Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Help needed for a conversation

115 replies

EnjoysAGoodChat · Yesterday 12:40

Any suggestions for how to respond to a women's organisation who is willing to talk about their reasons for being 'inclusive'? I'm delighted that they are willing to talk. I just need some help for when I do have the conversation next week to argue against this position:

not being inclusive of the trans community is dangerous for trans people, in terms of their safety and well-being and for all women and girls as we all will then get policed in how we look. Short hair, trousers, too masculine, too good at sports etc. It leaves it open for all women and girls to be questioned which is not a safe space for us to be in. It is getting to a point in some states in the US where they are trying to mandate that young girls show proof of female anatomy through expensive genetic or hormone tests, or a genital exam, if they want to play sports.

OP posts:
Catiette · Yesterday 20:52

I feel sorry for OP too. Personally, OP, I would take the approach of asking them questions. It sounds as though they are very much wedded to the idea that including trans women is unambiguously, morally right. As such, if you focus on why trans women should be excluded, you risk reinforcing their preconceptions of prejudice. Instead, I would seek to expand their understanding of inclusion and moral right. This will also reinforce your good faith intentions. For example,

How do they accommodate religious and ethnic minority women who are unable to share spaces with males? Whatever answer they give is likely to provoke further questions. Perhaps they don't accommodate these women at all, in which case, what led them to prioritise trans women over other demographics - depending on the type of group, you could refer to women's difficulty integrating, risk of FGM or forced marriage etc. The suggestion that such women and their cultures are themselves close minded or sexist would be an own goal, inviting concerned questions about this perception, or an interesting discussion of how best to bring about positive integration and change.

The same question, but for victims of male violence. To pre-empt the suggestion that they reframe their trauma, as the delightful saying goes, you could briefly refer to women unable even to engage with close male relatives following assault - this is not prejudice, but a physiological response. Were they to suggest that what such women don't know won't hurt them, you could call them out on this directly – appalling! – or take the more strategic approach of asking about the potential psychological damage done, were they to find out by chance.

What about how they manage the expectations of the women in these two groups above? Do they make their trans inclusive stance explicit, and do they explain it clearly? Here, you could refer to surveys showing that a significant proportion of the British population does not understand the terms trans woman and trans man. This, of course, forces them into an ethical conundrum: do they risk denying a trans woman's existence, as contributors above suggest, by clearly defining them as a male? Or do they risk misleading equally vulnerable demographics? Conversely, perhaps they expect such women to declare their religious beliefs and sexual trauma before accessing the group?!?

It's depressingly easy, with careful preparation, to tie proponents of this ideology in knots by demanding a focus on a more meaningful definition of inclusion through acknowledgement of other oppressed groups. Be aware however, that the typical pattern seen here is for the person taking the stance they would describe as trans-inclusive to strawman arguments like this (thereby paving the way back to easy accusations of prejudice) or for them to get angry. Both types of response reflect the challenge of justifying so-called trans inclusion without, at the very least, the reasonable acknowledgement that this is favouring one group over others. This is an admission few are prepared to make, which suggests that they are aware that the next phase of the conversation – why trans women have been chosen over these other groups – is even harder for them to argue.

Catiette · Yesterday 21:04

Excuse the generalisations made above about some of these hypothetical female demographics, and be alert to the risk of being called out on those yourself, or accused of exploiting these groups in support of a transphobic cause. This is a galling response to a complex, difficult issue. Approaching discussing it in any context requires careful thought and a cool head!

GriseldaandMike · Yesterday 21:09

Oh god in the last few weeks if 2026 is anyone really trying to claim it is unladylike to be good at sport? I take it they think the Lionesses are a mens team.

Hindsight101 · Yesterday 21:41

Transperson · Yesterday 14:46

I'm suggesting that trans women are much more visible in men's toilet.

As someone explained upthread - not our problem mate.

Transperson · Yesterday 22:02

Hindsight101 · Yesterday 21:41

As someone explained upthread - not our problem mate.

Cool idc

EnjoysAGoodChat · Yesterday 22:18

Letterinmychest · Yesterday 19:35

Has the group invited you to join them, hence you needing to respond @EnjoysAGoodChat ?

Edited

I've been to the organisation's events in the past and have subsequently become a lot more awake to the importance of speaking up about my sex realist views so have arranged a conversation.

The thread went off on a bit of dance but there were excellent suggestions and links in there so I've got plenty to put together good responses for the conversation next week. Thanks again to those who helped with that.

OP posts:
EnjoysAGoodChat · Yesterday 22:27

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 14:44

Ok, not the one I was thinking of, but it will do:

https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/18973/html/

Thanks! This is really helpful.

