Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Secondary schools to stop teaching GCSE early

123 replies

xuanve · 10/11/2026 08:19

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c680z89dk827o
Are there people like me who think the increasing disengagement in Year 7 to Year 9 is due to the lack of structured learning that GCSE program offers, rather than the other way round? My children become much more engaged when they can drop subjects that they have no interest in and focus on the ones they like best and will continue doing throughout secondary years.

Students sit at individual desks as they sit an exam in a hall.

Secondary schools told to stop teaching GCSEs before Year 10

The government says pupils in Year 7 to 9 should have "richer, more engaging" learning than preparing for GCSEs.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c680z89dk827o

OP posts:
Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 15:05

“Do they sit the actual exams early though or do they have to wait?”

@Ubertomusic - no they don’t sit exams early apart from a couple at the end of year 10, if they really want to, and I think RS is end of year 10.

What I meant is he has been given a GCSE History topic - eg medicine through time - with the textbook and they are studying it in class and learning about it including how to answer long form multipoint questions now (open book).
In Maths when they cover topics they are also given GCSE questions on those topics, if the class is ready. When and how exactly the GCSE prep starts is up for debate. They only officially start triple science in year 9 content wise. The rest is “prep”. But of course reading for pleasure and greater depth and answering GCSE style questions in tests - what is that?
There is a massive grey zone so not really sure what the Education Secretary is getting at. I agree all children should be challenged at their level and learning should be joyous. But what exactly is taught for GCSEs and when is only part of the picture. The clubs on offer and the whole educational offering matters just as much. You could have a school just drilling a narrow set of 8 GCSEs with a very high Progress 8 and amazing extracurricular extension. That would not necessarily be a narrow sweat shop style school, it is how they have chosen to deliver it.

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 15:37

Nutmuncher · 11/11/2026 15:03

I didn’t say follow their education practices, I said China is advancing its AI capabilities significantly faster than we are. They (USA too) are light years ahead of us and unless we shift our strategy when it comes to education priorities our young people are going to struggle to compete.

As also mentioned our Universities need an overhaul too if they are to remain attractive to overseas students- this needs to be a top priority as the revenue from foreign students in terms of rent and living expenses is a major contributor to many of our local economies.

Don't you see that they are able to advance faster precisely because of their education system and methods, among other things (gov investments etc)? 😁 So we would have to follow their education practices if we want to catch up.

I don't believe we stand a chance as we simply refuse to work as hard as the Chinese :)

Re. universities and foreign students, we cannot hate foreigners, including the Chinese, and at the same time want to take their money 😂 Or rather we can of course dream on, but they're not stupid.

Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 16:21

There are 1.4 billion Chinese and top 10% of that number is still double the UK population. Out of that many people you will find a fair few STEM geniuses (and piano as well of course…), it is a numbers game. Add in State sponsoring, regulation that favours that type of progress of course they are going to do well in AI and engineering etc We cannot copy that model without those numbers.

LumberPainJackie · 11/11/2026 16:49

I also am not sure we are ready to completely kill what mental health our children have by adding the severe amounts of stress involved in the intensive cramming and competitively driven style teaching the Chinese favour. I am confident most parents would be less than impressed and in the state sector many would simply not engage in the same way that Chinese parents do, with "listen to your teacher and try your hardest"!

Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 18:01

OK well DS2 has a fair few Chinese friends or Hong Kong Chinese who can be just as cheeky and lazy as the rest of his friends!
What I do like about the motto of some of the parents of his friends is the conviction that perseverance and hard work is the most important and they will often say things like needing to have innate talent is just an excuse. Whereas our motto tends to be about privilege and social class buys success or innate talent is something you are born with. When the reality is that sheer determination and hard work should really matter most, I agree with that. I think a lot of kids here are written off by low expectations all round.

LumberPainJackie · 11/11/2026 18:15

Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 18:01

OK well DS2 has a fair few Chinese friends or Hong Kong Chinese who can be just as cheeky and lazy as the rest of his friends!
What I do like about the motto of some of the parents of his friends is the conviction that perseverance and hard work is the most important and they will often say things like needing to have innate talent is just an excuse. Whereas our motto tends to be about privilege and social class buys success or innate talent is something you are born with. When the reality is that sheer determination and hard work should really matter most, I agree with that. I think a lot of kids here are written off by low expectations all round.

