Please or to access all these features

Weight loss chat

A space to talk openly about weight loss journeys and challenges. Mumsnet hasn't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. You may wish to speak to a medical professional before starting any diet.

Is being Obese an illness?

803 replies

agel · 18/10/2026 16:15

Yes or No
Im really not trying to start an argument. I want to understand what people actually think/know/believe about this.

I am obese and am trying to gain some sort of control over my eating through therapy at the moment. I’ve tried diets and exercising that do work but long term I don’t seem to be able to change my lifestyle enough to keep the weight off. I hate living like this and how people treat me differently because of my size. My family don’t understand at all. My partner is not understanding and it’s seriously affecting our relationship in many ways. It seems unfair because I don’t feel I have much control over this. It’s actually very lonely being in this situation. I rarely mention the topic of my health or weight to others because pardon the pun it’s always the elephant in the room! But you can almost hear what people are thinking. I hate the judgemental looks and comments. I rarely go out now because of anxiety and panic attacks brought on by this situation.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 08:06

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:04

Oh come on, that clearly can’t be the case, it’s a human creation after all.

What cannot be the case?

MoneyJo · 26/10/2026 08:07

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:05

Be sure to read the small print about accidents after alcohol, for example…. 😉

I have no idea why you're posting that to me. I barely drink alcohol. I have nothing against consequences for people who break the law by driving over the limit or something like that. It's your dystopia I reject.

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 08:08

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:00

Another gimme for free: https://www.cancerresearchuk.org/about-cancer/causes-of-cancer/sun-uv-and-cancer/how-do-sunbeds-cause-skin-cancer

i think you’ll note it implies 0 sun bed usage as the safe level.

Ok, great so one single use of a sunbed means you're on the hook for the cancer bill, thanks for clarifying. So someone presents at the doctor's with signs of skin cancer. They're asked if they have ever used a sunbed. They will say no. How do you prove otherwise?

And someone else develops lung cancer, admits that they smoked in their twenties. Maybe that's caused the cancer thirty years later, but maybe it's air pollution. Who makes the decision? Do we err on the side of 'well, they made the choice to smoke for a while so it doesn't matter whether or not it was actually the traffic that caused the cancer - or a combination - or a genetic susceptibility - or plain bad luck because in truth we will never know for certain why one person gets cancer and another doesn't'.

And then an obese person develops breast cancer, and maybe it's because of her weight. But she has a family history of it so maybe it's that. But then, genetics loads the gun and environment pulls the trigger - look, her slim sister hasn't got cancer so it's probably her fault for being obese. Now let's decide if her obesity is her fault or if she qualifies for the 'no, it's ok, you're fat because of an acceptable reason'. Does she pay or not pay for the cancer treatment or did she die before anyone could decide what to do?!

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:10

MoneyJo · 26/10/2026 08:07

I have no idea why you're posting that to me. I barely drink alcohol. I have nothing against consequences for people who break the law by driving over the limit or something like that. It's your dystopia I reject.

Some limited research would help you come to the conclusion as to why I’m posting it…

many insurance policies exclude injuries (slips / trips / falls / whatever) that have happened after alcohol. Note, this doesn’t just mean illegal acts which as you point out are also excluded.

Ie they already follow the concept of if you’ve caused something that was unavoidable, they’re not picking up the bill.

whether you drink or not is irrelevant.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:18

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 08:08

Ok, great so one single use of a sunbed means you're on the hook for the cancer bill, thanks for clarifying. So someone presents at the doctor's with signs of skin cancer. They're asked if they have ever used a sunbed. They will say no. How do you prove otherwise?

And someone else develops lung cancer, admits that they smoked in their twenties. Maybe that's caused the cancer thirty years later, but maybe it's air pollution. Who makes the decision? Do we err on the side of 'well, they made the choice to smoke for a while so it doesn't matter whether or not it was actually the traffic that caused the cancer - or a combination - or a genetic susceptibility - or plain bad luck because in truth we will never know for certain why one person gets cancer and another doesn't'.

