Please or to access all these features

Weight loss chat

A space to talk openly about weight loss journeys and challenges. Mumsnet hasn't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. You may wish to speak to a medical professional before starting any diet.

Is being Obese an illness?

803 replies

agel · 18/10/2026 16:15

Yes or No
Im really not trying to start an argument. I want to understand what people actually think/know/believe about this.

I am obese and am trying to gain some sort of control over my eating through therapy at the moment. I’ve tried diets and exercising that do work but long term I don’t seem to be able to change my lifestyle enough to keep the weight off. I hate living like this and how people treat me differently because of my size. My family don’t understand at all. My partner is not understanding and it’s seriously affecting our relationship in many ways. It seems unfair because I don’t feel I have much control over this. It’s actually very lonely being in this situation. I rarely mention the topic of my health or weight to others because pardon the pun it’s always the elephant in the room! But you can almost hear what people are thinking. I hate the judgemental looks and comments. I rarely go out now because of anxiety and panic attacks brought on by this situation.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:14

OrangeBlaze · 25/10/2026 23:01

The dystopian part was your suggestion of denying healthcare to fat people. That's a genuinely monstrous idea, to force medics to let patients suffer, be in pain, maybe even die because you've decided it's their fault and is something we would only see in a dystopia.

'Medicalising' obesity though? Well, it's a medical condition. Caused as has been explained ad nauseum by a complex interplay of factors social, behavioural and biological. The latter requiring medication.

There is no turning back the clock on the modern world. And if you don't agree with the government having influence on people's lives (in a positive way - like regulating food corporations, increasing green spaces etc which apparently you don't like though as said previously removing access to healthcare for those deemed undeserving is fine by you!) then there really is no way to mitigate the obesogenic elements of the environment. It's not a problem 'of our own solving' when the only solution you will countenance is people just managing to not be fat - because that patently isn't happening and isn't going to happen. People have been getting fatter in a sharp increase all across the world over the past few decades and the only thing having an impact on that is the breakthrough of GLP-1s. That is how the problem is actually getting solved - no one has come up with another solution that works in reality.

No, I never advocated for denying of healthcare. Just the charging for it when it’s the direct result of preventable issus. Very different, and one that treats adults as adults: both those incurring the unnecessary costs and those others currently having to foot the bill for it.

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 07:16

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:14

No, I never advocated for denying of healthcare. Just the charging for it when it’s the direct result of preventable issus. Very different, and one that treats adults as adults: both those incurring the unnecessary costs and those others currently having to foot the bill for it.

Where does that stop

do we not pay for maternity care as no one needs to get pregant,
do we not pay for cancer treatment jf someone ate upf food
do we not treat broken bones if someone played a sport

or is it just fat people you wish not to pay for,

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I beg to differ. There isn’t some great all powerful entity in the ether that’s forced us to construct society the way we have (high density foods, low physical activity) nor forced people to continue to eat beyond their calorific requirements.

It’s a peculiar suggestion to imply there is: what else is outwith our control?

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 07:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:31

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 07:16

Where does that stop

do we not pay for maternity care as no one needs to get pregant,
do we not pay for cancer treatment jf someone ate upf food
do we not treat broken bones if someone played a sport

or is it just fat people you wish not to pay for,

We’d stop at those interventions required as a result of action, or inaction, generally considered negative at a population level.

ie injury through sport covered as sport positive overall noting there are negatives (eg your broken bones!) at an individual level

pregnancy of course paid for as that’s not a negative for society

cancer treatment: it would depend. Simple examples: skin cancer due to sun beds, not paid for. Lung cancer due to environmental exposure, paid for.

The underpinning concept: if you’ve knowingly taking action or inaction known to likely lead to a negative health outcome then: a) you’re welcome to do so but b) you pick up the bill (rather than others have to pick it up)

It’s not a radical concept if you think about it and it’s already applied in areas of our life eg health insurance overseas, private health insurance, life insurance or more broadly elsewhere.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I’ve no problem with them paying for the medications themselves, I never said I did, you’ve invented that bit. I do however think it’s crazy that we’ve ended up in a scenario that means people have to do that.