I agree and think a lot of particularly immigrant families place a higher value on education and effort than some English, which is what I meant with that comment. I just can't see an aggressive Chinese rote learning style flying in those areas where parents threaten teachers for giving detentions.

Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 18:19

Yes @LumberPainJackie and I think the Rosenthal Rat Experiment (Pygmalion) is also relevant. I think the low expectations of some sections of society especially working class boys are really harmful.

swdd · 11/11/2026 18:35

Not sure if Chinese excellence in AI and STEM is because of cramming/rote learning or in spite of it! Looking at this year's Fields Medallists in Maths, two out of the four came through the Chinese basic education system. A huge portion of top-earning talent in Silicon Valley AI firms originates from mainland China. I really doubt pure cramming alone could ever get people that far!

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 18:51

Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 18:01

OK well DS2 has a fair few Chinese friends or Hong Kong Chinese who can be just as cheeky and lazy as the rest of his friends!
What I do like about the motto of some of the parents of his friends is the conviction that perseverance and hard work is the most important and they will often say things like needing to have innate talent is just an excuse. Whereas our motto tends to be about privilege and social class buys success or innate talent is something you are born with. When the reality is that sheer determination and hard work should really matter most, I agree with that. I think a lot of kids here are written off by low expectations all round.

In music it's even more obvious than in academics 😁

swdd · 11/11/2026 19:10

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 18:51

In music it's even more obvious than in academics 😁

It really all comes down to parental involvement, which is nowhere more obvious than in learning an instrument. Traditional Chinese parenting consistently puts the child's schedule and development well ahead of parental leisure, whereas British parents regularly use babysitters for adult nights out—a classic example of the cultural contrast. At equivalent income levels, Chinese parents are also more willing to curtail their own lifestyle spending to afford private school fees, 11+ tutoring, or high-level music instruction.

ParentOfOne · 11/11/2026 19:11

@swdd Fields medallists? You cannot use incredibly rare and isolated examples, limited to a handful of cases, to infer much about a population of more than a billion people

There is no shortage of discussions, including on mumsnet, on the merits or demerits of various parenting styles. I am not sure discussing it in a thread on the new GCSEs would really add much

swdd · 11/11/2026 19:18

ParentOfOne · 11/11/2026 19:11

@swdd Fields medallists? You cannot use incredibly rare and isolated examples, limited to a handful of cases, to infer much about a population of more than a billion people

There is no shortage of discussions, including on mumsnet, on the merits or demerits of various parenting styles. I am not sure discussing it in a thread on the new GCSEs would really add much

Ignore the example then. It isn't my intention to join a parliamentary debate here on UK government policy; I'm just pointing out that attributing excellence in AI to just cramming is an oversimplification.

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 19:19

swdd · 11/11/2026 19:10

It really all comes down to parental involvement, which is nowhere more obvious than in learning an instrument. Traditional Chinese parenting consistently puts the child's schedule and development well ahead of parental leisure, whereas British parents regularly use babysitters for adult nights out—a classic example of the cultural contrast. At equivalent income levels, Chinese parents are also more willing to curtail their own lifestyle spending to afford private school fees, 11+ tutoring, or high-level music instruction.

Not just that, the kids are also expected to work really hard and they do, but my point in reference to Araminta's post was more about using innate talent or lack of it as an excuse whereas in music, despite all the talk about talent, it's obvious that talent alone wouldn't take you far and perseverance and hard work are of paramount importance.

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 19:25

swdd · 11/11/2026 19:18

Ignore the example then. It isn't my intention to join a parliamentary debate here on UK government policy; I'm just pointing out that attributing excellence in AI to just cramming is an oversimplification.

I'm just pointing out that attributing excellence in AI to just cramming is an oversimplification.

If you re-read my post, you will see "among other things (gov investments)" 😁 The Chinese also have a stable gov that do long term planning whereas we have a carousel of PMs who haven't got a clue.

There was no oversimplification in the first place.

ParentOfOne · 11/11/2026 19:29

@Ubertomusic The Chinese also have a stable gov that do long term planning whereas we have a carousel of PMs who haven't got a clue.

Yes, dictatorships do have this odd tendency to change their leaders less frequently than democracies!

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 19:33

ParentOfOne · 11/11/2026 19:29

@Ubertomusic The Chinese also have a stable gov that do long term planning whereas we have a carousel of PMs who haven't got a clue.

Yes, dictatorships do have this odd tendency to change their leaders less frequently than democracies!