And then an obese person develops breast cancer, and maybe it's because of her weight. But she has a family history of it so maybe it's that. But then, genetics loads the gun and environment pulls the trigger - look, her slim sister hasn't got cancer so it's probably her fault for being obese. Now let's decide if her obesity is her fault or if she qualifies for the 'no, it's ok, you're fat because of an acceptable reason'. Does she pay or not pay for the cancer treatment or did she die before anyone could decide what to do?!

These are no different in concept to the alcohol whilst on holiday scenario.

maybe the slip / trips/ fall whatever may still have happened even if the alcohol wasn’t consumed but it was and it’s know to increase the likelihood of it so it’s not covered.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:20

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 08:06

What cannot be the case?

Money can’t be the great all powerful controlling non-human controlled entity in the sky that humans have no power over but to obey… particularly because we created it so it’s if our own making!

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 08:23

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:18

These are no different in concept to the alcohol whilst on holiday scenario.

maybe the slip / trips/ fall whatever may still have happened even if the alcohol wasn’t consumed but it was and it’s know to increase the likelihood of it so it’s not covered.

Ok, so the sunbed user lies and gets her cancer treatment covered.

The former smoker has to pay up, and no one is ever held accountable for the air pollution.

And, surprise surprise, obese people do pay for their cancer treatment in your scenario on the basis that it might have contributed.

And that's not at all dystopian in your opinion! I do think though that all the lovely savings made in not treating anyone who has ever made a poor decision in their life might quickly evaporate in the absolute tsunami of lawsuits that would be taken out as in your system I don't think many people would qualify for treatment at all!

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 08:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I’m surprised you’re equating personal opinion and views to looks? Seems very shallow.

If you want an image: currently on a rest period of a couple of months between my last Ultra before starting training for my next training block starts in November. Nothing better than a long distance race to get you motivated to get out there over the winter months and help work off the Christmas excesses.

whether or not that will help you judge if I’m “healthy” just by looking at me is another point. I’d suggest not as such approach’s are limited and shallow

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 08:33

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:31

I’m surprised you’re equating personal opinion and views to looks? Seems very shallow.

If you want an image: currently on a rest period of a couple of months between my last Ultra before starting training for my next training block starts in November. Nothing better than a long distance race to get you motivated to get out there over the winter months and help work off the Christmas excesses.

whether or not that will help you judge if I’m “healthy” just by looking at me is another point. I’d suggest not as such approach’s are limited and shallow

Edited

Sure 😂

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 08:34

@ExpectMore do we also make anyone who has ever eaten a ham sandwich pay if they develop bowel cancer? Ham, bacon and sausages are known carcinogens.

Red meat eaters? They'll be paying too won't they? Do you get a free pass if you were fed it as a child but gave it up as soon as you were an adult? This won't be a bureaucratic nightmare to figure out at all, don't worry.

Have you ever used nonstick pans? Did you choose a career as a cabinet maker (you idiot, exposure to sawdust has been linked to nasal cancer! That one's your fault so pay up!).

Alcohol contributes to cancer, so anyone who has ever had a glass of wine can pay too of course. Hold on though, does red wine have a protective effect on cardiovascular health or did that debunked? The safest thing is for everyone in the world to quickly become an expert in all the factors that might contribute to cancer, do all of our research and then make sure we don't do anything wrong at all. That's pretty straightforward, isn't it?

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 08:39

We're in trouble if the Daily Mail get involved in deciding who has and hasn't caused their own cancer, apparently lightbulbs give you skin cancer - so anyone reckless enough to have electric lighting in their home can pay for their own treatment I guess (first and I hope only DM link I'll ever post!) https://www.dailymail.com/health/article-506082/Environmentally-friendly-light-bulbs-skin-cancer.html

Environmentally friendly light bulbs ‘can give you skin cancer’

Energy-saving light bulbs can be bad for your skin, doctors are warning. The fluorescent devices produce a more intense light and can aggravate a range of existing problems, especially in those with light-sensitive conditions

https://www.dailymail.com/health/article-506082/Environmentally-friendly-light-bulbs-skin-cancer.html

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 08:42

Anyway, I've gone off-topic delving into the ridiculousness of @ExpectMore 's suggested solution to the rise in obesity. It has really diverted me this morning!

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 08:47

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:20

Money can’t be the great all powerful controlling non-human controlled entity in the sky that humans have no power over but to obey… particularly because we created it so it’s if our own making!

