I’ve been following all your comments since the start of series when I watched on catch up - thank you! It’s part of my strictly habit...I pause after each couple and catch up on your comments
Just started watching half way through last year.
I was disappointed in Michelle and Gio tonight. I think potentially I was expecting much more as there was so much hype surrounding their dance all week
A little similar to Emma last week with her CC - lots build up about it being her week etc then felt a bit of a flop. Michelle’s routine looked quite identical to one from dWS that someone linked to earlier in week - is it a direct copy of something else then?! There was another one posted that didn’t have the ball costumes and looked fab. I was just expecting a bit more.
Thought Karim was good but I can’t quite take to him as much as I feel I should given his dance skills. He seems too hyper, the heart hands are so annoying (didn’t notice many tonight though!) and he does seem to have his face on the screen muscling in on those time with Claudia. I don’t think he’s doing on purpose - I think he’s genuinely trying to congratulate others but he needs to WAIT until they have their moment to shine with Claud (esp last week with Kelvin).
Kelvin & Oti were amazing especially on second watching. He deserves higher score that Karmin (but not 40). Hope he’s first 40 seems genuinely decent guy. Think he’s been quite embarrassed by the whole hips thing.
I loved Chris tonight and I adore Karen and her hair and style. I think he’s just having fun and he’s really improved.
Emma & Anton I loved too. Especially her shocked expression at her 10s. Having not watched for long I don’t know all the old Anton history but he’s quite a character 
Saffron I just can’t take to. She’s inoffensive but doesn’t seem to be memorable. The music was stuck in my head for ages after the show though but not her dance. AJ just always seems to be “on” I never feel like he’s speaking genuinely it’s all a bit of a performance with ever sentence thought out even on the VTs. He seems extremely talented for his age though - the judges always seem to direct specific positive comments towards him (rather than his celebrity) which they don’t do as much to the other pros.
And finally Alex - probably a little controversial but I’m not sure I do like her
It’s all a bit too much huge smiles “I love this” even on ITT it’s not fake as such I think she’s being genuine but it’s somehow isn’t sitting right with me either 
Judges - as a relative newbie Bruno isn’t annoying to me but I could see how he would be after many many years of his big performance critiques. Shirley is decent but does seem to take against people and her tone can be awful (thinking to Emma few weeks ago!). Craig is the one that seems more realistic/serious with his scoring (and I know NOTHING about dancing but he seems like he’s marking properly). Motsi...she’s disappointment me and I feel sad. She started brilliantly but never seems to say anything helpful/relevant and is OTT is her praise at time (eh tonight to Karim!)
Group dance was a bit blah. I LOVED the one few weeks ago with fame theme. I like being able to see the dancers properly too.
Sorry that’s so long ☺️