OP posts:
EnjoysAGoodChat · Yesterday 22:37

alcovecupboards · Yesterday 16:02

Just to be clear - you're going to an already trans-inclusive organisation as a new person and trying to force them to change position? Or are you already a member? Does this organisation have any speciality that only serves biological females?

I've just asked whether I was still welcome actually, with this view (that people can't change sex and pretending they can leads to significant fallout). This question has lead to a suggested conversation and good on them for being open to that because their feelings on this are strong.

OP posts:
alcovecupboards · Yesterday 22:39

EnjoysAGoodChat · Yesterday 22:37

I've just asked whether I was still welcome actually, with this view (that people can't change sex and pretending they can leads to significant fallout). This question has lead to a suggested conversation and good on them for being open to that because their feelings on this are strong.

None of that answers the question, but yes, I have found that people who respects trans people and their identities are generally open to conversations - despite claims on here to the opposite. I'm sure you can find a happy middle ground, unless you don't wish to find one and have another agenda.

Dragonasaurus · Yesterday 22:40

Transperson · Yesterday 15:01

Being percieved as female.

Edited

Deleted for derailing

EnjoysAGoodChat · Yesterday 22:47

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · Yesterday 17:17

Here we go, point by point rebuttal to use, hope it helps.

Why a women-only group must mean female-only
Anyone can support a campaign for women’s rights. A women’s organisation exists so that women can also meet among themselves, decide what matters to them and speak in their own name. Those are different things. A man can support the first without being entitled to a seat at the second.

1. Can an organisation admit males and still be women-only?
No. Once it admits a male member, its membership is mixed-sex. It can still campaign for women. What it can no longer promise is a meeting where women decide their priorities among themselves.
The law in Great Britain is clear. Section 212 of the Equality Act 2010 defines a woman as “a female of any age”. In April 2025, the UK Supreme Court unanimously confirmed that sex in the Act means biological sex. Neither self-identification nor a Gender Recognition Certificate changes that. The Court expressly upheld women’s freedom to associate on the basis of sex. Paragraph 12.68 of the EHRC’s statutory Code gives the precise example: a women-only association may lawfully refuse a trans woman’s application because the applicant is male.

2. Does that put trans people’s safety or wellbeing at risk?
If a trans person is being threatened, the people making the threats are responsible and whoever runs that setting should act. Why should women have to give up their meeting because of somebody else’s behaviour? Women are not a shield.
Belonging matters. Being turned away can hurt. But wanting the company of a particular group does not give anyone a right to it. Nor does a female-only rule exclude the whole trans community. A trans man is female and meets the sex criterion. The same rule applies to everyone.

3. Will women be judged for short hair, trousers, looking masculine or being “too good” at sport?
A woman with a shaved head is as female as a woman in a dress. A girl who wins a race has given you a reason to congratulate her. She has given you no reason to question her sex.
That is precisely why the distinction between sex and stereotypes matters. Women qualify however they look, dress or behave. If someone tells a girl she is too strong, too fast or too masculine to be female, a women’s organisation should challenge the person saying it. Why should the girl lose her female-only group as well?

4. Doesn’t this leave any woman open to being questioned?
Look at what women’s groups actually do. FiLiA’s Women’s Assembly asks applicants to tick a box saying “I confirm that I am female” and confirm by email. Lilidots, a Scottish walking group for lesbian and bisexual women, explains who its walks are for and asks newcomers to email and answer a few joining questions. Neither published process asks for medical evidence.
The EHRC Code says that clearly explaining who a group is for will often be the main step organisers need to take. They can deal privately with a genuine concern. If a member starts interrogating another woman because she dislikes her haircut, the organiser can tell her to stop. A woman is entitled both to a female-only meeting and to turn up looking exactly as she pleases.

5. What about girls being made to undergo genetic tests, hormone tests or genital examinations?
To attend a women’s meeting? No. The American example concerns competitive school sport. It tells us nothing about how women join a walking group or attend a campaign meeting in Britain. We can read those groups’ joining instructions for ourselves.
Even in elite athletics, genetic screening can use a cheek swab. Collecting the sample takes minutes, with the laboratory result coming later. An ordinary women’s group needs neither a swab nor a genital examination. Presenting the examination of girls’ bodies as the price women must pay for meeting on their own is scaremongering.

What did the organisation promise the woman walking through its door?
It promised that she could speak among women. As Naomi Cunningham argues, she needs to be able to trust that promise before she walks in. An exception made because the organisers think nobody will notice takes that choice away from her. The committee sees the person it welcomes. Who counts the woman who quietly stays home?
She owes nobody a history of abuse, proof that a particular man is dangerous, or an explanation of why she wants the company of her own sex. If the organisation admits male members, call it mixed-sex. If it promises women a group of their own, keep it female-only.