Right. But my point is that the personal choice argument doesn't hold any weight once you realise how little choice individuals actually have and the strength of environmental influences.

We often discuss obesity as though it is primarily a matter of individual responsibility. People are told to eat less, cook from scratch, exercise more and make better choices.
But this overlooks a fundamental question: who actually has the money, time and power to make those choices?

Dr Chris van Tulleken, infectious diseases doctor, UCL professor and author of Ultra-Processed People, has spent years examining how our food environment is shaped by powerful multinational corporations.
His central argument is that the obesity epidemic is not simply a collective failure of willpower. It is closely connected to a food system in which commercial profitability frequently takes precedence over public health.

1. Poverty dramatically restricts food choices
The Food Foundation's latest Broken Plate findings reveal just how unequal access to healthy food has become in Britain.

  • Households with children in the poorest fifth of the population would need to spend approximately 85% of their disposable income to afford the government-recommended healthy diet.
  • Healthier foods are nearly twice as expensive per calorie as less healthy foods.
  • More than one-third of food outlets in the most deprived areas are fast-food businesses.
  • Just 3% of traditional food and soft-drink advertising expenditure goes towards fruit and vegetables.

Consider what this means for a family managing rent, electricity, transport, childcare and other essentials.
A cheap, calorie-dense, ready-to-eat product may be the most financially practical option. Fresh ingredients may be affordable individually, but preparing a varied, nutritious diet consistently can involve greater costs, planning, equipment and potential food waste.
This does not mean healthy eating on a low income is impossible. It means the financial and practical obstacles are substantially greater.

2. Poverty also creates time poverty
Money is only part of the equation.
People on low incomes may be working long or unpredictable shifts, combining multiple jobs, travelling significant distances to work or managing childcare without paid support.
Cooking from scratch requires time to shop, prepare, cook, clean and plan the next meal.
When someone finishes a demanding shift, collects their children and has limited time before bedtime, convenience food is not necessarily evidence of laziness or ignorance.
It may be a rational response to their circumstances.
Van Tulleken has repeatedly challenged the assumption that everyone has the money, time or facilities to prepare healthy meals. He argues that telling individuals to make better choices is inadequate when the environment in which those choices are made remains unchanged.

3. Food manufacturers have enormous resources to influence what we eat
Multinational food companies can invest heavily in product formulation, packaging, consumer research, distribution, promotions and advertising.
Their commercial incentive is to develop products that people will repeatedly purchase and consume.
Many ultra-processed products are designed to be exceptionally appealing through combinations of sweetness, saltiness, fat, texture, flavourings and convenience.
Some are easy to eat quickly, require little preparation and can encourage consumption beyond immediate nutritional needs.
Van Tulleken argues that some of these products have addictive or addiction-like properties for some consumers. The extent to which particular foods should scientifically be classified as addictive remains debated, but the evidence that certain ultra-processed dietary patterns encourage greater consumption is increasingly substantial.
This raises an important question: how meaningful is individual choice when companies can spend millions studying how to influence our preferences and eating behaviour?

4. Advertising reinforces the inequality
Food advertising does not simply inform consumers that products exist. It is designed to influence attention, preferences, purchasing and consumption.
Companies use emotional associations, familiar characters, branding, promotions, product placement and digital marketing to make products desirable.
Children are particularly important because food preferences and brand familiarity can develop early.
The Food Foundation reports that 40% of food and non-alcoholic drink promotions are for products high in fat, salt and/or sugar.
Meanwhile, fruit and vegetables receive only a tiny proportion of traditional advertising expenditure.
The imbalance is striking. The foods we are encouraged to consume are not necessarily those that best support our long-term health.
And people living in deprived communities may face a particularly difficult combination of financial constraints, abundant fast-food outlets and exposure to unhealthy food marketing.

5. The relationship between deprivation and obesity is measurable
According to the Health Survey for England 2024, obesity prevalence among women was approximately 41% in the most deprived areas, compared with 23% in the least deprived areas.
Among men, the corresponding figures were 34% and 28%.
These differences are not plausibly explained by assuming that poorer people simply have less willpower.
They reflect a complex interaction between economic circumstances, food environments, working conditions, stress, biology and other social determinants of health.

