Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie: Employment Tribunal, associated legal claims, and related matters - thread #68

1000 replies

nauticant · 04/10/2026 13:02

Sandie Peggie, a nurse at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy (VH), brought claims in the employment tribunal against her employer; Fife Health Board (the Board) and another employee, Dr B Upton. Ms Peggie’s claims were of sexual harassment, harassment related to a protected belief, indirect discrimination and victimisation. Dr Upton claimed to be a transwoman, that is observed as male at birth but asserting a female gender identity.

The Employment Tribunal hearing started on Monday 3 February 2025 and after a prolonged process judgment was handed down on 8 December 2025. That judgment is being appealed and an appeal hearing is expected to take place in 2027.

A second Employment Tribunal, Sandie Peggie vs Royal College of Nursing, has just been heard. The hearing started on Wednesday 23 September 2026 and ended on Thursday 1 October 2026. It is possible that a decision will be handed down before Christmas of this year.

Additional legal claims have been raised. Sandie Peggie is taking action against three senior managers who were witnesses in the first Employment Tribunal - Dr Kate Searle, Dr Maggie Currer and Esther Davidson, against Carol Potter, the chief executive of NHS Fife, for victimisation, against NHS Fife for discrimination, and against its director of people and culture David Miller for harassment. In addition, Sandie Peggie is being investigated by the Nursing and Midwifery Council over fitness to practice.

The past proceedings were live tweeted by www.x.com/tribunaltweets. Tribunal Tweets are likely to be providing coverage in future proceedings. There's additional information on Tribunal Tweets' substack: www.tribunaltweets.substack.com/.

Links to previous threads #1 to #60 can be found in this thread: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5379717-sandie-peggie-list-of-threads-covering-employment-tribunal-and-afterwards

Thread 61: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5472628-sandie-peggie-vs-nhs-fife-health-board-and-dr-beth-upton-following-employment-tribunal-judgment-thread-61 8 January 2026 to 3 August 2026

Thread 62: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5562302-sandie-peggie-vs-nhs-fife-health-board-and-dr-beth-upton-following-employment-tribunal-judgment-thread-62 3 August 2026 to 24 September 2026

Thread 63: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5581909-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-63 24 September 2026 to 27 September 2026

Thread 64: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5583133-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-64 27 September 2026 to 29 September 2026

Thread 65: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5583663-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-65 29 September 2026 to 30 September 2026

Thread 66: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5584074-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-66 30 September 2026 to 1 October 2026

Thread 67: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5584523-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-67 1 October 2026 to ????

OP posts:
Thread gallery
34
Lacksie · 02/11/2026 14:36

Exactly as I thought — NC spent far too much time trying to establish that the RCN had been ‘captured by gender ideology’, without establishing the crucial link between that alleged institutional culture and SP’s treatment.

MyAmpleSheep · 02/11/2026 14:45

Let's see if there's to be an appeal.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 14:48

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 14:36

Exactly as I thought — NC spent far too much time trying to establish that the RCN had been ‘captured by gender ideology’, without establishing the crucial link between that alleged institutional culture and SP’s treatment.

You should have messaged NC on X and shared your expert legal opinion @Lacksie 🙄

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 02/11/2026 15:45

I've only given it a cursory read so far, but if I understand it correctly the reasoning is:

  • She didn't say the magic words.
  • The various staff involved were too ignorant and untrained to understand the issues, therefore weren't discriminating.
  • If there had been discrimination it would have been because of the respondent's belief, not the claimant's. Which is, in the view of the law, all absolutely hunky dory.

With an incidental note that judge failed to notice that the notes taken 'during the call' were later admitted as having been made several days later.

SlackJawedDisbeliefXY · 02/11/2026 15:50

The various staff involved were too ignorant and untrained to understand the issues, therefore weren't discriminating.

I noticed that too. Seems that RCN spent most of its time educating their employees about GI belief and forgot to tell them that GC belief was also protected. Odd that

prh47bridge · 02/11/2026 15:52

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 14:36

Exactly as I thought — NC spent far too much time trying to establish that the RCN had been ‘captured by gender ideology’, without establishing the crucial link between that alleged institutional culture and SP’s treatment.

That is not why the ET found against Sandie. To say yet again, it was for RCN to show that there was no link, not for NC to show that there was one. The ET found that the RCN succeeded in showing there was no link. Given RCN's consistent failure to support members with GC views, I am not convinced they've got it right. However, the question now is whether Sandie will appeal and, if she does, what an EAT will make against it.

