Please or to access all these features

Higher education

Talk to other parents whose children are preparing for university on our Higher Education forum.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

How much does University Choice Matter for Legal Career?

141 replies

Femusia · 21/09/2026 18:37

If you work in top law firms (Magic Circle, US firms, and others) in the UK or top barristers chambers or are familiar with the legal profession, to what extent would you say the University you go to matters to secure a training contract or pupillage and to bolster your career?

Apparently, there’s been efforts to introduce university-blind admissions among some firms, but the vast majority of successful students are out of Oxbridge and other Russel Group universities?

How do the other Russel Group universities fare compared to Oxbridge? I suppose the top London universities are highly regarded, but does anyone know how Bristol/Birmingham/Manchester/Leeds are regarded?

One thing I found was that universities like Manchester and Bristol admitted up to 400 students as undergraduates while Oxbridge and UCL admitted up to 250. Is it that big of a deal or not?

OP posts:
MeetMeOnTheCorner · 25/09/2026 07:06

@Pussygaloregalapagos There are specialist accountants and good chambers immediately advise barristers to use one. DD has separate accounts for tax and VAT and the appropriate sums are saved as the money comes in. Then they are not touched until the Government comes calling. They have to be financially disciplined though because they are liable for all of their expenses and taxes.

ElizabethAdey · 03/10/2026 17:04

One practical thing that hasn't come up, in case your child is applying this year: the LNAT. Some universities ask for it and some don't (Bristol does, for example), and the deadlines differ. For 2027 entry, Bristol and Durham want everything done by 13 January. For the January-deadline group (King's, LSE, UCL and others) the test has to be booked by 20 January and sat by 25 January. The full list of LNAT universities is on lnat.ac.uk.

On the bigger question, I'd add one thing to the good advice above. Students who are happy at university tend to do better there, and a strong 2:1 or a first, plus holiday schemes, will carry more weight than the difference between two very good universities. So I'd choose between Bristol, Leeds, Manchester and the rest on where your child will actually thrive: city or campus, the size of the year group, and how the course is assessed.
Liz

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 04/10/2026 09:50

@ElizabethAdey Manchester supplies far more lawyers for the Manchester market than it does for London. Leeds ditto. Bristol is LNAT and far more dc are London based and want higher paid London jobs. They aren’t really the same. The student aims and ambitions do matter.

ElizabethAdey · 07/10/2026 11:39

@MeetMeOnTheCorner That's a fair point, thank you. Where a child wants to work is a better guide than the league tables, so it's worth asking early which cities they'd like to be in, and then checking where the firms or chambers they like actually recruit from.
Liz

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 07/10/2026 13:10

@ElizabethAdey Essentially start with LNAT and consider what work and where at the same time. Then dc can draw up a sensible shortlist.

Femusia · 10/10/2026 04:35

JuliettaCaeser · 21/09/2026 22:25

Also corporate work isn’t necessarily boring. Closing an international deal gives a real buzz! And the money is brilliant. Hated criminal work you spend your life with really horrible people who are often thick as well as cruel. Sounds obvious but the reality of criminal work is really not glamorous or even particularly interesting.

I got into a Magic Circle from a red brick uni with a 2.1. But had training in a quirky area of law that was booming and my face fitted apparently. There was me and a girl from Liverpool uni but everyone else was Oxbridge Harvard or Yale. That was years ago though,

Did you feel like the Oxbridge grads looked down on you or felt out of place? Did everybody tell each other where they studied or could you keep it a secret?

OP posts:
MeetMeOnTheCorner · 10/10/2026 08:18

@Femusia That post is confusing. How she’s done criminal and corporate is a mystery. If you train in a quirky area of law, it’s not criminal! The corporate job sounds like it wasn’t a grad job straight out of uni.

It’s perfectly clear that not all grads are Oxbridge or Ivy League. For a new grad, a 2:1 from a red brick is not the usual recruit. The odds are against it and no grad has trained in a quirky area of law. None of them. A three year law degree doesn’t accommodate this. So I’m unsure this story is worth much to grads in this era.

