Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Help needed for a conversation

115 replies

EnjoysAGoodChat · Yesterday 12:40

Any suggestions for how to respond to a women's organisation who is willing to talk about their reasons for being 'inclusive'? I'm delighted that they are willing to talk. I just need some help for when I do have the conversation next week to argue against this position:

not being inclusive of the trans community is dangerous for trans people, in terms of their safety and well-being and for all women and girls as we all will then get policed in how we look. Short hair, trousers, too masculine, too good at sports etc. It leaves it open for all women and girls to be questioned which is not a safe space for us to be in. It is getting to a point in some states in the US where they are trying to mandate that young girls show proof of female anatomy through expensive genetic or hormone tests, or a genital exam, if they want to play sports.

OP posts:
FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 14:58

Transperson · Yesterday 14:56

What makes you think you or anyone else has a choice over my decision to go to which bathroom.

Service providers have no realistic way of enforcing this.

You do understand "I know perfectly well I'm not supposed to be here but how you gonna stop me?" isn't making a great case for the reasonablness of trans people, right?

Transperson · Yesterday 14:59

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 14:58

"You women say no but I'm going to do it anyway"

Quite the week for it, isn't it?

Come and call the gender police 🚨🚨🚨

ATinyStepAndThereTheConclusionsWere · Yesterday 15:00

Transperson · Yesterday 14:58

I'm not going to detransition lmao

What were you before you transitioned into a transperson? A caterpillar?

Transperson · Yesterday 15:00

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 14:58

You do understand "I know perfectly well I'm not supposed to be here but how you gonna stop me?" isn't making a great case for the reasonablness of trans people, right?

I explained to u a thousand times my take, I heard Ur take a thousand times.

I go to where I am the safest and not get outed. You can't stop me from caring about my safety.

BackToLurk · Yesterday 15:01

Transperson · Yesterday 14:54

It's a complete sentence in its own, more visible and noticeable compared to cis/trans men.

Cambridge Dictionary visible
Meaning of visible in English visible adjective
uk /ˈvɪz.ə.bəl/ us /ˈvɪz.ə.bəl/
Able to be seen:You should wear something light-coloured when you're cycling at night so that you're more visible.The writing on the tombstone was barely visible.There are few visible signs of the illness that kept her in hospital for so long.The comet should be visible to the naked eye.

Edited

Your arguing their 'increased visibility' is tied to an increased risk of assault, compared to other men. What are they more visible as that would make them more likely to be assaulted than any other men?

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 15:01

Transperson · Yesterday 14:59

Come and call the gender police 🚨🚨🚨

Behold the person who thinks he's a woman

They do our work for us
#letthemspeak

Transperson · Yesterday 15:01

BackToLurk · Yesterday 15:01

Your arguing their 'increased visibility' is tied to an increased risk of assault, compared to other men. What are they more visible as that would make them more likely to be assaulted than any other men?

Being percieved as female.

Transperson · Yesterday 15:02

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 15:01

Behold the person who thinks he's a woman

They do our work for us
#letthemspeak

Go on, I'm waiting.

Helleofabore · Yesterday 15:02

I think these are a good reminder.

These videos are a reminder of the other common reaction from men we see to our rejection that they are female people in any way. This is the reaction to being told ‘no, you should respect female people’s needs for single sex provisions’ by a celebrity.

Alexandra Billings self published these videos . This one first I believe.

https://x.com/gaynotqueer1/status/2032811484271817092?s=46

Then the chilling and menacing response to women saying 'no' here stitched into Amy Sousa’s response.

https://x.com/knownheretic/status/2032639781658833142?s=4
The menace is chilling to see. Yet, apparently we are supposed to welcome these same men into provisions designated as single sex for our protection from men threatening and intimidating us.

It becomes so clear that these men hate female people in general when they gloat over not being able to stop them accessing provisions that they should be excluded from and lack the inclination to self exclude from. Just as they gloat over organisational decisions to remove female single sex provisions in response to law changes that exclude male people from those provisions.