Each of your examples or scenarios have logical solutions and / or are hyperbole and I’ll remind you that my “horrific regime” is common in many advanced countries as it’s accepted that the state can’t just continue to pay for decisions it’s citizens make when it’s a known fact that the decisions are poor decisions.

Ffiohna · 26/10/2026 07:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

@CoconutSwirl despite the pages of personal, honest, varied, and intelligent posts on this thread, this poster just can’t seem to stop parroting the same crap. An earlier post gave me a similar sort of comment and I have chosen not to waste any more energy in reacting as there’s no point.

Thank you for sharing your experience. I feel so much for you.

I know that I would be the same if I went on WLI. In my case wli would sort the cause of my consuming more calories than maintaining needs. That elusive off switch.

I actually think it’s a form of cruelty for many people to prescribe and just withdraw. I wish this aspect was much more prominent at the start of prescribing, really honestly brutal that when you stop, you will likely have to go back to sitting with hunger or whatever. That would provide a more truthful basis upon which to choose to start or not.

Flowers
OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 07:36

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:24

I beg to differ. There isn’t some great all powerful entity in the ether that’s forced us to construct society the way we have (high density foods, low physical activity) nor forced people to continue to eat beyond their calorific requirements.

It’s a peculiar suggestion to imply there is: what else is outwith our control?

This article www.theguardian.com/society/2026/oct/25/the-joy-of-veg-maxxing-how-to-eat-many-many-more-plants-without-really-trying isn't about obesity, but this sentence really stood out to me:

She points to the charity the Food Foundation’s most recent Broken Plate report, which showed that a fifth of UK households would need to spend 85% of their income on food to afford the government-recommended healthy diet, and that the price gap between healthier and less healthy food is now the widest it has been in over a decade.

Also, elsewhere it states that due to deteriorating soil quality, fruit and vegetables are now 20-50% less nutritious than they were in the 1960s.

Now, neither of those things are in themselves wholly responsible for the rise in obesity, but just examples of elements that are absolutely outwith our control. As food prices rise and food quality declines, an individual is going to find it more difficult to maintain a healthy diet. And these are just two aspects of a changing world. We are all enormously influenced by environment, it's absolutely absurd to suggest otherwise.

Can you explain why obesity has risen so sharply in the past few decades across the entire world? Do you think it's because people are suddenly lazier and greedier than they used to be, or can you accept that they are living in different circumstances? And that there is no going back?

The Broken Plate 2026

The Food Foundation's 2026 Broken Plate report examines the state of the UK's food industry, food system, health, affordability and sustainability

https://foodfoundation.org.uk/publication/broken-plate-2026

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:41

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 07:36

This article www.theguardian.com/society/2026/oct/25/the-joy-of-veg-maxxing-how-to-eat-many-many-more-plants-without-really-trying isn't about obesity, but this sentence really stood out to me:

She points to the charity the Food Foundation’s most recent Broken Plate report, which showed that a fifth of UK households would need to spend 85% of their income on food to afford the government-recommended healthy diet, and that the price gap between healthier and less healthy food is now the widest it has been in over a decade.

Also, elsewhere it states that due to deteriorating soil quality, fruit and vegetables are now 20-50% less nutritious than they were in the 1960s.

Now, neither of those things are in themselves wholly responsible for the rise in obesity, but just examples of elements that are absolutely outwith our control. As food prices rise and food quality declines, an individual is going to find it more difficult to maintain a healthy diet. And these are just two aspects of a changing world. We are all enormously influenced by environment, it's absolutely absurd to suggest otherwise.

Can you explain why obesity has risen so sharply in the past few decades across the entire world? Do you think it's because people are suddenly lazier and greedier than they used to be, or can you accept that they are living in different circumstances? And that there is no going back?