And they appear to be more successful too 🤷‍♀️
We will never catch up with China on AI, it's delusional to think otherwise.
Not that we need to, AI is generally overrated.

swdd · 11/11/2026 19:39

Actually, the UK secondary education system performs much better than people give it credit for. In the latest PISA rankings, the UK placed 8th in science, 10th in maths, and 10th in reading—ranking top among major Western nations, right behind the leading Asian countries. The UK should take pride in an education system that attracts so many international students. Reading Mumsnet, however, gives you the impression that the UK is the worst country on earth for education!

swdd · 11/11/2026 19:53

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 19:33

And they appear to be more successful too 🤷‍♀️
We will never catch up with China on AI, it's delusional to think otherwise.
Not that we need to, AI is generally overrated.

Given the vast differences in scale, comparing the UK with the US and China in AI doesn't make much sense in the first place (and I know it wasn't you who brought it up). Whether underrated or overrated, AI cannot be ignored. Thankfully, the UK is still right at the cutting edge of science and technology, and as a fan of the UK educational system, I'm eager to see more novel and practical AI applications emerge in UK schools.

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 20:07

swdd · 11/11/2026 19:53

Given the vast differences in scale, comparing the UK with the US and China in AI doesn't make much sense in the first place (and I know it wasn't you who brought it up). Whether underrated or overrated, AI cannot be ignored. Thankfully, the UK is still right at the cutting edge of science and technology, and as a fan of the UK educational system, I'm eager to see more novel and practical AI applications emerge in UK schools.

Didn't you say upthread that STEM GCSE are far too easy compared to your home country? 🙂

AI bubble is about to burst I think but it will remain as a useful tool for certain tasks for sure.

Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 20:22

Key stage 3
Compulsory national curriculum subjects are:

  • English
  • maths
  • science
  • history
  • geography
  • modern foreign languages
  • design and technology
  • art and design
  • music
  • physical education
  • citizenship
  • computing
Schools must also provide:
  • relationships and health education
  • sex education
  • religious education (RE)
You may choose to take your child out of sex education/RE

So then does it mean all of the above have to be on offer until the end of year 9?

No mention of drama currently. Maybe they can wrap that into English, oracy and drama?

swdd · 11/11/2026 20:27

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 20:07

Didn't you say upthread that STEM GCSE are far too easy compared to your home country? 🙂

AI bubble is about to burst I think but it will remain as a useful tool for certain tasks for sure.

Yes, which I feel is a good thing because it leaves room to learn a wide variety of things, including soft skills. I am against very early exam preparation for such easy GCSE stuff, which seems a waste of time.

Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 20:31

@swdd - so have you now had a kid actually do these “easy” GCSEs? I mean all 4 of mine are supposedly top 2% ish and none of them found it easy. Sheer content of it all and 11 subjects and all the stuff to remember all at once, I mean they all had to work hard and youngest has not done them yet. It is the marathon aspect of it that is difficult, the older 3 did 11-12 GCSEs all within the space of weeks and weeks of study and multiple exams per subject. They all very revising solidly I would say from February of year 11. Yes they got excellent grades but the process itself was not “Easy”, far from it.

swdd · 11/11/2026 20:41

Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 20:31

@swdd - so have you now had a kid actually do these “easy” GCSEs? I mean all 4 of mine are supposedly top 2% ish and none of them found it easy. Sheer content of it all and 11 subjects and all the stuff to remember all at once, I mean they all had to work hard and youngest has not done them yet. It is the marathon aspect of it that is difficult, the older 3 did 11-12 GCSEs all within the space of weeks and weeks of study and multiple exams per subject. They all very revising solidly I would say from February of year 11. Yes they got excellent grades but the process itself was not “Easy”, far from it.

Why take 11 or 12 GCSE subjects then? Of course, the more you take, the harder it gets. I thought 9 is OK and 10 is more than enough, even for Oxbridge—isn't it quality over quantity?

Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 20:45

Well they wanted to, and GCSE Music wasn’t exactly that hard for them but they still wanted to do it and then an additional maths GCSE and a second language as they all just like languages.

swdd · 11/11/2026 20:47

Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 20:45

Well they wanted to, and GCSE Music wasn’t exactly that hard for them but they still wanted to do it and then an additional maths GCSE and a second language as they all just like languages.

It is fine if they wanted to challenge themselves. I predict my laid-back DD might choose an 'easy' route and take no more than 10.

Swipe left for the next trending thread