XelaM · 10/10/2026 08:27

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 10/10/2026 08:18

@Femusia That post is confusing. How she’s done criminal and corporate is a mystery. If you train in a quirky area of law, it’s not criminal! The corporate job sounds like it wasn’t a grad job straight out of uni.

It’s perfectly clear that not all grads are Oxbridge or Ivy League. For a new grad, a 2:1 from a red brick is not the usual recruit. The odds are against it and no grad has trained in a quirky area of law. None of them. A three year law degree doesn’t accommodate this. So I’m unsure this story is worth much to grads in this era.

Definitely possible to get to a MC or SC firm having done criminal in a high street firm. I have done this - I just transitioned into White Collar crime.

The corporate law and quirky training is unusual though.

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 10/10/2026 08:39

@Femusia The latest info I can find on magic circle recruitment is 31% Oxbridge, 58% RG, 6% international and 5% non RG. So not overwhelmingly Oxbridge or USA unis. However non RG is low. Oxbridge has about 1% of law grads.

Femusia · 10/10/2026 17:36

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 10/10/2026 08:39

@Femusia The latest info I can find on magic circle recruitment is 31% Oxbridge, 58% RG, 6% international and 5% non RG. So not overwhelmingly Oxbridge or USA unis. However non RG is low. Oxbridge has about 1% of law grads.

How about top set barristers?

OP posts:
MeetMeOnTheCorner · 10/10/2026 19:26

@Femusia Some in London are 100% Oxbridge. What do you understand by “top sets”? Did you know barristers sets are ranked for their quality of work? So Band 1 is top. This could be criminal, family, commercial m, media, etc etc. Legal 500 lists the Band 1 sets. You have to do the research for the area of law that interests. Some areas have few in Band1 and some will have quite a few. There’s fewer from Oxbridge in Family and criminal. Overall Legal Cheek, who surveyed 50 “top sets” reported that in 2025, 58% of juniors were Oxbridge. That won’t be family or criminal I would think but these areas do have too sets in Bsnd 1 for, eg, matrimonial and children. Also many sets give full cvs of barristers so you can check recent tenants.

Femusia · 10/10/2026 21:36

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 10/10/2026 19:26

@Femusia Some in London are 100% Oxbridge. What do you understand by “top sets”? Did you know barristers sets are ranked for their quality of work? So Band 1 is top. This could be criminal, family, commercial m, media, etc etc. Legal 500 lists the Band 1 sets. You have to do the research for the area of law that interests. Some areas have few in Band1 and some will have quite a few. There’s fewer from Oxbridge in Family and criminal. Overall Legal Cheek, who surveyed 50 “top sets” reported that in 2025, 58% of juniors were Oxbridge. That won’t be family or criminal I would think but these areas do have too sets in Bsnd 1 for, eg, matrimonial and children. Also many sets give full cvs of barristers so you can check recent tenants.

Edited

But again I don’t understand this. Why is Oxbridge instinctively seen as the best? Someone could’ve got an offer from Oxbridge and just not wanted to go or just not applied.

OP posts:
quequerido · 10/10/2026 22:21

We know lots of kids who have magic and silver circle training contracts. Without exception they went to good universities but not necessarily top ones. Off the top of my head, Oxford, Bristol, Nottingham, Leeds, Exeter

returntomotherland · 10/10/2026 22:43

I am a barrister at a set that would likely be regarded as a "top set" (Band 1 in key practice areas, though the legal directories are not the oracle commenters on here have implied). I am also on the pupillage interview panel.

Some comments here are totally misconceived in my view, and in particular confuse correlation with causation.

My chambers is university-blind. We do not take university attended into account at all. And yet, our pupils are more likely than not to have gone to Oxbridge. This is because being accepted into Oxbridge is not, as so many imply, a random event which says nothing about the person accepted. It is not like having red hair. It is a mark of high academic ability, and likely also of other positive characteristics like hard work and being good at interview.

We get hundreds of applicants for a few places in chambers. Many of our applicants are people who not only went to Oxbridge, but excelled there. It follows that for someone who did not go to Oxbridge to get the offer, they must outperform people who excelled at Oxbridge. This may well be possible if they are indeed bright enough for Oxbridge but didn't go there, but it is frankly unlikely if they went to the University of Buckingham, as a matter of common sense.

