Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Help needed for a conversation

115 replies

EnjoysAGoodChat · Yesterday 12:40

Any suggestions for how to respond to a women's organisation who is willing to talk about their reasons for being 'inclusive'? I'm delighted that they are willing to talk. I just need some help for when I do have the conversation next week to argue against this position:

not being inclusive of the trans community is dangerous for trans people, in terms of their safety and well-being and for all women and girls as we all will then get policed in how we look. Short hair, trousers, too masculine, too good at sports etc. It leaves it open for all women and girls to be questioned which is not a safe space for us to be in. It is getting to a point in some states in the US where they are trying to mandate that young girls show proof of female anatomy through expensive genetic or hormone tests, or a genital exam, if they want to play sports.

OP posts:
Transperson · Yesterday 14:31

BackToLurk · Yesterday 14:28

So? You said it was because they were assaulted.

A person perceived as male going to the men's won't put a target on their back.

It does with trans women.

something2say · Yesterday 14:32

Reads to me like they have to toe the line and include trans instead of third spaces for them, to retain funding perhaps and be PC?

Transperson, you fear violence from males, yet violence from males against females is why we need safe spaces. Trans women are males so they must not be in our safe spaces.

I would pull out of this conversation tbh as they have set their stall out and you're just walking into an argument about 'is trans valid y/n....'

Shedmistress · Yesterday 14:33

I think show them this thread in a day or two about the chaos, upset and general whataboutery that a man joining in to a women's activity results in.

The whole thread and organisation will just be about him.

So they may as well just give up now.

BackToLurk · Yesterday 14:33

Transperson · Yesterday 14:31

A person perceived as male going to the men's won't put a target on their back.

It does with trans women.

Are you suggesting that gay men aren't assaulted in men-only spaces?

MoistVonL · Yesterday 14:35

for all women and girls as we all will then get policed in how we look. Short hair, trousers, too masculine, too good at sports etc. It leaves it open for all women and girls to be questioned

On the contrary, welcoming trans-identifying girls or those who identify as non-binary only broadens the visual range of how women choose to present. A butch lesbian and a transman are no less female that Ariana Grande.

Whereas, breaking the law about SSS to permit trans-identifying men into women's spaces risks the privacy, dignity and safety of women who've been subject to male violence, to women who segregate women and men for religious reasons. It also perpetuates the sexist myth that being a woman and choosing to look feminine are the same thing. They aren't.

Helleofabore · Yesterday 14:39

If using a male single sex provision is so dangerous for different groups of male people, why isn’t there a uk national campaign to make them safer for all male people?

If there was so much danger for male people who are gender non-conforming, where is the campaign to make using the male single sex provisions more welcoming for any male person?

Female people are not therapeutic or security resources for male people to utilise to make them safe or to feel better in using what should be single sex provisions. All this wheedling about safety and comfort is sparple.

If there is an issue with safety in male single sex provisions then that is where focus needs to be.

We can fill threads of male people declaring that ‘phenotypically’ are female when they really are just a variation of male people. We can fill threads of people who believe they pass who don’t pass at all when interacting with others.

Just because one male person makes an unfounded declaration doesn’t make that declaration in any way true.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 14:42

@EnjoysAGoodChat, there was a recent ET (might have been Peggie? Or Leonardo? Someone help me out?) where either Maya Forstater or Alice Sullivan (or someone!) gave expert witness testimony to show that TIMs retain male patterns of criminality and violence, even after “transition.” That might be helpful to your argument.

Let me see if I can find…

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 14:44

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 14:42

@EnjoysAGoodChat, there was a recent ET (might have been Peggie? Or Leonardo? Someone help me out?) where either Maya Forstater or Alice Sullivan (or someone!) gave expert witness testimony to show that TIMs retain male patterns of criminality and violence, even after “transition.” That might be helpful to your argument.

Let me see if I can find…

Ok, not the one I was thinking of, but it will do:

https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/18973/html/

Transperson · Yesterday 14:46

BackToLurk · Yesterday 14:33

Are you suggesting that gay men aren't assaulted in men-only spaces?

I'm suggesting that trans women are much more visible in men's toilet.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 14:47

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 14:44

Ok, not the one I was thinking of, but it will do:

https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/18973/html/

Jo Phoenix gave a v good statement covering all of this for the Darlington nurses ET:

https://sex-matters.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Expert-witness-report-by-Prof-Jo-Phoenix.pdf

https://sex-matters.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Expert-witness-report-by-Prof-Jo-Phoenix.pdf

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 14:48

Transperson · Yesterday 14:25

Gay men aren't precieved as female though.

Will you FFS stop typing it as 'preceived.' It's PER-ceived.

Transperson · Yesterday 14:48

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 14:48

Will you FFS stop typing it as 'preceived.' It's PER-ceived.

