Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Secondary schools to stop teaching GCSE early

123 replies

xuanve · 10/11/2026 08:19

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c680z89dk827o
Are there people like me who think the increasing disengagement in Year 7 to Year 9 is due to the lack of structured learning that GCSE program offers, rather than the other way round? My children become much more engaged when they can drop subjects that they have no interest in and focus on the ones they like best and will continue doing throughout secondary years.

Students sit at individual desks as they sit an exam in a hall.

Secondary schools told to stop teaching GCSEs before Year 10

The government says pupils in Year 7 to 9 should have "richer, more engaging" learning than preparing for GCSEs.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c680z89dk827o

OP posts:
swdd · 11/11/2026 11:03

ParentOfOne · 11/11/2026 10:50

@swdd My argument is that formal school teaching is largely redundant in the age of AI
I disagree. It's the so-called paradox of knowledge. You need to have a good understanding of your field in order to use AI proficiently, to ask the right questions, and to understand when it is telling you porkies.

That's what I see at work, and many friends tell me the same, including university lecturers

University lecturers have a vested interest in school teaching, don't they? I totally agree that you need a good understanding of your field to use AI proficiently, but I just don't think traditional school education is the only way to achieve that. In fact, exam-driven learning often defeats the purpose of gaining a real understanding, making students good at passing exams rather than understanding the subject.

ParentOfOne · 11/11/2026 11:05

swdd · 11/11/2026 11:03

University lecturers have a vested interest in school teaching, don't they? I totally agree that you need a good understanding of your field to use AI proficiently, but I just don't think traditional school education is the only way to achieve that. In fact, exam-driven learning often defeats the purpose of gaining a real understanding, making students good at passing exams rather than understanding the subject.

@swdd University lecturers have a vested interest in school teaching, don't they?
What are you trying to imply? That teaching would be redundant but lecturers don't want to admit it?

exam-driven learning often defeats the purpose of gaining a real understanding, making students good at passing exams rather than understanding the subject.

In theory, yes: this can and does lead to teaching to the test
In practice, though, what is your alternative? My interpretation of Wales' catastrophic PISA results is that a wishy-washy let's-not-worry-about-tests kind of approach does NOT work in practice

Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 11:10

DS2 is in year 8 and they already do GCSE topics in eg History because the cohort is superselective. They won’t be taking those topics at GCSE level. They will have finished KS3 maths pretty soon as well. Not sure how she expects schools like DS’ to dumb their cohort down when they are ready for more content? And when she also wants them to ace Maths, Physics and Chem and ComSci in the supposed AI race?

swdd · 11/11/2026 11:22

ParentOfOne · 11/11/2026 11:05

@swdd University lecturers have a vested interest in school teaching, don't they?
What are you trying to imply? That teaching would be redundant but lecturers don't want to admit it?

exam-driven learning often defeats the purpose of gaining a real understanding, making students good at passing exams rather than understanding the subject.

In theory, yes: this can and does lead to teaching to the test
In practice, though, what is your alternative? My interpretation of Wales' catastrophic PISA results is that a wishy-washy let's-not-worry-about-tests kind of approach does NOT work in practice

That teaching would be redundant but lecturers don't want to admit it?
Unfortunately, yes.
Big lecture attendance at top unis is down to 20-40% now. Students just prefer AI-powered self-study over traditional lectures.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/06/10/students-have-stopped-going-to-lectures/

www.timeshighereducation.com/news/students-missing-twice-much-teaching-time-20-years-ago

In practice, though, what is your alternative?
I’m definitely not giving up on formal schooling and I still want my DD to go to a grammar school! But I do take traditional schooling with a pinch of salt. In the AI era, school just isn't as central as it used to be. Super-curriculars, self-learning at home, and playing with new tech are just as important now. When AI can explain things better than a teacher, the old classroom model naturally loses some of its value.

Verifying Device

https://www.thetimes.com/uk/education/article/students-miss-lectures-jobs-term-pfs9hpwgm

Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 11:26

The problem with politicians is that they always want a “one size fits all” cheap solution. And that is just not how life works. And they also narcissistically want to leave their mark/brand/tattoo our kids somewhat.

Right now it is true that society is both extremely complex to access and a fundamental deep understanding of English language and Maths is required for all, to some extent. And it is also true that creativity matters just as much in the world of AI as critical and deep thinking.

