come to feel, for any reason, that being a woman not merely attracts contempt from others, but is actually contemptible in itself, then being any kind of woman, however unconforming, won't fix her self- image to her own satisfaction.

Schylla · 20/11/2026 23:09

The problem is that actual social cost and anticipated social cost can be two different things.

The difference between trans men & women medicalising is for natal females it can be done after puberty & still have substantial masculinising effects so the imperative isn't as urgent consequently opening the door to maturity before serious decisions are made. Gendered surgery isn't generally available til an individual is an adult so there's plenty of time for reflection & anticipation of social costs for natal females transitioning.

LeftieRightsHoarder · Yesterday 00:31

Cobrakainerd · 20/11/2026 21:13

I think there's a lot of women who 60s/70s/80s were the stereotypical Tomboy. I certainly was. Joan probably fell into that category. Girls don't seem to have that option these days, but get pigeon holed into the trans shite.

Same here. I loved climbing trees etc, was never interested in make-up or high heels, and wanted to be a boy in order to have male freedom and opportunities. Thank God for Women’s Liberation, and the wonderful social and legal progress we made in the 70s and beyond.
Unbelievable how the misogynists are now tearing down our rights. The price of liberty certainly is eternal vigilance.

Apollo441 · Yesterday 00:42

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 20/11/2026 21:40

Oh yeah, she'd have been marched straight to the Transing Machine and forced into a pair of rainbow dungarees by our Dear Leader. That's how it works.

It's not at all that there's a big difference between being trans and wanting the freedoms boys have. Not at all.

😁

Oh do tell us what those big differences are. Since the difference are BIG you can easily show that it isn't anything to do with sexist stereotypes. Is it playing with boys toys, wearing boys clothes or liking short hair?

TransParentlyAnnoyed · Yesterday 01:13

Apollo441 · Yesterday 00:42

Oh do tell us what those big differences are. Since the difference are BIG you can easily show that it isn't anything to do with sexist stereotypes. Is it playing with boys toys, wearing boys clothes or liking short hair?

Nope. Being trans has nothing to do with clothes.

My son is trans. He wears skirts quite often. Played with a wide variety of toys as a kid - his brother's stuff, and My Little Ponies. Barbies. He liked JoJo Bows, ballet and all manner of girly stuff.

Being trans isn't cosplay. It's not about appearance or wanting what boys have.

It's about knowing you already are a boy, whatever your body shape. However you look, and whatever hobbies you enjoy.

Cattywillow · Yesterday 03:16

Another one who idolised George from Famous Five, wore my brother’s clothes, hung out with mostly boys and cut my hair as soon as I could. I had a secret boys name. I’m thankful that was all pretty unremarkable at the time. I look around the school yard now and can count on one hand the number of girls who don’t have very long hair. As girls we had much more freedom of expression back then. I did feel I had been saddled with the wrong anatomy, especially as I experienced puberty early which caused some distress. But, as others have said, I’m so grateful I was able to grow into embracing my sex healthy and whole and to experience all it has given me (which I definitely did not want as a teen).

NotBadConsidering · Yesterday 04:34

TRAs are always good at explaining what trans is not. They always struggle explaining what it is.

DeanElderberry · Yesterday 06:49

Schylla · 20/11/2026 21:17

But social costs & incentives make the difference to whether those pressures are successful so anyone believing the incentives outweigh the costs to transitioning particularly for trans women isn't living in reality.

Transwomen are not relevant to this thread, which is about women, and our feelings, opportunities, and experiences, which men know nothing of.

Many of us know young transmen and worry about the damage they have done to themselves.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 07:00

OldCrone · 20/11/2026 21:23

This thread isn't about men. It's about women and girls.

It's about a woman who said she wanted to be a boy when she was a child, how common this is among girls and would such girls be transed today.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 07:03

I never wanted to be a boy but I was very much a tomboy and grew up to be a lesbian. I tried weeing standing up through a toilet roll a couple of times, just to see what it was like, but that's about it for any interest in what it's like to be a boy.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · Yesterday 07:09

TransParentlyAnnoyed · Yesterday 01:13

Nope. Being trans has nothing to do with clothes.

