Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

841 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
RapidOnsetGenderCritic · Today 09:50

caprioska · Today 00:09

Only in gender identity circles and very conservative circles do 'woman' and 'man' have socially constructed sex stereotypes "attached". The rest of us recognise that 'feminine' men are just as much men as 'masculine' men, and 'masculine' women are just as much women as 'feminine' women. DW, for example, doesn't wear makeup (thank God) and isn't obsessed with removing body hair, and is a better plumber than I am. Those characteristics don't mean she is 'manly'.

Whether people recognise that socially constructed gender categories exist doesn't change that they do. A thing that even gender critical feminists acknowledge by virtue of being gender critical of trans people supposedly perpetuating sex stereotypes.

The personality traits and choices that are referred to as gender (as in conventionally feminine and masculine) are far more complex than a straight line from ultra masculine to ultra feminine, with everyone somewhere on that line. In any given society, some things are stereotypically associated with women and some with men, but they change over time, place, social category etc. For example, if you were to compare how men are expected to dress in a typical Church of England church (casual) with how men are expected to dress in a typical Mormon church in Utah (formal), you would see quite a difference.

But gendered associations still exist being the point.

And if 'non-binary' is purely a gender term, then many of us are non-binary. I certainly am, as I don't match the masculine stereotypes of UK cultures in every respect and have been known to have long hair (it was fashionable in my youth). I am also not as aggressive as men are 'supposed' to be in the UK; aggression was to some extent socialised out of me. So if a man squares up to me, I'm not spoiling for a physical fight; I have no desire to fight anyone. And yet, 'non-binary' is not clearly defined, and is not a word which is used to describe someone like me in the social circles I feel most at home in. In fact, I don't see any need at all for such a description, it just means normal people who are not slavish followers of cultural expectations for men and women. Similar to normal people who are not fashion victims.

Describing a phenomenon isn't an imposition of it as a self descriptor but I think its always helpful to have more clear language of it. If its a genderless society gender critical feminists are aiming for (one that I don't think is entirely possible given evolutionary pressures) then I don't see why this is so problematic other than for those who want to maintain associations to sex stereotypes that are entrenched in the words 'man' 'woman'.

I don't see 'gender' in terms of 'gender categories', and I'm not convinced it's helpful to do so. It is obvious that stereotypes exist, and that some people try to fit them. Most people don't put much effort into that for themselves. Those who do come in two main groupings: (a) those who try to be masculine men or feminine women, and (b) those who rebel against the stereotyping by trying to fit the other stereotype. I think it is healthiest to ignore the stereotypes as much as possible (we are all socially influenced) and allow our personalities some freedom from what other people expect of us. I appreciate strong women who don't make themselves invisible when there's conflict, who stand up for themselves and their principles, but I'm not impressed if they take on the worst stereotypes of men and behave in domineering and aggressive ways.

One of the issues with transgender identity thinking is that it entrenches stereotypes. I have more respect for those trans people who don't imitate the opposite sex than for those who do.

Imdunfer · Today 10:07

Imdunfer · Today 08:11

You forgot the German lawyer who wrote to the 15 year old victim of a convicted trans man demanding to know what she meant by misgendering his client as "he" during the trial.

I should have included this was a victim of rape.

Imdunfer · Today 10:12

Heggettypeg · Today 08:43

I did. It was by no means an exhaustive list, unfortunately!

Yes it's very sad, isn't it? I only added it because it is so utterly disgusting and I don't know how German politicians who created laws which allowed it to happen can look women in the eye.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · Today 10:39

I suppose that, having contributed to a derail as usual (I don't seem to be able to resist!), I should try to answer the original question.

The definition of Gender Critical that makes most sense to me is "critical of the imposition of gender stereotypes". On that basis I am gender critical, and that feels reasonable. It seems that in UK law, the definition is "believes that sex is real, unchangeable, binary, and is essential to each sex's dignity and safety in some circumstances". Though I agree with all that, because it is demonstrable, I think 'sex realist" is a better term to describe that, and sex realist does not imply gender critical as defined above. It feels rational and defensible.

I feel frustrated, angry that people are being led and sometimes coerced into a damaging worldview that appears to me to be unnecessary and controlling, that polices everyone's behaviour and language, and depends on stereotypes that are sometimes unhealthy. This belief that if you don't fit typical male behaviour patterns well enough, you are really a woman, and that if you struggle with the reality of being a woman you can reinvent yourself as a man is so **ing regressive and nonsensical, especially when taken to the extreme of body modification.