At the same time, we are supposed to believe that these men are most vulnerable and marginalised.
This set of tweets is from Daviana. Who started posting videos about how he knew he was a man etc. He was considered to be 'one of the reasonable ones' because of that.

Of course, as he has made more videos more has come out about what and how he really thinks. Including his behaviour towards his ex-wife...

https://x.com/KnownHeretic/status/2031523680136868150?s=20

https://x.com/KnownHeretic/status/2031873045682667588?s=20

https://x.com/KnownHeretic/status/2031975467725832460?s=20

These men are chilling once you see what they really think.
The gloating from this man as he also envisions negative impacts on female people because they rejected his demands seems to be highlighting just how common that reaction is from men who don’t get what they want from women.

Billings and Daviana are just two men who are showing women who they really are. There are thousands across the internet. It seems some men really cannot help themselves in showing that these demands are also part of the power dynamic.

It makes those ‘you got what you deserved after you rejected me’ behaviours all so familiar.

Oh... And I believe that Billings also believes that he 'passes'.

Amy E. Sousa, MA Depth Psychology (@KnownHeretic) on X

Zero men are more special than other men when it comes to sex segregated spaces.

https://x.com/KnownHeretic/status/2031523680136868150?s=20

ATinyStepAndThereTheConclusionsWere · Yesterday 15:02

Transperson · Yesterday 15:00

I explained to u a thousand times my take, I heard Ur take a thousand times.

I go to where I am the safest and not get outed. You can't stop me from caring about my safety.

You just don't care about the safety of women. Men in women's single sex spaces put all women at risk.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 15:02

Shedmistress · Yesterday 14:33

I think show them this thread in a day or two about the chaos, upset and general whataboutery that a man joining in to a women's activity results in.

The whole thread and organisation will just be about him.

So they may as well just give up now.

This.

You don't even need to wait a day or two, OP. It's happening in real time.

Schnapps00 · Yesterday 15:03

I can see both sides, however it cannot be beyond us in 2026 to create/adapt spaces where both biological females and trans women can both feel safe and have their rights respected, whether that's via a separate space, individual unisex facilities or other updates. I just don't see transwomen as being in remotely the same risk category as, say many straight men..(clearly not all men etc etc!!)

Transperson · Yesterday 15:04

ATinyStepAndThereTheConclusionsWere · Yesterday 15:02

You just don't care about the safety of women. Men in women's single sex spaces put all women at risk.

Maybe I don't see any risk or harm that I cause in person?? Because there isntttt anyy

BackToLurk · Yesterday 15:05

Transperson · Yesterday 15:01

Being percieved as female.

Edited

So if they aren't perceived as female, by anyone, they should be in the men's?

ATinyStepAndThereTheConclusionsWere · Yesterday 15:05

Transperson · Yesterday 15:04

Maybe I don't see any risk or harm that I cause in person?? Because there isntttt anyy

Your aggressive responses here to women saying no to you makes that seem very unlikely.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 15:06

EnjoysAGoodChat · Yesterday 12:40

Any suggestions for how to respond to a women's organisation who is willing to talk about their reasons for being 'inclusive'? I'm delighted that they are willing to talk. I just need some help for when I do have the conversation next week to argue against this position:

not being inclusive of the trans community is dangerous for trans people, in terms of their safety and well-being and for all women and girls as we all will then get policed in how we look. Short hair, trousers, too masculine, too good at sports etc. It leaves it open for all women and girls to be questioned which is not a safe space for us to be in. It is getting to a point in some states in the US where they are trying to mandate that young girls show proof of female anatomy through expensive genetic or hormone tests, or a genital exam, if they want to play sports.

OP My apologies for contributing to the merail me male derail.

I'll reply to your question properly when I have a little more time, but broadly I'd say remember that really this is about female people and what we need. That's the North star. The trans "I'm too womanny to be a man so I'm really a woman" narrative is just a distraction thrown up by some noisy male people who feel their needs are important enough to be the main narrative of women's stories.

