Please or to access all these features

Weight loss chat

A space to talk openly about weight loss journeys and challenges. Mumsnet hasn't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. You may wish to speak to a medical professional before starting any diet.

Is being Obese an illness?

803 replies

agel · 18/10/2026 16:15

Yes or No
Im really not trying to start an argument. I want to understand what people actually think/know/believe about this.

I am obese and am trying to gain some sort of control over my eating through therapy at the moment. I’ve tried diets and exercising that do work but long term I don’t seem to be able to change my lifestyle enough to keep the weight off. I hate living like this and how people treat me differently because of my size. My family don’t understand at all. My partner is not understanding and it’s seriously affecting our relationship in many ways. It seems unfair because I don’t feel I have much control over this. It’s actually very lonely being in this situation. I rarely mention the topic of my health or weight to others because pardon the pun it’s always the elephant in the room! But you can almost hear what people are thinking. I hate the judgemental looks and comments. I rarely go out now because of anxiety and panic attacks brought on by this situation.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 09:23

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 09:12

Well it certainly explains that poster's perspective that of course sports injuries should always be covered underneath the 'it's your fault, fatty, pay up system' she's advocating!

When I was a lot younger I used to think that smokers and drinkers shouldn't be helped by the NHS. I mean I was about 13-14 years old. Since then I've worked and studied in mental health, psychology, criminology and all sorts of bits and pieces across the social sciences so I have a LOT of information and perspectives that come from pretty much existing in the context of academics and professionals who have these conversations on the daily. I'm aware that that informs how I come to these internet debates and I would never in a million years think that we should deny healthcare to anyone. It goes against the hippocratic oath. Nazis received healthcare, riot protesters receive healthcare, everyone receives healthcare. No question.
However, I'm aware that people come to these discussions with different trajectories and my perspective as far (as I can hold my patience, I was called a Saint earlier in this thread but even they have a limit) will always be to practice curiosity. Because building rapport creates a better environment within which to share information and each come away with updated perspectives. It doesn't always happen but it's more likely to.

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 09:25

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 09:16

It does experience in a logical straight forward way but I can talk from the perspective of it making me overweight / obese also: I injured my knee years ago, had it operated on, in theory “didn’t work”, docs said I’d never run again (this was when running was just something I did to keep me fit for other others / generally healthy), and would likely need knee replacements.

I literally ballooned to 100kg as my maximum as I couldn’t exercise and at the time, was working way with work a lot so staying in hotels and eating unhealthily (cooked breakfasts, restaurants most evenings) and not exercising.

Got so fed up with the impact it had on my day to day and had a wobble when I went for a private medical assessment and many markers were out (some significantly) that I knew I had to get on top of it.

So I can see it from others perspectives from my own experience and when I’ve been bigger or smaller, the same overall equation holds: what goes in must balance off what goes out.

yes people’s metabolisms are different (menopause, genetic disposition etc etc) which makes it harder for some but the same fundamental principles apply.

You can't see it from other perspectives because you can't understand how and why other people might make different choices to you. You gained weight, you lost it. I've done that a dozen times in my life too. I've been dieting since I was ten. You might find if, god forbid, you are unable to run again and back in a situation where you have less control over your food intake as you describe that the weight would go back on and not come off as easily next time. Suddenly the calories in and out doesn't work quite as well as it did before and you have to drop those calories lower, and lower again. You can't understand why your body simply won’t cooperate the way it did before and the frustration and misery will grow and grow. I sincerely hope you don't experience that, but it would be great if you would actually understand how yoyo dieting damages the body and drags people into a spiral that becomes increasingly difficult to get out of. I hope you can continue with your ultras and never have to know firsthand what that's like, truly I do. But open your mind wide enough to actually read the posts you dismiss so easily and understand that your experience is not everyone's before you rush to blame others without bothering to so much as read the research you're shown.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 09:30

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 09:12

Well it certainly explains that poster's perspective that of course sports injuries should always be covered underneath the 'it's your fault, fatty, pay up system' she's advocating!

You’re missing the point.

