Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

825 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
caprioska · Today 00:09

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · Yesterday 22:53

Only in gender identity circles and very conservative circles do 'woman' and 'man' have socially constructed sex stereotypes "attached". The rest of us recognise that 'feminine' men are just as much men as 'masculine' men, and 'masculine' women are just as much women as 'feminine' women. DW, for example, doesn't wear makeup (thank God) and isn't obsessed with removing body hair, and is a better plumber than I am. Those characteristics don't mean she is 'manly'.

Two other points:–

The personality traits and choices that are referred to as gender (as in conventionally feminine and masculine) are far more complex than a straight line from ultra masculine to ultra feminine, with everyone somewhere on that line. In any given society, some things are stereotypically associated with women and some with men, but they change over time, place, social category etc. For example, if you were to compare how men are expected to dress in a typical Church of England church (casual) with how men are expected to dress in a typical Mormon church in Utah (formal), you would see quite a difference.

And if 'non-binary' is purely a gender term, then many of us are non-binary. I certainly am, as I don't match the masculine stereotypes of UK cultures in every respect and have been known to have long hair (it was fashionable in my youth). I am also not as aggressive as men are 'supposed' to be in the UK; aggression was to some extent socialised out of me. So if a man squares up to me, I'm not spoiling for a physical fight; I have no desire to fight anyone. And yet, 'non-binary' is not clearly defined, and is not a word which is used to describe someone like me in the social circles I feel most at home in. In fact, I don't see any need at all for such a description, it just means normal people who are not slavish followers of cultural expectations for men and women. Similar to normal people who are not fashion victims.

Only in gender identity circles and very conservative circles do 'woman' and 'man' have socially constructed sex stereotypes "attached". The rest of us recognise that 'feminine' men are just as much men as 'masculine' men, and 'masculine' women are just as much women as 'feminine' women. DW, for example, doesn't wear makeup (thank God) and isn't obsessed with removing body hair, and is a better plumber than I am. Those characteristics don't mean she is 'manly'.

Whether people recognise that socially constructed gender categories exist doesn't change that they do. A thing that even gender critical feminists acknowledge by virtue of being gender critical of trans people supposedly perpetuating sex stereotypes.

The personality traits and choices that are referred to as gender (as in conventionally feminine and masculine) are far more complex than a straight line from ultra masculine to ultra feminine, with everyone somewhere on that line. In any given society, some things are stereotypically associated with women and some with men, but they change over time, place, social category etc. For example, if you were to compare how men are expected to dress in a typical Church of England church (casual) with how men are expected to dress in a typical Mormon church in Utah (formal), you would see quite a difference.

But gendered associations still exist being the point.

And if 'non-binary' is purely a gender term, then many of us are non-binary. I certainly am, as I don't match the masculine stereotypes of UK cultures in every respect and have been known to have long hair (it was fashionable in my youth). I am also not as aggressive as men are 'supposed' to be in the UK; aggression was to some extent socialised out of me. So if a man squares up to me, I'm not spoiling for a physical fight; I have no desire to fight anyone. And yet, 'non-binary' is not clearly defined, and is not a word which is used to describe someone like me in the social circles I feel most at home in. In fact, I don't see any need at all for such a description, it just means normal people who are not slavish followers of cultural expectations for men and women. Similar to normal people who are not fashion victims.

Describing a phenomenon isn't an imposition of it as a self descriptor but I think its always helpful to have more clear language of it. If its a genderless society gender critical feminists are aiming for (one that I don't think is entirely possible given evolutionary pressures) then I don't see why this is so problematic other than for those who want to maintain associations to sex stereotypes that are entrenched in the words 'man' 'woman'.

inkymoose · Today 00:34

So ... how does it feel to be "gender critical"?

I'm afraid I don't like the term "gender critical". I can't really understand why such a term is used. It's difficult to understand what it actually means, there doesn't seem to be an agreed definition, and even if there was it seems to me it would just be playing into the hands of academic windbags and their leaden followers to describe oneself as gender critical.

So, as I don't accept the premise, it's difficult to describe how such a condition makes me feel. However, I've heard a lot of stupid rubbish in my time, spouted by fervent adherers to one kind of cultish belief or another. This is no different. It's a fad and it will pass. I feel relieved that the Supreme Court clarified that reference to a woman in law refers to a biological female (as if this should've been necessary!) so that's something.

