Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

827 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
OldCrone · Yesterday 21:18

caprioska · Yesterday 21:13

CIS gender, even if you are a woman who believes you are a woman but present entirely as a man.

You forgot the 'assigned' bit which is kind of relevant to socially construction.

Transgender, even when those people maintain that they have changed sex.

Sex traits are changeable.

Non-binary, meaning who knows what. Refusing to accept living with a gender stereotype? Welcome to the world of many normal women.

Woohoo well done! That wasn't so hard was it?

Are you agreeing now that non-binary is complete nonsense because most of us aren't walking stereotypes?

Imdunfer · Yesterday 21:22

caprioska · Yesterday 21:13

CIS gender, even if you are a woman who believes you are a woman but present entirely as a man.

You forgot the 'assigned' bit which is kind of relevant to socially construction.

Transgender, even when those people maintain that they have changed sex.

Sex traits are changeable.

Non-binary, meaning who knows what. Refusing to accept living with a gender stereotype? Welcome to the world of many normal women.

Woohoo well done! That wasn't so hard was it?

Transgender, even when those people maintain that they have changed sex.

Sex traits are changeable.

SOME sex traits are changeable, but none naturally, only by medical intervention.

But I was talking about transgender people who will not accept being called transexual and yet at the very same time insist that they have changed sex and become women.

So where does that leave your neat googled definition of "gender"?

I'd really appreciate it if you could stop the peurile comments you end posts with.

caprioska · Yesterday 21:26

OldCrone · Yesterday 21:18

Are you agreeing now that non-binary is complete nonsense because most of us aren't walking stereotypes?

No just the opposite. Non binary identity provides the solution from sex stereotypes that gender critical feminists claimed is the problem. Except sex stereotypes were not their real problem because they don't accept this logical conclusion to it. Its something else….👀

Imdunfer · Yesterday 21:30

caprioska · Yesterday 21:26

No just the opposite. Non binary identity provides the solution from sex stereotypes that gender critical feminists claimed is the problem. Except sex stereotypes were not their real problem because they don't accept this logical conclusion to it. Its something else….👀

Women have been happily rejecting the female sex stereotypes for decades without needing to invent non-binary. No "solution" was required, there was no problem.

inkymoose · Yesterday 21:31

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Yesterday 14:08

Doesn't it though. Leaving it alone seems to be impossible for the chaos-makers to manage, messing as they do with singular and plural for individuals.

I expect your language does have a distinction between one chair and two chairs, as we have an s at the end of plurals (well, apart from exceptions like sheep and giraffe, but English is a language full of exceptions)? Languages generally do; it's important to know whether one buffalo or a gurt herd of buffaloes is stampeding towards your house, for example, or stampeding towards all your houses if it's a village they are about to flatten.

That is leaving aside redefining simple words for obvious matters, such as "women" for female people. As opposed, obviously, to cervix-havers, menstruaters, and so forth, which are cumbersome and inaccurate.

Edited

I've got a friend who has a keen ear for neologisms, at any rate the ones that crop up in the social media whirlpool. She employs them without irony, although she's not unintelligent in any way. I can't talk to her about such things:
"Punching down"
"Check your privilege"
"I can't stand JK Rowling"
"Poor oppressed trans women"
etc

caprioska · Yesterday 21:32

Imdunfer · Yesterday 21:22

Transgender, even when those people maintain that they have changed sex.

Sex traits are changeable.

SOME sex traits are changeable, but none naturally, only by medical intervention.

But I was talking about transgender people who will not accept being called transexual and yet at the very same time insist that they have changed sex and become women.

So where does that leave your neat googled definition of "gender"?

I'd really appreciate it if you could stop the peurile comments you end posts with.

Edited

Trans people can't change their gametes or chromosomes so trans sexual isn't accurate. Sex traits & gendered traits are inextricably one in terms of gendered social associations so trans gender is the more accurate descriptor.

Again, why this distinction from reproductive sex (which is what gender critical feminists claim is the problem) isn't solving their purported grievances is contradictory.