Of course, the real solution would be for all schools to have enough funding to provide solutions tailored to different types of children and what suits them best ultimately, to achieve the above objectives. But as this is apparently impossible, sorry I am not buying any of the bullshit they come up with. I trust our head teacher more.

Badbadbunny · 11/11/2026 11:32

Nutmuncher · 11/11/2026 10:46

I actually think the next 5 years are going to be particularly exciting for young people, those careers that we were always conditioned to choose from for so long that are now slowly disappearing will be replaced by far more interesting and meaningful vocations. Education needs reforming because right now we’re equipping them with knowledge and skills that are likely to be obsolete.

Whilst true, education has needed a radical reform for many years, if not decades. At my son's secondary school, they didn't have any computer teaching at all and that was only 10-15 years ago. I don't have any confidence that there'll be any meaningful change in the foreseeable future to account for AI. My son's secondary between 2011 and 2019 was remarkably similar to my secondary in the late 70s/early 80s, in terms of subject and subject content, classrooms, etc. - going around open days in 2010 was like walking back in time to my old school 30 years earlier.

Badbadbunny · 11/11/2026 11:38

@swdd

That teaching would be redundant but lecturers don't want to admit it?
Unfortunately, yes. Big lecture attendance at top unis is down to 20-40% now. Students just prefer AI-powered self-study over traditional lectures.

I tend to agree with that, given my son's experience at Uni between 2020 and 2022, where for the first two years, all the lectures were online (due to covid) and he just got accustomed to "googling" the subject himself, watching various online resources (not Uni created), to teach himself the subjects as he didn't really get on with their pre-recorded lectures as he said there was no real person to person interaction which is a lot of the point of going to Uni - he never met his "personal tutor" who continued working from home for the entire three years! Even in his third year when physical lectures had restarted for some modules, he preferred his own methods of studying and barely looked at the lecture notes. He still got a First in Maths! AI wasn't as advanced then, so he didn't use it so much, but now, he's studying to be an actuary and he's doing a lot of his "self study" using AI rather than following the BPP study guides, and is progressing well - currently just finished the first level, so about 9 out of 14 exams passed in his first couple of years.

Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 11:44

The problem is kids learn from their parents and peers at least as much as from school, and now also from AI.

DS2 is currently obsessed with building his own PC and all the components, how to source them and when given macro supply chain issues. It is extremely dull for me but he has made a huge spreadsheet. That is the chat the boys at his school have at lunch, when and how to source and whose Dad knows what and whose colleague etc and how to upgrade it and the tech changes about to happen and why and the chips and coolers etc (it is all gobbledeegoob to me really). The CompSci they learn at school is a minor part of that. At the same time, most of the boys are doing the baby EPQ already and researching heavily anything from one of his friends obsessed with Ancient Greeks to another obsessed with the democratic reforms and proportional representation to another looking at football and money and whether that is a moral space. That is what these 12 and 13 year olds are doing, largely.
Whilst some of the ones down the road at my local school are hanging out swearing and vaping and driving their bikes on one wheel in groups terrorising old ladies and having a laugh.

LumberPainJackie · 11/11/2026 11:48

Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 11:10

DS2 is in year 8 and they already do GCSE topics in eg History because the cohort is superselective. They won’t be taking those topics at GCSE level. They will have finished KS3 maths pretty soon as well. Not sure how she expects schools like DS’ to dumb their cohort down when they are ready for more content? And when she also wants them to ace Maths, Physics and Chem and ComSci in the supposed AI race?

I think quite a few schools have recognised the issue about rote learning (wasn't Tiffin going to stop GCSEs altogether relatively recently?). DD's private does a "diploma" now for y7-8 where they learn all core subjects and 2 languages and do various projects they present on using essay/video/talks. Alongside this they learn sign language, first aid, neuroscience, touch typing - life skills as well as resilience and regulation and wellbeing/PSHE and the usual house events and after school clubs.

I think thinking outside the box at that age can give them a lot of skills that enhance life in general. DD was a year off so missed out, but I can see what they are trying to do going forward.

