Please or to access all these features

The royal family

Discussion about Charles Spencer's book - Swan Song : Diana, my sister , Beautiful, Beloved, Hunted.

1000 replies

BasiliskStare · 18/09/2026 13:13

I know there is a thread about the theft of some pre publication editions of this book.
This thread is more by way of a book club discussion about the actual book , the text. Threads will go where they will , but my intention is this is more for me to give my opinion on the book and for others who read it or are interested in the book to join in. I have pre-ordered from Kindle (half price otherwise I may not have 😊) But is only available on September 22nd. So a holding place if you like.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
35
AnotherSadDog · 24/09/2026 00:42

@HolidayHideaway
Which makes me wonder at the wisdom of the QM etc thinking Diana a suitable match (?) 19 & malleable? Her mother had deserted her - she was vulnerable, badly affected.

Her mother hadn't abandoned her. She had escaped from an abuser and violent alcoholic. She tried to gain custody of the children, but it was awarded to her ex-husband (in part due to her own mother's testimony).

HolidayHideaway · 24/09/2026 01:14

AnotherSadDog · 24/09/2026 00:42

@HolidayHideaway
Which makes me wonder at the wisdom of the QM etc thinking Diana a suitable match (?) 19 & malleable? Her mother had deserted her - she was vulnerable, badly affected.

Her mother hadn't abandoned her. She had escaped from an abuser and violent alcoholic. She tried to gain custody of the children, but it was awarded to her ex-husband (in part due to her own mother's testimony).

Interesting. Not how CS frames but prob that’s unsurprising. Diana badly affected regardless.

Fondmemories · 24/09/2026 06:45

ShamedBySiri · 23/09/2026 23:04

Charles would have been very advanced to have taken such a photo - it was taken in the 60’s and CS was born in 1964! I believe his parents parted when he was three, so a very clever child indeed!

She looks trapped . It's deeply unsettling.

quaintireneofrye · 24/09/2026 06:47

Fondmemories · 24/09/2026 06:45

She looks trapped . It's deeply unsettling.

It's a horrible picture, especially knowing what we know now.

simpsonthecat · 24/09/2026 06:52

I am not sure if this is the best thread as there are so many on Charles Spencer's book but I'm hoping there will be enough interested posters on this thread to read this article which I feel gets to the crux of it all. How the book has been reported on and where it leaves us, the public, wanting more unbiased reporting .

Also hoping my post won't end up being criticised endlessly by those who just want to paint CS as the arch villain and Charles Windsor as wronged against.

In other words, the article could (only 'could'!) provoke interesting discussion. Here's hoping.
Please don't trash my post before reading the article 😂😂
@BasiliskStare I hope my post and link fits in with your thread as discussion 😊

https://alternativeroyalreporter.substack.com/p/british-royal-journalism-doesnt-exist?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=919pmm

Janiie · 24/09/2026 06:56

bluegreygreen · 23/09/2026 21:25

Apparently Cat Jarman has posted on Instagram in support of the book.

https://archive.is/GrM5n

I did go to Instagram, to check it, so that I could post it rather than the media story, but she has now changed her profile to private so I can't see it.

How on earth can she support this one sided bilge? Isn't she an intelligent person so you'd think she could spot the many flaws a mile off.

Write about yout sister fine, just leave out all the axe grinding in the process.

quaintireneofrye · 24/09/2026 06:59

Janiie · 24/09/2026 06:56

How on earth can she support this one sided bilge? Isn't she an intelligent person so you'd think she could spot the many flaws a mile off.

Write about yout sister fine, just leave out all the axe grinding in the process.

Spencer said that she encouraged him because it's "the truth" , which is a very strange thing for an historian, based on the source material and lack of evidence.

Janiie · 24/09/2026 07:02

quaintireneofrye · 24/09/2026 06:59

Spencer said that she encouraged him because it's "the truth" , which is a very strange thing for an historian, based on the source material and lack of evidence.

I'm kind of embarrassed for Spencer. Fawning wife number 4 cheerleading for him, it's all so very desperate.

Here's a tip you pair of 'historians', get your facts right!

quaintireneofrye · 24/09/2026 07:11

Janiie · 24/09/2026 07:02

I'm kind of embarrassed for Spencer. Fawning wife number 4 cheerleading for him, it's all so very desperate.

Here's a tip you pair of 'historians', get your facts right!