I guess I feel a bit angry about it, about the need to represent myself as belonging to this gender critical group. Perhaps I should just give in and accept it. Or better still, let it go.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Today 04:35

caprioska · Yesterday 20:23

Maybe google the history of conservatism for the details.

Oh, it's the italiciser again.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Today 04:37

caprioska · Yesterday 20:19

If you think english royalty & their aristocracy have any salience in Australia I have news.

Australia is a country of immigrants with over half the Australian population being of a non english speaking back ground from races & ethnicities from all over the world. Not to mention our laws haven't permitted discrimination or hate speech for decades so a 'race' hierarchy is a bit of a tricky sell.

Neither have British laws. And we never had a White Britain policy either. "White Australia" ring a bell?

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Today 04:42

caprioska · Yesterday 20:37

Two clicks….

"Gender refers to the socially constructed norms, behaviours , expressions, and psychological roles that a given society associates with being a man, woman, boy, or girl, as well as identities beyond a strict binary."

So, you mean the regressive limiting expectations that are routinely weaponised against autistic women to other and exclude us, then?

There's a reason why so many children attending the Tavi were autistic.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Today 04:55

caprioska · Yesterday 21:26

No just the opposite. Non binary identity provides the solution from sex stereotypes that gender critical feminists claimed is the problem. Except sex stereotypes were not their real problem because they don't accept this logical conclusion to it. Its something else….👀

The problem is male supremacy over women, motivated by men's desire to own and control our bodies and enacted through force.

Sex stereotypes are part of patriarchy's propaganda machine, but they aren't the root problem. Individuals opting out of the performance doesn't end male supremacy and women opting out aren't any safer than those who don't.

Claiming to be non-binary is rather like foxes and hens both claiming to be cats: neither can change their nature and the foxes will remain a hazard to the hens.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Today 05:02

OldCrone · Yesterday 21:33

Non binary identity provides the solution from sex stereotypes

How do you come to that conclusion? If you want to get away from gender stereotyping, the solution is to say that you can be a woman (or man) with any personality.

Pretending that you're not a woman (or man) because you don't like the stereotypes which have been imposed on your sex is just another way of reinforcing the stereotypes. It's saying that the stereotypes are so important and so unchangeable that the only way to avoid them is to pretend you don't have a sex or that you're not the sex you are.

It really isn't logical at all. Is this an example of trans logic - something that pretends to be logic but isn't?

Summary of non-binary stance: "The masculine and feminine boxes still exist, and everyone else is expected to stay in them, but I want to be special so I'm making a third box just for me."

And this self-indulgent pompous ego-wanking is given the same legal protection as disabled people in some jurisdictions. Madness.

StealthTroublemaker · Today 05:07

caprioska · Yesterday 23:54

You conveniently forget the non binary button.

Whether you like it or not the the concepts of 'man' & 'woman'
are socially associated to typical behaviours & roles that despite women doing and presenting in a wide variety of ways in modernity still persists & that's because typical behaviours persist that are evolutionarily hard wired. So unless the nature of man changes neither will social associations.

Nope. You are wrong. Hope this helps. Well done on showing the inadequacies of the Australian educational system though. Now, about your feelings on being gender critical?

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Today 05:09

caprioska · Yesterday 21:36

Putting words to an already existing phenomena is hardly 'inventing' anything. If anything it supports it being socially accepted.

Its almost as if gender critical feminists don't want to deviate from traditional cultural beliefs…conservatism anyone?

The lack of words indicates acceptance.

The norm only ever gets labelled post-facto, if at all. Outliers are labelled immediately. We've had words for disabled people (some not very nice) for centuries, yet we still struggle to find natural-sounding terms for people who are not disabled. People who are not disabled have always been the accepted norm, with disabled people being the outliers even now, despite decades of civil rights progress.

Example: the term autism is around 100 years old. Neurotypical has been in common use for a decade at most.
Examples: what are the single word adjectives for people who don't have diabetes, epilepsy, or asthma? There aren't any. The people with those conditions are described as diabetic, epileptic, or asthmatic respectively.