Accordingly, the pupil who went to Oxbridge who gets an offer gets the offer not because of the Oxbridge "label" (which would not distinguish her from many other applicants anyway) but because the same characteristics that saw her offered a place at Oxbridge (and quite possibly excel at Oxbridge) are evident at interview/application stage.

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 10/10/2026 23:30

@Femusia I don’t select anyone but as @returntomotherlandsays, it’s a fact that Oxbridge grads do rather well for the reasons given. If anyone is serious about law, and wants a high flying career, they should never ever discount Oxbridge. Not going, if offered a place, is foolhardy, in my view and is this person serious about their career?

Of course not everyone gets in, but then look at the next best, and be selective. If a student doesn’t aspire to the best universities, why do they aspire to the best jobs? They have already made the hill steeper. Start with the best university.

Band 1 or 2 is all lay people have to go on. People “in the know” might know more but the league tables do give an insight into what’s a top set in a particular area of law for the rest of us. I do agree it’s all about performance in tests and interview. Given that many grads are not Oxbridge, it doesn’t mean they cannot compete, but they will need to be just as good or a bit better. They can be. However dc should get a feel of what area of law is most likely to accept them if not Oxbridge and do not apply if they don’t meet the criteria. There’s other sets who might well do so: it’s horses for courses and that lesson has to be learned.

However the bar only took around 300 pupils last year I think I read, so being average won’t get anyone very far.

Grain80 · 11/10/2026 07:55

returntomotherland · 10/10/2026 22:43

I am a barrister at a set that would likely be regarded as a "top set" (Band 1 in key practice areas, though the legal directories are not the oracle commenters on here have implied). I am also on the pupillage interview panel.

Some comments here are totally misconceived in my view, and in particular confuse correlation with causation.

My chambers is university-blind. We do not take university attended into account at all. And yet, our pupils are more likely than not to have gone to Oxbridge. This is because being accepted into Oxbridge is not, as so many imply, a random event which says nothing about the person accepted. It is not like having red hair. It is a mark of high academic ability, and likely also of other positive characteristics like hard work and being good at interview.

We get hundreds of applicants for a few places in chambers. Many of our applicants are people who not only went to Oxbridge, but excelled there. It follows that for someone who did not go to Oxbridge to get the offer, they must outperform people who excelled at Oxbridge. This may well be possible if they are indeed bright enough for Oxbridge but didn't go there, but it is frankly unlikely if they went to the University of Buckingham, as a matter of common sense.

Accordingly, the pupil who went to Oxbridge who gets an offer gets the offer not because of the Oxbridge "label" (which would not distinguish her from many other applicants anyway) but because the same characteristics that saw her offered a place at Oxbridge (and quite possibly excel at Oxbridge) are evident at interview/application stage.

@returntomotherlandI find your comment interesting, and I think it’s perhaps the assumption that the qualities which secure someone a place at Oxbridge are necessarily a reflection of innate ability that I would push back on.

I say this as an Oxbridge reject from over 25 years ago.
I was the child of immigrants, brought up in a very working-class household in a deprived part of the country. My parents were barely literate, and I attended a local comprehensive. We are also not white and I could not speak English until I started school. I applied to Oxbridge entirely off my own back, with no real guidance or preparation for what a law interview might involve.
I remember how much more prepared some of the other applicants seemed. Not necessarily more intelligent, but certainly more comfortable in that environment. They seemed to understand things that I simply didn’t know I needed to understand.

I went on to study law at a Russell Group university, but I think that lack of social and cultural capital continued to follow me. There were so many things, looking back, that I just wasn’t equipped for. Even relatively simple things like having the right clothes for interviews, knowing how to present myself, or feeling comfortable around people who had grown up in very different circumstances.

And despite doing all the things I thought I should be doing, attending law fairs, researching careers and so on, I never quite felt that I fitted in.

But I think there’s an important distinction here. Not fitting in didn’t mean I wasn’t intellectually capable of being there. It meant I was trying to navigate an environment where so much of what was expected seemed to be understood by others almost instinctively. I was having to work things out as I went along, often without even knowing what I didn’t know.