I already do pay extra to have injuries as a result of ny sport covered as many insurances exclude them (I climb and do other “extreme” sports).

plus: I lived internationally where I had to pay direct for treatment and have ended up in A&E needed treatment (broken foot bone in that case) that I had to pay for.

point being: I’m an adult, I take a conscious decision to pursue them (partly because I enjoy them, partly because I know they’re good for me), and am happy to pay to cover them.

why do you keep using the term “fatty”? It’s derogatory and your use of it undermines your credibility in what is meant to be a logical reasoned debate

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 09:33

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 09:25

You can't see it from other perspectives because you can't understand how and why other people might make different choices to you. You gained weight, you lost it. I've done that a dozen times in my life too. I've been dieting since I was ten. You might find if, god forbid, you are unable to run again and back in a situation where you have less control over your food intake as you describe that the weight would go back on and not come off as easily next time. Suddenly the calories in and out doesn't work quite as well as it did before and you have to drop those calories lower, and lower again. You can't understand why your body simply won’t cooperate the way it did before and the frustration and misery will grow and grow. I sincerely hope you don't experience that, but it would be great if you would actually understand how yoyo dieting damages the body and drags people into a spiral that becomes increasingly difficult to get out of. I hope you can continue with your ultras and never have to know firsthand what that's like, truly I do. But open your mind wide enough to actually read the posts you dismiss so easily and understand that your experience is not everyone's before you rush to blame others without bothering to so much as read the research you're shown.

I agree there’s a proportion of people with very difficult circumstances making it harder for them however where I think we disagree is that I think the vast majority of those that think they fit into this category don’t: they’re just not balancing the books.

look at all the studies on do obese folk have lower metabolic rates (thought to be a contributory factor). The answer is no, or at least not noticeably and in fact, they actually have higher metabolic rates (as there’s more mass to maintain!).

People often look for excuses rather than taking ownership. Most can take ownership, I agree some are genuinely “stuck”

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 09:38

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 09:30

You’re missing the point.

I already do pay extra to have injuries as a result of ny sport covered as many insurances exclude them (I climb and do other “extreme” sports).

plus: I lived internationally where I had to pay direct for treatment and have ended up in A&E needed treatment (broken foot bone in that case) that I had to pay for.

point being: I’m an adult, I take a conscious decision to pursue them (partly because I enjoy them, partly because I know they’re good for me), and am happy to pay to cover them.

why do you keep using the term “fatty”? It’s derogatory and your use of it undermines your credibility in what is meant to be a logical reasoned debate

And if, when you went up to 100kg, had you developed cancer at the point would you think it fair for you to pay for that treatment yourself? Sell your house, go into debt, make yourself bankrupt rather than burden the NHS with your poor choices? Or die if you couldn't afford it? Would that have been right? Or is having a knee injury and 'being away with work so having to eat a lot of cooked breakfasts' a valid exemption? I'm very interested to know.

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 09:44

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:55

I love your disbelief. I presume it’s because you’re thinking no-one would ever want to exercise for fun as it’s too much “effort”.

It’s why I’ve such an interest in the views on this thread as because of my hobby (which is ironically often referred to as “eating competitions” rather than “running competitions”), I’ve spent a lot of time researching nutrition, physiology, and psychology (as you’re not getting to the end of an ultra - at least in one piece - without knowing the basics!) and seen first hand how the simple equation plays out: what’s goes in must goes out.

eg when in an intense block and in particularly on a long run or back-to-back long run weekend, I struggle to eat enough. It’s difficult to get enough healthy calories in (so you resort to gels etc).

however… the converse is, when not training (eg I normally take 2 weeks off after an ultra then a month or so steady), it’s easy to fall into the trap of being lazy and eating crap (burgers, UPFs etc) and / or too much as I notice I rapidly balloon.

You presume wrong, I work our 5-6 days a week and have a fully kitted out home gym in a seperate building, that includes treadmill, spin bike, rower, climber, elliptical, weights and weight bench, genuinly,

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 09:45

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 09:38

And if, when you went up to 100kg, had you developed cancer at the point would you think it fair for you to pay for that treatment yourself? Sell your house, go into debt, make yourself bankrupt rather than burden the NHS with your poor choices? Or die if you couldn't afford it? Would that have been right? Or is having a knee injury and 'being away with work so having to eat a lot of cooked breakfasts' a valid exemption? I'm very interested to know.

Well it would depend on whether the cancer was linked to me being 100kg or not! Clearly

So at present, if any of the 13 cancers that are linked then yes. If some of the others (eg lung, bladder, brain etc) then no.

Why would I not agree to this given I’ve been advocating for it!

MoneyJo · 26/10/2026 09:48

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:10

Some limited research would help you come to the conclusion as to why I’m posting it…

many insurance policies exclude injuries (slips / trips / falls / whatever) that have happened after alcohol. Note, this doesn’t just mean illegal acts which as you point out are also excluded.

Ie they already follow the concept of if you’ve caused something that was unavoidable, they’re not picking up the bill.

whether you drink or not is irrelevant.