My son is trans. He wears skirts quite often. Played with a wide variety of toys as a kid - his brother's stuff, and My Little Ponies. Barbies. He liked JoJo Bows, ballet and all manner of girly stuff.

Being trans isn't cosplay. It's not about appearance or wanting what boys have.

It's about knowing you already are a boy, whatever your body shape. However you look, and whatever hobbies you enjoy.

Your child is female. This can't be changed. Your job as a parent is not to go along with a delusion. If your child has come to believe that she is male when she manifestly isn't, she needs skilled professional help to unpick what has made her feel that way and to reassure her that being a woman will be fine.

Schylla · Yesterday 07:22

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · Yesterday 07:09

Your child is female. This can't be changed. Your job as a parent is not to go along with a delusion. If your child has come to believe that she is male when she manifestly isn't, she needs skilled professional help to unpick what has made her feel that way and to reassure her that being a woman will be fine.

There's no guarantee psychotherapy works so stop spreading disinformation.

MontyMadness99 · Yesterday 07:28

There’s no guarantee that transitioning works so stop spreading disinformation.

Schylla · Yesterday 07:31

MontyMadness99 · Yesterday 07:28

There’s no guarantee that transitioning works so stop spreading disinformation.

Well done! No guarantees either way!

OldCrone · Yesterday 07:34

Schylla · Yesterday 07:22

There's no guarantee psychotherapy works so stop spreading disinformation.

So if a girl insists she's a boy, we should all go along with her delusion, rather than try to help her to accept her body and her sex?

Even if there's no guarantee that psychotherapy will work, that's not a reason to not try to help her at all.

MontyMadness99 · Yesterday 07:36

Schylla · Yesterday 07:31

Well done! No guarantees either way!

Being sanctimonious is not an attractive trait. FO.

Schylla · Yesterday 07:37

OldCrone · Yesterday 07:34

So if a girl insists she's a boy, we should all go along with her delusion, rather than try to help her to accept her body and her sex?

Even if there's no guarantee that psychotherapy will work, that's not a reason to not try to help her at all.

Stop exaggerating.

Who said that exploring motivations, options & holistic treatment as long as there's no coercion is problematic? Certainty not WPATH.

Schylla · Yesterday 07:38

MontyMadness99 · Yesterday 07:36

Being sanctimonious is not an attractive trait. FO.

"sanctimonious" = stating a fact.

Welcome to la la land.

MontyMadness99 · Yesterday 07:42

Schylla · Yesterday 07:38

"sanctimonious" = stating a fact.

Welcome to la la land.

Oh dear, yet again proving an inability to understand English and its nuances to comprehend which part of your own sentence was sanctimonious.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 07:42

Schylla · Yesterday 07:22

There's no guarantee psychotherapy works so stop spreading disinformation.

There's no guarantee that therapy would work to sort out all of a kid's mental health issues, but it should be tried and definitely before anything else is tried. Can you even give any examples of where transing children has worked? Where are all these people who were transed as children? Why do we never see them among the trans activists? The ones we do know, such as Jazz Jennings or Kim Petras obviously still have huge mental health issues and clearly know that they are actually gay males on some level (Jazz Jennings even admitted that he's a gay male and afraid to tell his parents about it when he did hypnotherapy).

Or are you suggesting that kids should be immediately transed with no therapy or mental health assessment beforehand?

Stop spreading the nasty lie that children are born in the wrong body.

idontknowhowtodreamyourdreams · Yesterday 07:55

I wanted to be a boy too. I thought if I were a boy then the awful things that were happening to me wouldn’t happen. They probably would have done - some men don’t care whether they are sexually abusing a boy or a girl. Just a child.

But in my young brain, if only I were a boy.

There are so many reasons why a child might hate their body and wish it to be different. These need to be explored with kindness, curiosity and professionalism. Not just affirmed.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · Yesterday 08:05

Schylla · Yesterday 07:22

There's no guarantee psychotherapy works so stop spreading disinformation.

Did I say there was any guarantee? No. What is known is that decades ago psychiatrists, psychologists and other professionals working with the very small numbers of people who had gender issues and sought help reported that they saw far more male patients than female (at least twice as many boys in the under-18s), and that children and teenagers generally came to terms with their natal sex once they were through puberty. Watchful waiting was the treatment and it worked in most cases.

Then the internet arrived, a wonderful way to spread social contagion, something we've known for centuries particularly affects teenage girls, a group also very susceptible to coping with misery and change by harming themselves in various ways that make them feel they still have some control of their lives. Suddenly we had an enormous increase in the number of girls announcing that they were really boys or had no gender.

There was no corresponding surge in the number of adult women announcing that they were really men or non-binary. If this this was all happening now because the stigma has gone, where are the adult femal transitioners? Particularly noticeable because the other big increase was in adult men, mostly middle-aged or older, announcing that they identified as women. In a great many of their cases it seems to be linked with fetishes and porn, another great gift of the internet, and not one that affects women in the same way.

Disastrously, instead of providing some form of psychological therapy and support for these girls (and boys), the various professions involved were captured by activists who pushed through changes in treatment with no robust evidence base. Watchful waiting was out. Unquestioning affirmation was in. Gatekeeping around hormonal and surgical treatment was effectively ended. There is no other mental health issue where a patient's obvious delusion is accepted and where everybody else is required to go along with it.

For teenage girls in particular this is a disaster if they start taking drugs that interfere with the very complex hormonal system of the female body. It makes irreversible changes that in adult life many wish had not happened. See also: double mastectomy in the late teens, hysterectomy not long after. As a great many of the girls affected are on the autistic spectrum and/or have various other mental health issues, they are exceptionally badly placed to make informed decisions on all these matters, especially if their brains have been frozen at the pre-pubertal stage of development.

Schylla · Yesterday 08:10

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 07:42

There's no guarantee that therapy would work to sort out all of a kid's mental health issues, but it should be tried and definitely before anything else is tried. Can you even give any examples of where transing children has worked? Where are all these people who were transed as children? Why do we never see them among the trans activists? The ones we do know, such as Jazz Jennings or Kim Petras obviously still have huge mental health issues and clearly know that they are actually gay males on some level (Jazz Jennings even admitted that he's a gay male and afraid to tell his parents about it when he did hypnotherapy).

Or are you suggesting that kids should be immediately transed with no therapy or mental health assessment beforehand?

Stop spreading the nasty lie that children are born in the wrong body.

There's no guarantee that therapy would work to sort out all of a kid's mental health issues, but it should be tried and definitely before anything else is tried.

Depends on the circumstances. If the context is adults, we don't typically require mental health assessments for those that don't raise that they have have mental distress & request medical bodily enhancements. If its minors the protocol is generally supposed to be explorative & holistic.

Can you even give any examples of where transing children has worked?

Seriously? There are no trans adults who say they 'knew' when they were children? Many trans adults claim just that most famously Caitlin Jenner.

Why do we never see them among the trans activists?

You know all trans activists do you?

still have huge mental health issues

Making a person's life easier from mental distress doesn't necessarily mean it will be eradicated particularly since there is so much social resistance & discrimination that remains. Being 'different', bullied & rejected for one's entire life has its intractable consequences.

clearly know that they are actually gay males on some leve

Data?

Or are you suggesting that kids should be immediately transed with no therapy or mental health assessment beforehand?

As I said, an exploration of motivations & holistic options that isn't coerced & is patient centred is ideal & with WPATH guidelines.

Stop spreading the nasty lie that children are born in the wrong body.

That be more your misguided 'interpretation'. Gender & sex aren't the same thing.

Schylla · Yesterday 08:12

idontknowhowtodreamyourdreams · Yesterday 07:55

I wanted to be a boy too. I thought if I were a boy then the awful things that were happening to me wouldn’t happen. They probably would have done - some men don’t care whether they are sexually abusing a boy or a girl. Just a child.

But in my young brain, if only I were a boy.

There are so many reasons why a child might hate their body and wish it to be different. These need to be explored with kindness, curiosity and professionalism. Not just affirmed.

The difference being you never said 'I am a boy' rather 'you want to be one'.

Big difference.