Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

Cancelled credit hire agreement, facing nearly £10k in charges. Has anyone successfully challenged this before?

126 replies

Goingroundthebend123 · 13/10/2026 22:48

Hi everyone, looking for advice from anyone who has dealt with On Hire, Winns Solicitors, Accident Management companies or Credit hire companies in the UK.

We had a non-fault accident and believed our insurer, Admiral, had referred us to a solicitor. We later discovered we’d actually called an accident management helpline and referred us to Winns Solicitors and have been given a credit hire car through On Hire, who hired it from Europcar. We thought it was a courtesy car and were reassured we wouldn’t have to pay anything if we weren’t at fault and cooperated with the claim. After being hounded to give bank statements at payslips at the end of last week, we became increasingly alarmed that our insurance company wouldn’t be asking for this and quickly realised our mistake. After researching credit hire horror stories and sleepless nights, we became worried about being pursued personally if the third-party insurer refused to pay (which is apparently common due to inflated car hire charges).

We’ve made the decision today, on day 13 of the 14-day cooling-off period, to cancel our contract with them, to stop the costs escalating to a point we wouldn’t be able to recover from should this process go on and on for months/years.

We have been told our cancellation charges are:

  • Engineer/estimate: £203.50 plus VAT
  • Storage: £48 per day plus VAT
  • Hire charges to date: £8,534.40

We could be facing nearly £10,000, which we simply cannot afford.

Our original intention after researching online, was to pay reasonable costs genuinely incurred by OnHire as Europcar’s online rate for the same car is £82 per day and the garage also told us their storage rate is £15 per day. When we returned the car to Europcar and explaining our station/distress they kindly showed us the invoice from themselves to OnHire and the rate is £580 per day! These figures seem outrageous!

We are planning to complain to the financial ombudsman about the accident management helpline referral, as we genuinely believed it was connected to Admiral but wondering if anyone has had any luck with this route for redress of compensation?

We’re not trying to avoid legitimate costs as we did have use of a car for 12 days, but we never knowingly agreed to this level of financial risk. I’m pregnant, incredibly stressed and we simply don’t have £10,000 to pay!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 08:28

Goingroundthebend123 · 13/10/2026 23:37

If you google “admiral claims” “admiral accident” anything along those lines their number appears first. I know, I know, how stupid are we. 😢 when you speak to them they say “hi it’s the accident claim line”, so we thought it was the admiral accident claim line”. Honestly it’s eating me up, i guess technically it isn’t a “scam”, they offer a service and we signed up to it just completely unaware of all the information.

Unfortunately a lot of companies pay Google to be put at the top of searches. This is a life lesson. Just the same as if a scammer calls you saying they're NatWest, you would check if they're really who they are before agreeing to anything. If there's any element of them having tricked you, like you referring to them as Admiral and them not correcting you, then you can of course use this too.

I would definitely go down the 14 day cooling off period rule. Were you provided with any sort of invoice or costs before commencing the hire?
The tricky thing is usually those rules are based on something which isn't used up, for example an item of unworn clothing or a service you haven't had yet. You may find you need to pay for maintenance/fuel at the very least.

SpiralSister · 14/10/2026 08:29

ITMA2000 · 14/10/2026 07:49

Can't understand this. Did you have an accident with your own car or with a hire car? If you owned the car, your insurance company wouldn't refer you to someone else to deal with claims, courtesy cars etc.

You couldn’t be more wrong, unfortunately.

ITMA2000 · 14/10/2026 08:32

Well obviously, insurance companies aren't car hire suppliers, and they don't do car repairs themselves- they refer customers to the people who do these things.
(If you have a house fire, Admiral doesn't come out to rebuilt it).
But you don't enter a contract yourself- your insurer does! If you decide to act unilaterally you are obviously on your own if things go wrong.