I know! Year 7s in History learn that?. What is the source telling me, who wrote it and why? What are the facts and what is the evidence?
Very poor.

Janiie · 24/09/2026 07:24

simpsonthecat · 24/09/2026 06:52

I am not sure if this is the best thread as there are so many on Charles Spencer's book but I'm hoping there will be enough interested posters on this thread to read this article which I feel gets to the crux of it all. How the book has been reported on and where it leaves us, the public, wanting more unbiased reporting .

Also hoping my post won't end up being criticised endlessly by those who just want to paint CS as the arch villain and Charles Windsor as wronged against.

In other words, the article could (only 'could'!) provoke interesting discussion. Here's hoping.
Please don't trash my post before reading the article 😂😂
@BasiliskStare I hope my post and link fits in with your thread as discussion 😊

https://alternativeroyalreporter.substack.com/p/british-royal-journalism-doesnt-exist?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=919pmm

Edited

You lost me at 'royal journalism doesn't exist'.

This isn't about 'royal' journalism. It's about a man who said he'd never make money from his dead sister doing just that and making shit and incorrect assumptions all over the place and pretending gossiping is 'fact'.

I hope he disappears never to be seen again sadly I think him and his equally grabby nephew Harry will rear their ugly heads on Diana's 30th anniversary with some more 'truth' aka as mud slinging.

smilesy · 24/09/2026 07:26

Illegally18 · 23/09/2026 22:45

Possibly it was CS himself who took it. And his choice to post it. It clearly means something to him. And no mental gymnastics on my part. Loads of photos look "off".

Just because it “means something to him”, doesn’t mean he has to put it online. As you say, lots of photos look “off” but most people would have the sense not to post such a photo, especially given what we know about his father’s propensity to slap his mother

quaintireneofrye · 24/09/2026 07:30

Janiie · 24/09/2026 07:24

You lost me at 'royal journalism doesn't exist'.

This isn't about 'royal' journalism. It's about a man who said he'd never make money from his dead sister doing just that and making shit and incorrect assumptions all over the place and pretending gossiping is 'fact'.

I hope he disappears never to be seen again sadly I think him and his equally grabby nephew Harry will rear their ugly heads on Diana's 30th anniversary with some more 'truth' aka as mud slinging.

They are so similar. Thet both love their titles and want money and fame.

simpsonthecat · 24/09/2026 07:30

Janiie · 24/09/2026 07:24

You lost me at 'royal journalism doesn't exist'.

This isn't about 'royal' journalism. It's about a man who said he'd never make money from his dead sister doing just that and making shit and incorrect assumptions all over the place and pretending gossiping is 'fact'.

I hope he disappears never to be seen again sadly I think him and his equally grabby nephew Harry will rear their ugly heads on Diana's 30th anniversary with some more 'truth' aka as mud slinging.

This may not be about 'royal' journalism to you. However there are very many different aspects about this book coming out and how it is reported on that is relevant. I am discussing on the reporting of said book.
I know you can't abide CS or Harry, that much is clear. However, that's not what my post is about.

Janiie · 24/09/2026 07:31

smilesy · 24/09/2026 07:26

Just because it “means something to him”, doesn’t mean he has to put it online. As you say, lots of photos look “off” but most people would have the sense not to post such a photo, especially given what we know about his father’s propensity to slap his mother

Yes it again demonstrates Spencers cluelessness. To post a pic of his father having his dm in such a tight grip. The look on her face. It's just absolutely a very disturbing snap shot isn't it.

Janiie · 24/09/2026 07:36

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

myrtleWilson · 24/09/2026 07:36

A Substack that calls people “cultists” is rolled out as an invitation to discuss the public’s need for unbiased reporting…. a bold approach as our legal eagles may say.

Janiie · 24/09/2026 07:43

The tabloids paid him*

Thegirlwhowent · 24/09/2026 07:58

noonames · 23/09/2026 08:39

Or better still, that PP could actually have a little think and come up with their own response 🤔

True. But you need to find some reliable sources for the basic information first - for which you'd probably use the Internet in some form. When AI comes up with answers, you then need to check the sources. Then you can have a think.

upinaballoon · 24/09/2026 08:07

OneLilacHedgehog · 23/09/2026 23:09

Some of you would and do support absolutely anything the royals do.

Some of you would, and do, damn the royals for everything they do.