Nutmuncher · 11/11/2026 11:55

Badbadbunny · 11/11/2026 11:32

Whilst true, education has needed a radical reform for many years, if not decades. At my son's secondary school, they didn't have any computer teaching at all and that was only 10-15 years ago. I don't have any confidence that there'll be any meaningful change in the foreseeable future to account for AI. My son's secondary between 2011 and 2019 was remarkably similar to my secondary in the late 70s/early 80s, in terms of subject and subject content, classrooms, etc. - going around open days in 2010 was like walking back in time to my old school 30 years earlier.

Schools are effectively the same as they were in the 80s and 90s which is utterly archaic in the age of AI. Education will have to adapt and rather quickly otherwise the UK will get left behind economically, China, the US and many other countries are rapidly advancing their AI abilities. Without significant investment and reform our schools will resemble Victorian classrooms - that’s happening in the next 2-3 years.

GCSEs and further education will count for nothing unless something changes fast.

PhotoDad · 11/11/2026 11:56

Spiderbadge · 11/11/2026 10:33

In science we always started the GCSE curriculum in year 9 then they pick if they are doing double or triple from year 10. I even worked in one school where we started the GCSE content at the end of year 8! It's because there is so much content for the sciences to fit in, even across 3 years it is rushed. So I'm not sure if it will apply for sciences unless they are also going to cut the content down by a third!

As a former science teacher, I completely agree that it was a push to fit it all into three years, so the syllabus would need pruning.

The problem in all subjects is that "what a person who will continue to A-level should learn/do" and "what someone who will never study this should learn/do" don't entirely overlap.

ParentOfOne · 11/11/2026 11:59

On the importance of traditional teaching, I guess we'll have to agree to disagree. The best students might learn proficiently with AI, but most students are unlikely to - nor should they, in fairness.

I can use AI to understand the very basics of a field I am unfamiliar with.
But, if I tried to use AI to calculate, I don't know, the bearing load of a construction, without any training in physics nor engineering, the result would be a high body count!

Badbadbunny · 11/11/2026 12:03

Nutmuncher · 11/11/2026 11:55

Schools are effectively the same as they were in the 80s and 90s which is utterly archaic in the age of AI. Education will have to adapt and rather quickly otherwise the UK will get left behind economically, China, the US and many other countries are rapidly advancing their AI abilities. Without significant investment and reform our schools will resemble Victorian classrooms - that’s happening in the next 2-3 years.

GCSEs and further education will count for nothing unless something changes fast.

I agree, and I think the even bigger issue is the foreign students attending our Unis which the entire sector is dependant upon. I just can't see why, say, Chinese students will continue to come to the UK for our Unis in the future when they are perfectly capable of building their own, better, Unis based around the future, i.e. AI. I'd be very worried if I worked in a Uni as I think the future is starting to look very bleak.

The radical reform of our education system needs to go right through secondary school, though to the Uni sector. At schools, we need to be doing more in terms of "manual" skills, to start to bridge the shortfall in the trades, motor mechanics, engineering, etc. I think Unis need to start offering more diverse courses, i.e. rather than nothing but degrees, they need to pivot to start doing more professional courses aimed at professional exams, rather than washing their hands of the students at the end of the degree course and passing them over to the professional/private tuition providers such as BPP for distant learning. Back in my day, our local Poly did day release and evening classes for accountancy, law, etc., for those who didn't have a degree/relevant degree - course specifically aimed at the exams of the professional bodies for adult workers etc. We really could do with some Unis converting back into Polys to give opportunities for adults!

CatatonicLadybug · 11/11/2026 12:07

swdd · 11/11/2026 10:42

Do grammar schools count as 'secondary schools' and follow government guidance? I suspect they have to take it into account for Ofsted inspections. What about independent schools?
Personally, I prefer a curriculum that isn't overly focused on exams. My argument is that formal school teaching is largely redundant in the age of AI, and GCSEs—especially in STEM subjects—are far too easy (compared to the more advanced curricula in my home country).
I hope my DD can step away from exams driven learning for the next few years and focus on a broader education with a wider range of experiences. I strongly favor a hybrid model that combines self-directed home learning with traditional schooling.

Grammar schools do count as state secondaries - they are funded by public funds but can cover more material in greater detail and attract top teachers because they are selecting students who have already proven they are academically able. The behind the scenes mechanics in terms of how schools are funded and governed is remarkably similar to a comprehensive.