Women have the right to say no to men. They do not need men’s agreement for that answer to stand.

Sources
Supreme Court judgment, particularly paragraphs 229–231
EHRC statutory Code, particularly paragraphs 12.68 and 13.166–13.173
FiLiA Women’s Assembly joining form
Lilidots walking group and joining arrangements
World Athletics guidance on cheek swabs and laboratory results
Naomi Cunningham, Sex, peanuts and statutory interpretation

Thanks you so much for putting that together. I have a tendency to go 'off point' if the beautiful short-lived clarity that comes with my strong morning coffee has faded. Your points are extremely helpful. I'll let you know how I go. Of course I'm not expecting any statement like, 'Oh, if only we'd thought of that!' but perhaps it will help them to understand why women need spaces that they can meet without men. I can only hope.

OP posts:
GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 22:54

Good luck OP, you'll be fine. You've had lots of constructive advice from the genuine posters on here. You seem clear about what you want to achieve, with no hidden agenda. Hope it goes well.

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 22:59

pontefractals · Yesterday 12:50

Maybe point out that you do not wish to exclude "the transgender community", just males. Transmen are (I presume and hope) fine.
Also add that the test to determine sex involves a cheek swab, not the infamous "genital examination ".
You're also not seeking to stop anyone doing anything, just requesting that they do it in the appropriate space for their immutable sex.

I don't want trans identified females in my space..Trans people need a third space imo.

EnjoysAGoodChat · Yesterday 23:00

Catiette · Yesterday 20:52

I feel sorry for OP too. Personally, OP, I would take the approach of asking them questions. It sounds as though they are very much wedded to the idea that including trans women is unambiguously, morally right. As such, if you focus on why trans women should be excluded, you risk reinforcing their preconceptions of prejudice. Instead, I would seek to expand their understanding of inclusion and moral right. This will also reinforce your good faith intentions. For example,

How do they accommodate religious and ethnic minority women who are unable to share spaces with males? Whatever answer they give is likely to provoke further questions. Perhaps they don't accommodate these women at all, in which case, what led them to prioritise trans women over other demographics - depending on the type of group, you could refer to women's difficulty integrating, risk of FGM or forced marriage etc. The suggestion that such women and their cultures are themselves close minded or sexist would be an own goal, inviting concerned questions about this perception, or an interesting discussion of how best to bring about positive integration and change.

The same question, but for victims of male violence. To pre-empt the suggestion that they reframe their trauma, as the delightful saying goes, you could briefly refer to women unable even to engage with close male relatives following assault - this is not prejudice, but a physiological response. Were they to suggest that what such women don't know won't hurt them, you could call them out on this directly – appalling! – or take the more strategic approach of asking about the potential psychological damage done, were they to find out by chance.

What about how they manage the expectations of the women in these two groups above? Do they make their trans inclusive stance explicit, and do they explain it clearly? Here, you could refer to surveys showing that a significant proportion of the British population does not understand the terms trans woman and trans man. This, of course, forces them into an ethical conundrum: do they risk denying a trans woman's existence, as contributors above suggest, by clearly defining them as a male? Or do they risk misleading equally vulnerable demographics? Conversely, perhaps they expect such women to declare their religious beliefs and sexual trauma before accessing the group?!?

It's depressingly easy, with careful preparation, to tie proponents of this ideology in knots by demanding a focus on a more meaningful definition of inclusion through acknowledgement of other oppressed groups. Be aware however, that the typical pattern seen here is for the person taking the stance they would describe as trans-inclusive to strawman arguments like this (thereby paving the way back to easy accusations of prejudice) or for them to get angry. Both types of response reflect the challenge of justifying so-called trans inclusion without, at the very least, the reasonable acknowledgement that this is favouring one group over others. This is an admission few are prepared to make, which suggests that they are aware that the next phase of the conversation – why trans women have been chosen over these other groups – is even harder for them to argue.

No need for sympathy!

I had not thought of this approach at all. I was also thinking as I read your suggestions that this place is important for many women and it would take a lot to challenge the status quo. I might ask, has anyone else ever questioned their policies? When did the policy change? What lead to that? Did anyone disagree? That kind of thing. Do they think that it would be possible for someone to question the policies without feeling awkward?

OP posts:
Kirschcherries · Yesterday 23:15

@EnjoysAGoodChat You have been given some really useful input on this thread.

One of the questions you might find useful is - Why was this group originally created for women rather than for everyone?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page