OldCrone · Yesterday 21:33

caprioska · Yesterday 21:26

No just the opposite. Non binary identity provides the solution from sex stereotypes that gender critical feminists claimed is the problem. Except sex stereotypes were not their real problem because they don't accept this logical conclusion to it. Its something else….👀

Non binary identity provides the solution from sex stereotypes

How do you come to that conclusion? If you want to get away from gender stereotyping, the solution is to say that you can be a woman (or man) with any personality.

Pretending that you're not a woman (or man) because you don't like the stereotypes which have been imposed on your sex is just another way of reinforcing the stereotypes. It's saying that the stereotypes are so important and so unchangeable that the only way to avoid them is to pretend you don't have a sex or that you're not the sex you are.

It really isn't logical at all. Is this an example of trans logic - something that pretends to be logic but isn't?

caprioska · Yesterday 21:36

Imdunfer · Yesterday 21:30

Women have been happily rejecting the female sex stereotypes for decades without needing to invent non-binary. No "solution" was required, there was no problem.

Putting words to an already existing phenomena is hardly 'inventing' anything. If anything it supports it being socially accepted.

Its almost as if gender critical feminists don't want to deviate from traditional cultural beliefs…conservatism anyone?

caprioska · Yesterday 21:37

OldCrone · Yesterday 21:33

Non binary identity provides the solution from sex stereotypes

How do you come to that conclusion? If you want to get away from gender stereotyping, the solution is to say that you can be a woman (or man) with any personality.

Pretending that you're not a woman (or man) because you don't like the stereotypes which have been imposed on your sex is just another way of reinforcing the stereotypes. It's saying that the stereotypes are so important and so unchangeable that the only way to avoid them is to pretend you don't have a sex or that you're not the sex you are.

It really isn't logical at all. Is this an example of trans logic - something that pretends to be logic but isn't?

Your'e confusing sex with gender again.

OldCrone · Yesterday 21:40

caprioska · Yesterday 21:37

Your'e confusing sex with gender again.

Am I? Or is it the people who identify as non-binary who are confusing sex and gender?

Do people who identify as non-binary usually call themselves 'non-binary women' and 'non-binary men'?

caprioska · Yesterday 21:45

OldCrone · Yesterday 21:40

Am I? Or is it the people who identify as non-binary who are confusing sex and gender?

Do people who identify as non-binary usually call themselves 'non-binary women' and 'non-binary men'?

Edited

Non-binary people typically refer to their biological sex or birth-assigned sex using standard descriptive terms like assigned male at birth (AMAB) or assigned female at birth (AFAB) or just male/female because 'woman' & 'man' have socially constructed sex stereotypes attached.

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 21:46

caprioska · Yesterday 20:42

Again - Same thing as google.

You act as if there aren't broadly accepted understandings of those terms.

Oh, I thought words could mean whatever we like now? Isn’t that what queer theory and post modernism are all about?

A man is a woman if he says so. Apparently. Literally true, and not metaphorically, so we keep being told.

It does become difficult to have discussions without universally accepted definitions of words, doesn’t it? Gender identity theory is so full of holes and contradictions, the shifting meaningless language is what holds it together.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Yesterday 21:46

caprioska · Yesterday 21:36

Putting words to an already existing phenomena is hardly 'inventing' anything. If anything it supports it being socially accepted.

Its almost as if gender critical feminists don't want to deviate from traditional cultural beliefs…conservatism anyone?

Phenomena is the plural of phenomenon. I wish you'd learn the original language before wombling off into the one you are busy inventing.

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 21:49

caprioska · Yesterday 21:45

Non-binary people typically refer to their biological sex or birth-assigned sex using standard descriptive terms like assigned male at birth (AMAB) or assigned female at birth (AFAB) or just male/female because 'woman' & 'man' have socially constructed sex stereotypes attached.

“Standard descriptive terms” 😂
“assigned male at birth” (appropriating the language of DSDs)

What bollocks. Sex isn’t assigned like a fucking sorting hat.

