Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

Cancelled credit hire agreement, facing nearly £10k in charges. Has anyone successfully challenged this before?

126 replies

Goingroundthebend123 · 13/10/2026 22:48

Hi everyone, looking for advice from anyone who has dealt with On Hire, Winns Solicitors, Accident Management companies or Credit hire companies in the UK.

We had a non-fault accident and believed our insurer, Admiral, had referred us to a solicitor. We later discovered we’d actually called an accident management helpline and referred us to Winns Solicitors and have been given a credit hire car through On Hire, who hired it from Europcar. We thought it was a courtesy car and were reassured we wouldn’t have to pay anything if we weren’t at fault and cooperated with the claim. After being hounded to give bank statements at payslips at the end of last week, we became increasingly alarmed that our insurance company wouldn’t be asking for this and quickly realised our mistake. After researching credit hire horror stories and sleepless nights, we became worried about being pursued personally if the third-party insurer refused to pay (which is apparently common due to inflated car hire charges).

We’ve made the decision today, on day 13 of the 14-day cooling-off period, to cancel our contract with them, to stop the costs escalating to a point we wouldn’t be able to recover from should this process go on and on for months/years.

We have been told our cancellation charges are:

  • Engineer/estimate: £203.50 plus VAT
  • Storage: £48 per day plus VAT
  • Hire charges to date: £8,534.40

We could be facing nearly £10,000, which we simply cannot afford.

Our original intention after researching online, was to pay reasonable costs genuinely incurred by OnHire as Europcar’s online rate for the same car is £82 per day and the garage also told us their storage rate is £15 per day. When we returned the car to Europcar and explaining our station/distress they kindly showed us the invoice from themselves to OnHire and the rate is £580 per day! These figures seem outrageous!

We are planning to complain to the financial ombudsman about the accident management helpline referral, as we genuinely believed it was connected to Admiral but wondering if anyone has had any luck with this route for redress of compensation?

We’re not trying to avoid legitimate costs as we did have use of a car for 12 days, but we never knowingly agreed to this level of financial risk. I’m pregnant, incredibly stressed and we simply don’t have £10,000 to pay!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Bernadinetta · 14/10/2026 07:22

BulbsQueen · 14/10/2026 07:16

Do a subject access request to the firm to find out where they got your details from. Admiral might have sold them

She phoned them herself and gave details. Admiral were not involved.

WildflowerMeadow · 14/10/2026 07:23

If it's any consolation OP this happened to me too, but in my case I rang the correct number for Admiral and they themselves referred me to an accident management company. They told me it would save me having to pay extra at renewal which was due shortly after the accident - I'm assuming they get a big commission.

It turned into an absolute nightmare as the credit hire car costs were ridiculous. It ended up with the third party insurer taking us to court and I ended up having to basically defend the accident management company (whose barrister rang me the day before to tell me what to say and what not to say).

I'm not a stupid person at all but things were worded really carefully and I didn't realise until it was too late what I had agreed to. I had to defend the accident management company through gritted teeth as I felt like they had completely conned me but it was the only way not to end up with a massive bill. In the end they got awarded a decent sum but not the full amount they were claiming and sent me a letter to confirm there was no liability on my side.

It was a horrible two years with it hanging over my head but in the end I came out without any financial loss. I will never insure with Admiral again, even if they are the cheapest option at renewal.

usedcars11 · 14/10/2026 07:24

We did similar but I realised at the last minute I’d erroneously called a sponsored ad number that looked VERY much like admiral. I’d been out through to about 3 different people all referring me on, arranging a hire car etc and the lady on the phone at the end said ‘you’ve not been referred here by admiral, you do realise this’ and I was shocked. VERY luckily I stopped it all at the last minute.
When I called Admiral they say it happens often as these sneaky claims management companies create website addresses and phone numbers almost identical to admiral.
There was a piece on the One Show last week where a number of people had been caught like this and run up huge bills.
They were refunded in the end but it took the One Show to get involved. Can you contact them?