What’s interesting to me now is seeing this from the other side, as a parent.

My daughter is 15 and attends a prestigious independent day school. Through her sport, she already has friends at some very prestigious boarding schools, and we’ve recently been discussing whether she might like to attend one for sixth form.

She has a confidence about entering those environments that I simply didn’t have at her age.

But it’s also the conversations we have at home. Just the other day, I was in the car with two of my children, and we somehow ended up having quite a deep conversation about identity, belonging, how we present ourselves, the people we gravitate towards (and them towards us) and the sort of person we want to become. We laughed afterwards about how quickly we’d gone from an ordinary car journey to something rather philosophical.

And it struck me that these are conversations I never had growing up.

Not because my parents didn’t care, but because their own experiences and circumstances were so different.
I can see how much my children are absorbing, almost without realising it, and how that shapes their confidence, their self-awareness and their ability to navigate the world. They are growing up with a sense of possibility and belonging that I had to work much harder to develop.
And I think this is where your argument troubles me a little.

I don’t doubt that many Oxbridge graduates are exceptionally intelligent, hardworking and impressive. Nor do I doubt that your chambers genuinely operates a university-blind process.

But being university-blind doesn’t necessarily mean that the process is blind to the advantages that helped shape the candidate sitting in front of you.

Confidence, articulacy, ease in an interview and even the ability to demonstrate intellectual ability in a particular way can all be influenced by parenting, schooling and the environments we’ve grown up in.
And I wonder whether, sometimes, we mistake someone’s ability to demonstrate their intelligence in a way that feels familiar and impressive to us for a measure of their underlying intellectual potential.

Because there is a difference between not having the ability and not having had the same opportunities to develop or demonstrate it.

So my question really is this: how does your chambers distinguish between someone who is exceptionally able and someone who is exceptionally able but has also benefited from years of preparation, encouragement and exposure to the sorts of environments in which they are now being assessed?

And perhaps more importantly, how do you recognise that same intellectual potential in someone who hasn’t had those advantages?

Because I do wonder how many genuinely bright people are lost to professions like the Bar, not because they lack the intellectual ability, but because they never quite acquire the confidence, knowledge or social capital to make that ability visible in the way these institutions recognise.

And that, I think, is how a profession can continue to reproduce a particular type of candidate, even when nobody involved consciously intends to do so.

Grain80 · 11/10/2026 08:04

Femusia · 10/10/2026 21:36

But again I don’t understand this. Why is Oxbridge instinctively seen as the best? Someone could’ve got an offer from Oxbridge and just not wanted to go or just not applied.

@Femusia Because they’re bright, of course. But I think there’s also an element of perpetuity here. Oxbridge has long been regarded as the gold standard, and that perception is reinforced by the professions that continue to draw heavily from it. It’s a self-perpetuating cycle, and one that people understandably feel they need to play along with. That doesn’t diminish the intellectual ability of those who attend Oxbridge, but nor does it mean that equally bright people aren’t studying at other excellent universities. The two aren’t mutually exclusive.

returntomotherland · 11/10/2026 11:10

@Grain80 This is a much broader question which I really don't have time to do justice to. But to be clear, and I think I was clear, I do not say that if you are very bright and articulate, you go to Oxbridge. I say that if you are at Oxbridge, you are (probably) very bright and articulate. Plenty of very bright people are at other universities, and if they are bright enough, they won't be disadvantaged at our chambers (and many other chambers) for not having gone to Oxbridge (save that the tutorial system must surely provide an advantage to anyone in the skills of defending an argument - but this is about the mode of education and not the label). But it should not surprise people that in an intellectually demanding competition, people who got to Oxbridge generally do well.

I'm not going to go into my background as it would be outing but I am acutely aware of social disadvantage. You are however conflating Oxbridge attendance with social advantage. It is absolutely not the case that all Oxbridge grads (at least nowadays) are white public school males. Many of our applicants got to Oxbridge despite social disadvantage, or at least despite state education. 3 of our last 4 offerees were state-educated. I personally disagree with private education for reasons you advert to and accordingly send my own children to state schools.