SlackJawedDisbeliefXY · 02/11/2026 15:55

I wonder, if the RCN continues not to educate their employees about protected GC belief, does the defense still hold that they can't discriminate against GC members because they don't understand what the protected characteristic is?

BettyBooper · 02/11/2026 16:02

'He accepted, when it was put to him,
that the progress pride flag was associated with gender ideology, but stated that he could see no reason why the respondent would not stock merchandise supporting different beliefs, if these were available, or to support networks of
individuals holding different beliefs.'

Time for the RCN to roll out their GC merchandise!

Any minute now...

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 16:12

prh47bridge · 02/11/2026 15:52

That is not why the ET found against Sandie. To say yet again, it was for RCN to show that there was no link, not for NC to show that there was one. The ET found that the RCN succeeded in showing there was no link. Given RCN's consistent failure to support members with GC views, I am not convinced they've got it right. However, the question now is whether Sandie will appeal and, if she does, what an EAT will make against it.

Yes the tribunal positively accepted the RCN’s explanations.

But my point about institutional culture stands: the decision says that even if the alleged institutional belief were established, that would not itself establish that SP’s treatment was because of her protected belief.
Evidence connecting the two was still needed.

On the burden of proof, the tribunal did not decide whether it had shifted to RCN to show no link, it said that question did not need to be considered because it had established the reasons for the decisions.

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 16:12

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 14:48

You should have messaged NC on X and shared your expert legal opinion @Lacksie 🙄

I think it was fairly obvious, so presumably that was all she had.

rebax · 02/11/2026 16:17

The core of the judgement:

In cases of direct discrimination, which involve consideration of the mental processes of the alleged discriminator, it is a prerequisite that the alleged discriminator was aware of the protected characteristic. The protected characteristic cannot be the grounds for the treatment if the alleged discriminator is not aware of it

So because the union officials were not aware of Forstater they cannot have discriminated?

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 16:20

rebax · 02/11/2026 16:17

The core of the judgement:

In cases of direct discrimination, which involve consideration of the mental processes of the alleged discriminator, it is a prerequisite that the alleged discriminator was aware of the protected characteristic. The protected characteristic cannot be the grounds for the treatment if the alleged discriminator is not aware of it

So because the union officials were not aware of Forstater they cannot have discriminated?

Doesn't that just mean they had to be aware of her belief?

moto748e · 02/11/2026 16:20

What happened to 'ignorance of the law is no excuse'?

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 16:21

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 16:12

I think it was fairly obvious, so presumably that was all she had.

So why not contact the NHS senior managers and NC and give your professional legal view to save all the time and energy, not to mention money and explain that these tribunals are lost before they start?

We have Allison Bailey coming up - what is your view on her chances?
We have the Conversion Therapy bill - any view on how that will go?

Sandie Peggie never professed to be perfect. I would love to know how this outcome sits with nurses around the country who have similar views to Sandie who the RCN refuse to support. Why they refuse to support them

To be honest I do not think the loss of this tribunal changes my view. Women have been sold down the river over the past decade. Stonewall are backtracking. JKR has put out a blistering post this weekend which has seen the TRAs and their allies go full on tantrum on SM.

Women and our supporters many of whom are men have seen this whole trans / DEI movement skew reality. We have a lecturer at Oxford wearing silicone fetish boobs and being lauded.

The experiment is over. We are fatigued by trans and devastatingly young women opting out of womanhood are the collateral damage.

@Lacksie why spend all day (and night) on MN when you could be earning a small fortune taking on legal cases?

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 16:23

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 16:21

So why not contact the NHS senior managers and NC and give your professional legal view to save all the time and energy, not to mention money and explain that these tribunals are lost before they start?

We have Allison Bailey coming up - what is your view on her chances?
We have the Conversion Therapy bill - any view on how that will go?

Sandie Peggie never professed to be perfect. I would love to know how this outcome sits with nurses around the country who have similar views to Sandie who the RCN refuse to support. Why they refuse to support them

To be honest I do not think the loss of this tribunal changes my view. Women have been sold down the river over the past decade. Stonewall are backtracking. JKR has put out a blistering post this weekend which has seen the TRAs and their allies go full on tantrum on SM.