I feel determined to tell my story as an example of how damaging gender identity ideas are to ordinary loving families (trans people are not the only ones who feel marginalised and battered). I feel determined to argue for an understanding of sex and gender that doesn't promise the impossible (changing sex) but does permit people not to conform to rigid expectations of behaviour that don't have good societal reasons.

We do have behavioural expectations for the general good – it's not considered acceptable to kill someone except in very limited circumstances; the exact limits of that are debated, and set out in law which is open to a degree of interpretation. So it is with gender expectations. We should have debate between the three main positions: conservative, gender identity, "gender critical" or "sex realist". It doesn't help when people don't understand the commonalities and differences between each of these. Sex realist can apply to both conservative and gender critical.

lcakethereforeIam · Today 10:55

I don't personally feel 'gender critical'. I just feel like me, no different than I did before a chunk of the world (some of which posts on MN) lost its marbles. I used to argue with, judge, roll my eyes or whatever with people who were wrong or spouting nonsense depending on the subject or the circumstances. This now encompasses the aforesaid chunk. I also try to have empathy in some cases, when they believe they're 'being kind' or are genuinely vulnerable, arguably even victims. I've no time for people in positions of authority who push this rubbish. They, to reach these positions, I would presume are reasonably intelligent and know they're talking crap. Instead they're doing harm for, as far as I can see, no honourable reason.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Today 11:33

I note with amusement that after I pointed out the error, our antipodean friend is capable of learning and used "phenomenon" as the singular of phenomena further down the thread. Three out of five for effort; well done!

AND the information that sex and gender are not the same thing has percolated. Unfortunately s/he seems to have got them the wrong way round, but it's a start.

Tears0fTheMushroom · Today 14:18

Oh to have the confidence of a mediocre man like CapriTwobeeKoolforNorthernIcelandicGretelChoppingBaileyGoodnewsHowse...

Every post he makes is a perfect illustration of this saying.

He's completely ignorant of what he does not understand and yet he manages to be rude and condescending in his ignorance.

Just like every mid-wit mansplainer I've ever come across.
Although it can be amusing, sometimes I do wish he'd just bugger off and stop trying to bore us all into a coma.

FlorbelaEspanca · Today 15:00

caprioska · 12/11/2026 07:37

There is no such thing as

You could say the same about belief in god & yet people base their whole identities around it. This is no different.

They are different. As Popper observed, "God exists" is a statement that could be true, but because in principle it cannot be refuted it lies outside the remit of science. The sex of mammals lies very much within the realm of science. Show me one mammal that has changed sex: then, and only then, will I cease to believe that they cannot. And this is a matter of biochemistry: putting on a frock and changing your name does not count.

DeanElderberry · Today 15:32

FlorbelaEspanca · Today 15:00

They are different. As Popper observed, "God exists" is a statement that could be true, but because in principle it cannot be refuted it lies outside the remit of science. The sex of mammals lies very much within the realm of science. Show me one mammal that has changed sex: then, and only then, will I cease to believe that they cannot. And this is a matter of biochemistry: putting on a frock and changing your name does not count.

Sex exists and is scientifically demonstrable, but gender is a (very recent) theoretical product of the imagination and does not exist in a scientifically provable way.

I believe in God but am a gender atheist.

Transperson · Today 16:30

DeanElderberry · Today 15:32

Sex exists and is scientifically demonstrable, but gender is a (very recent) theoretical product of the imagination and does not exist in a scientifically provable way.

I believe in God but am a gender atheist.

Hormones influence your phenotypic sex.
To a large degree you can influence it.

Transperson · Today 16:31

FlorbelaEspanca · Today 15:00

They are different. As Popper observed, "God exists" is a statement that could be true, but because in principle it cannot be refuted it lies outside the remit of science. The sex of mammals lies very much within the realm of science. Show me one mammal that has changed sex: then, and only then, will I cease to believe that they cannot. And this is a matter of biochemistry: putting on a frock and changing your name does not count.

Lived reality is not something people can say did or didn't happen unless they are talking about their own lived experience.

God might or might not exist but my gender identity does.

HousePlantEmergency · Today 16:31

caprioska · Yesterday 21:53

Genetic & gametal tests aren't usually tested for at birth so yeah it kinda is.

Jesus, this kid 😂😂

A uterus can be seen at a standard 20 week scan, along with genitalia. By this stage, a penis and a dome-shaped scrotal sac are also clearly visible between the legs.

Nothing is "assigned". WE CAN SEE IT.
As can highly qualified sonographers.