The pattern is especially pronounced among women.
6. Scientific research increasingly supports the importance of the food environment
A 2025 randomised controlled trial published in Nature Medicine compared minimally processed and ultra-processed diets that both followed the UK's Eatwell Guide.
Participants lost weight on both diets, but weight loss was approximately twice as great during the minimally processed diet: 2.06% compared with 1.05% over eight weeks.
This is particularly interesting because both diets were designed to comply with established healthy-eating guidance.
The findings suggest that food processing and the characteristics of the foods themselves may influence weight regulation beyond conventional nutritional recommendations.
The study was relatively small and short, so it does not settle every question about ultra-processed foods. Nevertheless, it adds experimental evidence to a growing body of research.

7. Ultimately, this is a question of money and power
Van Tulleken's work asks us to look beyond the individual and examine the commercial structures determining what food is produced, promoted, distributed and made affordable.
Food manufacturers have substantial resources to influence consumer behaviour and, through lobbying and industry relationships, public policy.
Meanwhile, households with the least money often have the fewest practical options.
The result is a deeply unequal food environment in which those facing the greatest financial pressures may also face some of the greatest barriers to healthy eating.
This does not mean personal behaviour is irrelevant, or that every ultra-processed food is harmful. It means individual behaviour takes place within a system that powerfully influences it.

We cannot adequately explain a population-wide obesity epidemic by treating millions of individuals as though they have independently developed a problem with self-control.
We need to examine why the food environment has changed, who profits from those changes and why the healthiest options are not consistently the most affordable, convenient and accessible.
If we want to address obesity seriously, the conversation needs to move beyond telling individuals to make better choices and towards understanding who has the power to shape those choices in the first place.

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 08:51

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:31

I’m surprised you’re equating personal opinion and views to looks? Seems very shallow.

If you want an image: currently on a rest period of a couple of months between my last Ultra before starting training for my next training block starts in November. Nothing better than a long distance race to get you motivated to get out there over the winter months and help work off the Christmas excesses.

whether or not that will help you judge if I’m “healthy” just by looking at me is another point. I’d suggest not as such approach’s are limited and shallow

Edited

That's pretty awesome. How long was the Ultra? (I'm not into running - tried to start numerous times over the years but just don't think it's my thing, I tend to walk for my cardio and am big into strength training gym circuit classes at the mo. So if I'm out on even guessing this was a run that's longer than a marathon feel free to correct my ignorance lol).

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:55

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 08:33

Sure 😂

I love your disbelief. I presume it’s because you’re thinking no-one would ever want to exercise for fun as it’s too much “effort”.

It’s why I’ve such an interest in the views on this thread as because of my hobby (which is ironically often referred to as “eating competitions” rather than “running competitions”), I’ve spent a lot of time researching nutrition, physiology, and psychology (as you’re not getting to the end of an ultra - at least in one piece - without knowing the basics!) and seen first hand how the simple equation plays out: what’s goes in must goes out.

eg when in an intense block and in particularly on a long run or back-to-back long run weekend, I struggle to eat enough. It’s difficult to get enough healthy calories in (so you resort to gels etc).

however… the converse is, when not training (eg I normally take 2 weeks off after an ultra then a month or so steady), it’s easy to fall into the trap of being lazy and eating crap (burgers, UPFs etc) and / or too much as I notice I rapidly balloon.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 09:00

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 08:51

That's pretty awesome. How long was the Ultra? (I'm not into running - tried to start numerous times over the years but just don't think it's my thing, I tend to walk for my cardio and am big into strength training gym circuit classes at the mo. So if I'm out on even guessing this was a run that's longer than a marathon feel free to correct my ignorance lol).

genuinely awesome. I love it as it gets me into the hills which are my sanctuary and gives me something to focus on, work towards, and stay healthy (I’ve a personal connection to health as my parents died young - one through life choices {weight, smoking etc}, one bad luck, so I’m determined to do what I can to be around for my kids).

