Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

Cancelled credit hire agreement, facing nearly £10k in charges. Has anyone successfully challenged this before?

126 replies

Goingroundthebend123 · 13/10/2026 22:48

Hi everyone, looking for advice from anyone who has dealt with On Hire, Winns Solicitors, Accident Management companies or Credit hire companies in the UK.

We had a non-fault accident and believed our insurer, Admiral, had referred us to a solicitor. We later discovered we’d actually called an accident management helpline and referred us to Winns Solicitors and have been given a credit hire car through On Hire, who hired it from Europcar. We thought it was a courtesy car and were reassured we wouldn’t have to pay anything if we weren’t at fault and cooperated with the claim. After being hounded to give bank statements at payslips at the end of last week, we became increasingly alarmed that our insurance company wouldn’t be asking for this and quickly realised our mistake. After researching credit hire horror stories and sleepless nights, we became worried about being pursued personally if the third-party insurer refused to pay (which is apparently common due to inflated car hire charges).

We’ve made the decision today, on day 13 of the 14-day cooling-off period, to cancel our contract with them, to stop the costs escalating to a point we wouldn’t be able to recover from should this process go on and on for months/years.

We have been told our cancellation charges are:

  • Engineer/estimate: £203.50 plus VAT
  • Storage: £48 per day plus VAT
  • Hire charges to date: £8,534.40

We could be facing nearly £10,000, which we simply cannot afford.

Our original intention after researching online, was to pay reasonable costs genuinely incurred by OnHire as Europcar’s online rate for the same car is £82 per day and the garage also told us their storage rate is £15 per day. When we returned the car to Europcar and explaining our station/distress they kindly showed us the invoice from themselves to OnHire and the rate is £580 per day! These figures seem outrageous!

We are planning to complain to the financial ombudsman about the accident management helpline referral, as we genuinely believed it was connected to Admiral but wondering if anyone has had any luck with this route for redress of compensation?

We’re not trying to avoid legitimate costs as we did have use of a car for 12 days, but we never knowingly agreed to this level of financial risk. I’m pregnant, incredibly stressed and we simply don’t have £10,000 to pay!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Graymalkin · 14/10/2026 02:32

OP, this is a well documented scam which -unbelievably- isn't really a scam but a legit practice, however morally bankrupt. DP got stung in this way years ago. What made matters worse was that after a period of DP trying to contest the contract which was infuriatingly watertight, the company sold his 'debt' to a collection firm who became intimidating quite quickly. There used to be information about this on Martin Lewis' MSE website (search 'credit hire contract scam' or similar), and we used advice from there to force them to back down in the end, but not before DP had seriously contemplated harming himself. Act now, OP, this is really nasty.

Autumn64 · 14/10/2026 02:44

The daily mail, guardian and radio 4 you and yours all do consumer advice stories which may help you.
I had not heard of this before it’s awful and no wonder everyone’s car insurance has gone up so much!

Sensiblesal · 14/10/2026 03:23

Goingroundthebend123 · 13/10/2026 23:07

We didn’t use our insurers in anyway so there is no paperwork from them. We have signed all the paperwork relating to instructing the solicitors, receiving the hire car etc. it was all sent over on WhatsApp while we were on the phone and told to sign asap to get the claim underway. Admittedly we didn’t read all 11 pages as we repeatedly asked if it was going to cost us anything and kept being told “as long as it wasn’t your fault then no”. Turns out that’s not strictly in the fine print 😢 yes I know we’ve been totally stupid.

do you have courtesy car cover with admiral & also legal expenses cover?

if not, as a last resort, do you have legal cover on your home insurance? They won’t help with the claim itself/car insurance stuff but might help with advice re potential breach of contract with whoever this company is

if admiral are now picking up the claim & the TP is at fault you may still be able to recover some if not all of these costs but it might take some time.

edited as saw your updates. Still check what actual covers you have with admiral, glad they are trying to help.

please try not to stress & let your partner take the strain

HappyHedgehog247 · 14/10/2026 04:10

I would report this post and ask for it to get moved to legal.

Amberlynnswashcloth · 14/10/2026 04:10

Do you have any proof that they told you/lead you to believe that there would be no charges if not your fault such as anything in writing or audio recording?

ukgone2pot · 14/10/2026 04:38

This is utterly disgusting and I'm sick to death of things like this being allowed to happen - sorry OP.