SpiralSister · 14/10/2026 08:35

You seem to be trying to convince yourself here. Several posters, including me, have related their experiences of being legitimately referred to accident management companies by their insurers. Nothing to do with acting ‘unilaterally’. Granted, that is what the OP has done (unwittingly), but it is common practice for insurers to pass the whole thing on. Not sure why you can’t believe it - it’s a fact.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 14/10/2026 08:36

Have you signed any type of contingent fee arrangement with the law firm? If so you probably need to check that out as well as many "no win, no fee" scummy law firms will try and charge you to get out of those as well.

Hatetagsinclothes · 14/10/2026 08:43

DoraSpenlow · 14/10/2026 07:58

I am beginning to think that the whole insurance thing is just set up to make ridiculous profits. No wonder we all pay so much for insurance.

I had someone go into the back of me at traffic lights. All went well and my car was fixed with no cost to me. Out of interest I asked the body shop for a list of what was done and the cost. They happily provided it to me.

some months later I was contacted because my insurance company hadn't been paid by the other driver's insurers and they wanted me to take them to court. I could never understand why they didn't do it in their name, but whatever. In the court documents the amount they quoted was more than double the figure the garage told me. Now I know they have admin costs and such but that was ridiculous. I refused to sign and have heard no more about it.

OP I hope everything gets sorted for you soon.

Of course this is why insurance is banned in some religions.

They should include 3rd party in road tax and what isn’t spent in claims can be used on the roads

HesterLeggatt · 14/10/2026 08:45

ITMA2000 · 14/10/2026 07:52

they referr6us themselves to an accident management company to deal with us.
I simply don't believe this. There must be more to this story. Insurance companies deal with claims, full stop.

They really don’t. We had exactly the same thing with Admiral. Most insurance companies are really just brokers now.

I have to say for balance that we did go with the accident management company as that was what Admiral advised when I rang them to discuss, and it was cut and dry absolutely not my fault, and Auxillis were very good.

Cancelled credit hire agreement, facing nearly £10k in charges. Has anyone successfully challenged this before?
Goingroundthebend123 · 14/10/2026 08:49

Wow thank you all so much for your comments and support. I can’t believe how many people have been affected by this too. It’s so frustrating as if I wasn’t throwing up and sleeping most of the days, I think we would have cottoned on sooner and therefor lessened our costs, I’m just not in the right headspace at the moment.

Struggling to remember all points but will go back through all the advice, watch this, listen to this, read this ones after work this evening.

We have complained to the accident management company already for their “referral of services” - looking on the FOS website, this is going to be the most successful route and come in the form of redress and awarding compensation.

We have also done a SAR request for all companies involved so awaiting for the call recordings, remembering how it happened on the day is a bit hazy so it would be good to know.

Since we realised on Friday we have self recorded all the calls, at this point as we were starting to question though, they started unraveling that yes we could be liable but only if we didn’t cooperate, lied about not being at fault or stole the hire car.

Perhaps we should have stayed with them and gone for the long fight but I don’t think I’d have it in me with a new born baby, on Maternity leave/pay, I have 0 appetite for risk and we thought it was better to get out during the cooling off period and as soon as we realised than keep going.

I think someone said maybe we could still reclaim the costs from the 3rd party, does anyone think it’s worth calling them? I saw someone say that all parties have a responsibility to keep costs to a minimum and that’s what we are genuinely trying to do!

After speaking with admiral they did also give us two options, use their services and pay our excess or be transferred to a 3rd party solicitor/accident management company to deal with the claim. We have gone with the option of paying our excess as I think it helps us in better standing that had we been aware of what we were signing up to, we genuinely wouldn’t have chosen that option and would always choose to use our own insurance company.

OP posts:
Newbutoldfather · 14/10/2026 08:54

@Goingroundthebend123 ,

Did you see my link to the BBC story about the case involving the same companies and extortionate hire charges?

The issue isn’t your mistake, really. That is done. It is the ludicrous hire charges.

I do struggle to believe that they can legitimately charge you nearly 10k for 13 days car hire, unless it is was some kind of supercar. It is definitely worth talking to a solicitor.

MrsPottsMumofChip · 14/10/2026 08:54

Try calling citizens advice op.

WhistPie · 14/10/2026 08:55

Could I suggest, though it's a bit late for the OP, that when you arrange your insurance you put a contact in your phone called 'Car Insurance' and add the accident helpline number?

