Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

Cancelled credit hire agreement, facing nearly £10k in charges. Has anyone successfully challenged this before?

126 replies

Goingroundthebend123 · 13/10/2026 22:48

Hi everyone, looking for advice from anyone who has dealt with On Hire, Winns Solicitors, Accident Management companies or Credit hire companies in the UK.

We had a non-fault accident and believed our insurer, Admiral, had referred us to a solicitor. We later discovered we’d actually called an accident management helpline and referred us to Winns Solicitors and have been given a credit hire car through On Hire, who hired it from Europcar. We thought it was a courtesy car and were reassured we wouldn’t have to pay anything if we weren’t at fault and cooperated with the claim. After being hounded to give bank statements at payslips at the end of last week, we became increasingly alarmed that our insurance company wouldn’t be asking for this and quickly realised our mistake. After researching credit hire horror stories and sleepless nights, we became worried about being pursued personally if the third-party insurer refused to pay (which is apparently common due to inflated car hire charges).

We’ve made the decision today, on day 13 of the 14-day cooling-off period, to cancel our contract with them, to stop the costs escalating to a point we wouldn’t be able to recover from should this process go on and on for months/years.

We have been told our cancellation charges are:

  • Engineer/estimate: £203.50 plus VAT
  • Storage: £48 per day plus VAT
  • Hire charges to date: £8,534.40

We could be facing nearly £10,000, which we simply cannot afford.

Our original intention after researching online, was to pay reasonable costs genuinely incurred by OnHire as Europcar’s online rate for the same car is £82 per day and the garage also told us their storage rate is £15 per day. When we returned the car to Europcar and explaining our station/distress they kindly showed us the invoice from themselves to OnHire and the rate is £580 per day! These figures seem outrageous!

We are planning to complain to the financial ombudsman about the accident management helpline referral, as we genuinely believed it was connected to Admiral but wondering if anyone has had any luck with this route for redress of compensation?

We’re not trying to avoid legitimate costs as we did have use of a car for 12 days, but we never knowingly agreed to this level of financial risk. I’m pregnant, incredibly stressed and we simply don’t have £10,000 to pay!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
WarmLilacHiker · 14/10/2026 10:23

Another vote for Google needing to take more responsibility. It's not just insurance, a long time ago I used to work for sky and we would always have (usually older) people call up complaining we had charged them ridiculous amounts just to call us when we advertised it as free. It was always because they googled the number and the top options were very expensive premium rate numbers. Also not a scam but feels like it should be and it's supported by google's business model

DeftGoldHedgehog · 14/10/2026 10:45

I've been reading about people who have actually been referred on to them by insurers so it isn't just people ringing the wrong number. I agree though that Google or other search providers should not allow one company to remotely appear as if they are another. And the company should itself not be doing it! It's also 'passing off' if done intentionally.

DeftGoldHedgehog · 14/10/2026 10:52

I'd also make a complaint to the FCA and SRA about your confusion and how you were signed up to the process and how (deliberately) lacking in transparency it was @Goingroundthebend123 They will likely do bugger all but the more people complain the better. The PM is also on a bit of a consumer crusade at the moment to stop rip offs. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/aug/09/andy-burnham-british-people-ripped-off-cost-of-living

Maybe try your MP or even No 10 directly?

Subscriptions you can’t easily cancel, sales that aren’t sales – I’ll end the rip-offs that British people hate | Andy Burnham

These everyday hassles are small, but they add up – especially in a cost of living crisis. That’s why my government will tackle them head-on, says UK prime minister Andy Burnham

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/aug/09/andy-burnham-british-people-ripped-off-cost-of-living

BurnoutGP · 14/10/2026 10:54

Absolutely awful and I know you are kicking yourself but I just cannot get past why you didn't get up your insurance email and call the number on it? My DD recently had an accident and did just that. Whole thing sorted including hire car, collection and write off of car, and payment/settlement within few weeks. All very easy. Yes she had to pay the excess. I hope you do get it sorted. A very hard lesson to learn.

Violet76 · 14/10/2026 12:19

Something similar being festured on Radio 4 You and Yours just now

Goingroundthebend123 · 14/10/2026 17:07

Thank you again all for even more advice since this morning! Definitely going to log complaints with anyone and everyone who will listen 🤣

Spoken with our home legal insurance today and explained, they think we should be covered under the policy but I need to upload all documents, statements and any evidence we have this evening so they can assess the likelihood of pursuing a claim. They agreed the costs should be deemed “reasonable”, even if we knew what we were signing up for (which we also didn’t fully understand). Obviously very early stages but I feel a bit better that there might be some hope.