Independents do not count and are not governed by this guidance. They will always take note of it but they can choose what to apply when and where and what to ignore as long as the school on a whole is meeting is functioning as a school (and if it wasn’t, people would stop paying money to send their children there, although there are other checks too). Top performing indies will merely be reading this and moving on as they have developed their own strategies that work if they have most of their students scoring mostly 8s and 9s. Unfortunately a lot of the strategy they use just isn’t practical in a state school where classes are larger and truly mixed ability so it’s mostly a non sequitur in terms of improving results at state secondaries.

LumberPainJackie · 11/11/2026 12:16

@CatatonicLadybug while I agree in part, I do think that secondary should be about more than just GCSE rote learning, which is what I think the gov is trying to do. I can only hope they do implement some of the things DD's private does to give early school leavers who may not excel at GCSE's something else to work with. At the moment the retake situation is not working for anyone. Having other abilities and skills to fall back on that aren't the core subjects would surely be no bad thing. While DD's school is a very high achieving one they are aware that the system is broken and life skills are more in demand. Dd in y8 also had lessons in budgeting (healthy food shopping as an example), which was actually something she found very helpful. I think using these years to improve public health in similar ways would be no bad thing.

Badbadbunny · 11/11/2026 12:32

We had a compulsory A level subject in our sixth form, which was "General Studies" that consisted of one lecture each week on a random subject, and a double lesson each week where we chose a "module" for each half term from a wide choice of subjects, such as history/geography (subject matter being something not on the O/A level curriculum), a foreign language not previously taught, i.e. Spanish or Italian or Latin, motor cycle mechanic (where a moped was taken apart (including the engine) and rebult in the term), art, music, wood/metalwork, drama, all as "one term" modules teaching/exploring things not taught previously, but the most popular was "general knowledge" which was basically a weekly "pub quiz" covering all kinds of topics generally found on TV quiz shows or pub quizzes! No year end exams (except the A level itself), no tests, no revision, no homework, etc., just subjects made informal and fun, that people wanted to learn without stress etc.

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 13:30

@CatatonicLadybug I agree re. Eng Lit but the problem is deeper I think. If a child reads for pleasure in primary, it is unlikely they would be doing AI summaries in secondary because it's not enjoyable. It's down to parents though to instil the love of reading, schools can do very little in a class of 30.

With fewer people reading for pleasure, I guess there will be no point in the very near future to test everyone on big novels analysis. It's a very superficial testing of some outcomes of rote learning if a child doesn't read beyond the set books in a classroom. They won't be applying these skills in real life and work. I guess literature and some other subjects (history?) will become yet another differentiator between the classes, just like Latin that was defunded in state schools. The toffs will still be reading novels whilst the plebs will get functional English skills and that's it.

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 13:43

Araminta1004 · 11/11/2026 11:10

DS2 is in year 8 and they already do GCSE topics in eg History because the cohort is superselective. They won’t be taking those topics at GCSE level. They will have finished KS3 maths pretty soon as well. Not sure how she expects schools like DS’ to dumb their cohort down when they are ready for more content? And when she also wants them to ace Maths, Physics and Chem and ComSci in the supposed AI race?

Do they sit the actual exams early though or do they have to wait?

DD is taking one GCSE in y9 as that's what her school requires to free up time for a more advanced subject, but will have to wait for two MFLs even though she's ready because unis might think she's a native speaker (she's not).

LumberPainJackie · 11/11/2026 13:44

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 13:30

@CatatonicLadybug I agree re. Eng Lit but the problem is deeper I think. If a child reads for pleasure in primary, it is unlikely they would be doing AI summaries in secondary because it's not enjoyable. It's down to parents though to instil the love of reading, schools can do very little in a class of 30.

With fewer people reading for pleasure, I guess there will be no point in the very near future to test everyone on big novels analysis. It's a very superficial testing of some outcomes of rote learning if a child doesn't read beyond the set books in a classroom. They won't be applying these skills in real life and work. I guess literature and some other subjects (history?) will become yet another differentiator between the classes, just like Latin that was defunded in state schools. The toffs will still be reading novels whilst the plebs will get functional English skills and that's it.

It would be a better use of time for schools to ensure reading time, surely? One of the main jumps from primary to secondary for dd was the lack of any time to just read. Everything was a set lesson. Maybe in years 7-8 the new rules could include reading time as an option to keep literature up. Some sort of book club where they could present on their book or draw comparisons to the set text.

