I'm not convinced the producers have decided yet who got Lucille.
The cast are saying they don't yet know ( except Norman Reedus but then he does so much social media and gives so many interviews he probably doesn't remember what he says half the time - less is more, Norman, less is more).
I can just imagine the writers room right now with everyone coming up with possible solutions, all the while trying to please Kirkman, Gimple, the money men, the games company, the advertising buyers, comic.con etc.