Women and our supporters many of whom are men have seen this whole trans / DEI movement skew reality. We have a lecturer at Oxford wearing silicone fetish boobs and being lauded.

The experiment is over. We are fatigued by trans and devastatingly young women opting out of womanhood are the collateral damage.

@Lacksie why spend all day (and night) on MN when you could be earning a small fortune taking on legal cases?

To be honest I do not think the loss of this tribunal changes my view.

Was that ever remotely in question?

moto748e · 02/11/2026 16:24

The Judge's decisions are not the fault of any MN poster, thoughbut.

popery · 02/11/2026 16:25

The RCN's FCFTP guide said "Gender identity: a person’s intrinsic sense of being male (boy or man), female (girl or woman) or an alternative gender, for example transgender, girlboy boygirl, eunuch, genderqueer."

They are stating that female = girl or woman?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 16:30

I’d prefer to listen to actual lawyers’ opinions on the merits of the case rather than self important grandstanding by randoms.

Wishesandhorses · 02/11/2026 16:33

This reminds me of the one where someone absolutely knew the law much better than the Supreme Court Judges, and for some mad reason just hadn't been asked to be involved.

BezMark · 02/11/2026 16:35

A disappointing result there but a defence of 'we just don't know what we're doing shrugs soz lol' was played and succeeded.

I don't think the RCN or the involved officers of the union covered themselves in glory there.

rebax · 02/11/2026 16:41

BezMark · 02/11/2026 16:35

A disappointing result there but a defence of 'we just don't know what we're doing shrugs soz lol' was played and succeeded.

I don't think the RCN or the involved officers of the union covered themselves in glory there.

Very Nelsonian - "We have the right to be ignorant sometimes".

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 16:43

BezMark · 02/11/2026 16:35

A disappointing result there but a defence of 'we just don't know what we're doing shrugs soz lol' was played and succeeded.

I don't think the RCN or the involved officers of the union covered themselves in glory there.

Agree.

prh47bridge · 02/11/2026 16:55

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 16:12

Yes the tribunal positively accepted the RCN’s explanations.

But my point about institutional culture stands: the decision says that even if the alleged institutional belief were established, that would not itself establish that SP’s treatment was because of her protected belief.
Evidence connecting the two was still needed.

On the burden of proof, the tribunal did not decide whether it had shifted to RCN to show no link, it said that question did not need to be considered because it had established the reasons for the decisions.

Edited

That is one of the areas where the judgment is potentially challengeable. They say that, even if the union held the belief claimed, that would not establish of itself that the relevant decision makers acted because of that belief. That flies in the face of established case law. If the union holds beliefs that are hostile to GC individuals as contended by NC, that is enough on its own to establish a prima facie case for the union to answer. In an employment case, if a claimant from a racial minority can show that there is evidence that management is racially prejudiced, that is enough to establish a prima facie case. The same standard should apply here. Rather than the tribunal needing evidence that the minds of the relevant decision makers were influenced by the claimant's protected characteristic as stated in this judgment, they should have needed evidence that their minds were NOT so influenced. Despite correctly stating the test at paragraph 106, the way they have set out the test in paragraph 109 appears to reverse the burden of proof from that set out in law.

MarieDeGournay · 02/11/2026 16:56

rebax · 02/11/2026 16:17

The core of the judgement:

In cases of direct discrimination, which involve consideration of the mental processes of the alleged discriminator, it is a prerequisite that the alleged discriminator was aware of the protected characteristic. The protected characteristic cannot be the grounds for the treatment if the alleged discriminator is not aware of it

So because the union officials were not aware of Forstater they cannot have discriminated?

I always try to keep an open mind, and I understand that sometimes The Law comes up with funny rulings because of other bits of The Law😏

But I think you make very good point, rebax:
RCN hasn't done up-to-date training about the law/discrimination/etc with its staff, even the most directly relevant staff, so they can't be held responsible for anything that requires up-to-date knowledge about the law/discrimination/etc ...
Including supporting a member on a matter that involves the current state of the law/discrimination/etc ...

It seems very circular, and very favourable towards the RCN.

But what do I know, I accept that I'm not legally qualified.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 17:07

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 16:23

To be honest I do not think the loss of this tribunal changes my view.

Was that ever remotely in question?

Absolutely. I was very happy to read and be schooled on this. TW are men. TM are women. We have afforded them kindness over the past decade but ignored reality

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.