Noted

Shedmistress · Yesterday 14:50

Transperson · Yesterday 14:46

I'm suggesting that trans women are much more visible in men's toilet.

Put some trousers on then.

BackToLurk · Yesterday 14:51

Transperson · Yesterday 14:46

I'm suggesting that trans women are much more visible in men's toilet.

Visible as what?

Grammarnut · Yesterday 14:52

Transperson · Yesterday 14:25

Gay men aren't precieved as female though.

Nor are TiMs.

Helleofabore · Yesterday 14:52

Transperson · Yesterday 14:46

I'm suggesting that trans women are much more visible in men's toilet.

So is any other gender non conforming male person.

Have you got that exact list of phenotypical changes that make you female yet? Or is it just what we suspected and the sole point is ‘breast development’ which can happen to many male people for different reasons and a male breast is not a female breast?

Grammarnut · Yesterday 14:53

Transperson · Yesterday 14:19

You are turning it into trans people's problem. And individually they will do right for themselves.

It's a service providers job to enforce SSS, but they have no reasonable way of enforcing this.

In practice trans people have a choice and they won't put themselves under harms way.

What makes you think you can intrude on women who do not want you in THEIR spaces? Good men stay out so bad men stand out. You, Trasnp, are saying TiMs are bad men. Logic, sir, logic.

Transperson · Yesterday 14:54

BackToLurk · Yesterday 14:51

Visible as what?

It's a complete sentence in its own, more visible and noticeable compared to cis/trans men.

Cambridge Dictionary visible
Meaning of visible in English visible adjective
uk /ˈvɪz.ə.bəl/ us /ˈvɪz.ə.bəl/
Able to be seen:You should wear something light-coloured when you're cycling at night so that you're more visible.The writing on the tombstone was barely visible.There are few visible signs of the illness that kept her in hospital for so long.The comet should be visible to the naked eye.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 14:56

Transperson · Yesterday 14:25

Gay men aren't precieved as female though.

Actually for a long time that was exactly how gay men were seen, as "feminised" or "not real men".

Which is obviously just as sexist as the idea that a man with feelings of not being or wanting to present like other men is pretty much the same as a woman, certainly woman-enough to be included in female language, rights and spaces without any friction or questions raised about on what basis exactly is this male person being considered might-as-well-be-female?

Transperson · Yesterday 14:56

Grammarnut · Yesterday 14:53

What makes you think you can intrude on women who do not want you in THEIR spaces? Good men stay out so bad men stand out. You, Trasnp, are saying TiMs are bad men. Logic, sir, logic.

Edited

What makes you think you or anyone else has a choice over my decision to go to which bathroom.

Service providers have no realistic way of enforcing this.

Helleofabore · Yesterday 14:57

Transperson · Yesterday 14:54

It's a complete sentence in its own, more visible and noticeable compared to cis/trans men.

Cambridge Dictionary visible
Meaning of visible in English visible adjective
uk /ˈvɪz.ə.bəl/ us /ˈvɪz.ə.bəl/
Able to be seen:You should wear something light-coloured when you're cycling at night so that you're more visible.The writing on the tombstone was barely visible.There are few visible signs of the illness that kept her in hospital for so long.The comet should be visible to the naked eye.

Edited

If using a male single sex provision is so dangerous for different groups of male people, why isn’t there a uk national campaign to make them safer for all male people?

If there was so much danger for male people who are gender non-conforming, where is the campaign to make using the male single sex provisions more welcoming for any male person?

Female people are not therapeutic or security resources for male people to utilise to make them safe or to feel better in using what should be single sex provisions.

If you have a safety problem using male provisions set up for your sex category of human, please start a campaign. It was never appropriate to use the female provision.

Shedmistress · Yesterday 14:57

Transperson · Yesterday 14:54

It's a complete sentence in its own, more visible and noticeable compared to cis/trans men.

Cambridge Dictionary visible
Meaning of visible in English visible adjective
uk /ˈvɪz.ə.bəl/ us /ˈvɪz.ə.bəl/
Able to be seen:You should wear something light-coloured when you're cycling at night so that you're more visible.The writing on the tombstone was barely visible.There are few visible signs of the illness that kept her in hospital for so long.The comet should be visible to the naked eye.

Edited

So change into something less visible.

Transperson · Yesterday 14:58

Shedmistress · Yesterday 14:57

So change into something less visible.

I'm not going to detransition lmao

Helleofabore · Yesterday 14:58

Transperson · Yesterday 14:56

What makes you think you or anyone else has a choice over my decision to go to which bathroom.

Service providers have no realistic way of enforcing this.

They do.

They can ban your use of a service. An employer can take action if it is your work place.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 14:58

"You women say no but I'm going to do it anyway"

Quite the week for it, isn't it?