I onto got into ultras around 2022 and the community is incredible. Very different to marathon running as in ultras, it feels like every one is in it together which is great rather than everyone as individuals against the clock.

hey stick with it, the hardest runs are always the first shortest runs! I tell many people that come to me when they’re starting out running that I can genuinely attest to the hardest runs I’ve ever done being those 10/15 minute runs in which I spent more time walking between every other (= most!) lampposts! As once you can run 30 mins+ you can just keep going

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 09:02

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 08:51

That's pretty awesome. How long was the Ultra? (I'm not into running - tried to start numerous times over the years but just don't think it's my thing, I tend to walk for my cardio and am big into strength training gym circuit classes at the mo. So if I'm out on even guessing this was a run that's longer than a marathon feel free to correct my ignorance lol).

Sorry, forgot to answer specific Q. I’ve done a few. Most in the order of 50m. Next goal is to crack the 100m mark - have given myself to 2028 to do that as it currently feels like a step beyond… which is why I like it.

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 09:05

It’s why I’ve such an interest in the views on this thread as because of my hobby (which is ironically often referred to as “eating competitions” rather than “running competitions”), I’ve spent a lot of time researching nutrition, physiology, and psychology (as you’re not getting to the end of an ultra - at least in one piece - without knowing the basics!) and seen first hand how the simple equation plays out: what’s goes in must goes out.

So your interest @ExpectMore comes from your straightforward experience. Your body functions as you expect it to, in a way that makes sense to you. Calories in and calories out works for you and so you assume this applies in the same way to everyone else. You are sure that it's just common sense and logical and that it's only a question of willpower. So you come onto threads like this and completely ignore, disregard and dismiss the experience of others. You know how things work in your life and in your body. You assume that everyone could make similar choices to you and that if they did then they would reap the same benefits as you have done. And so you don't need to extend empathy to anyone else. It leads you to a place where you'd be happy to let someone die of a disease they can't afford to treat because you think it's their fault for not having the exact same life experience as you.

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 09:09

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 09:05

It’s why I’ve such an interest in the views on this thread as because of my hobby (which is ironically often referred to as “eating competitions” rather than “running competitions”), I’ve spent a lot of time researching nutrition, physiology, and psychology (as you’re not getting to the end of an ultra - at least in one piece - without knowing the basics!) and seen first hand how the simple equation plays out: what’s goes in must goes out.

So your interest @ExpectMore comes from your straightforward experience. Your body functions as you expect it to, in a way that makes sense to you. Calories in and calories out works for you and so you assume this applies in the same way to everyone else. You are sure that it's just common sense and logical and that it's only a question of willpower. So you come onto threads like this and completely ignore, disregard and dismiss the experience of others. You know how things work in your life and in your body. You assume that everyone could make similar choices to you and that if they did then they would reap the same benefits as you have done. And so you don't need to extend empathy to anyone else. It leads you to a place where you'd be happy to let someone die of a disease they can't afford to treat because you think it's their fault for not having the exact same life experience as you.

I was just thinking whilst making a coffee that it's awesome to hear a bit about people's background in order to understand their perspective and that I'd just learnt so much in just a couple of paragraphs. It's valuable and all it took was a bit of interest and the abiity to separate an intellectual debate from an interpersonal connection.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 09:10

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 08:47

Right. But my point is that the personal choice argument doesn't hold any weight once you realise how little choice individuals actually have and the strength of environmental influences.

We often discuss obesity as though it is primarily a matter of individual responsibility. People are told to eat less, cook from scratch, exercise more and make better choices.
But this overlooks a fundamental question: who actually has the money, time and power to make those choices?

Dr Chris van Tulleken, infectious diseases doctor, UCL professor and author of Ultra-Processed People, has spent years examining how our food environment is shaped by powerful multinational corporations.
His central argument is that the obesity epidemic is not simply a collective failure of willpower. It is closely connected to a food system in which commercial profitability frequently takes precedence over public health.

1. Poverty dramatically restricts food choices
The Food Foundation's latest Broken Plate findings reveal just how unequal access to healthy food has become in Britain.

  • Households with children in the poorest fifth of the population would need to spend approximately 85% of their disposable income to afford the government-recommended healthy diet.
  • Healthier foods are nearly twice as expensive per calorie as less healthy foods.
  • More than one-third of food outlets in the most deprived areas are fast-food businesses.
  • Just 3% of traditional food and soft-drink advertising expenditure goes towards fruit and vegetables.