Your local citizens advice might be able to help..some branches have free solicitors and they may be able to help you.

Rosebud987 · 14/10/2026 04:54

Yes I did this too - and I’m a solicitor so don’t feel stupid.

Credit hire is only legally meant to be available for people who cannot possibly hire a car by any other means so any savings, credit worthiness etc. email them back, tell them you weren’t eligible for the hire in the first place and they need to make their claim through the insurance. My PA used to work in credit hire and this is what she told me to do. They need to bill the at fault parties insurance then it’s up to them to argue it.

EatingTillIDie · 14/10/2026 05:43

Definitely go down the invalid contract because you were not eligible for the hire. It is a bit like PPI. Insurers have a duty to check you are not taking something you dont need because you are already covered. This could be a similar angle to take. If you are covered under your actual insurance then great. They asked you to prove why you only needed the hire for a short amount of time well, actually you never needed it at all.

DeftGoldHedgehog · 14/10/2026 06:03

I'd get your MP involved, OP. Look at the state of this, and see the comments below. If it's not a scam, it's a racket.

www.lawgazette.co.uk/news/judge-awards-just-1200-after-credit-hire-firm-claimed-50k/5122950.article

CuteHANDBAG · 14/10/2026 06:11

REALLY SORRY but I’ve had ai do the answer with my input. I’m in a bumpy bus and can’t type it all out but I have heard of this scam (which is legal but awful) before. Ai bit …..below

I would immediately make a Subject Access Request (SAR) to the accident management helpline and all companies involved, specifically requesting recordings of every telephone conversation. Under UK data protection law, you’re entitled to request these, and they normally have one month to respond.
If the financial risks and potential personal liability weren’t clearly explained, you may have grounds to challenge the agreement. That doesn’t automatically make the contract invalid, but it’s certainly worth investigating.
The Financial Ombudsman can investigate complaints about an insurer’s or broker’s referral to a credit hire company, although generally not the credit hire agreement itself. This depends on who actually referred you.
I’d also get independent legal advice before agreeing to pay anything. The £580 daily hire charge seems particularly worth challenging. Under consumer cancellation rules, excessive charges may be assessed against market rates, depending on the contract and circumstances.

SleeplessRoads · 14/10/2026 06:18

Tbf cancelling was probably the worse thing you can do. We were aware of this when we got a credit hire car and was a bit nervous. The other sides insurer ultimately paid half of the preposterous credit hire costs and our insurer/claims manager wrote off the other half. They had told us all along that something like that would happen - so they obviously inflate the cost, the other insurers know that and they meet in the middle at no direct cost to the claimant. It is all a bit scammy, but in a way that annual premiums cover it.

You could try to negotiate with them on the basis and see if they would settle with you at a lower amount?

Blueberrybonanza · 14/10/2026 06:31

My friend did this with her driving licence, thought she was paying the DVLA and rung the first number that appeared and somehow got entered into a recurring payment scam costing hundreds more than the updating licence fee. It also took months to sort as she couldnt cancel.
Think google have now removed the DVLA and TV licence scams from the top searches now but obviously not others.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 14/10/2026 06:38

I don’t know legally where you stand but this is disgusting of them to do this.

parkezvous · 14/10/2026 06:38

OP I very recently had a no fault accident, was hit from behind at traffic lights. We are also with Admiral. I’ve had no less than 3 different companies call me to try and get me to sort repairs/hire car through them, all very vague - calling from the claims dept etc.. would have been easy to sign up for this. Luckily I was busy at work and DH was dealing with it so I declined everything and we went direct through Admiral. These companies are so crafty, telling me I’ll lose my no claims, I’ll prob have to pay for the courtesy car etc so much pressure. I wouldn’t let this go OP, as a PP said AI a factual email and contact admiral

DavidPeckham · 14/10/2026 06:41

Been there got the T-shirt and I agree with the above poster about not cancelling. I had a motorbike accident a couple of years back and got put onto a similar company - 4th dimension alongside a law firm. This was done at the roadside when I called up to report I had been knocked off and my bike was unrideable. The company arranged a tow truck and the bike got taken back to their premises. I was then offered a courtesy bike at something like £350 a day and all I had to do was sign on the dotted line. I took a good look at the contract and it had a few lines in there about as long as I co-operated with everything then I would not be liable for any costs. There was one line however that said if my claim was still going on after a year from the date of getting the hire bike I would become liable for all costs.

I rang them up straight away to query that and was assured on the phone that this wouldn’t be the case, but that was it for me as 365 x £350 a day = a small house! I refused to sign and demanded my bike back. I became liable then for the tow charge of £250 but thankfully that was it. Doing some research after and speaking with others, it does seem that as long as you play along you won’t get charged for anything. Have you read what you signed really carefully? Is there anything in there about if you co-operate with everything then you won’t be liable for costs? If you have now cancelled then it will likely be too late.

I wrote a complaint to the company and regulator. Heard nothing back. It is absolutely ridiculous how these companies operate and it’s part of the reason our insurance is so high. My claim ended up taking just under two years to settle. From a courts perspective you have a duty to keep all costs to a minimum so not sure how this would have played out had I presented the other side with a bill of £100k for a hire bike!

DavidPeckham · 14/10/2026 06:49

I think also what is most scandalous is that the insurance company I used passed me into these people as part of their process. It is really easy as I initially did to think that you are dealing with your insurers when you have actually been passed to a credit hire company. So it’s not like the insurers are trying to avoid stupid costs for one another, they are actively participating in the whole racket. You have my sympathies.

Betterbeingdead · 14/10/2026 06:50

Goingroundthebend123 · 13/10/2026 23:46

Googled this and clicked the second option, in a stressed state scan read and probably assumed the first one was an ad but not the second one 😫

Blimey that's terrifying it even looks like the word admiral at the end. I had no idea sorry it doesn't help you but very grateful you have stopped me ever falling in that trap x best of luck

JustMyView13 · 14/10/2026 06:53

These companies are predatory, it should be illegal. We had a case just closed after 2.5yrs where another driver used one against a family member. Essentially they persuaded the kid to take out an expensive credit agreement, file false injury claims etc. the total claim was ridiculous. Admiral - our insurer - noted it’s a growing problem but incurred a lot of costs fighting it.

LightDuvet · 14/10/2026 06:57

Rosebud987 · 14/10/2026 04:54

Yes I did this too - and I’m a solicitor so don’t feel stupid.

Credit hire is only legally meant to be available for people who cannot possibly hire a car by any other means so any savings, credit worthiness etc. email them back, tell them you weren’t eligible for the hire in the first place and they need to make their claim through the insurance. My PA used to work in credit hire and this is what she told me to do. They need to bill the at fault parties insurance then it’s up to them to argue it.

This is the correct advice, OP. Good luck.

Bernadinetta · 14/10/2026 07:05

That is horrifying OP- and look, as a PP pointed out, on your search the one you selected actually says “admrl” to make it looks like it’s something to do with Admiral. My car insurance is with Hastings and I’ve just done the same search and look- “hstngs” appears for that entry! Maybe that could help your case of genuinely believing it was related to your insurer. One further down the search even uses Hastings’ full name! (I have added an imagine which may take a few moments to load)

For the future and for others; many insurers have their own app, Hastings does, so rather than going to google for anything I go straight to the app- I have a login for it, that way I know it’s really them.

Cancelled credit hire agreement, facing nearly £10k in charges. Has anyone successfully challenged this before?
TennisLady · 14/10/2026 07:10

I’m sure my MIL had something similar but she did go directly through her insurer. Basically the other insurer contested the hire car fees and they were saying she’d have to go to court which stressed her out no end, but they then settle outside of court. Apparently this is just how it happens these days, but I’m amazed how it’s being allowed to happen!

BulbsQueen · 14/10/2026 07:16

Do a subject access request to the firm to find out where they got your details from. Admiral might have sold them

Motheranddaughter · 14/10/2026 07:19

Hopefully you do have legal advice cover on your Home insurance because I do think you should take legal advice

mybiggreenfrog · 14/10/2026 07:20

Check you have legal cover on your insurance, if so use it to get advice.

IzzyLeng · 14/10/2026 07:20

I had similar happen to me years ago but realised the day the courtesy car was delivered. I’d rung my insurance and definitely spoke to them, they picked the car up and said I was entitled to a courtesy car and a car hire firm would contact me. They did and then dropped a car off with some paperwork.

I saw the thing which said I’d be liable for all costs if the accident was found to be my fault. I rang them straight back and said to come and pick the car up. And said this wasn’t my understanding of a courtesy car. I’m still confused by it all but was never charged for anything.