The "Proximate Cause" Rule: To deny a claim based on an alcohol exclusion, the insurer must legally prove that alcohol was the direct or primary cause of the accident, rather than just present in your system

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 09:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 09:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 10:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Why? Because I apply rules fairly and equally?

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 10:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I’m going to ignore you as your continuous personal attacks are proving you can’t engage in sensible discussion

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 10:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TaraRhu · 26/10/2026 10:21

I think in terms of true 'medical' terms it is a disease. But it is misleading because it is self induced. The pharmaceutical companies like saying it's a disease because it makes people feel like it's something that just happened them rather than it being a result of eating too much of the wrong things. Obviously it's extremely hard to get rid of excess body fat when you get very obese, and it's not easy. But ultimately it is self inflicted in most cases

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 10:21

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 10:03

I’m going to ignore you as your continuous personal attacks are proving you can’t engage in sensible discussion

It’s a question not liking the question doesn’t make it an attack, you seem very comfortable in dishing it out and don’t see it as attacks, in fact you took severe umbrage when your posts were deleted, but show incredible levels of sensitivity and categorise any question you dislike as a personal attack,

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 10:28

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 10:21

It’s a question not liking the question doesn’t make it an attack, you seem very comfortable in dishing it out and don’t see it as attacks, in fact you took severe umbrage when your posts were deleted, but show incredible levels of sensitivity and categorise any question you dislike as a personal attack,

Given that you have been told by numerous posters that the way you engage is literally unbearable I would say it is probably time you did some self reflection and evaluated how you're showing up here. Because it isn't just one person's opinion and experience now. It's numerous.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 10:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Have you got kids? Have you ever taught them consequences?

Do A, B happens
Do X, Y happens

Did you consider that exercise “brutal and unfair”?

Transparent consequences aren’t only fair but act as a behavioural motivator, which is what this is about. As a country we have a health and coupled budgetary affordability problem.

A previous poster even said “money” was the all controlling entity: great, let’s make it work for us as a country. If the cost of an unhealthy diet + treatment is more than the costs of a healthy diet, let’s motivate the healthy diet.

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 10:35

TaraRhu · 26/10/2026 10:21

I think in terms of true 'medical' terms it is a disease. But it is misleading because it is self induced. The pharmaceutical companies like saying it's a disease because it makes people feel like it's something that just happened them rather than it being a result of eating too much of the wrong things. Obviously it's extremely hard to get rid of excess body fat when you get very obese, and it's not easy. But ultimately it is self inflicted in most cases

Is it though, always? I developed very high cortisol during peri. You could argue that the resulting impacts of that in terms of how my body behaved ie changes in insulin production, and laying down glucose as fat and unable to break it down was still my fault as I put the food in my mouth,that instead I should have achieved what felt impossible and in fact under eaten, lived by life like that for five years

and when I developed sleep apnea, due to weight gain, suffering severe sleep deprivation, I should have done the same, it was my fault, especially as I chose to continue in a high stress role at the same time.

and it was still my fault that I developed high blood pressure, so high the doctors couldn’t control it with medication and were considering adrenal gland cancer, the blood pressure medication I was on was brutal.

you could then argue it was still my fault as I developed metabolic disease and insulin resistance, and I reached my peak at bmi 32.

i then guess if you follow the argument being made by the poster who is anti weight loss injections I should have rejected my gps advice, and not purchased privately weight loss meds, as it was my fault and I should have been able to control myself more, the fact I was ill was all my fault,

and here I am today, back down to bmi 20, maintaning for about 20 or so months, work out most days, no longer on any medication other than a low dose of mounjaro, no high cortisol, no insulin resistance normal healthy blood pressure no sleep apnea, and you could argue like others, I should not have been able to access those meds, it’s my fault my body cannot cope with additonal weight, I should have been able to withstand the extremely high cortisol that peri brought me, and have enough self control to not need drugs.

as that’s what’s being argued isn’t it, it’s all my fault, and I should not have been able to access those meds even though I paid privately . I should have suffered more, risked an event, risked leaving my husband a widow and my child without a mother, all because I lacked self control,.

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 10:39

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 09:16

But her 'opinion' is backed up by research and evidence. And the obesity issue is a global one. 'Agree to differ' doesn't really work when one person demonstrates a solid and comprehensive grounding and the other just dismisses it without engaging whatsoever. Why come on a discussion thread if you can't take on board anything that anyone else is saying?

Based on this, @ExpectMore I'm going to challenge your online identity and expect more from you. Can you properly read my post and hold your view that whether people eat UPFs is simply down to making the right choices?

The choices people make are heavily influenced and controlled by marketing and socioeconomic standing. Do you agree or disagree? If you disagree, why?