Consider what this means for a family managing rent, electricity, transport, childcare and other essentials.
A cheap, calorie-dense, ready-to-eat product may be the most financially practical option. Fresh ingredients may be affordable individually, but preparing a varied, nutritious diet consistently can involve greater costs, planning, equipment and potential food waste.
This does not mean healthy eating on a low income is impossible. It means the financial and practical obstacles are substantially greater.

2. Poverty also creates time poverty
Money is only part of the equation.
People on low incomes may be working long or unpredictable shifts, combining multiple jobs, travelling significant distances to work or managing childcare without paid support.
Cooking from scratch requires time to shop, prepare, cook, clean and plan the next meal.
When someone finishes a demanding shift, collects their children and has limited time before bedtime, convenience food is not necessarily evidence of laziness or ignorance.
It may be a rational response to their circumstances.
Van Tulleken has repeatedly challenged the assumption that everyone has the money, time or facilities to prepare healthy meals. He argues that telling individuals to make better choices is inadequate when the environment in which those choices are made remains unchanged.

3. Food manufacturers have enormous resources to influence what we eat
Multinational food companies can invest heavily in product formulation, packaging, consumer research, distribution, promotions and advertising.
Their commercial incentive is to develop products that people will repeatedly purchase and consume.
Many ultra-processed products are designed to be exceptionally appealing through combinations of sweetness, saltiness, fat, texture, flavourings and convenience.
Some are easy to eat quickly, require little preparation and can encourage consumption beyond immediate nutritional needs.
Van Tulleken argues that some of these products have addictive or addiction-like properties for some consumers. The extent to which particular foods should scientifically be classified as addictive remains debated, but the evidence that certain ultra-processed dietary patterns encourage greater consumption is increasingly substantial.
This raises an important question: how meaningful is individual choice when companies can spend millions studying how to influence our preferences and eating behaviour?

4. Advertising reinforces the inequality
Food advertising does not simply inform consumers that products exist. It is designed to influence attention, preferences, purchasing and consumption.
Companies use emotional associations, familiar characters, branding, promotions, product placement and digital marketing to make products desirable.
Children are particularly important because food preferences and brand familiarity can develop early.
The Food Foundation reports that 40% of food and non-alcoholic drink promotions are for products high in fat, salt and/or sugar.
Meanwhile, fruit and vegetables receive only a tiny proportion of traditional advertising expenditure.
The imbalance is striking. The foods we are encouraged to consume are not necessarily those that best support our long-term health.
And people living in deprived communities may face a particularly difficult combination of financial constraints, abundant fast-food outlets and exposure to unhealthy food marketing.

5. The relationship between deprivation and obesity is measurable
According to the Health Survey for England 2024, obesity prevalence among women was approximately 41% in the most deprived areas, compared with 23% in the least deprived areas.
Among men, the corresponding figures were 34% and 28%.
These differences are not plausibly explained by assuming that poorer people simply have less willpower.
They reflect a complex interaction between economic circumstances, food environments, working conditions, stress, biology and other social determinants of health.

The pattern is especially pronounced among women.
6. Scientific research increasingly supports the importance of the food environment
A 2025 randomised controlled trial published in Nature Medicine compared minimally processed and ultra-processed diets that both followed the UK's Eatwell Guide.
Participants lost weight on both diets, but weight loss was approximately twice as great during the minimally processed diet: 2.06% compared with 1.05% over eight weeks.
This is particularly interesting because both diets were designed to comply with established healthy-eating guidance.
The findings suggest that food processing and the characteristics of the foods themselves may influence weight regulation beyond conventional nutritional recommendations.
The study was relatively small and short, so it does not settle every question about ultra-processed foods. Nevertheless, it adds experimental evidence to a growing body of research.

7. Ultimately, this is a question of money and power
Van Tulleken's work asks us to look beyond the individual and examine the commercial structures determining what food is produced, promoted, distributed and made affordable.
Food manufacturers have substantial resources to influence consumer behaviour and, through lobbying and industry relationships, public policy.
Meanwhile, households with the least money often have the fewest practical options.
The result is a deeply unequal food environment in which those facing the greatest financial pressures may also face some of the greatest barriers to healthy eating.
This does not mean personal behaviour is irrelevant, or that every ultra-processed food is harmful. It means individual behaviour takes place within a system that powerfully influences it.