Pipedreams607 · 24/09/2026 08:24

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

I think publishing a book about your sister once in thirty years who died in such tumultuous circumstances is entirely acceptable.

Especially when every Tom, Dick and Harry will be writing a book about her on the thirtieth anniversary of her death.

Especially when it is known that a deliberate PR strategy, paid for and instigated by our head of state, and future head of the Church of England, to rehabilitate Camilla’s image to prepare for their marriage, involved trashing Diana’s credibility and reputation posthumously.

It was an appalling thing to do to the late mother of your own children.

Please see what Tom Sykes is reporting on this issue and his interview with Phil Craig. Also what Patrick Jephson has written on the subject.

They allege that the book written by Penny Junor was one of the major ways in which Diana was smeared and that PJ was fed lots of anti-Diana intel by friends of Charles.

This isn’t made up. This is documented. Penny Junor has talked about it herself in the documentary made by Phil Craig when she faced questions from Jephson on this subject.

And fwiw, I agree with Phil Craig that this is the real reason why Charles Spencer wrote the book. To get revenge for what was done to his sister back then.

King Charles may be a happier, wiser person now, but back then he wasn’t. He had spent many years talking to pseudo-intellectuals like Laurens Van Der Post, sharing his ideas about the environment and architecture with MPs via his spidery letters, creating a benign image of himself talking to flowers, preparing for his future role, when Diana rocks up who had more charisma in her little finger and he was jealous of her immediate popularity.

I think it is excellent that these issues can be re-examined more objectively thirty years on.

Particularly as ^Simpsonthecat* has pointed out, with the British media being so biaised towards the monarchy for the simple reason that reporting on the institution makes the media pots of money. They may bash its shell a little, but ultimately they aren’t going to destroy the golden egg.

The journalists who have exclusive access to cover the British royal family's events have to be sycophantic to a certain degree in order to maintain their position in the royal rota.

It’s therefore refreshing to see some alternative viewpoints aired and this period of history re-examined in light of what we know now and I am glad for Diana’s sake that her brother’s book has opened the door for that to happen.

noonames · 24/09/2026 08:27

simpsonthecat · 24/09/2026 06:52

I am not sure if this is the best thread as there are so many on Charles Spencer's book but I'm hoping there will be enough interested posters on this thread to read this article which I feel gets to the crux of it all. How the book has been reported on and where it leaves us, the public, wanting more unbiased reporting .

Also hoping my post won't end up being criticised endlessly by those who just want to paint CS as the arch villain and Charles Windsor as wronged against.

In other words, the article could (only 'could'!) provoke interesting discussion. Here's hoping.
Please don't trash my post before reading the article 😂😂
@BasiliskStare I hope my post and link fits in with your thread as discussion 😊

https://alternativeroyalreporter.substack.com/p/british-royal-journalism-doesnt-exist?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=919pmm

Edited

In the run-up to the release of Swan Song, most of the British media fell over itself to smear Charles Spencer and failed to do its job.

I don’t think this is even true as a starting point - some are even now offering him a sympathetic platform. The papers reported with glee CS’s claims against KC3, to the point where the palace felt they had to say something. It was reported as very damaging to KC3, with the usual ‘could this bring down the monarchy?’ type questions. The press reported the BP rebuttal, then as the serialisation continued, the book seemed more about KC3 and CS than Diana. People began to suspect his motives, just as it became clear that there were also errors of fact involved. CS could have done really well out of this had he written a better book. He started with many of the public still on side. I think he lost them because:

a) people find the idea that KC3 was giddy like a lottery winner hard to believe when he looks anything but in all the contemporary footage

b) they find the idea that KC3 behaved so badly hard to believe when contemporary interviews with CS contradict this

c) many still have a fondness for Diana, dislike people exploiting her and would prefer she was left to RIP, especially by the man who said he would never profit from her

d) many have a fondness for one or both of her sons, suspect the book is difficult for them and disapprove of CS’s carelessness of their feelings, especially since he swore to protect them in the famous eulogy

e) he wasn’t close to Diana as an adult and wasn’t very nice to her either

f) people find it a bit odd and distasteful to come up with the irrelevant “don’t forget - Charles has big ears” type stories - what has that to do with his sister’s legacy - again raises suspicions that it’s less about her and more about taking potshots at KC3 (which would be fine if he weren’t pretending it’s all about honouring Diana)

g) the style and content are ripe for lampooning and people find the centring of himself a bit eye rolly generally

h) too many basic errors of fact undermine everything - why should anyone believe anything he says when he can’t be relied upon to factcheck / tell the truth

i) everybody likes to prick a pompous, privileged balloon, makes no odds whether royal or merely aristocratic

quaintireneofrye · 24/09/2026 08:31

Pipedreams607 · 24/09/2026 08:24

I think publishing a book about your sister once in thirty years who died in such tumultuous circumstances is entirely acceptable.