You’re accidentally agreeing with my post without realising it: nothing has forced the cost of food to be such, the quality of food to be such. We (humans) have created that environment. If we haven’t, what has?

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 07:45

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:31

We’d stop at those interventions required as a result of action, or inaction, generally considered negative at a population level.

ie injury through sport covered as sport positive overall noting there are negatives (eg your broken bones!) at an individual level

pregnancy of course paid for as that’s not a negative for society

cancer treatment: it would depend. Simple examples: skin cancer due to sun beds, not paid for. Lung cancer due to environmental exposure, paid for.

The underpinning concept: if you’ve knowingly taking action or inaction known to likely lead to a negative health outcome then: a) you’re welcome to do so but b) you pick up the bill (rather than others have to pick it up)

It’s not a radical concept if you think about it and it’s already applied in areas of our life eg health insurance overseas, private health insurance, life insurance or more broadly elsewhere.

So yes just fat people then,

look I think we all get it, you think fat peiple just need to move more and eat less and the nhs shouldn’t pay for tnem, for some reason you also seem to take issue with weight loss meds even though fat people pay for them themselves, you don’t wish this to be available to them.

i don’t think repeatedly posting these views could make it any clearer, we all understand exactly what you think,

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 07:46

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:35

I’ve no problem with them paying for the medications themselves, I never said I did, you’ve invented that bit. I do however think it’s crazy that we’ve ended up in a scenario that means people have to do that.

Each of your examples or scenarios have logical solutions and / or are hyperbole and I’ll remind you that my “horrific regime” is common in many advanced countries as it’s accepted that the state can’t just continue to pay for decisions it’s citizens make when it’s a known fact that the decisions are poor decisions.

Please do tell me the logical solutions to the examples I posed! And where was the hyperbole? Are you disputing the role of steroids and of trauma in some cases of obesity? Or do those get you a free pass? And which advanced countries implement this system of making people pay the full cost of cancer treatment if they're sunbed users???? That's absolutely ridiculous. No one can ever point directly to one cause of cancer and say that's definitively it. We can identify increased risk factors, but that's not the same thing. You'd have to draw a line - is it one use of a sunbed once in your life and that's it, no skin cancer treatment for you unless you can pay? Or is it five uses, or weekly use for a year, or monthly use over five years - what will you base it on and how? Did you forget to put on suncream and get burned on holiday once? Whoops, if you develop skin cancer the bill is all yours! Smoke one cigarette in your teens and foot the bill for lung cancer treatment after years of living by a busy road?

And of course, obesity increases the risk of many cancers, doesn't it? So fatties best pay for their own chemo, right? Because it's probably their fault, after all?

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:47

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 07:45

So yes just fat people then,

look I think we all get it, you think fat peiple just need to move more and eat less and the nhs shouldn’t pay for tnem, for some reason you also seem to take issue with weight loss meds even though fat people pay for them themselves, you don’t wish this to be available to them.

i don’t think repeatedly posting these views could make it any clearer, we all understand exactly what you think,

You’re wildly missing the point if your first sentence is the conclusion you draw, particularly as my examples included non-obesity related scenarios.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:51

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 07:46

Please do tell me the logical solutions to the examples I posed! And where was the hyperbole? Are you disputing the role of steroids and of trauma in some cases of obesity? Or do those get you a free pass? And which advanced countries implement this system of making people pay the full cost of cancer treatment if they're sunbed users???? That's absolutely ridiculous. No one can ever point directly to one cause of cancer and say that's definitively it. We can identify increased risk factors, but that's not the same thing. You'd have to draw a line - is it one use of a sunbed once in your life and that's it, no skin cancer treatment for you unless you can pay? Or is it five uses, or weekly use for a year, or monthly use over five years - what will you base it on and how? Did you forget to put on suncream and get burned on holiday once? Whoops, if you develop skin cancer the bill is all yours! Smoke one cigarette in your teens and foot the bill for lung cancer treatment after years of living by a busy road?