SnoopyIsReal · 14/10/2026 07:24

No help, I know, but we had an incident this year and insured with Admiral. They sorted everything out, although it did involve multiple teams calling us at different times. Hire car charge was about £20 per day - they have a deal with the hire car companies to keep costs low.
As others have said, contact Admiral and ask if you have legal cover that could help. £10k for 2 weeks is outrageous and with legal support it should be brought down - it would be unfair contract terms for a start.
Good luck

Hohofortherobbers · 14/10/2026 07:41

When we had a non fault claim we phoned Admiral and they referr6us themselves to an accident management company to deal with us. We declined and approached the other drivers insurance Avica, who were very happy to sort everything out for us with no involvement of the accident management company. It was probably 13 years ago now but I recall Admiral were very unhelpful

67789d · 14/10/2026 07:43

The JVS consumer programme on 3 Counties Radio are really helpful for getting involved and helping these kinds of situations

ChocolateCinderToffee · 14/10/2026 07:47

BerryTwister · 13/10/2026 23:56

I think it’s wrong of Google to allow sponsored web pages to appear at the top of searches. It happens all the time with everything - the first 1 or 2 websites are not what you actually googled. And if you’re in a hurry, especially stressed after a car accident, you just go for one of the top searches. It’s devious.

This. I once ended up paying 3x what I should have for gig tickets because I was buying through an agency. I think that’s been put a stop to now.

Sorry you got scammed, because scam it is.

Ethelspagetti · 14/10/2026 07:49

I’d honestly use your legal cover with your house insurance. My brother used his once and he said it was a life saver in a legal situation. As he would never have been able to pay the solicitor and courts costs himself. He won the case and was awarded compensation.

ITMA2000 · 14/10/2026 07:49

Can't understand this. Did you have an accident with your own car or with a hire car? If you owned the car, your insurance company wouldn't refer you to someone else to deal with claims, courtesy cars etc.

Angrybird76 · 14/10/2026 07:50

You're not stupid and it is a scam, designed to get the maximum out of people and putting the onus on the customer to ask the right questions. While it was smaller beer, this happened to me with an ETSA company. I clicked the first one and it wasnt the US government one. I agree that google shoundnt be allowed to do it. Hold your nerve and dont pay. I wrote to the Times money help page andbthey got my money back and a £100 goodwill pay gesture so maybe try them? https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&source=web&rct=j&url=www.thetimes.com/topic/ask-the-money-experts&ved=2ahUKEwic1Mb39LiXAxWBQ0EAHafVIRIQy_kOegoIAggACAAIDRAD&opi=89978449&cd&psig=AOvVaw0qrpsf94Yl94MdcXBVPEee&ust=1792046864599000

Redirect Notice

https://www.google.com/url?cd=&opi=89978449&psig=AOvVaw0qrpsf94Yl94MdcXBVPEee&rct=j&sa=i&source=web&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.thetimes.com%2Ftopic%2Fask-the-money-experts&ust=1792046864599000&ved=2ahUKEwic1Mb39LiXAxWBQ0EAHafVIRIQy_kOegoIAggACAAIDRAD

blankittyblank · 14/10/2026 07:52

ITMA2000 · 14/10/2026 07:49

Can't understand this. Did you have an accident with your own car or with a hire car? If you owned the car, your insurance company wouldn't refer you to someone else to deal with claims, courtesy cars etc.

She wasn't referred by admiral - she google Admiral claims, and clicked on a link she thought was Admiral, but wasn't.

ITMA2000 · 14/10/2026 07:52

Hohofortherobbers · 14/10/2026 07:41

When we had a non fault claim we phoned Admiral and they referr6us themselves to an accident management company to deal with us. We declined and approached the other drivers insurance Avica, who were very happy to sort everything out for us with no involvement of the accident management company. It was probably 13 years ago now but I recall Admiral were very unhelpful

they referr6us themselves to an accident management company to deal with us.
I simply don't believe this. There must be more to this story. Insurance companies deal with claims, full stop.

HarlanCobenDogshit · 14/10/2026 07:54

Also try your local Trading Standards. Mine were brilliant when I had signed up to a scammy window company who had hid the apr from the credit agreement.