Especially when every Tom, Dick and Harry will be writing a book about her on the thirtieth anniversary of her death.

Especially when it is known that a deliberate PR strategy, paid for and instigated by our head of state, and future head of the Church of England, to rehabilitate Camilla’s image to prepare for their marriage, involved trashing Diana’s credibility and reputation posthumously.

It was an appalling thing to do to the late mother of your own children.

Please see what Tom Sykes is reporting on this issue and his interview with Phil Craig. Also what Patrick Jephson has written on the subject.

They allege that the book written by Penny Junor was one of the major ways in which Diana was smeared and that PJ was fed lots of anti-Diana intel by friends of Charles.

This isn’t made up. This is documented. Penny Junor has talked about it herself in the documentary made by Phil Craig when she faced questions from Jephson on this subject.

And fwiw, I agree with Phil Craig that this is the real reason why Charles Spencer wrote the book. To get revenge for what was done to his sister back then.

King Charles may be a happier, wiser person now, but back then he wasn’t. He had spent many years talking to pseudo-intellectuals like Laurens Van Der Post, sharing his ideas about the environment and architecture with MPs via his spidery letters, creating a benign image of himself talking to flowers, preparing for his future role, when Diana rocks up who had more charisma in her little finger and he was jealous of her immediate popularity.

I think it is excellent that these issues can be re-examined more objectively thirty years on.

Particularly as ^Simpsonthecat* has pointed out, with the British media being so biaised towards the monarchy for the simple reason that reporting on the institution makes the media pots of money. They may bash its shell a little, but ultimately they aren’t going to destroy the golden egg.

The journalists who have exclusive access to cover the British royal family's events have to be sycophantic to a certain degree in order to maintain their position in the royal rota.

It’s therefore refreshing to see some alternative viewpoints aired and this period of history re-examined in light of what we know now and I am glad for Diana’s sake that her brother’s book has opened the door for that to happen.

Edited

Hopefully one which has better fact checking and good source material.

Pipedreams607 · 24/09/2026 08:33

quaintireneofrye · 24/09/2026 08:31

Hopefully one which has better fact checking and good source material.

Interesting that you ignore everything in my post and that’s your reply.

FWIW I agree that Penguin should have done a better job.

(Edited.)

quaintireneofrye · 24/09/2026 08:36

Pipedreams607 · 24/09/2026 08:33

Interesting that you ignore everything in my post and that’s your reply.

FWIW I agree that Penguin should have done a better job.

(Edited.)

Edited

Interesting that you infer my choosing not to directly respond to it as "ignoring".

Wewinnow · 24/09/2026 08:38

simpsonthecat · 24/09/2026 06:52

I am not sure if this is the best thread as there are so many on Charles Spencer's book but I'm hoping there will be enough interested posters on this thread to read this article which I feel gets to the crux of it all. How the book has been reported on and where it leaves us, the public, wanting more unbiased reporting .

Also hoping my post won't end up being criticised endlessly by those who just want to paint CS as the arch villain and Charles Windsor as wronged against.

In other words, the article could (only 'could'!) provoke interesting discussion. Here's hoping.
Please don't trash my post before reading the article 😂😂
@BasiliskStare I hope my post and link fits in with your thread as discussion 😊

https://alternativeroyalreporter.substack.com/p/british-royal-journalism-doesnt-exist?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=919pmm

Edited

Yeah, why hasn’t anyone asked King Charles whether he said what Charles Spencer says he did?
I agree with this part of your post: Journalists should have, at this point (they still could and should), pushed the Palace and Charles Windsor personally for a response, preferably in the same manner as Charles Spencer has spoken with the media. Surely, the first question would be
“What did you say to Charles Spencer?” Then perhaps various follow-ups on tone, etc., to gauge how a possible miscommunication, if indeed there was one, might have occurred? It’s hardly investigative journalism and seems basic to me. It’s also entirely possible Spencer is telling the truth.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.