Mitigating factors are considered so eg if someone has had to hold down a job while at uni that is taken into account. There is also a system of which my chambers is part that "flags" social disadvantage, but this only comes into play if two candidates are otherwise considered equally good. For the avoidance of doubt, I would personally have at least one social disadvantage flag.

However, and speaking personally rather than reflecting any chambers policy, the fact is that life is not fair. There is only so much that can be done. If you have a candidate who has grown up in an unstable household with parents who are not interested in education, nowhere to study quietly, and 5 siblings to look after, he or she will of course be massively disadvantaged against someone who had every advantage in life. The Bar (or indeed any profession) simply cannot totally correct for this.

Femusia · 11/10/2026 16:04

Grain80 · 11/10/2026 07:55

@returntomotherlandI find your comment interesting, and I think it’s perhaps the assumption that the qualities which secure someone a place at Oxbridge are necessarily a reflection of innate ability that I would push back on.

I say this as an Oxbridge reject from over 25 years ago.
I was the child of immigrants, brought up in a very working-class household in a deprived part of the country. My parents were barely literate, and I attended a local comprehensive. We are also not white and I could not speak English until I started school. I applied to Oxbridge entirely off my own back, with no real guidance or preparation for what a law interview might involve.
I remember how much more prepared some of the other applicants seemed. Not necessarily more intelligent, but certainly more comfortable in that environment. They seemed to understand things that I simply didn’t know I needed to understand.

I went on to study law at a Russell Group university, but I think that lack of social and cultural capital continued to follow me. There were so many things, looking back, that I just wasn’t equipped for. Even relatively simple things like having the right clothes for interviews, knowing how to present myself, or feeling comfortable around people who had grown up in very different circumstances.

And despite doing all the things I thought I should be doing, attending law fairs, researching careers and so on, I never quite felt that I fitted in.

But I think there’s an important distinction here. Not fitting in didn’t mean I wasn’t intellectually capable of being there. It meant I was trying to navigate an environment where so much of what was expected seemed to be understood by others almost instinctively. I was having to work things out as I went along, often without even knowing what I didn’t know.

What’s interesting to me now is seeing this from the other side, as a parent.

My daughter is 15 and attends a prestigious independent day school. Through her sport, she already has friends at some very prestigious boarding schools, and we’ve recently been discussing whether she might like to attend one for sixth form.

She has a confidence about entering those environments that I simply didn’t have at her age.

But it’s also the conversations we have at home. Just the other day, I was in the car with two of my children, and we somehow ended up having quite a deep conversation about identity, belonging, how we present ourselves, the people we gravitate towards (and them towards us) and the sort of person we want to become. We laughed afterwards about how quickly we’d gone from an ordinary car journey to something rather philosophical.

And it struck me that these are conversations I never had growing up.

Not because my parents didn’t care, but because their own experiences and circumstances were so different.
I can see how much my children are absorbing, almost without realising it, and how that shapes their confidence, their self-awareness and their ability to navigate the world. They are growing up with a sense of possibility and belonging that I had to work much harder to develop.
And I think this is where your argument troubles me a little.

I don’t doubt that many Oxbridge graduates are exceptionally intelligent, hardworking and impressive. Nor do I doubt that your chambers genuinely operates a university-blind process.

But being university-blind doesn’t necessarily mean that the process is blind to the advantages that helped shape the candidate sitting in front of you.

Confidence, articulacy, ease in an interview and even the ability to demonstrate intellectual ability in a particular way can all be influenced by parenting, schooling and the environments we’ve grown up in.
And I wonder whether, sometimes, we mistake someone’s ability to demonstrate their intelligence in a way that feels familiar and impressive to us for a measure of their underlying intellectual potential.

Because there is a difference between not having the ability and not having had the same opportunities to develop or demonstrate it.

So my question really is this: how does your chambers distinguish between someone who is exceptionally able and someone who is exceptionally able but has also benefited from years of preparation, encouragement and exposure to the sorts of environments in which they are now being assessed?

And perhaps more importantly, how do you recognise that same intellectual potential in someone who hasn’t had those advantages?

Because I do wonder how many genuinely bright people are lost to professions like the Bar, not because they lack the intellectual ability, but because they never quite acquire the confidence, knowledge or social capital to make that ability visible in the way these institutions recognise.

And that, I think, is how a profession can continue to reproduce a particular type of candidate, even when nobody involved consciously intends to do so.

If you don’t mind saying, how did your legal career end up? Did not going to Oxbridge harm you?

OP posts:
LoserWinner · 11/10/2026 16:49

I have a family member who works for a magic circle law firm. They did their degree (Law) at LSE and worked for a few years as a paralegal. One firm (not MC) funded the LPC professional qualification to become a solicitor. They practised some years as a solicitor in various specialisms, then as a solicitor advocate for a city law firm specialising in a specific area of law. They were then head-hunted for a specific role in the MC firm. The money and perks are fabulous, but the hours, pressure and demands are insane, to the point where I worry a lot about my relative’s well-being.

Grain80 · 11/10/2026 19:33

returntomotherland · 11/10/2026 11:10

@Grain80 This is a much broader question which I really don't have time to do justice to. But to be clear, and I think I was clear, I do not say that if you are very bright and articulate, you go to Oxbridge. I say that if you are at Oxbridge, you are (probably) very bright and articulate. Plenty of very bright people are at other universities, and if they are bright enough, they won't be disadvantaged at our chambers (and many other chambers) for not having gone to Oxbridge (save that the tutorial system must surely provide an advantage to anyone in the skills of defending an argument - but this is about the mode of education and not the label). But it should not surprise people that in an intellectually demanding competition, people who got to Oxbridge generally do well.

I'm not going to go into my background as it would be outing but I am acutely aware of social disadvantage. You are however conflating Oxbridge attendance with social advantage. It is absolutely not the case that all Oxbridge grads (at least nowadays) are white public school males. Many of our applicants got to Oxbridge despite social disadvantage, or at least despite state education. 3 of our last 4 offerees were state-educated. I personally disagree with private education for reasons you advert to and accordingly send my own children to state schools.

Mitigating factors are considered so eg if someone has had to hold down a job while at uni that is taken into account. There is also a system of which my chambers is part that "flags" social disadvantage, but this only comes into play if two candidates are otherwise considered equally good. For the avoidance of doubt, I would personally have at least one social disadvantage flag.

However, and speaking personally rather than reflecting any chambers policy, the fact is that life is not fair. There is only so much that can be done. If you have a candidate who has grown up in an unstable household with parents who are not interested in education, nowhere to study quietly, and 5 siblings to look after, he or she will of course be massively disadvantaged against someone who had every advantage in life. The Bar (or indeed any profession) simply cannot totally correct for this.

@returntomotherlandI think there’s a difference between recognising disadvantage after assessing someone’s ability and recognising how that disadvantage may have shaped their ability to demonstrate it in the first place.

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 11/10/2026 19:36

@Grain80 The big issue for barristers is how chambers are organised. Barristers are self employed. This means that many network with solicitors to get work. They have to build up a portfolio of work and get ranked. Up to 22.5% of their earnings are paid to chambers to run the chambers. People that fit in and can earn decent money because they have ability and confidence are very much who they will choose. Young people from less advantaged backgrounds can of course have all those attributes too but no confidence, not making the best of your opportunities by not going to Oxford, or if chambers thinks you won’t make money, are also red flags. These are commercial enterprises and not charities. There are other ways to be a barrister at the employed bar and its horses for courses.

Grain80 · 11/10/2026 19:40

Femusia · 11/10/2026 16:04

If you don’t mind saying, how did your legal career end up? Did not going to Oxbridge harm you?

@Femusia(please note I had a lot to say to spoke this into AI for the grammar etc but it’s all my words) I actually left law relatively early on, but I don’t think not going to Oxbridge disadvantaged me. Quite the opposite, really. Attending a Russell Group university gave me access to people, opportunities and networks that I simply wouldn’t have encountered growing up in a very deprived borough, attending a local comprehensive and coming from a working-class immigrant family.
I think I recognised quite early on at university that I needed to build those networks, although I’m not entirely sure how I knew that at the time. I was quite deliberate about the people I got to know and the friendships I developed. I also got involved in sport, despite not being particularly good at it, partly because it opened up another social circle.
But I was also working throughout university because I had to, and I think that inevitably came at a cost. Time spent working was time I couldn’t spend studying, socialising or getting involved in the sorts of activities that other students could.
I remember arriving at university and immediately recognising how different my background was from so many of my peers. My accent was different, my clothes were different, and there was an entire world of experiences and social connections that I simply hadn’t been exposed to.
And I think those differences became particularly apparent when it came to training contract applications and interviews.
Hand on heart, I don’t think I was any less intellectually capable than many of my peers who went on to secure training contracts at leading firms. But I certainly didn’t have the same confidence, polish, life experiences or understanding of how to present myself. Nor did I have the family connections or guidance that some of them could draw upon.
Looking back, I can see how differently equipped we were, even though we had attended the same university and received the same education.
And that’s perhaps the distinction I’m trying to make. The university itself wasn’t the disadvantage. If anything, it was one of the greatest opportunities I’d had.
I was taught by exceptionally able academics, including Oxbridge graduates, and received an intellectually rigorous education. Friends from university went on to become partners at leading City firms and general counsel at FTSE 250 companies. Clearly, attending a Russell Group university didn’t prevent them from reaching the very top of the profession.
But many of them also had advantages beyond their academic qualifications that I simply didn’t have.
Interestingly, I now work in a commercial role within the legal sector, speaking regularly with partners, general counsel and senior legal professionals across organisations ranging from FTSE 100 companies to startups. I’ve built a broad network across the profession, including the Bar, but it’s something I’ve had to cultivate over many years.
So no, I don’t think Oxbridge was the missing piece for me. I think it was the social and cultural capital that others arrived at university already possessing, and which I had to spend much of my early adult life learning to develop.
And perhaps that’s what gets lost in these discussions. Two people can attend the same excellent university, receive the same education and be equally intellectually capable, yet leave with very different opportunities because of everything else they bring with them.

returntomotherland · 11/10/2026 21:55

Grain80 · 11/10/2026 19:33

@returntomotherlandI think there’s a difference between recognising disadvantage after assessing someone’s ability and recognising how that disadvantage may have shaped their ability to demonstrate it in the first place.

Please do set out how you suggest we should account for the individual disadvantages affecting each of our hundreds of applicants, bearing in mind that (i) the median applicant is 27 years old and (ii) the essence of the job they are interviewing for is being able to present submissions with confidence?

returntomotherland · 11/10/2026 22:16

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 11/10/2026 19:36

@Grain80 The big issue for barristers is how chambers are organised. Barristers are self employed. This means that many network with solicitors to get work. They have to build up a portfolio of work and get ranked. Up to 22.5% of their earnings are paid to chambers to run the chambers. People that fit in and can earn decent money because they have ability and confidence are very much who they will choose. Young people from less advantaged backgrounds can of course have all those attributes too but no confidence, not making the best of your opportunities by not going to Oxford, or if chambers thinks you won’t make money, are also red flags. These are commercial enterprises and not charities. There are other ways to be a barrister at the employed bar and its horses for courses.

I worry about the combination of confidence and inaccuracy in this message, given there will be people reading it and taking it as gospel.

All self-employed barristers have to network with solicitors and build up a rapport with them, in order to build up and sustain a practice. It is absolutely not expected that anyone will already have a network to tap into at the start. You build one when you join chambers (similarly, somebody, possibly also this poster, posted earlier about MC firms preferring Oxbridge grads as trainees because of their networks for bringing work into the firm. This is, in my experience, nonsense).

People do not or should not need to "fit in" in chambers as long as they have basic levels of social competence. Moderate to excellent social competence is better still, and most certainly not the preserve of the socially advantaged. There is absolutely space at the Bar for people of all personalities and backgrounds. I do not fit the mould and it has only been an advantage in my practice. Some old school solicitors might not warm to me because I do not fit the mould, but there are more than enough solicitors who do warm to me because I do not fit the mould. If anything, my impression is that solicitors rather like unpretentious, "normal" barristers they can get on with (yes, even in commercial law).

I don't understand the suggestion that "not making the best of your opportunities by not going to Oxford" is a red flag. Not going to Oxford is not a red flag.

Swipe left for the next trending thread