They became my proxy and corresponded on my behalf with the scammers.

ITMA2000 · 14/10/2026 07:55

blankittyblank · 14/10/2026 07:52

She wasn't referred by admiral - she google Admiral claims, and clicked on a link she thought was Admiral, but wasn't.

Got it. Thanks. In this case, I wouldn't pay a penny.

Gagagardener · 14/10/2026 07:57

That sounds hirrible! Can't help much, but I heard a radio programme about this sort of thing, probably in late Aug/early Sept. You and Yours? Likely to have been a Wed..Have a busy day, so no time to track it down, but if you can find it there might be useful information..Good luck!

DoraSpenlow · 14/10/2026 07:58

I am beginning to think that the whole insurance thing is just set up to make ridiculous profits. No wonder we all pay so much for insurance.

I had someone go into the back of me at traffic lights. All went well and my car was fixed with no cost to me. Out of interest I asked the body shop for a list of what was done and the cost. They happily provided it to me.

some months later I was contacted because my insurance company hadn't been paid by the other driver's insurers and they wanted me to take them to court. I could never understand why they didn't do it in their name, but whatever. In the court documents the amount they quoted was more than double the figure the garage told me. Now I know they have admin costs and such but that was ridiculous. I refused to sign and have heard no more about it.

OP I hope everything gets sorted for you soon.

Gagagardener · 14/10/2026 08:02

Found it..August 10, You and Yours, BBC Radio 4, available on BBC Sounds.

byedriver · 14/10/2026 08:08

Hi OP - sorry to see this is happening. I've seen quite a few posts on here similar over the years.

I notice the reason these numbers sit at the top of Google is because Google allows the 'accident management companies' to advertise against insurance company brand names. So they pay Google £1.50 a click (or whatever) to be placed above the genuine company web page. If Google did not allow this, Admiral, Hastings etc genuine websites would sit at the top of the results.

I would recommend a strongly worded complaint to Google AdWords about your predicament. I actually think they are culpable for some of this, and I am AMAZED they allow it. They are really quite strict across many other sectors.

byedriver · 14/10/2026 08:14

Further thought, complain to the Advertising Standards Agency and copy in Google legal. No it won't solve your particular issue, but it may stop the companies going forward if everyone does this and Google tightens up in this area. Basically cutting off their oxygen.

TennisLady · 14/10/2026 08:15

ITMA2000 · 14/10/2026 07:52

they referr6us themselves to an accident management company to deal with us.
I simply don't believe this. There must be more to this story. Insurance companies deal with claims, full stop.

Apparently they do.
www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/businesses/resolving-complaint/case-studies/customer-complains-shouldnt-referred-credit-hire-services

Newbutoldfather · 14/10/2026 08:18

Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer.

However, as a PO said, you can only be charged a ‘reasonable’ amount.

What was the car?

I would check what that car would cost you to hire from two or three of the main hire car companies, and offer that in settlement.

Then, I would hope, if they sue you, you could hopefully lose your legal cover to defend yourself.

BobTheTeckel · 14/10/2026 08:18

HRTFT...Seen you don't have legal cover, but did you have a hire car as part of your Admiral policy (I have a multicar policy with them and from years of experience knew they offered ver different levels of cover), assuming your car wasn't immediately written off.

Newbutoldfather · 14/10/2026 08:23

You may be interested in the below, which I found with a quick search. As I kind of suspected, Winn solicitors have a close relationship with On Hire…..that is to say that they own them!!

www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c4g245mq7mlo

SpiralSister · 14/10/2026 08:27

TennisLady · 14/10/2026 07:10

I’m sure my MIL had something similar but she did go directly through her insurer. Basically the other insurer contested the hire car fees and they were saying she’d have to go to court which stressed her out no end, but they then settle outside of court. Apparently this is just how it happens these days, but I’m amazed how it’s being allowed to happen!

Exactly what happened to me. Completely legal, referred by my insurance. Third party settled out of court.
6 months of stress for something that was entirely not my fault.
It’s a legalised scam, with all parties aware and playing it - with the exception of the poor sap, the driver. Shameful.