To quote the great Alf Stewart: You're acting like a pork chop.

BlueLegume · Today 16:34

Transperson · Today 16:30

Hormones influence your phenotypic sex.
To a large degree you can influence it.

Do ‘try & keep up’ @Transperson
Phenotype was last weeks buzzword we are onto ‘passing’s this week. As I say ‘do try & keep up’.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · Today 16:50

Transperson · Today 16:30

Hormones influence your phenotypic sex.
To a large degree you can influence it.

"Phenotypic sex" isn't a very meaningful concept. One's phenotype is a product of one's sex, not sex itself. Sex is reproductive role, as in the (potential) production of one or other of the two gametes. Reproduction is the underlying purpose that in many species has resulted in the two sexes that occur in all mammals and many other species. So gamete type defines the two sexes, and phenotype is the visible signs of the underlying sex.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 16:56

Transperson · Today 16:31

Lived reality is not something people can say did or didn't happen unless they are talking about their own lived experience.

God might or might not exist but my gender identity does.

Edited

I agree. You have never lived as a girl or woman.

BlueLegume · Today 17:01

Can we say I have a ‘financial’ identity and identify as a billionaire @Transperson if not why not?

StealthTroublemaker · Today 17:02

Transperson · Today 16:30

Hormones influence your phenotypic sex.
To a large degree you can influence it.

No dude. Growing moobs and getting smoother skin are not changing sex. Otherwise half the men on beaches in the summer would be classed as women. Why is it always about the moobs.

StealthTroublemaker · Today 17:03

Transperson · Today 16:31

Lived reality is not something people can say did or didn't happen unless they are talking about their own lived experience.

God might or might not exist but my gender identity does.

Edited

only in your head dude. Only in your head.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Today 17:32

For me, this is what people mean by saying gender criticals are conservatives: they're characterised by black-and-white thinking; instinctive dismissiveness of anything that challenges their worldview; a deep-seated fear and paranoia of anyone who isn't exactly like them; a lack of empathy; an inability to understand that other people might have different experiences, perspectives, or needs from them;

AT LAST. The definition of GCs I was asking for yesterday! I'm surprised caprioska couldn't produce that list, sounds like the vocab of disapproval and moral superiority over GCs is right up his/her street.

That's a comprehensive list of mental defects, are you SURE you're not projecting a tad?

and generally they're just incredibly arrogant, condescending, selfish, and uncaring about anyone but themselves.

Bugger it, that's the third irony meter that's exploded this week, and still only Tuesday.

FanOfGailDines · Today 17:52

DeanElderberry · Today 15:32

Sex exists and is scientifically demonstrable, but gender is a (very recent) theoretical product of the imagination and does not exist in a scientifically provable way.

I believe in God but am a gender atheist.

Me too.

DeanElderberry · Today 18:04

StealthTroublemaker · Today 17:03

only in your head dude. Only in your head.

Yes. also, ultimately, God only exists in my head. okay, also in the heads of other believers and in their writings.

Not scientifically provable, and attempts to 'prove the existence of God' can never work, because God is a matter of belief. Which doesn't stop God from being important, or even true, but true and factual are very different things.

GriseldaandMike · Today 18:29

Transperson · Today 16:30

Hormones influence your phenotypic sex.
To a large degree you can influence it.

Having long hair and boobs doesn't make you a woman- it's not what makes a woman a woman. If a woman has a double mastectomy and a shaven head thank to cancer she is still a woman.

The phenotypic differences between men and women are numerous and having one or two altered by cross sex hormones doesn't alter either a person's sex or in the majority of cases other people's perception of their sex. The fact the women in front of you in a queue (who therefore can not see you) or behind you in a queue (and therefore can only see your back) don't call you out as a man doesn't mean you are now a woman.

kitex · Today 18:34

@Transperson Just stop your nonsense. You will never be a woman. You don’t know what it is to be a woman because you are a man. Being a woman isn’t a feeling. We are all fed with this ridiculous notion that TIMs can become women.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Today 18:39

kitex · Today 18:34

@Transperson Just stop your nonsense. You will never be a woman. You don’t know what it is to be a woman because you are a man. Being a woman isn’t a feeling. We are all fed with this ridiculous notion that TIMs can become women.

This ought to be pinned at the top of this board. Especially the Just stop your nonsense bit. 😂

kitex · Today 18:52

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Today 18:39

This ought to be pinned at the top of this board. Especially the Just stop your nonsense bit. 😂

I’m fed up with this drivel they keep spouting.