StealthTroublemaker · Today 05:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Today 05:37

caprioska · Yesterday 23:56

After sex traits are 'observed' the individual is assigned to a sex category.

There, fixed it for you.

If a tree falls in a forest with no one to hear it, does it make a sound?

Pseudo-intellectual wankers: Well, it depends on how you define "sound", and has the tree even fallen if there is no one to witness its performance of falling?

The rest of us: Of course it bloody makes a sound. The laws of physics exist and function with or without an audience.

--

If a baby is born in the forest with no midwife to examine it, does it magically lack a sex because no one assigned it one?

Pseudo-intellectual wankers: Well, it depends on how you define "sex", and there's vanishingly-rare disorders, and also clownfish.

The rest of us: Of course it bloody does. The laws of developmental biology exist with or without an audience.

Just as Schrödinger's Cat was one of two binary states, alive or dead, even if the box stopped the observer from seeing which, so Schrödinger's Baby is one of male or female, even if a rare disorder is present. Puberty doesn't need an audience, just as the propogation of sound doesn't. The forest baby, even if raised by wolves without ever meeting a human, will mature down a preordained, sexed, developmental pathway.

-

That, rarely, midwives are mistaken as to the sex of a newborn, does not mean that they are "assigning" sex. They are still observing it. If I misread a piece of sheet music when preparing a transposed part, that doesn't mean that I'm "assigning" pitches, it just means that my observations have a margin of error.

caprioska · Today 06:08

Your analogy is irrelevant because no one is suggesting reproductive sex doesn't exist because 'assigned' is used. Its just a technically accurate description of what actually happens in most cases: sex is assumed & recorded based on an assumption that's just a surface level observation.

Deal.

ByPearlExpert · Today 06:22

StealthTroublemaker · For me, this is what people mean by saying gender criticals are conservatives: they're characterised by black-and-white thinking; instinctive dismissiveness of anything that challenges their worldview; a deep-seated fear and paranoia of anyone who isn't exactly like them; a lack of empathy; an inability to understand that other people might have different experiences, perspectives, or needs from them; and generally they're just incredibly arrogant, condescending, selfish, and uncaring about anyone but themselves.

StealthTroublemaker · Today 06:39

ByPearlExpert · Today 06:22

StealthTroublemaker · For me, this is what people mean by saying gender criticals are conservatives: they're characterised by black-and-white thinking; instinctive dismissiveness of anything that challenges their worldview; a deep-seated fear and paranoia of anyone who isn't exactly like them; a lack of empathy; an inability to understand that other people might have different experiences, perspectives, or needs from them; and generally they're just incredibly arrogant, condescending, selfish, and uncaring about anyone but themselves.

Edited

That’s nice dear. In that case transpeople should definitely use the spaces relevant to their sexes. Don’t want to meet any nasty GC people do they?

StealthTroublemaker · Today 06:40

caprioska · Today 06:08

Your analogy is irrelevant because no one is suggesting reproductive sex doesn't exist because 'assigned' is used. Its just a technically accurate description of what actually happens in most cases: sex is assumed & recorded based on an assumption that's just a surface level observation.

Deal.

Bless you for. trying. Have a participation trophy. 🏆

Shedmistress · Today 07:04

ByPearlExpert · Today 06:22

StealthTroublemaker · For me, this is what people mean by saying gender criticals are conservatives: they're characterised by black-and-white thinking; instinctive dismissiveness of anything that challenges their worldview; a deep-seated fear and paranoia of anyone who isn't exactly like them; a lack of empathy; an inability to understand that other people might have different experiences, perspectives, or needs from them; and generally they're just incredibly arrogant, condescending, selfish, and uncaring about anyone but themselves.

Edited

You missed out 'meanie poo poo heads'.

Do better.

caprioska · Today 07:05

StealthTroublemaker · Today 06:40

Bless you for. trying. Have a participation trophy. 🏆

Anyone know what happened to @seethlaw? 🤔

Perenelle · Today 07:37

ByPearlExpert · Today 06:22

StealthTroublemaker · For me, this is what people mean by saying gender criticals are conservatives: they're characterised by black-and-white thinking; instinctive dismissiveness of anything that challenges their worldview; a deep-seated fear and paranoia of anyone who isn't exactly like them; a lack of empathy; an inability to understand that other people might have different experiences, perspectives, or needs from them; and generally they're just incredibly arrogant, condescending, selfish, and uncaring about anyone but themselves.

