Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

815 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
Imdunfer · Today 18:59

Transperson · Today 16:31

Lived reality is not something people can say did or didn't happen unless they are talking about their own lived experience.

God might or might not exist but my gender identity does.

Edited

TP that's a ridiculous thing to say, sorry.

You are talking, I think, about indefinable feelings, which of course can't be said not to be true.

But if someone says that their lived experience is that they are, for example, a firefighter, when they are not then it's demonstrable that it never happened.

And it is demonstrable that you are not a woman by a non invasive DNA sample.

I would argue that it is also demonstrable that you do not feel like a woman, because you are not one and can therefore have no idea whether your feelings are how a woman feels or not.

What you do feel is the desire to live as if you were a woman. That desire I completely respect, with the exception of you using women's spaces and participating in anything designated for women only.

Comtesse · Today 19:03

caprioska · Today 06:08

Your analogy is irrelevant because no one is suggesting reproductive sex doesn't exist because 'assigned' is used. Its just a technically accurate description of what actually happens in most cases: sex is assumed & recorded based on an assumption that's just a surface level observation.

Deal.

How about ultrasounds? I don’t think they are “surface level observations”. The sonographers can typically observe the baby’s sex at the 20 week scan.

BlueLegume · Today 19:08

Comtesse · Today 19:03

How about ultrasounds? I don’t think they are “surface level observations”. The sonographers can typically observe the baby’s sex at the 20 week scan.

@caprioska so thousands of sonographers are trained to look at a 20 weeks scan and if they see a penis they say ‘it’s a boy’.

caprioska · Today 06:08
Your analogy is irrelevant because no one is suggesting reproductive sex doesn't exist because 'assigned' is used. Its just a technically accurate description of what actually happens in most cases: sex is assumed & recorded based on an assumption that's just a surface level observation.

If I decide getting into an intimate situation with someone and they have a penis I will realise they are a man - because I can observe at a surface level he has a penis. If I was a lesbian and reject said penis what is your view on my reaction.

I have word saladed and use vervbal gymnastics because you do. Honestly the nonsense is beyond parody now.

Why are the NHS even training sonographers if you believe they are doing a ‘surface level observation?’

caprioska · Today 20:38

FlorbelaEspanca · Today 15:00

They are different. As Popper observed, "God exists" is a statement that could be true, but because in principle it cannot be refuted it lies outside the remit of science. The sex of mammals lies very much within the realm of science. Show me one mammal that has changed sex: then, and only then, will I cease to believe that they cannot. And this is a matter of biochemistry: putting on a frock and changing your name does not count.

🥱
Sex & gender aren’t the same thing….

caprioska · Today 20:41

Comtesse · Today 19:03

How about ultrasounds? I don’t think they are “surface level observations”. The sonographers can typically observe the baby’s sex at the 20 week scan.

🥱 Ultrasounds don't do chromosomes or gametes.

TheHereticalOne · Today 20:50

caprioska · Today 20:38

🥱
Sex & gender aren’t the same thing….

Great. Agreed. Then I ask again, why should someone's gender identity have any impact whatsoever on determining which sex category they belong in for the purpose of single sex services?

Imdunfer · Today 20:53

caprioska · Today 20:38

🥱
Sex & gender aren’t the same thing….

We all agree on that, you don't need to keep writing it again and again. You have changed your gender presentation. We all agree you cannot change your sex and although you now present as a woman, you aren't one.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · Today 20:55

caprioska · Today 20:41

🥱 Ultrasounds don't do chromosomes or gametes.

"Sex & gender aren't the same thing ..."

I agree, so why do you thing chromosomes and gametes have any relevance to the determination of gender? There may (or may not) be some correlation, but they are different concepts and the social constructs are not intrinsically required to have any correlation with sex, as you cannot change sex, and your personality can be any personality.

caprioska · Today 21:00

TheHereticalOne · Today 20:50

Great. Agreed. Then I ask again, why should someone's gender identity have any impact whatsoever on determining which sex category they belong in for the purpose of single sex services?

Already answered this upthread:

"Because our legal system allows spaces to be contested based on not being justifiably designated to the opposite sex."

BlueLegume · Today 21:00

I’m so close to asking if the gender vs sex thing are people in the first camp who actually do not or have not ever actually had sex or intimacy. Not being cruel or bigoted.

Some comments just sound so immature akin to kids not liking what someone said at school and claiming ‘you are bullying me’.

caprioska · Today 21:02

Imdunfer · Today 20:53

We all agree on that, you don't need to keep writing it again and again. You have changed your gender presentation. We all agree you cannot change your sex and although you now present as a woman, you aren't one.

But you don't all agree on that because you keep bringing up sex when the context is gender. And as I already said this is often wilfully done as a means to deny identities because of competing rights.

caprioska · Today 21:05

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · Today 20:55

"Sex & gender aren't the same thing ..."

