Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Secondary schools to stop teaching GCSE early

123 replies

xuanve · 10/11/2026 08:19

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c680z89dk827o
Are there people like me who think the increasing disengagement in Year 7 to Year 9 is due to the lack of structured learning that GCSE program offers, rather than the other way round? My children become much more engaged when they can drop subjects that they have no interest in and focus on the ones they like best and will continue doing throughout secondary years.

Students sit at individual desks as they sit an exam in a hall.

Secondary schools told to stop teaching GCSEs before Year 10

The government says pupils in Year 7 to 9 should have "richer, more engaging" learning than preparing for GCSEs.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c680z89dk827o

OP posts:
Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 20:51

I mean you are quickly at 12: 2 English, 3 for triple science, standard maths, (further or ad maths or stats), history, geography, music, and 2 languages. DS1 also did DT. I mean you are very quickly at 11-12. Oh well and they all had to do RS at their schools in year 10. So actually with that one they did more. I just let them do what they wanted.

I mean I guess if they all had just done standard maths and double science and just geography and one language it would have been easier. But they didn’t want to, nor did most of their friends and mostly the grammar schools they went to pretty much only offered triple science. And everyone knows that if you want to do Further Maths at their schools at A level doing the further maths GCSEs is helpful.

Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 21:00

But back to the topic, DS2 (my youngest) school does a very wide range of subjects in years 7&8 and not that many science or maths lessons. They then currently do lots of science lessons from year 9 and a bit more maths (the boys come in very advanced in maths as a cohort into year 7). So if they aren’t allowed to do their current thing, they will presumably just end up doing more science in years 7&8 again as ultimately it is a STEM and medicine heavy school so they cannot just go ignore the sciences, just because the Government ordained it - so something else will have to give earlier in terms of hours allocated. The way they have structured the curriculum works for their own typical cohort, it is done that way for a reason. It is sad that some schools are having to narrow too early but presumably they do that because they feel they cannot otherwise get enough of their kids to pass Maths and English GCSEs and ordaining them to do more not less without extra funding, will that actually to lead to more passes in the two most important subjects to access literacy and numeracy required by modern society? I doubt it.

mids2019 · Yesterday 06:04

ParentOfOne · 10/11/2026 12:33

@clary They have removed the questions in TL from the reading and listening papers so all are asked and answered in English. On the writing paper the questions again are in English not TL

Honestly, if after 5 years of studying a foreign language (from Y7 to Y11), students still need the questions to be in English, it's not a great sign.

We may be doing well in other subjects, eg if you believe the PISA tests are reliable and representative, but requiring questions in English after 5 years of FL is terrible.

For example, is it true (I'll confess I'm not sure) that, at Spanish GCSE, the subjunctive is required only for the higher tier, and, even there, only in limited form, so that many students just memorise the most common forms without really understanding it?

To my mind in a diverse UK with many people being bilingual anyway forcing children to learn a modern western European language does not make sense. In many inner city areas there are probably children fluent in a range of middle eastern and Asian languages who would wish to take this language as a formal GCSE (as they would be presumably good at it) and yet are denied the choice because of outraged views on language teaching from a less globalised era. I know a daughter of Polish immigrants whose daughter is doing a Polish GCSE privately and is on unsurprisingly for a grade 9/ Does this make her particularly academic or just lucky enough to have been brought up in a household with 2 languages spoken...I tend towards the latter.

the elephant in the room with MFL is that English is effectively the world's second language and we should recognize this fact and focus very much on English and not MFL. (We also have Google translate which although inefficient does a reasonable job if you do need to speak French or Spanish).

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 08:29

MFL is the main subject DD doesn't enjoy and as Araminta explained it feels she would have had a better time schedule-wise without it. I enjoyed French at school but you are lucky if you can have a full conversation without them switching to English (I pride myself on people saying that my accent is good) but DD has no desire to speak in English let alone abroad! I do think perhaps with computing, wellbeing and the requirement for triple science kids are being forced out of the subjects that can give light relief such as drama, music and art.

I also feel DD and peers only have vague ideas on what jobs there are, despite having more by y11 than we did in the 90s. I am confident that if more kids had a plan or idea of an area they wanted to work in, doing the GCSE work would make more sense to them. It is the despair of having no idea that makes it all seem pointless to a large % of the cohort. Maybe y7&8 could focus more on the industries and realistic job roles and requirements.

ParentOfOne · Yesterday 08:41

@mids2019 In many inner city areas there are probably children fluent in a range of middle eastern and Asian languages who would wish to take this language as a formal GCSE (as they would be presumably good at it) and yet are denied the choice because of outraged views on language teaching from a less globalised era

Are you sure that there truly is as much demand as you say? How can you be so sure?

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 08:47

ParentOfOne · Yesterday 08:41

@mids2019 In many inner city areas there are probably children fluent in a range of middle eastern and Asian languages who would wish to take this language as a formal GCSE (as they would be presumably good at it) and yet are denied the choice because of outraged views on language teaching from a less globalised era

Are you sure that there truly is as much demand as you say? How can you be so sure?

I thought they would already do this? DD's school has a large population of overseas pupils who take a GCSE in their native language the year before in many cases. I always assumed the state sector provided the same but actually logically they may not be able to tutor for the different languages in the same way. I think some of the girls do online tutoring but it would be a funding issue I suspect. That does seem to be an area there could be improvements. Easier perhaps for large groups of say Polish or Ukrainian kids than other countries though. I do think it gives a boost and having one out of the way before taking the rest is a relief by all accounts.

ParentOfOne · Yesterday 08:54

There are also different opinions on the merits of teaching languages which are so different from ours (the US State Department classifies languages by level of difficulty for a native English speaker diplomat to learn, for example).

Some say it makes little sense to study Chinese, Korean, Arabic, because they are so different and difficult that, even after 5 years of study, most kids will have only learn the very very basics.
Some disagree and say that, even if kids don't become proficient in 5 years, it's still worthwhile, still an introduction, etc

I know nothing about these languages so I don't have an opinion myself.

CatatonicLadybug · Yesterday 10:44

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 08:47

I thought they would already do this? DD's school has a large population of overseas pupils who take a GCSE in their native language the year before in many cases. I always assumed the state sector provided the same but actually logically they may not be able to tutor for the different languages in the same way. I think some of the girls do online tutoring but it would be a funding issue I suspect. That does seem to be an area there could be improvements. Easier perhaps for large groups of say Polish or Ukrainian kids than other countries though. I do think it gives a boost and having one out of the way before taking the rest is a relief by all accounts.

Some state schools definitely do this. At a large and poorly performing comprehensive, we had two after school clubs that were GCSEs in languages that were spoken at home for at least a classroom worth of students. One was taught by a member of staff who also happened to be a native speaker but otherwise taught a STEM subject; the other was taught by a member of the community who was a native speaker with a degree in something other than that language and education. She was hired as an instructor rather than a teacher and didn't work at the school the rest of the time - similar contract to the instrumental music teachers but for a whole class rather than private lessons.

Students all scored well so it helped the school's results. Because it was a poorly performing school, it was also often quite helpful to the students to have a strong pass in their results.

It did take some community outreach and admin creativity to set it up, which I realise is now even more challenging to come by than when their programme started, but it does exist and it can be done at a state school if there is a student group who would benefit.

Owlbookend · Yesterday 11:23

School isn't supposed to be an 11 year training programme for work nor is it supposed to be just about just studying your preferred subjects. It should be an education (or at least I think it should) covering both key maths and literacy skills, but also exposure to science, humanties, technology and the arts. A broad curriculum is important for everyone.
The issue with 3 year KS4s is that the breadth is cut-off very early. Students already drop subjects earlier than in most other countries when you take options in Y9, but when you take them in Y8 you are dropping them very, very early. My DD was never going to take music or drama to GCSE for example, but im glad she got to explore them at KS3. Keeping a broad curriculum in Y7-9 doesnt mean you dont teach advanced content. Maths, science & some other subjects started GCSE content before Y10 in her comprehensive, but they kept they broader curriculum offer going alobgside it.
I have friends with kids at grammars that take options in Y8 and run 3 year GCSE courses. I find this particularly strange for a high attaining cohort. I don't know why they feel the need for it.

Owlbookend · Yesterday 11:25

& home language GCSEs are definetely supported at DD's school. Polish etc. are taken.

stickygotstuck · Yesterday 12:24

Owlbookend · Yesterday 11:23

School isn't supposed to be an 11 year training programme for work nor is it supposed to be just about just studying your preferred subjects. It should be an education (or at least I think it should) covering both key maths and literacy skills, but also exposure to science, humanties, technology and the arts. A broad curriculum is important for everyone.
The issue with 3 year KS4s is that the breadth is cut-off very early. Students already drop subjects earlier than in most other countries when you take options in Y9, but when you take them in Y8 you are dropping them very, very early. My DD was never going to take music or drama to GCSE for example, but im glad she got to explore them at KS3. Keeping a broad curriculum in Y7-9 doesnt mean you dont teach advanced content. Maths, science & some other subjects started GCSE content before Y10 in her comprehensive, but they kept they broader curriculum offer going alobgside it.
I have friends with kids at grammars that take options in Y8 and run 3 year GCSE courses. I find this particularly strange for a high attaining cohort. I don't know why they feel the need for it.

Totally agree with this.

Education is not teaching to the test and only learning about what you fancy/find easy.

But I think you'll find most people will look at you as if you've grown two heads if you say this.

Education is also not about stressing teens out of their heads to attain high grades without an express purpose or application. But that is exactly what has become. Ask any A level student.

mids2019 · Yesterday 13:38

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 08:47

I thought they would already do this? DD's school has a large population of overseas pupils who take a GCSE in their native language the year before in many cases. I always assumed the state sector provided the same but actually logically they may not be able to tutor for the different languages in the same way. I think some of the girls do online tutoring but it would be a funding issue I suspect. That does seem to be an area there could be improvements. Easier perhaps for large groups of say Polish or Ukrainian kids than other countries though. I do think it gives a boost and having one out of the way before taking the rest is a relief by all accounts.

Isn't this a advantage given to those from bilingual households so the foreign language can't be truly called an indicator of intellectual ability?

I just think in the modern world MFLs should be deprioritised compared to Maths, English, Science etc. Being biligual to an extent is not an intellectual meausre IMHO but a circumstance of upbringing.

ParentOfOne · Yesterday 13:44

@mids Isn't this a advantage given to those from bilingual households so the foreign language can't be truly called an indicator of intellectual ability?

I think some universities ignore A-levels taken in a home language, for this very reason. I haven't looked into the details

Owlbookend · Yesterday 14:04

As far as I am aware, colleges & unis dont deproritise home language GCSEs or A levels. There is no objective criteria for what a native speaker is & they cant infer it from applications.

There is research into maintaining two or more languages, & although im not familiar with it I think there are indications it has wider cognitive benefits.

Owlbookend · Yesterday 14:09

I had a quick look at the research - like a lot of these things it is a bit equivocal.

Araminta1004 · Yesterday 14:39

Isn’t it like saying buying lots of books/taking your kid to the library every week and reading to them gives a massive advantage in English? Or getting them piano lessons from age 6 etc gives an advantage in Music GCSE or getting them lots of paints/pens and canvas and opportunity to draw and look gives them lots of advantage in Art? Or taking them to the museum and playing radio 4 and discussing history gives them an advantage in humanities? Obviously a lot of what parents do at home and the environment the kids grow up in including diet exercise and screen time limits gives a big advantage educationally. So speaking a second language will also give a benefit, whether or not you take the GCSE in it - it gives long term advantage to speak several language. That is why all the super rich hire multilingual nannies and get their kids a bilingual or even trilingual education. Yet the working class Brits need to supposedly just sweat Maths English and Science.

ParentOfOne · Yesterday 15:15

A quick google search brings up a dozen examples, like the two below.
There will be varying opinions on how fair or unfair this is. But, regardless of our opinions, anyone considering an A-level in their home language should be mindful of these rules.

I do not know how representative these rules are.

Leicester, medicine admission:

https://le.ac.uk/study/medicine/entry-requirements/mbchb-2027
If a candidate’s third A-level is a language subject other than English of which they are a home or native speaker, then an adjusted offer will be made to reflect this if they get to offer stage. We will ask candidates to sign a declaration as to whether they are a native or home speaker of that language later in the application process.

Manchester, economics:
https://www.manchester.ac.uk/study/undergraduate/courses/2027/10224/bsc-economics/entry-requirements/

We accept native language A Levels providing they are taken in the same sitting as your other subjects. We will not accept thecombination of Mathematics, Further Mathematics and a native language.

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 16:00

Thread is veering away from the OP which was what should kids be doing in y7&8 if the gov decide state schools are no longer allowed to start GCSE's early.

I think debating which GCSE's are important maybe falls into options of GCSEs and beyond (i.e. starting Y9).

I know several of dd's peers (y11) still have no idea where they are heading or have any idea which A levels to take let alone Uni courses. Perhaps if they had had a better introduction into the workplace options - what types of STEM jobs, working with animals, working with children, working in law - all of the rest, more would have a better focus. I remember feeling similarly that we were left on our own to visiting the library at school where they had an area that was supposed to be for career planning. I went to an all girls school and I don't remember there being all that many options, if I am honest. I tried asking the librarian what a Colourist did, thinking it was to do with art in Media, but no one knew! Unless parents work in these areas I don't think many kids or even some teachers would be able to advise. Maybe the American Show & Tell idea would be a good idea with parents coming in to talk about their careers and how they got into them? Dd's school has past pupils coming back, but she said they all say the same thing which roughly translates to "it doesn't matter what degree you get you probably won't work in that area anyway" with the exception of STEM. Given that, cutting out options so early does seem remarkably silly.

MFL · Yesterday 18:08

It is indeed ridiculous to have a narrow education. Also, the discussion above on MFLs is bizarre. Why should academic dc have their options narrowed down? Clearly stem dc now get more and more options and MFLs are increasingly sidelined along with arts. We are not valuing the breadth of education MFLs can offer and stupidly we see them as vocational. This is very narrow and wrong. Understanding other cultures matters more than ever before. A broad education matters.

Choosing from 14 or so subjects in y9 down to 9 or 10 in y10-11 makes sense and narrowing down earlier is too early. The grammars don’t do this where I live. An educated workforce needs educational breadth not narrow focussed automatons.

Owlbookend · Yesterday 18:45

ParentOfOne · Yesterday 15:15

A quick google search brings up a dozen examples, like the two below.
There will be varying opinions on how fair or unfair this is. But, regardless of our opinions, anyone considering an A-level in their home language should be mindful of these rules.

I do not know how representative these rules are.

Leicester, medicine admission:

https://le.ac.uk/study/medicine/entry-requirements/mbchb-2027
If a candidate’s third A-level is a language subject other than English of which they are a home or native speaker, then an adjusted offer will be made to reflect this if they get to offer stage. We will ask candidates to sign a declaration as to whether they are a native or home speaker of that language later in the application process.

Manchester, economics:
https://www.manchester.ac.uk/study/undergraduate/courses/2027/10224/bsc-economics/entry-requirements/

We accept native language A Levels providing they are taken in the same sitting as your other subjects. We will not accept thecombination of Mathematics, Further Mathematics and a native language.

That's interesting - ive not seen that before. I wonder how they define a home or native speaker. Very reliant on self declaration, but i suppose it has to be. I have had friends whose parents didnt speak much of their nstive language st home.

swdd · Yesterday 20:02

Araminta1004 · Yesterday 14:39

Isn’t it like saying buying lots of books/taking your kid to the library every week and reading to them gives a massive advantage in English? Or getting them piano lessons from age 6 etc gives an advantage in Music GCSE or getting them lots of paints/pens and canvas and opportunity to draw and look gives them lots of advantage in Art? Or taking them to the museum and playing radio 4 and discussing history gives them an advantage in humanities? Obviously a lot of what parents do at home and the environment the kids grow up in including diet exercise and screen time limits gives a big advantage educationally. So speaking a second language will also give a benefit, whether or not you take the GCSE in it - it gives long term advantage to speak several language. That is why all the super rich hire multilingual nannies and get their kids a bilingual or even trilingual education. Yet the working class Brits need to supposedly just sweat Maths English and Science.

To a certain extent, the examples you gave share a similar logic with language subjects, though there are subtle differences. To take an extreme example, if an overseas student from France takes French A-level as one of their subjects, it will naturally be discounted even if officially accepted, simply because it fails to demonstrate the ability to learn a "foreign language."
Looking at it from a reciprocal perspective, bilingual children whose parents are not native British speakers naturally have a smaller English vocabulary than native monolingual British children, even though their combined vocabulary across both languages is significantly larger. Therefore, if there were absolute fairness, bilingual children ought to receive extra credit for their English (for instance, I would like my bilingual daughter to be awarded extra points in English for the 11+ and future GCSEs). Of course, we cannot iron out every environmental unfairness, so judging broadly by outcomes is a form of fairness I can accept.

Bunnycat101 · Yesterday 21:22

There is a massive difference between a selective cohort doing maths gcse a year early (where most of the kids will get 9 then move into a-level prep) versus schools which were sitting something like English lit in year 10 to get it out the way. I just can’t see that that ever really benefited the kids as essay subjects build and require maturity to write well, develop arguments and positions etc.

I’m not sure you can apply the same principles to very selective schools and those catering to a broader cohort.

MFL · Yesterday 21:27

Yes but lots of bilingual dc have one British parent but the other foreign parent teaches the MFL. Some of these dc are very bright and Oxford certainly doesn’t say no to them. They speak English at school and MFL at home. Even better if parents are teachers. How would the courses know a parent is from, say Germany, and a teacher, if the family name was British. Their A level
in the mfl isn't discounted.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page