If you change insurers the next year, then change the phone number at the same time.

ITMA2000 · 14/10/2026 08:56

SpiralSister · 14/10/2026 08:35

You seem to be trying to convince yourself here. Several posters, including me, have related their experiences of being legitimately referred to accident management companies by their insurers. Nothing to do with acting ‘unilaterally’. Granted, that is what the OP has done (unwittingly), but it is common practice for insurers to pass the whole thing on. Not sure why you can’t believe it - it’s a fact.

I know what you are saying, but the insurer makes the referral or instructs the customer. A customer can't just decide to do what they want to remedy because they believe they are at no fault and their claim is legitimate. You have to wait for the insurance company to make a decision, however inconvenient waiting is.

SpiralSister · 14/10/2026 09:04

ITMA2000 · 14/10/2026 08:56

I know what you are saying, but the insurer makes the referral or instructs the customer. A customer can't just decide to do what they want to remedy because they believe they are at no fault and their claim is legitimate. You have to wait for the insurance company to make a decision, however inconvenient waiting is.

Of course they can’t, and no one here has done that.

Goingroundthebend123 · 14/10/2026 09:04

WhistPie · 14/10/2026 08:55

Could I suggest, though it's a bit late for the OP, that when you arrange your insurance you put a contact in your phone called 'Car Insurance' and add the accident helpline number?

If you change insurers the next year, then change the phone number at the same time.

The absolute worst and most embarrassing thing is, I searched in my phone after and I had their number saved. Honestly, I know everyone says it but I would never usually make this sort of mistake, I used to work in financial services, deal with FOS complaints. We had done all the right things right up until the actual accident and the shock and panic just takes over. I can’t stop crying, just feel so so utterly stupid.

OP posts:
Namemechangey · 14/10/2026 09:10

we had this exact thing with Winn solicitors, it took 18 months to settle, the other driver had admitted fault straight away (our car was parked and he drove into it writing it off) credit hire bill was 60k. We got threatening letters and all sorts.
we spent hours and hours, days and weeks back and forth with them.
eventually the other parties solicitor paid, they challenged the amount, I believe it was settled at a lower amount with Winn.
its an absolute racket, in the end we weren’t out of pocket but it caused us so much stress and upset over 18 months of our lives.

TwinklyRoseTurtle · 14/10/2026 09:14

Used them multiple times with a work company car- totally normal for them to ask for bank statements/credit cards statements it’s only so they can justify why a car hire was needed that’s all nothing to worry about

Namemechangey · 14/10/2026 09:15

Adding, you need to raise a complaint asap with Winn, a formal complaint, it’s the only way that they properly take your calls and deal with you. Insurance should pay the costs not you. But it’s a fight. Try and find evidence that you were unaware that you weren’t told the details properly about how credit hire works, we thought it was a courtesy car just like you, ours was charged at 600 a day for an equivalent car and like I said above the costs were 60k and they were sending us letters saying we had to pay the costs.

Newname26 · 14/10/2026 09:33

Admiral have an App. It might be worth downloading it.
The last twice I've made claims it have been done through the App or on the Website.
Punch in the details, up load the photo and wait for a call back.

I've never quite worked out the link between Auxillis and Admiral. I have wondered if one owns the other.

Goingroundthebend123 · 14/10/2026 09:33

Namemechangey · 14/10/2026 09:10

we had this exact thing with Winn solicitors, it took 18 months to settle, the other driver had admitted fault straight away (our car was parked and he drove into it writing it off) credit hire bill was 60k. We got threatening letters and all sorts.
we spent hours and hours, days and weeks back and forth with them.
eventually the other parties solicitor paid, they challenged the amount, I believe it was settled at a lower amount with Winn.
its an absolute racket, in the end we weren’t out of pocket but it caused us so much stress and upset over 18 months of our lives.

Oh my gosh this sounds awful. It’s made me feel a little bit better though that we did the right thing, I honestly don’t think I could handle the stress of this for years and the worry with a newborn baby. Did they make you go to court etc?