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 10:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

To answer your Q: would I happily watch my adult child?

of course I wouldn’t be happy to sit back and watch it happen. I’d be thoroughly disappointed with their life choices particularly as I would have been looking to intervene and support as the situation grew worse. I’d also not let them get into destitution, I’d likely step in and cover the costs (assuming I could do of course) in exchange for a few choice words pointing out how it shouldn’t happen again.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 10:48

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 10:39

Based on this, @ExpectMore I'm going to challenge your online identity and expect more from you. Can you properly read my post and hold your view that whether people eat UPFs is simply down to making the right choices?

The choices people make are heavily influenced and controlled by marketing and socioeconomic standing. Do you agree or disagree? If you disagree, why?

I agree it’s heavily influenced but we all still have autonomy.

I view it analogous to smoking. Years ago, it wasn’t recognised as being unhealthy, was encouraged socially, was subject to heavy marketing.

Nowadays? You’d have to have been living on the moon to have not heard the message re. It being unhealthy so anyone choosing to do it is doing so in full knowledge that it is doing them no good.

UPF will be the same.

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 11:06

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 10:48

I agree it’s heavily influenced but we all still have autonomy.

I view it analogous to smoking. Years ago, it wasn’t recognised as being unhealthy, was encouraged socially, was subject to heavy marketing.

Nowadays? You’d have to have been living on the moon to have not heard the message re. It being unhealthy so anyone choosing to do it is doing so in full knowledge that it is doing them no good.

UPF will be the same.

That's a perspective I hadn't thought of. What about those who are priced out of being able to afford to eat healthily regardless of what they would like to choose based on what we know nowadays about nutrition? I'd also say there's quite a bit of inequality around how informed different sectors of society are. Many won't have time to sit around researching even if they do have a general idea of what is unhealthy. I think that if someone had no interest in health or nutrition and just ate what is encouraged through advertising it has a poor impact on health. Even the NHS isn't that good at giving advice around this sort of thing. We had the food triangle for so long and it's now been debunked for example.

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 11:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 11:28

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 11:06

That's a perspective I hadn't thought of. What about those who are priced out of being able to afford to eat healthily regardless of what they would like to choose based on what we know nowadays about nutrition? I'd also say there's quite a bit of inequality around how informed different sectors of society are. Many won't have time to sit around researching even if they do have a general idea of what is unhealthy. I think that if someone had no interest in health or nutrition and just ate what is encouraged through advertising it has a poor impact on health. Even the NHS isn't that good at giving advice around this sort of thing. We had the food triangle for so long and it's now been debunked for example.

I think some might have to spend more of their income on quality food than others, but I think in the uk there’s a very small proportion who if they choose to prioritise food, couldn’t afford to eat healthily (when I grew up in poverty, we literally had next to nothing but always had healthy food as cooking from scratch with basic ingredients was cheaper than takeaways, eating out etc. similarly when I first set out and was on just above NMW I found it possible to afford good food, if you prioritise that).

Im also not sure there’s much excuse for not understanding the basics of nutrition in the uk. It’s taught to every school kid. Don’t you think?

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 11:50

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 10:48

I agree it’s heavily influenced but we all still have autonomy.

I view it analogous to smoking. Years ago, it wasn’t recognised as being unhealthy, was encouraged socially, was subject to heavy marketing.

Nowadays? You’d have to have been living on the moon to have not heard the message re. It being unhealthy so anyone choosing to do it is doing so in full knowledge that it is doing them no good.

UPF will be the same.

But people didn't stop smoking just because they were told it was unhealthy. Tobacco companies were made subject to extremely heavy restrictions and regulations. Taxed highly, not allowed to advertise, forced to put graphic health warnings with photos of diseased organs on the packaging. If this happens with UPFs, then yes consumption will decrease. But you do need to regulate companies in order to make it happen. Earlier in the thread you said you didn't think the government should be intervening in people's food choices. But you engage in overly simplistic magical thinking and expect that people will just make better choices because you can't understand any of the very many reasons they can't or don't.

If governments had not intervened with tobacco companies then smoking rates would be much higher now. It might make no sense to you, but it's the truth. Because of the interventions, public health in that measure at least has improved. That's a good thing. It's much better than saying smokers are stupid and weak willed and should be denied NHS care. It hits the corporations making gigantic profits and it protects individuals. Similar measures could be taken with UPFs, but if they aren't then consumption probably won't decrease especially for the lowest-income families who are priced out of healthy eating - again, you dismiss that in the face of plenty of evidence and research, but it is true nonetheless.

Swipe left for the next trending thread