And of course, obesity increases the risk of many cancers, doesn't it? So fatties best pay for their own chemo, right? Because it's probably their fault, after all?

I won’t waste my time working through each of your examples as as I say the solutions are obvious. I will however give you a clue by way of a worked example: of course those suffering obesity as a result of taking steroids would have their costs covered as… it’s outwith their control. See? You can get to the answer yourself by applying the concept.

in control? Costs not covered

Outwith control? costs covered.

MoneyJo · 26/10/2026 07:54

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:31

We’d stop at those interventions required as a result of action, or inaction, generally considered negative at a population level.

ie injury through sport covered as sport positive overall noting there are negatives (eg your broken bones!) at an individual level

pregnancy of course paid for as that’s not a negative for society

cancer treatment: it would depend. Simple examples: skin cancer due to sun beds, not paid for. Lung cancer due to environmental exposure, paid for.

The underpinning concept: if you’ve knowingly taking action or inaction known to likely lead to a negative health outcome then: a) you’re welcome to do so but b) you pick up the bill (rather than others have to pick it up)

It’s not a radical concept if you think about it and it’s already applied in areas of our life eg health insurance overseas, private health insurance, life insurance or more broadly elsewhere.

This post is so shocking and dystopian.

What about health consequences of poor mental health and lack of self care? That wouldn't fit your tick box of what to treat for free.

What about teen pregnancies? Should we treat those? I mean it's not what society wants, is it?

I actually find this post really sick.

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 07:55

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:41

You’re accidentally agreeing with my post without realising it: nothing has forced the cost of food to be such, the quality of food to be such. We (humans) have created that environment. If we haven’t, what has?

Well no one thinks it happened by magic. I obviously haven't disputed that humans collectively make society; that's exactly why I think that humans collectively need to fix the problems - so regulation, environmental standards, better public transport, more access to green spaces and playgrounds, taxing major corporations fairly and holding them to account. Because an individual can't do anything about the fact that the apple they're eating is 50% less nutritious than it was fifty years ago. But society, through good governance, can. Where I disagree with you is that you think individuals need to fix the problems that society causes - that a person living in an obesogenic environment needs to simply not get fat. Whereas I believe that as a society, we need to address the obesogenic environment. And one tool we have now is medication, which in itself is shifting the behaviour of food corporations who are now moving towards higher-protein smaller-portion foods to cater for those on injections. So things do start to shift and change. There are so many factors we can address before we get to 'make fat people pay out of pocket for their medical treatment' which is impractical, a legal impossibility and also something that wouldn't even work.

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 07:56

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:51

I won’t waste my time working through each of your examples as as I say the solutions are obvious. I will however give you a clue by way of a worked example: of course those suffering obesity as a result of taking steroids would have their costs covered as… it’s outwith their control. See? You can get to the answer yourself by applying the concept.

in control? Costs not covered

Outwith control? costs covered.

Right, and the trauma? Is that outwith or in control?

The sunbed use? How many uses before you don't get treatment for skin cancer? Sorry, I don't find that one so clear cut as you're suggesting!

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:59

MoneyJo · 26/10/2026 07:54

This post is so shocking and dystopian.

What about health consequences of poor mental health and lack of self care? That wouldn't fit your tick box of what to treat for free.

What about teen pregnancies? Should we treat those? I mean it's not what society wants, is it?

I actually find this post really sick.

Don’t travel in that case as you’ll struggle to get medical insurance that covers you….

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 07:59

ExpectMore · 25/10/2026 22:13

That’s a really nice way to describe my concern re. the use of these drugs that I’ve not occurred to articulate in that way before: the medicalisation of a problem that in reality, is one of our own creation and thus can be one of our own solving without the need for meds through healthy eating and activity.