I find just refocussing on the simple facts that female people exist and our sex has consequences always helps me make my points clearly.

Transperson · Yesterday 15:07

BackToLurk · Yesterday 15:05

So if they aren't perceived as female, by anyone, they should be in the men's?

That's what I personally did when I didn't pass.

I don't want to tell other trans people what to do, isn't up to me.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 15:07

@EnjoysAGoodChat, another piece that might be helpful is this one from the Critic called “Neither marginalised, abused nor vulnerable”. It debunks the myth that trans people are the most vulnerable minority - in fact they are the least vulnerable, particularly in the UK.

https://archive.ph/BGyAR

Shedmistress · Yesterday 15:09

Schnapps00 · Yesterday 15:03

I can see both sides, however it cannot be beyond us in 2026 to create/adapt spaces where both biological females and trans women can both feel safe and have their rights respected, whether that's via a separate space, individual unisex facilities or other updates. I just don't see transwomen as being in remotely the same risk category as, say many straight men..(clearly not all men etc etc!!)

You mean, all a man has to say is 'im a lady' and he becomes immediately no risk to women across the board?

How does that work then?

Beowulfa · Yesterday 15:19

OP, I would ask the organisation why they exist in the first place, ie why do men NOT need specific spaces to meet, and help with advocating?

Why would someone born male, growing up seeing men in STEM careers and leadership roles, who has never been spoken over in a meeting or asked to make the tea, has never had their career impacted by assumed or actual pregnancy and who will never need to worry about menopause need any kind of extra assistance?

Ereshkigalangcleg · Yesterday 15:57

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 14:42

@EnjoysAGoodChat, there was a recent ET (might have been Peggie? Or Leonardo? Someone help me out?) where either Maya Forstater or Alice Sullivan (or someone!) gave expert witness testimony to show that TIMs retain male patterns of criminality and violence, even after “transition.” That might be helpful to your argument.

Let me see if I can find…

Think was Peggie. JR kept mispronouncing Maya’s surname.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 16:01

Ereshkigalangcleg · Yesterday 15:57

Think was Peggie. JR kept mispronouncing Maya’s surname.

Fab - thank you!

@EnjoysAGoodChat, here’s Maya’s expert witness statement:

https://sex-matters.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/signed-Maya-Forstater.WS_.pdf

https://sex-matters.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/signed-Maya-Forstater.WS_.pdf

alcovecupboards · Yesterday 16:02

Just to be clear - you're going to an already trans-inclusive organisation as a new person and trying to force them to change position? Or are you already a member? Does this organisation have any speciality that only serves biological females?

DramaAndBullshit · Yesterday 16:07

Transperson · Yesterday 13:25

Maybe just let trans people exist in peace?

You are welcome to exist, no one is stopping you or denying you exist, no one wishes you harm or promotes violence on you.

But, please exist in the appropriate places, ie: not female only sex segregated spaces. There are plenty of unisex spaces that you can exist in, you don’t need to impose on biological women and ignore our boundaries.

DramaAndBullshit · Yesterday 16:19

Transperson · Yesterday 13:57

If you police who is or isn't trans, how is that done? You expect them to enforce it right?

It has to be visual, which will enforce stereotypes about how women look.
Unless you do genotypic testing and even then it would exclude people with CAIS.

No one is suggesting invasive testing. A simple Adam’s Apple check is all we need to confirm the evidence of our own eyes. We know you’re a man, no matter how many people will politely tell you that you ‘pass’, you actually don’t.

If you don't feel safe in male only spaces I suggest you focus your efforts on making men less violent. That way everyone is safer, TiMs, gay men, and all women. Win:Win.

And holy shit the irony of a TiM saying visual checks enforce gender stereotypes. You’re saying that you ‘feel’ like a woman so you’ve changed your appearance to look like female. Let me guess, you’ve got longer hair, painted fingernails, and wear ‘women’s clothes’ and make up. That’s literally gender stereotypes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread