Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Secondary schools to stop teaching GCSE early

123 replies

xuanve · 10/11/2026 08:19

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c680z89dk827o
Are there people like me who think the increasing disengagement in Year 7 to Year 9 is due to the lack of structured learning that GCSE program offers, rather than the other way round? My children become much more engaged when they can drop subjects that they have no interest in and focus on the ones they like best and will continue doing throughout secondary years.

Students sit at individual desks as they sit an exam in a hall.

Secondary schools told to stop teaching GCSEs before Year 10

The government says pupils in Year 7 to 9 should have "richer, more engaging" learning than preparing for GCSEs.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c680z89dk827o

OP posts:
ParentOfOne · 10/11/2026 12:33

@clary They have removed the questions in TL from the reading and listening papers so all are asked and answered in English. On the writing paper the questions again are in English not TL

Honestly, if after 5 years of studying a foreign language (from Y7 to Y11), students still need the questions to be in English, it's not a great sign.

We may be doing well in other subjects, eg if you believe the PISA tests are reliable and representative, but requiring questions in English after 5 years of FL is terrible.

For example, is it true (I'll confess I'm not sure) that, at Spanish GCSE, the subjunctive is required only for the higher tier, and, even there, only in limited form, so that many students just memorise the most common forms without really understanding it?

clary · 10/11/2026 12:53

I am not an expert in Spanish and have only ever taught it at KS3 so I don't know about use of the subjunctive @ParentOfOne .

I do know that in French GCSE for example, there is no need to use the subjunctive at all – you could gain 100% without using it. Most French people that I have come across avoid it tho – they will say "il faut aller" rather than "il faut que j'aille".

Obviously there will be some (many?) nuances of the language that are not needed for GCSE – in the same way that you don't need, I dunno, calculus, for GCSE maths (or do you? I know I only did it as an intro to A level). It would be foolish to suggest otherwise. Using the conditional in German is a way to win extra marks for range of language. It's not as prescriptive tho as "you must use conditional in the writing paper to get the top mark, thank goodness.

I don't agree btw that MFL GCSE is dumbed down. As I say, the GBs are higher and the same skills and level of skill is needed. I think it was felt that TL instructions were putting off some of the weaker students. I have certainly had students who baulked at a written question because they didn't fully understand it. Yes they needed to learn to work through that and I did teach resilience in those areas. Still though. MFL is traditionally one of the GCSE (and A level) subjects that many YP "hate" and don’t want to take, and do badly at. I know a number of YP who have a rogue grade of 2 or 3 for their MFL amid 5-6-7-8 grades. So maybe the aim is to make them less afraid of having a go. They still need to write and speak in the language, and to the same level.

I also don't agree that doing two or three papers on the same subject is no harder than doing one. It would be a lot easier for the YP studying English lit if they only had to learn about AIC and the poems, and could skip the paper on R&J and ACC. In French, I imagine a lot of YP would love not to take the listening paper.

Ubertomusic · 10/11/2026 12:54

Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 12:31

Genuine curiosity.....
Do they study all the different subjects at the same time or do they do a term of one, then switch to another the next term?
How many times a week do they have a lesson in each subject?

There is no rotation so all at the same time. I don't know the number of hours per subject or the structure and content of humanities. STEM is very easy to compare though and I know for a fact that our friends at top private schools in the UK are doing the same level at roughly the same age so it is perfectly doable. However, they don't sit their GCSE early as they are targeting Oxbridge and it's not quite clear if sitting a lot of GCSE in y8-10 would be viewed unfavourably, even with top marks achieved. Our home educated friends in the UK sat the majority of core GCSE (eng-maths-three sciences-humanity-CS) aged around 13-14 with top marks, but the university rules may be different for HE.

ParentOfOne · 10/11/2026 13:04

@clary Most French people that I have come across avoid it tho – they will say "il faut aller" rather than "il faut que j'aille".

That's very different in Spanish - for some reason, which has always intrigued me, even the humblest and least educated Spanish speakers tend to use the subjunctive correctly, and this is quite a difference vs other Latin-derived languages. Plus, subjunctive in Spanish is used also in temporal clauses, eg. "call me when you arrive" --> arrive: subjunctive. So not requiring it after 5 years of studying Spanish is IMHO inexcusable - it's not a nuance at all.

clary · 10/11/2026 13:07

I bow to your much superior knowledge on this point. The spec asks for subjunctive at higher tier for specific verbs only, as you noted.

I am not sure what the equivalent would be for French and German? Subjunctive is not mentioned in the French spec at all.

Ubertomusic · 10/11/2026 13:33

@clary
It would be a lot easier for the YP studying English lit if they only had to learn about AIC and the poems, and could skip the paper on R&J and ACC.

I think an educated person should read widely and be able to understand complex texts in general, not just cram one text for an exam, but I get it that modern "education" is focused on something else entirely. Just like on another thread they "learn" French by parroting set phrases - no dumbing down at all in MFL 🤦‍♀️

clary · 10/11/2026 13:59

Ubertomusic · 10/11/2026 13:33

@clary
It would be a lot easier for the YP studying English lit if they only had to learn about AIC and the poems, and could skip the paper on R&J and ACC.

I think an educated person should read widely and be able to understand complex texts in general, not just cram one text for an exam, but I get it that modern "education" is focused on something else entirely. Just like on another thread they "learn" French by parroting set phrases - no dumbing down at all in MFL 🤦‍♀️

While I agree about an educated person, you I am sure can see that it is easier to learn the themes and quotes for two books rather than four?

And I have disputed on that thread that that is how I teach or indeed ever taught French even for GCSE. And tbh if you learned paragraphs of French by heart on various topics, it wouldn't help you a great deal with today's spec unless a) you were lucky and an essay theme you had learned came up or b) you learned multiple paragraphs on each of the many themes and sub-themes. Which would not be reasonable IMHO.

Unfortunately lots of people (reasonably enough tbf) posted on that thread that that is what they or their DC did. Yes, my older two also did this because of controlled assessment – they knew what they would be writing and speaking about. The spec from 2018 and now 2026 exams has made that much harder to do thank goodness, and requires much more basic language ability and skills to deal with unexpected questions, manipulate the language etc.

Ubertomusic · 10/11/2026 14:16

clary · 10/11/2026 13:59

While I agree about an educated person, you I am sure can see that it is easier to learn the themes and quotes for two books rather than four?

And I have disputed on that thread that that is how I teach or indeed ever taught French even for GCSE. And tbh if you learned paragraphs of French by heart on various topics, it wouldn't help you a great deal with today's spec unless a) you were lucky and an essay theme you had learned came up or b) you learned multiple paragraphs on each of the many themes and sub-themes. Which would not be reasonable IMHO.

Unfortunately lots of people (reasonably enough tbf) posted on that thread that that is what they or their DC did. Yes, my older two also did this because of controlled assessment – they knew what they would be writing and speaking about. The spec from 2018 and now 2026 exams has made that much harder to do thank goodness, and requires much more basic language ability and skills to deal with unexpected questions, manipulate the language etc.

Well, no I actually disagree - I think it's easier to learn themes across many books 😁 In fact, friends at a top private school in London were asked to read at least five Shakespeare's works and analyse the themes, structures, techniques etc - all this in y7. And it makes perfect sense to me as you can actually draw parallels when you read more, not less. That's how knowledge works, the wider and deeper it gets, the easier it is for a person to understand and analyse new content, and integrate it into their internal "system of knowledge". Cramming just one book with its quotes is rote learning and taking it in isolation from other works, whether by the same author or others, makes it essentially a dead weight. That's why so many DC struggle with this, it's incredibly boring and meaningless outside of the exams context, and people just switch off, especially if they do it across a very long period of time.

clary · 10/11/2026 14:35

@Ubertomusic I absolutely agree with that – definitely the best way to get the most from your learning of Shakespeare. See also watching multiple productions of the same play to experience and understand the different interpretations. That sounds great at that school.

I still think most 16yos would prefer just to sit one of the two English lit papers tbh tho. I honestly don’t know any who go "oh good, we've done Shakespeare, now we get to analyse the poetry!" A function of poor teaching no doubt. I agree about the exam-treadmill of KS4 (which is why I think it should be two not three years as it goes).

Ubertomusic · 10/11/2026 15:01

clary · 10/11/2026 14:35

@Ubertomusic I absolutely agree with that – definitely the best way to get the most from your learning of Shakespeare. See also watching multiple productions of the same play to experience and understand the different interpretations. That sounds great at that school.

I still think most 16yos would prefer just to sit one of the two English lit papers tbh tho. I honestly don’t know any who go "oh good, we've done Shakespeare, now we get to analyse the poetry!" A function of poor teaching no doubt. I agree about the exam-treadmill of KS4 (which is why I think it should be two not three years as it goes).

I guess most 16yo would prefer to sit no
papers at all 🤣

CatatonicLadybug · 11/11/2026 08:48

With the English lit papers (as well as several other subjects) there is an intersection of two problems. Everything (or almost everything) being exam papers leads to exam-led teaching, high stress levels, and a repetitive curriculum. Bringing coursework back into focus leads to a huge amount of AI-generated work that doesn’t correctly evaluate work students can produce on their own. This is a serious conundrum of current teaching. Years ago there were students who would cheat and either copy a classmate or a sample answer they thought the teacher wouldn’t spot, but that was rare and a significant risk for the student to take. AI is easily accessible and normalised, so there’s more of it and many honestly don’t see a problem with using it for coursework so there’s far more of it happening. Some even think it doesn’t ‘count’ if they use AI to generate a summary outline, but that’s actually an entire key skill you should be learning in the GCSE course so if you’re getting a robot to do that then… it’s not your work. So then we swing back to it will all have to be in the exam hall, and now there’s pressure to teach to the test. It’s like two doors that open into each other (and make you hit your head in the process)!

To answer a PP’s question about academies choosing to ignore the guidance, yes they could and then if the DfE was mad enough about it, they could reinstate year 9 SATs. That would force GCSE material to start no earlier than summer term of year 9, at the expense of more test prep teaching in KS3, so I would guess they do not intend to follow that path but it is an option on the back burner if the academies largely choose not to play ball.

The problem with the guidance is its detachment from reality. Having a wider curriculum across KS3 is ideal and wonderful and would definitely lead to a more enriched and engaged student population. But it requires things schools don’t have and the guidance doesn’t give: money and expertise. I’ve taught in a tiny indie secondary and a massive comprehensive. In the tiny school, you needed one person who could teach multiple enrichment subjects, so a very small pool of potential teachers. Yes you can replace one of those gems with two or three part timers, but schools need full timers to uphold their pastoral care and curriculum development, so you can’t do that indefinitely really. The large school could manage a full time post fine, but then that one teacher saw basically 1500 students, seeing each once a fortnight. It makes assessment incredibly wobbly as it is simply too much information for one person to
process accurately. Which made the staffing for these positions an absolute revolving door and progress and attainment in those subjects suffered greatly as a result.

There are so many things the Conservatives stripped from education that I really want to see returned that I’m glad to see this guidance but it needs a bigger plan of action to see real change.

stickygotstuck · 11/11/2026 09:00

FWIW, one of the reasons we chose DD's secondary school is that they picked GCSE options later than other local schools. And she still found it extremely hard to pick.

I think breadth is more important than anything else when it comes to education. But I know I am in the minority.

ParentOfOne · 11/11/2026 10:18

@CatatonicLadybug To answer a PP’s question about academies choosing to ignore the guidance, yes they could and then if the DfE was mad enough about it, they could reinstate year 9 SATs. That would force GCSE material to start no earlier than summer term of year 9, at the expense of more test prep teaching in KS3

Some academy heads are very much the 'my way or the highway' types. Take Mossbourne Academies: even after an investigation confirmed emotional abuse, shouting at children, humiliating them, etc, their attitude is still: "f@@@ off, we ain't gonna change".
If those schools don't care about investigations confirming emotional abuse, I very much doubt they will care about generic, non-binding guidance about when to start GCSEs

Badbadbunny · 11/11/2026 10:23

MargotLeadbetterOBE · 10/11/2026 08:32

Mine was glad to drop subjects that didn’t interest her in Y9. She had two years of trying out all subjects then could decide the ones she wasn’t interested in taking further. They can still do clubs in and out of school on other interests but a three year run up to the GCSE gives better overall results - as is the case in our school.

So was mine. So was I. It was a relief for me to be able to stop doing subjects I had no aptitude/interest in doing. My son said the same. His school did a "carousel" of different non academic subjects, so they had plenty of exposure in years 8 and 9, 4 different languages, metalwork, woodwork, cookery, different types of art, music, drama, etc. Nothing was missed out, but if they wanted to persue any particular subject they had to choose it as an option.

Breadth is only useful if the kids enjoy it and are interested in it. Making them do a subject that they hate or have no interest in, doesn't help them, in fact it probably worsens their school experience, as they are more likely to be disruptive, disinterested, etc.

LumberPainJackie · 11/11/2026 10:28

I was sad when DD no longer got to do art, purely because the school put computer science into the same choices group as Arts. I am still unsure why or how, as universities describe it as a science. If they did more on python in the GCSE syllabus perhaps I could see it might be creative, but really she is mostly learning what is inside a computer and bored out of her brain. She has zero free sessions at school (10 GCSEs) and no way to decompress fully in a creative way which is a complete oversight in my opinion. I can only hope she engages with it as a hobby once the stress of exams and Uni are out of the way.

Spiderbadge · 11/11/2026 10:33

In science we always started the GCSE curriculum in year 9 then they pick if they are doing double or triple from year 10. I even worked in one school where we started the GCSE content at the end of year 8! It's because there is so much content for the sciences to fit in, even across 3 years it is rushed. So I'm not sure if it will apply for sciences unless they are also going to cut the content down by a third!

Nutmuncher · 11/11/2026 10:34

I do wonder whether this is the start of a shift in education policy in expectation of future outcomes with AI and the wider automation of jobs coming in the next few years. The curriculum is in urgent need of overhauling to prepare pupils for the very different world they’re going to find themselves in.

LumberPainJackie · 11/11/2026 10:38

Nutmuncher · 11/11/2026 10:34

I do wonder whether this is the start of a shift in education policy in expectation of future outcomes with AI and the wider automation of jobs coming in the next few years. The curriculum is in urgent need of overhauling to prepare pupils for the very different world they’re going to find themselves in.

There is a complete lack of guidance from the gov on how to pick subjects that will actually lead to careers at all for the kids stuck in this pivotal moment doing GCSE's and A levels. It is almost as if they have no idea or haven't thought ahead to millions of kids taking out huge loans with no work at the end of it meaning the govt will have to foot their loan repayments. Very worrying next 5 years ahead.

swdd · 11/11/2026 10:42

Do grammar schools count as 'secondary schools' and follow government guidance? I suspect they have to take it into account for Ofsted inspections. What about independent schools?
Personally, I prefer a curriculum that isn't overly focused on exams. My argument is that formal school teaching is largely redundant in the age of AI, and GCSEs—especially in STEM subjects—are far too easy (compared to the more advanced curricula in my home country).
I hope my DD can step away from exams driven learning for the next few years and focus on a broader education with a wider range of experiences. I strongly favor a hybrid model that combines self-directed home learning with traditional schooling.

Nutmuncher · 11/11/2026 10:46

LumberPainJackie · 11/11/2026 10:38

There is a complete lack of guidance from the gov on how to pick subjects that will actually lead to careers at all for the kids stuck in this pivotal moment doing GCSE's and A levels. It is almost as if they have no idea or haven't thought ahead to millions of kids taking out huge loans with no work at the end of it meaning the govt will have to foot their loan repayments. Very worrying next 5 years ahead.

I actually think the next 5 years are going to be particularly exciting for young people, those careers that we were always conditioned to choose from for so long that are now slowly disappearing will be replaced by far more interesting and meaningful vocations. Education needs reforming because right now we’re equipping them with knowledge and skills that are likely to be obsolete.

ParentOfOne · 11/11/2026 10:50

@swdd My argument is that formal school teaching is largely redundant in the age of AI
I disagree. It's the so-called paradox of knowledge. You need to have a good understanding of your field in order to use AI proficiently, to ask the right questions, and to understand when it is telling you porkies.

That's what I see at work, and many friends tell me the same, including university lecturers

LumberPainJackie · 11/11/2026 10:51

Nutmuncher · 11/11/2026 10:46

I actually think the next 5 years are going to be particularly exciting for young people, those careers that we were always conditioned to choose from for so long that are now slowly disappearing will be replaced by far more interesting and meaningful vocations. Education needs reforming because right now we’re equipping them with knowledge and skills that are likely to be obsolete.

I hope it is exciting for them, but it should be terrifying for the government that the graduates are unlikely to find work and the national debt will increase.

It will be exciting for the trades for a bit, until people who need them can't afford them any more.

LumberPainJackie · 11/11/2026 10:53

ParentOfOne · 11/11/2026 10:50

@swdd My argument is that formal school teaching is largely redundant in the age of AI
I disagree. It's the so-called paradox of knowledge. You need to have a good understanding of your field in order to use AI proficiently, to ask the right questions, and to understand when it is telling you porkies.

That's what I see at work, and many friends tell me the same, including university lecturers

Which is great whilst the kids are in education, but companies and corporates are using AI with gay abandon. DD hates AI and refuses to use it, but that won't get her a job.

clary · 11/11/2026 10:58

His school did a "carousel" of different non academic subjects, so they had plenty of exposure in years 8 and 9, 4 different languages, metalwork, woodwork, cookery, different types of art, music, drama

@Badbadbunny I know what you mean by a carousel of subjects but I would be wary of calling any of those subjects “non-academic”. Especially (ahem) MFL :) But music, drama, DT, food tech, art, all have challenging curricula and require a good deal of work.

Kirbert2 · 11/11/2026 11:00

My son is due to start high school next September and I like everything about the school he'll most likely to end up at except the fact that they have to pick options in the January of Year 8. They are young enough when trying to decide in Year 9.