I also remember General Studies being popular and surely very useful as a guided self learning exercise.

The push to stop the GCSEs being the sole focus of secondary makes sense to me but I do think the government need to explicitly fill that gap rather than leave schools wondering or set some guidance if it will be up to the schools what provisions they have. I'd love it if they could mix science and food prep for example or music and maths. So many ways to make the years excite the kids.

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 13:53

swdd · 11/11/2026 11:22

That teaching would be redundant but lecturers don't want to admit it?
Unfortunately, yes.
Big lecture attendance at top unis is down to 20-40% now. Students just prefer AI-powered self-study over traditional lectures.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/06/10/students-have-stopped-going-to-lectures/

www.timeshighereducation.com/news/students-missing-twice-much-teaching-time-20-years-ago

In practice, though, what is your alternative?
I’m definitely not giving up on formal schooling and I still want my DD to go to a grammar school! But I do take traditional schooling with a pinch of salt. In the AI era, school just isn't as central as it used to be. Super-curriculars, self-learning at home, and playing with new tech are just as important now. When AI can explain things better than a teacher, the old classroom model naturally loses some of its value.

It's interesting though that Coursera and the like have been around for at least a decade iirc but did not manage to replace traditional unis, even despite the rising costs of uni education. I haven't double checked in a while, but I remember one of the problems was that people could not sustain long term engagement with digital platforms, without real life communication. It would be interesting to see if new generations can sustain comms with AI (I personally find its sycophantic style repulsive but younger ppl might not have these idiosyncrasies).

swdd · 11/11/2026 14:05

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 13:53

It's interesting though that Coursera and the like have been around for at least a decade iirc but did not manage to replace traditional unis, even despite the rising costs of uni education. I haven't double checked in a while, but I remember one of the problems was that people could not sustain long term engagement with digital platforms, without real life communication. It would be interesting to see if new generations can sustain comms with AI (I personally find its sycophantic style repulsive but younger ppl might not have these idiosyncrasies).

School still brings three main things to the table: screening (degree prestige to prove your caliber), socializing (peer motivation, networking, and like-minded friends), and learning, which breaks down into soft face-to-face experiences versus the hard lecture-homework-exam loop. In my view, AI or even Coursera can easily replace the hard teaching part, but the social and screening value of a good school is still irreplaceable.

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 14:09

Nutmuncher · 11/11/2026 11:55

Schools are effectively the same as they were in the 80s and 90s which is utterly archaic in the age of AI. Education will have to adapt and rather quickly otherwise the UK will get left behind economically, China, the US and many other countries are rapidly advancing their AI abilities. Without significant investment and reform our schools will resemble Victorian classrooms - that’s happening in the next 2-3 years.

GCSEs and further education will count for nothing unless something changes fast.

A Chinese classroom is very much traditional cramming though.

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 14:23

swdd · 11/11/2026 14:05

School still brings three main things to the table: screening (degree prestige to prove your caliber), socializing (peer motivation, networking, and like-minded friends), and learning, which breaks down into soft face-to-face experiences versus the hard lecture-homework-exam loop. In my view, AI or even Coursera can easily replace the hard teaching part, but the social and screening value of a good school is still irreplaceable.

I still cannot see how a 14-16yo can utilise AI for proper learning. As mentioned above, you have to know your field really well to use AI efficiently. Teenagers usually don't know much when they start a subject so the whole situation is inherently ambivalent.

Blankscreen · 11/11/2026 14:27

The top private school round here teaches GCSEs for 3 years and it must be because it generated better results.

They literally cover the content in year 9 and 10 and spend the whole of year 11 revising and practising for the exams.

Nutmuncher · 11/11/2026 15:03

Ubertomusic · 11/11/2026 14:09

A Chinese classroom is very much traditional cramming though.

I didn’t say follow their education practices, I said China is advancing its AI capabilities significantly faster than we are. They (USA too) are light years ahead of us and unless we shift our strategy when it comes to education priorities our young people are going to struggle to compete.

As also mentioned our Universities need an overhaul too if they are to remain attractive to overseas students- this needs to be a top priority as the revenue from foreign students in terms of rent and living expenses is a major contributor to many of our local economies.