Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Help needed for a conversation

115 replies

EnjoysAGoodChat · Yesterday 12:40

Any suggestions for how to respond to a women's organisation who is willing to talk about their reasons for being 'inclusive'? I'm delighted that they are willing to talk. I just need some help for when I do have the conversation next week to argue against this position:

not being inclusive of the trans community is dangerous for trans people, in terms of their safety and well-being and for all women and girls as we all will then get policed in how we look. Short hair, trousers, too masculine, too good at sports etc. It leaves it open for all women and girls to be questioned which is not a safe space for us to be in. It is getting to a point in some states in the US where they are trying to mandate that young girls show proof of female anatomy through expensive genetic or hormone tests, or a genital exam, if they want to play sports.

OP posts:
pontefractals · Yesterday 12:50

Maybe point out that you do not wish to exclude "the transgender community", just males. Transmen are (I presume and hope) fine.
Also add that the test to determine sex involves a cheek swab, not the infamous "genital examination ".
You're also not seeking to stop anyone doing anything, just requesting that they do it in the appropriate space for their immutable sex.

Shedmistress · Yesterday 12:57

I'd go back to the reasons for having a 'women's organisation' in the first place, and inform them that if they exclude men but not men who say they are women they are at risk of a discrimination claim and point them to the man who tried to join the WI and how they need to decide to either be completely mixed sex or stay singe sex, sex meaning females.

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 13:04

EnjoysAGoodChat · Yesterday 12:40

Any suggestions for how to respond to a women's organisation who is willing to talk about their reasons for being 'inclusive'? I'm delighted that they are willing to talk. I just need some help for when I do have the conversation next week to argue against this position:

not being inclusive of the trans community is dangerous for trans people, in terms of their safety and well-being and for all women and girls as we all will then get policed in how we look. Short hair, trousers, too masculine, too good at sports etc. It leaves it open for all women and girls to be questioned which is not a safe space for us to be in. It is getting to a point in some states in the US where they are trying to mandate that young girls show proof of female anatomy through expensive genetic or hormone tests, or a genital exam, if they want to play sports.

Ask them what material benefit women and girls get from making their spaces abd sports mixed sex and how this will keep women and girls safer than excluding men.

SylvanMoon · Yesterday 13:24

What type of an organisation is it, as that will shape how you argue that it's relevant for its work to be single sex?

Transperson · Yesterday 13:25

Maybe just let trans people exist in peace?

dementedpixie · Yesterday 13:40

Transperson · Yesterday 13:25

Maybe just let trans people exist in peace?

They can peacefully exist in the single sex space that corresponds to their actual sex

Transperson · Yesterday 13:42

dementedpixie · Yesterday 13:40

They can peacefully exist in the single sex space that corresponds to their actual sex

So you want them to get assaulted?

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 13:47

Are you able to say what kind of organisation it is @EnjoysAGoodChat or give a general idea?

It's positive that they're willing to talk

EnjoysAGoodChat · Yesterday 13:50

SylvanMoon · Yesterday 13:24

What type of an organisation is it, as that will shape how you argue that it's relevant for its work to be single sex?

It is an organisation that is specifically about advocating for women and a space for women to meet.

Thank you so much for all the advice from everyone. I'll do a bit of studying and read the previous links. I really want to be able to explain it clearly because they think they are absolutely right about this and the position that I am taking is denying people's humanity/existence.

I'll give it a go! Thanks

OP posts:
EnjoysAGoodChat · Yesterday 13:54

Just to add: I was most mystified by the bit about being policed about how we all look.

OP posts:
Transperson · Yesterday 13:57

EnjoysAGoodChat · Yesterday 13:54

Just to add: I was most mystified by the bit about being policed about how we all look.

If you police who is or isn't trans, how is that done? You expect them to enforce it right?

It has to be visual, which will enforce stereotypes about how women look.
Unless you do genotypic testing and even then it would exclude people with CAIS.

Grammarnut · Yesterday 14:14

Transperson · Yesterday 13:42

So you want them to get assaulted?

That isn't women's problem to deal with, it is men's.

Grammarnut · Yesterday 14:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Transperson · Yesterday 14:19

Grammarnut · Yesterday 14:14

That isn't women's problem to deal with, it is men's.

Edited

You are turning it into trans people's problem. And individually they will do right for themselves.

It's a service providers job to enforce SSS, but they have no reasonable way of enforcing this.

In practice trans people have a choice and they won't put themselves under harms way.

Transperson · Yesterday 14:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Only mumsnet says things like this, I don't have any problems irl

BackToLurk · Yesterday 14:22

Transperson · Yesterday 13:42

So you want them to get assaulted?

Gay men get assaulted, is that a reason to give them access to female-only spaces?

Transperson · Yesterday 14:25

BackToLurk · Yesterday 14:22

Gay men get assaulted, is that a reason to give them access to female-only spaces?

Gay men aren't precieved as female though.

CheeseNPickle3 · Yesterday 14:26

I suppose you could ask them if being "inclusive" means not being able to turn anyone away at all. It's not just women and the "trans community" that they'd be including.

If that's the case, surely they're no longer an organisation for women and you'd have to ask what exactly their purpose is.

ItsAllGoingToBeFine · Yesterday 14:27

Transperson · Yesterday 14:25

Gay men aren't precieved as female though.

Neither are TIMs

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 14:27

Transperson · Yesterday 14:25

Gay men aren't precieved as female though.

Just like butch lesbians aren’t perceived as men.

Justme56 · Yesterday 14:28

No one has to do genital inspections, or be worried about being mistaken for the opposite sex if trans people were honest about their sex from the start. Why is this never considered? It would be better just to argue that maybe because they are trans they may feel unsafe in a male environment and take it from there rather than give the impression that trans people are deceitful.

BackToLurk · Yesterday 14:28

Transperson · Yesterday 14:25

Gay men aren't precieved as female though.

So? You said it was because they were assaulted.

Transperson · Yesterday 14:30

ItsAllGoingToBeFine · Yesterday 14:27

Neither are TIMs

They do though (this is survivorship bias).