Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Would Joan Collins have transitioned as a teenager?

111 replies

Neversofaraway · 20/11/2026 20:22

https://www.thetimes.com/article/2b532778-04c9-4179-a2c3-f2a807c0a9ff?shareToken=467145f8b3db82824e20f63dc1235e45

I first heard Joan Collins on WH some years ago saying that she wanted to be a boy when she was a teenager and here she is repeating it in today's Times.
Like many of us she didn't fancy becoming an adult women.

Would she have been transitioned under today's regime?

Verifying Device

https://www.thetimes.com/article/2b532778-04c9-4179-a2c3-f2a807c0a9ff?shareToken=467145f8b3db82824e20f63dc1235e45

OP posts:
OldCrone · Yesterday 08:23

Schylla · Yesterday 08:10

There's no guarantee that therapy would work to sort out all of a kid's mental health issues, but it should be tried and definitely before anything else is tried.

Depends on the circumstances. If the context is adults, we don't typically require mental health assessments for those that don't raise that they have have mental distress & request medical bodily enhancements. If its minors the protocol is generally supposed to be explorative & holistic.

Can you even give any examples of where transing children has worked?

Seriously? There are no trans adults who say they 'knew' when they were children? Many trans adults claim just that most famously Caitlin Jenner.

Why do we never see them among the trans activists?

You know all trans activists do you?

still have huge mental health issues

Making a person's life easier from mental distress doesn't necessarily mean it will be eradicated particularly since there is so much social resistance & discrimination that remains. Being 'different', bullied & rejected for one's entire life has its intractable consequences.

clearly know that they are actually gay males on some leve

Data?

Or are you suggesting that kids should be immediately transed with no therapy or mental health assessment beforehand?

As I said, an exploration of motivations & holistic options that isn't coerced & is patient centred is ideal & with WPATH guidelines.

Stop spreading the nasty lie that children are born in the wrong body.

That be more your misguided 'interpretation'. Gender & sex aren't the same thing.

Can you even give any examples of where transing children has worked?
Seriously? There are no trans adults who say they 'knew' when they were children? Many trans adults claim just that most famously Caitlin Jenner.

Of course they claim that. If you think about it for a second you'll understand why. But just in case you're struggling, it's because it's an attempt to take the sexual element out of "trans". And an adult male claiming he "always knew" he was a laydee when he's fathered several children is obviously nonsense.

But if you read the question properly, you'll see that you didn't actually answer the question. Jenner wasn't transed as a child, so he's not an example of "where transing children has worked".

BobbleBear · Yesterday 08:33

Yes, I grew up in the 70’s and definitely would have wanted to transition, thinking it was a valid option.

I was convinced I must be a boy in my early teens because I wasn’t doing the girly stuff right. I was small but quite muscular and sporty, (taunted that I had footballers legs) and I was good at maths & sciences. I was very plain verging on ugly with my buck teeth and NHS glasses and hopeless at being organised, neat and tidy plus it’s obvious now, I was autistic, so didn’t share that secret communication language the other girls seemed to possess.

Thank fuck it wasn’t a thing back then!!

I’m in my 60’s now and still have pixie cut v short hair (it’s never been longer than my chin), but I’m definitely a woman, married with children.

Perenelle · Yesterday 08:33

If it were just about (social) gender and not about (physical) sex, why should the treatment be to change ones body?

Without diminishing the distress that individuals are certainly feeling, there is just so much inconsistency in the whole trans ideology.

Also highly agree that it is important to differentiate between the motives - a middle-aged father “remembering” feeling like a girl all his life is vastly different than an autistic teenage girl with trauma background.

Schylla · Yesterday 08:39

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · Yesterday 08:05

Did I say there was any guarantee? No. What is known is that decades ago psychiatrists, psychologists and other professionals working with the very small numbers of people who had gender issues and sought help reported that they saw far more male patients than female (at least twice as many boys in the under-18s), and that children and teenagers generally came to terms with their natal sex once they were through puberty. Watchful waiting was the treatment and it worked in most cases.

Then the internet arrived, a wonderful way to spread social contagion, something we've known for centuries particularly affects teenage girls, a group also very susceptible to coping with misery and change by harming themselves in various ways that make them feel they still have some control of their lives. Suddenly we had an enormous increase in the number of girls announcing that they were really boys or had no gender.

There was no corresponding surge in the number of adult women announcing that they were really men or non-binary. If this this was all happening now because the stigma has gone, where are the adult femal transitioners? Particularly noticeable because the other big increase was in adult men, mostly middle-aged or older, announcing that they identified as women. In a great many of their cases it seems to be linked with fetishes and porn, another great gift of the internet, and not one that affects women in the same way.

Disastrously, instead of providing some form of psychological therapy and support for these girls (and boys), the various professions involved were captured by activists who pushed through changes in treatment with no robust evidence base. Watchful waiting was out. Unquestioning affirmation was in. Gatekeeping around hormonal and surgical treatment was effectively ended. There is no other mental health issue where a patient's obvious delusion is accepted and where everybody else is required to go along with it.

For teenage girls in particular this is a disaster if they start taking drugs that interfere with the very complex hormonal system of the female body. It makes irreversible changes that in adult life many wish had not happened. See also: double mastectomy in the late teens, hysterectomy not long after. As a great many of the girls affected are on the autistic spectrum and/or have various other mental health issues, they are exceptionally badly placed to make informed decisions on all these matters, especially if their brains have been frozen at the pre-pubertal stage of development.

All these claims have long been debunked.

What is known is that decades ago psychiatrists, psychologists and other professionals working with the very small numbers of people who had gender issues and sought help reported that they saw far more male patients than female (at least twice as many boys in the under-18s), and that children and teenagers generally came to terms with their natal sex once they were through puberty. Watchful waiting was the treatment and it worked in most cases.

This research was based on flawed methodology where the individuals concerned never claimed to be trans, did not claim to have gender dysphoria but were effeminate males whose parents were concerned about their disposition who turned out to be gay.

Then the internet arrived, a wonderful way to spread social contagion, something we've known for centuries particularly affects teenage girls, a group also very susceptible to coping with misery and change by harming themselves in various ways that make them feel they still have some control of their lives. Suddenly we had an enormous increase in the number of girls announcing that they were really boys or had no gender.

There's no research evidence to support social contagion of trans men. The only research was discredited for using parental opinions sourced from anti trans forums rather than directly from the source. It is reasonably theorised that teenage females come out younger as trans at larger rates than males because the social cost is understandably substantially lower. What the evidence shows is the numbers even up into adulthood as males tend to come out after leaving school to avoid bullying.

the various professions involved were captured by activists who pushed through changes in treatment with no robust evidence base.

"Captured" or advances in medical understanding of efficacy. The idea that the whole medical profession was trans 'captured' globally is as nonsensical as it was for climate science or vaccines. There's no evidence of such a spectacular conspiratorial hoodwinking other than crank wishful thinking.

It makes irreversible changes that in adult life many wish had not happened.

Medical treatments generally are routinely recommended based on tradeoffs. This is no different.

As a great many of the girls affected are on the autistic spectrum and/or have various other mental health issues, they are exceptionally badly placed to make informed decisions on all these matters, especially if their brains have been frozen at the pre-pubertal stage of development.

Gender identification isn't considered a mental disorder by global experts & that various mental health issues correlate aren't necessarily a smoking gun. In fact its not uncommon for people who are considered social outcasts to be susceptible to suffering from depression & anxiety.

Autism is highly correlated to sensitivity & single mindedness that is resistant to abiding by social norms hence if an autistic person has gender dysphoria they are more likely to recognise it (sensitivity) & resist social pressures to repress it.

thirdfiddle · Yesterday 08:42

Well as a sheer numbers game, it is inevitable that some of us who wished to be a boy when we were younger /would/ have believed the ideology and believed we were and transitioned. Why shouldn't Joan be one of them.

The lack of hordes of adult female transitioners is a big problem for trans ideology. Either adult women did feel the same as the current generation and most grew out of it. Or they didn't feel as intensely as the current generation do, in which case there must surely be a large degree of cultural influence.

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 08:45

I would just like to add, for all the tiresome trans activists, we do know that sex is not ”gender”. Very clearly in fact.

It is the gender theory believers that are very keen on blurring the difference between the two, to the point of claiming that sex is so complex it cannot possibly be determined or observed, and must therefore be replaced with “gender”.

However, the word “gender” is used in a number of ways, and I do not yet have a single explanation of what trans believers mean by the word - none of them can tell me, and every one that I have interacted with gives a different answer, or (even more importantly) uses the word “gender” to mean something different in one sentence followed by the next in order to obfuscate arguments.

It is used:

  1. a euphemism and synonym for sex
  2. the social expectations that we put on people of either sex
  3. ”expression” or presentation in the clothes/style associated with one sex or the other.
  4. Some sort of inner gender essence that somehow means you are really the opposite sex (only possessed by trans identified people).