OP posts:
Goingroundthebend123 · 14/10/2026 09:34

Namemechangey · 14/10/2026 09:15

Adding, you need to raise a complaint asap with Winn, a formal complaint, it’s the only way that they properly take your calls and deal with you. Insurance should pay the costs not you. But it’s a fight. Try and find evidence that you were unaware that you weren’t told the details properly about how credit hire works, we thought it was a courtesy car just like you, ours was charged at 600 a day for an equivalent car and like I said above the costs were 60k and they were sending us letters saying we had to pay the costs.

We have logged a formal complaint and pulled out of the contract. Maybe we should have stayed and tried to fight, I don’t know. We have instructed our insurance company now. £60,000? It’s just absolute insanity!!

OP posts:
aCatCalledFawkes · 14/10/2026 09:35

I ended up briefly dealing with a third party accident management company that my car insurance people referred me on to. They were a nightmare, thankfully I googled the company (there is even a facebook group about them) and told my insurance company firmly I wasn't going through them. Luckily my brother works in insurance, he told me that I had the right to choose where my car gets fixed and my friends partner helped me out as he's a mechanic by doing a quote for me.

It was about £500 worth of damage that they were trying to convince me to take an expensive credit hire car out for. No wonder insurance prices are being inflated with these kinds of people.

SidmyCat · 14/10/2026 09:42

This happened to us years ago. The hire car was over £300 a day. It was a no fault claim and the bill was £15k.
The other driver's insurance company challenged why we needed such an expensive car - we had to take family members to a funeral in Wales so that was how I justified it although they chose the car.
It looked like it was going to court and I was terrified but at the last moment they withdrew and paid.
Had another accident a couple of years ago - again I wasn't in the car. Admiral told me to ring their claims handlers and then it didn't count as a claim. This time I had a second car so I didn't take the hire car.
Other driver's insurer also offered to repair my car, loan me a car and give me some money.

IzzyLeng · 14/10/2026 09:42

£600 a day is insane. They are profiteering and this will definitely affect peoples insurance premiums - for everybody.

Honestly if I had an accident now even though my policy says I can have a hire car I'd rather buy a little run about for 1k to use and then sell again afterwards. No way would I have a courtesy car even if my insurance company tell me it's ok.

REP22 · 14/10/2026 09:43

Graymalkin · 14/10/2026 02:32

OP, this is a well documented scam which -unbelievably- isn't really a scam but a legit practice, however morally bankrupt. DP got stung in this way years ago. What made matters worse was that after a period of DP trying to contest the contract which was infuriatingly watertight, the company sold his 'debt' to a collection firm who became intimidating quite quickly. There used to be information about this on Martin Lewis' MSE website (search 'credit hire contract scam' or similar), and we used advice from there to force them to back down in the end, but not before DP had seriously contemplated harming himself. Act now, OP, this is really nasty.

BBC Watchdog had something on this a few months ago - might be worth getting in touch with them?

venus7 · 14/10/2026 09:49

Goingroundthebend123 · 13/10/2026 23:32

It is really really shitty!

sorry if unclear, it’s nothing to do with admiral… when you google “admiral accident phone number” other websites appear and in haste/panic/stress we called the first one at the top. We then said hello been in an accident etc, do you need our policy number? Nope just a reg blah blah… we assumed it was admiral but it was an independant 3rd party accident management helpline who then referred us to solicitor (which when we eventually spoke to admiral, they do also refer people to these services who can’t afford/don’t want to pay their excess) it just so happens we seem to have ended up with one of the shitty ones! Although technically we don’t know that, they could have won the case and we didn’t pay a penny but when you see the reviews/news article/forums about these companies, we just didn’t feel it was worth the risk, especially with a baby on the way. One man said they took him for over 60k and he lost his house!

I know this is too late for you, but it is a really good idea to keep your insurer's number to hand. As you say, after an accident, you're panic stricken. There are so many fake sites.
I keep my insurer's number written down, in a folder with the breakdown number.

Swipe left for the next trending thread