I agree, so why do you thing chromosomes and gametes have any relevance to the determination of gender? There may (or may not) be some correlation, but they are different concepts and the social constructs are not intrinsically required to have any correlation with sex, as you cannot change sex, and your personality can be any personality.

I never said chromosomes or gametes determine gender.

StealthTroublemaker · Today 21:10

caprioska · Today 21:02

But you don't all agree on that because you keep bringing up sex when the context is gender. And as I already said this is often wilfully done as a means to deny identities because of competing rights.

So what you are suggesting is all spaces are mixed sex but single gender? But if gender differs from person to person depending on their definitions of what gender means to them, how can anyone determine which spaces they should use? We’d need working definitions of gender. Or are you suggesting all spaces are just mixed sex mixed gender?

StealthTroublemaker · Today 21:10

caprioska · Today 21:05

I never said chromosomes or gametes determine gender.

So what does then?

caprioska · Today 21:13

StealthTroublemaker · Today 21:10

So what you are suggesting is all spaces are mixed sex but single gender? But if gender differs from person to person depending on their definitions of what gender means to them, how can anyone determine which spaces they should use? We’d need working definitions of gender. Or are you suggesting all spaces are just mixed sex mixed gender?

?
Sorry but this isn't reflect of anything I have said.

Imdunfer · Today 21:13

caprioska · Today 21:02

But you don't all agree on that because you keep bringing up sex when the context is gender. And as I already said this is often wilfully done as a means to deny identities because of competing rights.

Well that's what happens when you try to claim sex based rights on the basis of the gender you present as. That's you confusing sex and gender, not us.

caprioska · Today 21:15

StealthTroublemaker · Today 21:10

So what does then?

Socially? Typical associations to sex.
Personally? Individual traits, values, beliefs & social construction.

StealthTroublemaker · Today 21:15

caprioska · Today 21:13

?
Sorry but this isn't reflect of anything I have said.

Yes it does. You’re the one claiming sex is complicated….. I suppose it would be for those people who don’t get out much….

BlueLegume · Today 21:17

caprioska · Today 21:02

But you don't all agree on that because you keep bringing up sex when the context is gender. And as I already said this is often wilfully done as a means to deny identities because of competing rights.

Gender is a made up thing @caprioska we are all the sex we were born into.

If you are a man who thinks they are and wants to dress as a woman, fine. You will still have a prostate. When as you age, that becomes an issue you will require male healthcare. What if laws change in your favour and once you declare you are a ‘woman’ you lose male healthcare such as prostate care

If you are a woman who thinks they are a man as above. Will you accept you may get ovarian or cervical cancer?

caprioska · Today 21:23

Imdunfer · Today 21:13

Well that's what happens when you try to claim sex based rights on the basis of the gender you present as. That's you confusing sex and gender, not us.

Edited

You aren't listening. 'Sex based rights' (an exemption from anti discrimination law) aren't a given. Exclusion needs to be justified via the criteria for special exemptions.

In other words natal males can challenge an exemption if it its not legally justified. & this is irrelevant to gender identification.

It's you who are confusing gender identification as being the barrier to 'sex based rights' when the barrier is lack of justification.

kitex · Today 21:25

@caprioska Sex matters more than gender. Gender is a made up construct. I agree with @BlueLegume

Perenelle · Today 21:25

caprioska · Today 21:15

Socially? Typical associations to sex.
Personally? Individual traits, values, beliefs & social construction.

Actually, I think I might agree in this point, that “gender” is a kind of social construct.

The question is, why does this social or individual gender should affect areas in ones life or society where physical or bodily state aka sex is relevant?

caprioska · Today 21:28

BlueLegume · Today 21:17

Gender is a made up thing @caprioska we are all the sex we were born into.

If you are a man who thinks they are and wants to dress as a woman, fine. You will still have a prostate. When as you age, that becomes an issue you will require male healthcare. What if laws change in your favour and once you declare you are a ‘woman’ you lose male healthcare such as prostate care

If you are a woman who thinks they are a man as above. Will you accept you may get ovarian or cervical cancer?

Social construction of gender categories is a widely accepted interpretation of social structures that's agreed to by gender critical feminists.

kitex · Today 21:28

caprioska · Today 21:23

You aren't listening. 'Sex based rights' (an exemption from anti discrimination law) aren't a given. Exclusion needs to be justified via the criteria for special exemptions.

In other words natal males can challenge an exemption if it its not legally justified. & this is irrelevant to gender identification.

It's you who are confusing gender identification as being the barrier to 'sex based rights' when the barrier is lack of justification.

“lack of justification.”

Are you kidding me!!! There is plenty of justification.

caprioska · Today 21:30

kitex · Today 21:25

@caprioska Sex matters more than gender. Gender is a made up construct. I agree with @BlueLegume

Good for you! As I said, individuals have & are entitled to their own subjective personal interpretations of the world however illogical some of us think it to be. See. Religion.