Given that we all agree that sex is distinct from gender:

  1. why do activists want access to spaces that are separated by sex for physical reasons of female vulnerability?
  2. why do activists want change the sex marker on their birth certificates?
  3. why do plenty of trans women claim to have changed sex rather than gender?
FancyKitten · Yesterday 08:46

My six year old boy has started saying he wants to be a girl. I think it’s because he likes hanging out with girls at school. The boys play rougher games at that age & are starting to get more macho & competitive.

I’ve said, do you want to grow your hair & wear a dress then? He’s said no! I’ve replied, well you’re a boy. He then reasons, God made us all a boy or a girl & that’s the way it is. I think he might be learning about Adam & Eve at school. Granny has said, you can get an injection to become a girl. And he’s like, no way! It’s all just completely normal questioning as far as I’m concerned.

What JC is saying is really interesting as we’ve always had cultural movements, music scenes where one can dress-up, wear clothes of the opposite sex. Experiment with make-up, gender identity etc… But actually transitioning? I think it’s fine to be gender-fluid or more boyish / girlish. As others have mentioned, being a tomboy. Or not being ready to be an adult woman / man. Going through puberty. It’s perfectly natural to try finding your place within the world, and within your newly-emerging self.

importantupdate · Yesterday 08:47

I don’t know, but I know for sure I would have, and my sister too.

It’s probably the reason I’m very much against gender bollocks now.

I used to practice peeing standing up in the bath, shove socks down my pants…every time we went on holiday when I was a kid I’d introduce myself as a boy to any kids I met. I cried so much when my dm made me start wearing a bra and used to take it off in the toilets and hide it in my bag. If I’d had the option of a breast binder I’d have been all over that!

Schylla · Yesterday 08:48

OldCrone · Yesterday 08:23

Can you even give any examples of where transing children has worked?
Seriously? There are no trans adults who say they 'knew' when they were children? Many trans adults claim just that most famously Caitlin Jenner.

Of course they claim that. If you think about it for a second you'll understand why. But just in case you're struggling, it's because it's an attempt to take the sexual element out of "trans". And an adult male claiming he "always knew" he was a laydee when he's fathered several children is obviously nonsense.

But if you read the question properly, you'll see that you didn't actually answer the question. Jenner wasn't transed as a child, so he's not an example of "where transing children has worked".

This illogical reason falls apart simply by virtue of trans men existing. What? They are sex perverts too? Your unproven 'sex deviance' assumptions say more about you than anything else.

Research shows children who identify as gender dysphoric & or trans identifying do tend to maintain this stable identity into adulthood if they insistently, persistently & consistently claimed to be as such for long periods of time.

Btw, how can you prove 'they never knew'? Works both ways.

MoistVonL · Yesterday 08:48

Schylla · Yesterday 08:12

The difference being you never said 'I am a boy' rather 'you want to be one'.

Big difference.

Because back then it was impossible. No one could transition as a child so "wish" was as far as it could go.

The massive cohort of tween and teen girls suddenly identifying as trans - a 4400% increase - is what happens when distressed girls are shown a (to them) plausible way out of escaping becoming a woman.

I'd have jumped at it if I could have, because being sexually assaulted in my pre-teens made me scared of what men and boys did to me as I hit puberty. And rightly so.

Schylla · Yesterday 08:52

Perenelle · Yesterday 08:33

If it were just about (social) gender and not about (physical) sex, why should the treatment be to change ones body?

Without diminishing the distress that individuals are certainly feeling, there is just so much inconsistency in the whole trans ideology.

Also highly agree that it is important to differentiate between the motives - a middle-aged father “remembering” feeling like a girl all his life is vastly different than an autistic teenage girl with trauma background.

If it were just about (social) gender and not about (physical) sex, why should the treatment be to change ones body?

Sex traits are also gendered traits. Natal females aren't getting breast enhancements in droves to accentuate their reproductive abilities. They are doing so because it aligns with their personal conception of ideal womanhood. In other words its about gender not sex.

Schylla · Yesterday 08:59

MoistVonL · Yesterday 08:48

Because back then it was impossible. No one could transition as a child so "wish" was as far as it could go.

The massive cohort of tween and teen girls suddenly identifying as trans - a 4400% increase - is what happens when distressed girls are shown a (to them) plausible way out of escaping becoming a woman.

I'd have jumped at it if I could have, because being sexually assaulted in my pre-teens made me scared of what men and boys did to me as I hit puberty. And rightly so.

False. Researchers report the difference in terminology from very young children who have no idea of the limitations of biology from decades ago. They use the difference in terminology as a distinction between the two. See Steensma research.