It’s frightening we’ve created medicines because we’ve created a system in which people can’t stop over consuming and not moving enough.

it’s very dystopian in nature.

Absolutely, especially regarding the dystopian aspect. The thing is, when you refer to 'we' I assume you mean humans in general. My perspective is through a systemic lens where the corporations who manufacture the UPFs, hire the scientists and psychologists to encourage addiction the foods and advertising most likely to get people to consume long term and to excess - well they have considerably more power (read: money) than the 'we' who make up the general population 2/3 of which have consumed these foods to the point of being overweight or obese. Just to caveat that I know UPFs aren't the only reason for the obesity epidemic however I've recently learned they are the top reason, so I'm not going to write this disclaimer anymore heh.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:00

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 07:56

Right, and the trauma? Is that outwith or in control?

The sunbed use? How many uses before you don't get treatment for skin cancer? Sorry, I don't find that one so clear cut as you're suggesting!

Another gimme for free: https://www.cancerresearchuk.org/about-cancer/causes-of-cancer/sun-uv-and-cancer/how-do-sunbeds-cause-skin-cancer

i think you’ll note it implies 0 sun bed usage as the safe level.

How do sunbeds cause skin cancer? | Cancer Research UK

Sunbeds, sunlamps and tanning booths use harmful UV rays and increase the risk of melanoma skin cancer.

https://www.cancerresearchuk.org/about-cancer/causes-of-cancer/sun-uv-and-cancer/how-do-sunbeds-cause-skin-cancer

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 08:02

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:24

I beg to differ. There isn’t some great all powerful entity in the ether that’s forced us to construct society the way we have (high density foods, low physical activity) nor forced people to continue to eat beyond their calorific requirements.

It’s a peculiar suggestion to imply there is: what else is outwith our control?

I mean my apologies for bursting that bubble, but there is indeed a powerful entity but it's not as mysterious as you might suppose. It's called money.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:02

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 07:59

Absolutely, especially regarding the dystopian aspect. The thing is, when you refer to 'we' I assume you mean humans in general. My perspective is through a systemic lens where the corporations who manufacture the UPFs, hire the scientists and psychologists to encourage addiction the foods and advertising most likely to get people to consume long term and to excess - well they have considerably more power (read: money) than the 'we' who make up the general population 2/3 of which have consumed these foods to the point of being overweight or obese. Just to caveat that I know UPFs aren't the only reason for the obesity epidemic however I've recently learned they are the top reason, so I'm not going to write this disclaimer anymore heh.

Yes you’re right I’m talking about society in general, of which we are all a part.

UPFs are horrible. There’s a few interesting articles and documentaries on them. Thankfully easy to avoid once you understand the rights and how to identify them.

MoneyJo · 26/10/2026 08:04

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 07:59

Don’t travel in that case as you’ll struggle to get medical insurance that covers you….

Why would I? What strange insurance rules will you invent in your dystopia? I have no problem with travel insurance in the real world where most of us live.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:04

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 08:02

I mean my apologies for bursting that bubble, but there is indeed a powerful entity but it's not as mysterious as you might suppose. It's called money.

Oh come on, that clearly can’t be the case, it’s a human creation after all.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:05

MoneyJo · 26/10/2026 08:04

Why would I? What strange insurance rules will you invent in your dystopia? I have no problem with travel insurance in the real world where most of us live.

Be sure to read the small print about accidents after alcohol, for example…. 😉

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 08:06

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 08:02

Yes you’re right I’m talking about society in general, of which we are all a part.

UPFs are horrible. There’s a few interesting articles and documentaries on them. Thankfully easy to avoid once you understand the rights and how to identify them.

Unfortunately not as easy to avoid as you may think. They are cheaper than eating healthily. A healthy calorie is 4X the price of an unhealthy calorie. It is not cheap to eat healthily and there is also the question of being time poor and being forced to resort to convenience.