We cannot adequately explain a population-wide obesity epidemic by treating millions of individuals as though they have independently developed a problem with self-control.
We need to examine why the food environment has changed, who profits from those changes and why the healthiest options are not consistently the most affordable, convenient and accessible.
If we want to address obesity seriously, the conversation needs to move beyond telling individuals to make better choices and towards understanding who has the power to shape those choices in the first place.

I don’t know, it’s perhaps a point we’ll have to agree to differ on as I think we (I’m talking about those of us in the UK) have a significant degree of control over our own lives but I accept that control isn’t unlimited and I accept you may have a different opinion.

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 09:12

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 09:09

I was just thinking whilst making a coffee that it's awesome to hear a bit about people's background in order to understand their perspective and that I'd just learnt so much in just a couple of paragraphs. It's valuable and all it took was a bit of interest and the abiity to separate an intellectual debate from an interpersonal connection.

Well it certainly explains that poster's perspective that of course sports injuries should always be covered underneath the 'it's your fault, fatty, pay up system' she's advocating!

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 09:13

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 09:10

I don’t know, it’s perhaps a point we’ll have to agree to differ on as I think we (I’m talking about those of us in the UK) have a significant degree of control over our own lives but I accept that control isn’t unlimited and I accept you may have a different opinion.

I mean it's not my opinion, I've shared the supporting evidence. I live in the UK too and I think the obesity thing is far more complex than you might understand. Whether you do want to understand it is another story. Because that's a lot of information for you to read and then answer with 2 sentences basically saying it's on individual vibes lol.

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 09:16

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 09:10

I don’t know, it’s perhaps a point we’ll have to agree to differ on as I think we (I’m talking about those of us in the UK) have a significant degree of control over our own lives but I accept that control isn’t unlimited and I accept you may have a different opinion.

But her 'opinion' is backed up by research and evidence. And the obesity issue is a global one. 'Agree to differ' doesn't really work when one person demonstrates a solid and comprehensive grounding and the other just dismisses it without engaging whatsoever. Why come on a discussion thread if you can't take on board anything that anyone else is saying?

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 09:16

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 09:05

It’s why I’ve such an interest in the views on this thread as because of my hobby (which is ironically often referred to as “eating competitions” rather than “running competitions”), I’ve spent a lot of time researching nutrition, physiology, and psychology (as you’re not getting to the end of an ultra - at least in one piece - without knowing the basics!) and seen first hand how the simple equation plays out: what’s goes in must goes out.

So your interest @ExpectMore comes from your straightforward experience. Your body functions as you expect it to, in a way that makes sense to you. Calories in and calories out works for you and so you assume this applies in the same way to everyone else. You are sure that it's just common sense and logical and that it's only a question of willpower. So you come onto threads like this and completely ignore, disregard and dismiss the experience of others. You know how things work in your life and in your body. You assume that everyone could make similar choices to you and that if they did then they would reap the same benefits as you have done. And so you don't need to extend empathy to anyone else. It leads you to a place where you'd be happy to let someone die of a disease they can't afford to treat because you think it's their fault for not having the exact same life experience as you.

It does experience in a logical straight forward way but I can talk from the perspective of it making me overweight / obese also: I injured my knee years ago, had it operated on, in theory “didn’t work”, docs said I’d never run again (this was when running was just something I did to keep me fit for other others / generally healthy), and would likely need knee replacements.

I literally ballooned to 100kg as my maximum as I couldn’t exercise and at the time, was working way with work a lot so staying in hotels and eating unhealthily (cooked breakfasts, restaurants most evenings) and not exercising.

Got so fed up with the impact it had on my day to day and had a wobble when I went for a private medical assessment and many markers were out (some significantly) that I knew I had to get on top of it.

So I can see it from others perspectives from my own experience and when I’ve been bigger or smaller, the same overall equation holds: what goes in must balance off what goes out.

yes people’s metabolisms are different (menopause, genetic disposition etc etc) which makes it harder for some but the same fundamental principles apply.

Swipe left for the next trending thread