There is no massive difference in cohort between males & females btw. Females come out as trans younger because they mature faster & there is a lower social cost but males catch up in their twenties.

OldCrone · Yesterday 09:01

Schylla · Yesterday 08:48

This illogical reason falls apart simply by virtue of trans men existing. What? They are sex perverts too? Your unproven 'sex deviance' assumptions say more about you than anything else.

Research shows children who identify as gender dysphoric & or trans identifying do tend to maintain this stable identity into adulthood if they insistently, persistently & consistently claimed to be as such for long periods of time.

Btw, how can you prove 'they never knew'? Works both ways.

Your unproven 'sex deviance' assumptions say more about you than anything else.

I'm not making any assumptions. Here are some quotes from trans identifying males.

"At the centre of sissy porn lies the asshole, a kind of universal vagina through which femaleness can always be accessed. Getting fucked makes you female because fucked is what a female is."
"...an open mouth, an expectant asshole, blank, blank eyes."
Andrea Long Chu - Trans identified male writer

"...My sexual orientation was not gay. It was not straight. It was not pan. It was is always an attraction to misogyny."
"...my gender was so influenced by a need to be used by men."
"...Not feeling femme enough without being a victim of rape"
Hunter Schafer - Trans identified male activist and actor

"I would imagine myself being sold into sex slavery and having strange men take advantage of me."
Julia Serano, Trans identified male academic, writer and activist

Research shows children who identify as gender dysphoric & or trans identifying do tend to maintain this stable identity into adulthood if they insistently, persistently & consistently claimed to be as such for long periods of time.

What research? The vast majority (80% or more) desist after puberty if not medicalised.

borntobequiet · Yesterday 09:03

I grew up in the late fifties/early sixties, was very unhappy with my developing body and had “masculine” interests, so if anyone had told me transitioning was possible I’d have jumped at it. And I agree with Joan. Casual sexism was everywhere in those days but women weren’t treated with the sort of contempt and cruelty evident now, and society expected men to treat women with courtesy and consideration. Women could also defend themselves physically. For example, I had a number of casual jobs in hotels, bars and restaurants. Sometimes male staff would make inappropriate remarks or get handsy - it was not unknown for them to get a resounding slap to discourage such behaviour. The slap would be considered well-deserved and the slappee laughed at for inviting it. I can’t imagine a young woman having the confidence to do that now.

Schylla · Yesterday 09:08

OldCrone · Yesterday 09:01

Your unproven 'sex deviance' assumptions say more about you than anything else.

I'm not making any assumptions. Here are some quotes from trans identifying males.

"At the centre of sissy porn lies the asshole, a kind of universal vagina through which femaleness can always be accessed. Getting fucked makes you female because fucked is what a female is."
"...an open mouth, an expectant asshole, blank, blank eyes."
Andrea Long Chu - Trans identified male writer

"...My sexual orientation was not gay. It was not straight. It was not pan. It was is always an attraction to misogyny."
"...my gender was so influenced by a need to be used by men."
"...Not feeling femme enough without being a victim of rape"
Hunter Schafer - Trans identified male activist and actor

"I would imagine myself being sold into sex slavery and having strange men take advantage of me."
Julia Serano, Trans identified male academic, writer and activist

Research shows children who identify as gender dysphoric & or trans identifying do tend to maintain this stable identity into adulthood if they insistently, persistently & consistently claimed to be as such for long periods of time.

What research? The vast majority (80% or more) desist after puberty if not medicalised.

Anecdotal cherry picked quotes doesn't qualify as data.

What research? The vast majority (80% or more) desist after puberty if not medicalised.

As I already explained that 'data' was proven to be unrelated to trans people.

MoistVonL · Yesterday 09:10

Researchers report the difference in terminology from very young children who have no idea of the limitations of biology from decades ago

Straw man. I didn't mention very young children. I said teens and tweens looking for an escape and lo and behold, you can transition! Become cool and interesting in Y8 and Y9, not bullied, and have clubs and celebration days for you and the other children like you.

I've seen it play out in real time. It's hard not to reach out for that when you're a distressed, vulnerable teen fearing the changes you are going through.

Funny how th cohort most affected is the cohort of society that got generations has seen to be prone to social contagion, isn't it? Fainting fits, self harm, eating disorders, trans identification...

Plus ça change

OldCrone · Yesterday 09:10

Schylla · Yesterday 08:59

False. Researchers report the difference in terminology from very young children who have no idea of the limitations of biology from decades ago. They use the difference in terminology as a distinction between the two. See Steensma research.