Edited

Every accusation is a confession.

StealthTroublemaker · Today 07:39

caprioska · Today 07:05

Anyone know what happened to @seethlaw? 🤔

Who is Seethlaw and why should I care?

caprioska · Today 07:48

StealthTroublemaker · Today 07:39

Who is Seethlaw and why should I care?

😂

nutmeg7 · Today 07:56

I think I have the answer!

Some people don’t understand the meaning of “assigned”.

It carries the sense of being allocated somewhat arbitrarily.

Of course, there might be those who don’t understand what “allocated” or “arbitrarily” means.

Heggettypeg · Today 08:02

ByPearlExpert · Today 06:22

StealthTroublemaker · For me, this is what people mean by saying gender criticals are conservatives: they're characterised by black-and-white thinking; instinctive dismissiveness of anything that challenges their worldview; a deep-seated fear and paranoia of anyone who isn't exactly like them; a lack of empathy; an inability to understand that other people might have different experiences, perspectives, or needs from them; and generally they're just incredibly arrogant, condescending, selfish, and uncaring about anyone but themselves.

Edited

An excellent description of the kind of trans identifying male who insists on shoving himself into women's spaces whether he is welcome there or not. And insists that women mustn't stay out, or leave, if he is there.

And of the kind of transactivist who screams "Transwomen are women. No debate!" and tries to get people sacked for believing that sex is real and matters in certain situations and calls them bigots and far right for understanding reality

And the trans ally who told lesbians that they are "sexual racists" if they won't do dick.

And the transwoman who told rape victims to "reframe their trauma" and his handmaidens who refused to offer those victims same sex services or even to tell them that same sex services were available elsewhere in the same city.

And the transactivist brats who (ab)used live insects to disrupt a meeting.

And the transwoman who defined woman as "an expectant asshole... blank blank eyes" and said that sissy porn made him trans.

Google "terfisaslur" for an interesting insight into the flexible thinking and compassion shown by your own side.

Lovely, lovely people. So much nicer than those horrid TERFs.

Imdunfer · Today 08:08

ByPearlExpert · Today 06:22

StealthTroublemaker · For me, this is what people mean by saying gender criticals are conservatives: they're characterised by black-and-white thinking; instinctive dismissiveness of anything that challenges their worldview; a deep-seated fear and paranoia of anyone who isn't exactly like them; a lack of empathy; an inability to understand that other people might have different experiences, perspectives, or needs from them; and generally they're just incredibly arrogant, condescending, selfish, and uncaring about anyone but themselves.

Edited

What wonderful stereotyping of a hugely diverse group of people commonly called "the majority" in the UK.

Imdunfer · Today 08:11

Heggettypeg · Today 08:02

An excellent description of the kind of trans identifying male who insists on shoving himself into women's spaces whether he is welcome there or not. And insists that women mustn't stay out, or leave, if he is there.

And of the kind of transactivist who screams "Transwomen are women. No debate!" and tries to get people sacked for believing that sex is real and matters in certain situations and calls them bigots and far right for understanding reality

And the trans ally who told lesbians that they are "sexual racists" if they won't do dick.

And the transwoman who told rape victims to "reframe their trauma" and his handmaidens who refused to offer those victims same sex services or even to tell them that same sex services were available elsewhere in the same city.

And the transactivist brats who (ab)used live insects to disrupt a meeting.

And the transwoman who defined woman as "an expectant asshole... blank blank eyes" and said that sissy porn made him trans.

Google "terfisaslur" for an interesting insight into the flexible thinking and compassion shown by your own side.

Lovely, lovely people. So much nicer than those horrid TERFs.

You forgot the German lawyer who wrote to the 15 year old victim of a convicted trans man demanding to know what she meant by misgendering his client as "he" during the trial.

Heggettypeg · Today 08:43

Imdunfer · Today 08:11

You forgot the German lawyer who wrote to the 15 year old victim of a convicted trans man demanding to know what she meant by misgendering his client as "he" during the trial.

I did. It was by no means an exhaustive list, unfortunately!