OP posts:
Goingroundthebend123 · 14/10/2026 17:10

Newbutoldfather · 14/10/2026 08:54

@Goingroundthebend123 ,

Did you see my link to the BBC story about the case involving the same companies and extortionate hire charges?

The issue isn’t your mistake, really. That is done. It is the ludicrous hire charges.

I do struggle to believe that they can legitimately charge you nearly 10k for 13 days car hire, unless it is was some kind of supercar. It is definitely worth talking to a solicitor.

Thanks for the article, I think it was the same one I saw which set the alarm bells ringing!!!

Don’t want to be too outing but we do have quite a “fancy” car and they gave us a Ford! (No offence to Ford drivers, I actually really enjoyed driving it and even suggested we look at one it to replace our second car!)

OP posts:
Passaggressfedup · 15/10/2026 16:47

This happened to me more than 10 years ago, and it was indeed my cheap insurance provider that had transferred me to them. Sheila's Wheel I think it was at the time.

When I took the car where they told me to go, they wanted me to sign the hire purchase paperwork. I questioned why I would need to do that and they were extremely aggressive and threatening. I told them to go and get lost.

I went to a local repair shop who quoted 1/3rd of the costs. I then contacted the other party's insurance provider and told them the situation. The other party had admitted liability. They were so grateful I'd got in touch with them directly, they paid the repair company directly there and then. Sorted.

Since then, I only have insurance with direct line and manage anything including claims via their portal. They are absolutely brilliant and everything is easy and worryless. So worth the extra cost.

mummyh2016 · 15/10/2026 17:25

Try not to beat yourself up, the odds are it would’ve happened if you’d called the right number anyway. Last year I had an accident, called my insurers, booked in my repair, they said I’d get a phone call from enterprise to arrange my courtesy car. Had a call a couple of hours later, they asked me how the accident happened which I thought was strange but at the same time I was too stressed out about the crash. It wasn’t until later on in the call when it came up about me being liable for costs if found to be at fault the alarm bells started ringing. I’d purposely added a courtesy car onto my policy previously as I need a car for work. My argument was why should I be liable if I have it added on the policy anyway? I ended the call, went back to my insurers who acted like this was normal. In the end they said I could have a courtesy car from the repairers. Now this wasn’t a company I had contacted myself this was someone my insurers had told me was going to call. It’s a joke.

HarryBTel · 16/10/2026 12:28

Hello I am a consumer journalist and have been looking into this issue. Would you be free to chat? My email is [email protected]. You can Google me if unsure! Hope to speak soon

HoldMyWine · 16/10/2026 12:51

Don’t feel foolish OP, I had someone drive into me and rang my insurers Admiral. They told me the best option was to go through Auxillis who would handle everything and give me a car plus I wouldn’t lose my no claims bonus.
I haven’t had an accident before and assumed my insurers were acting in my best interests.
I had 2 years of stress after that, having to provide all my bank statements and wage slips, eventually having to go to court, coupled with emails telling me if I didn’t cooperate I would be liable for all costs. I find it difficult to talk about even now.
The court found against me and ruled that I didn’t need a hire car.
I didn’t have to pay anything as I was covered by an indemnity policy by auxillis. Although I’m still convinced at some point a big bill will drop through my door.
I felt such a fool
for being taken in by it.
i believe Admiral own or part own Auxillis and I am sure other insurance companies do the same.
it is one big scam.

Newname26 · 17/10/2026 08:32

Thats weird I've never had that amount of stress with Admiral or Auxillis.
The last time I had a bump, was 2/3 years ago like you someone rear ended me.
They queried why I needed the courtesy car, I said i needed it to get to work, collect my youngest from afterschool and general domestic stuff like shopping.
And that was the end of it, no questions over seeing bank statements or anything else.

I've been insured with Admiral for about 25 years every time someone beats their quote I phone them and they match it.

Over that time I've had various silly bumps, but never actually had an issue with them.

WildflowerMeadow · 18/10/2026 13:17

HoldMyWine · 16/10/2026 12:51

Don’t feel foolish OP, I had someone drive into me and rang my insurers Admiral. They told me the best option was to go through Auxillis who would handle everything and give me a car plus I wouldn’t lose my no claims bonus.
I haven’t had an accident before and assumed my insurers were acting in my best interests.
I had 2 years of stress after that, having to provide all my bank statements and wage slips, eventually having to go to court, coupled with emails telling me if I didn’t cooperate I would be liable for all costs. I find it difficult to talk about even now.
The court found against me and ruled that I didn’t need a hire car.
I didn’t have to pay anything as I was covered by an indemnity policy by auxillis. Although I’m still convinced at some point a big bill will drop through my door.
I felt such a fool
for being taken in by it.
i believe Admiral own or part own Auxillis and I am sure other insurance companies do the same.
it is one big scam.

This was my experience with Auxillis (referred by Admiral) exactly. My no fault accident turned into a really stressful two years where Auxillis ended up threatening me with having to pay thousands if I didn't go to court on their behalf.

The cost of the hire car they gave me was scandalously high I discovered once we got to the court stage. I ended up being grilled aggressively for 45 minutes by the other side's barrister who tried every which way to get me to admit I hadn't needed the car in the first place. She also interrogated my financials to try to say I could have paid for a hire car myself. Auxillis eventually got awarded the cost of a standard hire car which was one fifth of the cost they were charging the other side's insurers.

My barrister, provided by Auxillis, said it was rare for it it to get to court stage, most insurers settle out of court at the last minute apparently, so I had just been 'unlucky'.

It was an incredibly stressful and upsetting experience and I would never insure with Admiral again as a result. The only bright side was I had signed the Auxillis indemnity so even though they only got a fraction of the costs they were claiming I didn't need to pay anything.

Had I known what I do now I would have insisted that Admiral handle the claim themselves and just dealt with losing my no claims discount temporarily.

Newname26 · 18/10/2026 13:20

That's crazy that obviously indicated Axuillis are taking the piss when it comes to the hire car charges

HoldMyWine · 18/10/2026 19:36

Newname26 · 18/10/2026 13:20

That's crazy that obviously indicated Axuillis are taking the piss when it comes to the hire car charges

Yes from my understanding Auxilis own the car hire side of it so can charge what they like.

GooseCreekandtheRiver · 19/10/2026 08:52

HoldMyWine · 18/10/2026 19:36

Yes from my understanding Auxilis own the car hire side of it so can charge what they like.

And Admiral get a “referral fee” (kick back) from Auxilis.

Moltenpink · 19/10/2026 11:04

HarryBTel · 16/10/2026 12:28

Hello I am a consumer journalist and have been looking into this issue. Would you be free to chat? My email is [email protected]. You can Google me if unsure! Hope to speak soon

@Goingroundthebend123 just bumping this post as it could be helpful if genuine. Good luck, it all sounds horrifically stressful and unfair.

Collaborate · 19/10/2026 11:23

I had a door ding a few months back. My car insurance includes a courtesy car. The cost was being covered by the other car's insurance.

After getting booked in for the repair I got a call from the car hire cowboys. I am a solicitor and used to work at a firm where they had a credit hire department so I know how scammy they all are.

I drive an electric car and they were quoting something like £600 a day for a "similar" car. I said I would take their most basic car and refused to involve themselves in their scam.

In the end I got a Fiat 500 and used that for 2 days. I had to complain via my insurance company before the garage offered me a courtesy car.

Icequeen18 · 09/11/2026 21:54

Please can you PM me ?

Icequeen18 · 10/11/2026 15:17

It has been covered twice by “you and yours” and also been highlighted by RIP Off Britain on TV, and twice on BBC Morning Live. It’s disgusting that it is still going on. I class myself as feeling like a victim. ,

TableTopTree · 16/11/2026 09:33

You can't complain to FOS, about the rental, because car rental is not a regulated activity (despite the claims management company itself being regulated).

You can in theory complain about the referral to the accident management company but it will almost certainly be in the t&c that they are allowed to do this. FOS takes the view that if the business sent you info, they are entitled to assume you have read and understand it.

Have a thorough look through the paperwork - if there is any reference to this arrangement? If so, then I don't think your complaint will succeed. Firms are very alive to this, and usually include it in the t&c.

Icequeen18 · 16/11/2026 17:01

Moltenpink · 19/10/2026 11:04

@Goingroundthebend123 just bumping this post as it could be helpful if genuine. Good luck, it all sounds horrifically stressful and unfair.

It is unbelievably stressful and extremely upsetting. I can speak from experience.

Icequeen18 · 16/11/2026 17:04

Are you absolutely sure that you were speaking to your insurance in the first place? In my case, I wasn’t. I googled the number which I thought was my own insurer and it turned out it wasn’t.

Icequeen18 · 16/11/2026 17:04

Are you absolutely sure that you were speaking to your insurance in the first place? In my case, I wasn’t. I googled the number which I thought was my own insurer and it turned out it wasn’t.

Icequeen18 · 16/11/2026 17:09

Yes, my MP had this discussed . The more people that are made aware, the less it will happen and maybe eventually get stamped out.

Swipe left for the next trending thread