There is no massive difference in cohort between males & females btw. Females come out as trans younger because they mature faster & there is a lower social cost but males catch up in their twenties.

There is no massive difference in cohort between males & females btw.

Where are all the late transitioning women who have married men and given birth?

According to you there should be just as many of them as there are late transitioning males who have married women and fathered children.

Schylla · Yesterday 09:11

borntobequiet · Yesterday 09:03

I grew up in the late fifties/early sixties, was very unhappy with my developing body and had “masculine” interests, so if anyone had told me transitioning was possible I’d have jumped at it. And I agree with Joan. Casual sexism was everywhere in those days but women weren’t treated with the sort of contempt and cruelty evident now, and society expected men to treat women with courtesy and consideration. Women could also defend themselves physically. For example, I had a number of casual jobs in hotels, bars and restaurants. Sometimes male staff would make inappropriate remarks or get handsy - it was not unknown for them to get a resounding slap to discourage such behaviour. The slap would be considered well-deserved and the slappee laughed at for inviting it. I can’t imagine a young woman having the confidence to do that now.

I can’t imagine a young woman having the confidence to do that now.

My dude, have you been living under a rock? Try telling a young woman today they look hot & watch how fast they call the cops! 😂

MoistVonL · Yesterday 09:12

Schylla claims everything they don't like has been "debunked", when its only been "debunked" by TRA mouthpieces.

They've even rolled out the No True Scotsman with "those trans identifying kids who desisted aren't trans".

borntobequiet · Yesterday 09:14

MoistVonL · Yesterday 09:12

Schylla claims everything they don't like has been "debunked", when its only been "debunked" by TRA mouthpieces.

They've even rolled out the No True Scotsman with "those trans identifying kids who desisted aren't trans".

They've even rolled out the No True Scotsman with "those trans identifying kids who desisted aren't trans".

Yes, that one stood out to me too.

OldCrone · Yesterday 09:15

Schylla · Yesterday 09:08

Anecdotal cherry picked quotes doesn't qualify as data.

What research? The vast majority (80% or more) desist after puberty if not medicalised.

As I already explained that 'data' was proven to be unrelated to trans people.

What research? The vast majority (80% or more) desist after puberty if not medicalised.
As I already explained that 'data' was proven to be unrelated to trans people.

So children who claim to be trans and are treated by gender clinics aren't "trans people"? Careful, you'll be claiming that trans people don't exist next.

Schylla · Yesterday 09:15

MoistVonL · Yesterday 09:10

Researchers report the difference in terminology from very young children who have no idea of the limitations of biology from decades ago

Straw man. I didn't mention very young children. I said teens and tweens looking for an escape and lo and behold, you can transition! Become cool and interesting in Y8 and Y9, not bullied, and have clubs and celebration days for you and the other children like you.

I've seen it play out in real time. It's hard not to reach out for that when you're a distressed, vulnerable teen fearing the changes you are going through.

Funny how th cohort most affected is the cohort of society that got generations has seen to be prone to social contagion, isn't it? Fainting fits, self harm, eating disorders, trans identification...

Plus ça change

Oh please. The current cultural zeitgeist is saturated with trans demonisation & dehumanisation. The idea that children who are gender non conforming in the least not being bullied is a particularly ludicrous one.

Honestly, how low can you go to diminish this obvious prevalent harm?
The shamelessness is breathtaking.

Schylla · Yesterday 09:17

OldCrone · Yesterday 09:15

What research? The vast majority (80% or more) desist after puberty if not medicalised.
As I already explained that 'data' was proven to be unrelated to trans people.

So children who claim to be trans and are treated by gender clinics aren't "trans people"? Careful, you'll be claiming that trans people don't exist next.

No. Reread the thread you are totally confused.

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 09:19

Schylla · Yesterday 08:52

If it were just about (social) gender and not about (physical) sex, why should the treatment be to change ones body?

Sex traits are also gendered traits. Natal females aren't getting breast enhancements in droves to accentuate their reproductive abilities. They are doing so because it aligns with their personal conception of ideal womanhood. In other words its about gender not sex.

Here’s a great example of what I mean about activists blurred arguments, and multiple conflicting meanings being assigned to the word “gender”.

“Sex isn’t gender”.
”Sex traits are gendered traits”.

Gender isn’t physical sex, so how are physical sex traits part of whatever you mean by “gender”?

borntobequiet · Yesterday 09:19

I see we’re getting to the condescending and belittling phase.