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 21:51

caprioska · Yesterday 21:26

No just the opposite. Non binary identity provides the solution from sex stereotypes that gender critical feminists claimed is the problem. Except sex stereotypes were not their real problem because they don't accept this logical conclusion to it. Its something else….👀

But as no one conforms 100% to sex stereotypes, that means everyone is non binary? Awesome. So as everyone is non binary, we’ve just eliminated sex stereotypes. So, if we’ve just eliminated sex stereotypes, how does someone “present as the opposite sex”?

caprioska · Yesterday 21:53

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 21:49

“Standard descriptive terms” 😂
“assigned male at birth” (appropriating the language of DSDs)

What bollocks. Sex isn’t assigned like a fucking sorting hat.

Genetic & gametal tests aren't usually tested for at birth so yeah it kinda is.

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 21:53

caprioska · Yesterday 21:45

Non-binary people typically refer to their biological sex or birth-assigned sex using standard descriptive terms like assigned male at birth (AMAB) or assigned female at birth (AFAB) or just male/female because 'woman' & 'man' have socially constructed sex stereotypes attached.

But sex is not “assigned at birth”. It is fixed at conception and can be observed I utero, Not say Australian education is lacking but…..

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 21:54

caprioska · Yesterday 21:36

Putting words to an already existing phenomena is hardly 'inventing' anything. If anything it supports it being socially accepted.

Its almost as if gender critical feminists don't want to deviate from traditional cultural beliefs…conservatism anyone?

Is it yourself you are trying so hard to convince with the smearing?

I mean do crack on, we know this is nonsense so it makes no difference if you want to keep repeating your obsession that understanding there are 2 sexes in mammals is somehow uniquely conservative.

Truly hilarious 😂

caprioska · Yesterday 21:56

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 21:51

But as no one conforms 100% to sex stereotypes, that means everyone is non binary? Awesome. So as everyone is non binary, we’ve just eliminated sex stereotypes. So, if we’ve just eliminated sex stereotypes, how does someone “present as the opposite sex”?

Identity being an individually subjective values belief based pursuit that's also subject to social influences & categorisations means that its upto personal interpretation so 100% conformity is a moot point.

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 21:57

caprioska · Yesterday 21:53

Genetic & gametal tests aren't usually tested for at birth so yeah it kinda is.

Oh dear. Have you spoken to a midwife ever? In what percentage of humans is sex at all ambiguous at birth? Oh yes, 0.018%

So no, not “assigned”. How ignorant. You do know many people find out before the child is even born! Astonishing though that might seem to you, what with science and all.

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 21:58

caprioska · Yesterday 21:56

Identity being an individually subjective values belief based pursuit that's also subject to social influences & categorisations means that its upto personal interpretation so 100% conformity is a moot point.

Yadda yadda

caprioska · Yesterday 21:58

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 21:53

But sex is not “assigned at birth”. It is fixed at conception and can be observed I utero, Not say Australian education is lacking but…..

We don't routinely test for chromosomes or gametes so false.

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 21:59

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 21:53

But sex is not “assigned at birth”. It is fixed at conception and can be observed I utero, Not say Australian education is lacking but…..

Well, it does seem to be sadly lacking and based on strange mix of fantasy and ignorance.

caprioska · Yesterday 22:00

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 21:54

Is it yourself you are trying so hard to convince with the smearing?

I mean do crack on, we know this is nonsense so it makes no difference if you want to keep repeating your obsession that understanding there are 2 sexes in mammals is somehow uniquely conservative.

Truly hilarious 😂

Conveniently confusing sex & gender again? Zero sum identity invalidation yadda yadda yadda strikes again…

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 22:00

caprioska · Yesterday 21:58

We don't routinely test for chromosomes or gametes so false.

So are you saying sonographers are lying when they tell parents a baby’s sex??? Or don’t you have those in Australia? Do you just have someone who wanders round randomly assigning babies sexes? Who’d have thought it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread