With the English lit papers (as well as several other subjects) there is an intersection of two problems. Everything (or almost everything) being exam papers leads to exam-led teaching, high stress levels, and a repetitive curriculum. Bringing coursework back into focus leads to a huge amount of AI-generated work that doesn’t correctly evaluate work students can produce on their own. This is a serious conundrum of current teaching. Years ago there were students who would cheat and either copy a classmate or a sample answer they thought the teacher wouldn’t spot, but that was rare and a significant risk for the student to take. AI is easily accessible and normalised, so there’s more of it and many honestly don’t see a problem with using it for coursework so there’s far more of it happening. Some even think it doesn’t ‘count’ if they use AI to generate a summary outline, but that’s actually an entire key skill you should be learning in the GCSE course so if you’re getting a robot to do that then… it’s not your work. So then we swing back to it will all have to be in the exam hall, and now there’s pressure to teach to the test. It’s like two doors that open into each other (and make you hit your head in the process)!
To answer a PP’s question about academies choosing to ignore the guidance, yes they could and then if the DfE was mad enough about it, they could reinstate year 9 SATs. That would force GCSE material to start no earlier than summer term of year 9, at the expense of more test prep teaching in KS3, so I would guess they do not intend to follow that path but it is an option on the back burner if the academies largely choose not to play ball.
The problem with the guidance is its detachment from reality. Having a wider curriculum across KS3 is ideal and wonderful and would definitely lead to a more enriched and engaged student population. But it requires things schools don’t have and the guidance doesn’t give: money and expertise. I’ve taught in a tiny indie secondary and a massive comprehensive. In the tiny school, you needed one person who could teach multiple enrichment subjects, so a very small pool of potential teachers. Yes you can replace one of those gems with two or three part timers, but schools need full timers to uphold their pastoral care and curriculum development, so you can’t do that indefinitely really. The large school could manage a full time post fine, but then that one teacher saw basically 1500 students, seeing each once a fortnight. It makes assessment incredibly wobbly as it is simply too much information for one person to
process accurately. Which made the staffing for these positions an absolute revolving door and progress and attainment in those subjects suffered greatly as a result.
There are so many things the Conservatives stripped from education that I really want to see returned that I’m glad to see this guidance but it needs a bigger plan of action to see real change.