@user149799568 With respect, it is most unclear to me what you are trying to say.
Are you trying to argue that PISA is flawed and that Welsh kids are actually much better at reading and maths that the flawed test would suggest? If so, why? I would gently remind you that pretty much no one in Wales is arguing this.
Are you maybe trying to say that, yes, Welsh kids do poorly at reading and maths, but they are brilliant in other areas, not reflected in the PISA tests? If so, then:
- what are these areas and why do you think that?
- Even if that's true, so what? Does being brilliant in other areas make it OK to do poorly in reading and maths? I don't understand. I genuinely don't
Thousands of Welsh children are bilingual, which counts for nothing in England
What should it count for? What do you think we should be doing about it, which we are not? Give them a medal? Pat them on the back? Tell them they need to achieve a lower standard in reading and maths than their English peers because... they speak another language??
Disappointing cultural stereotyping there, PoO.
?? What would be the stereotyping? It is quite factual that people in Nordic countries speak English much better than Italians and Spaniards. There are many reasons, other than the potential similarity between the languages; eg in Italy and Spain movies and TV shows are always dubbed, and the way Italians learn English is heavily influenced by the way they used to learn Latin and ancient Greek: lots of theoretical grammar, followed by lots of literature, with little practical applications.
It is absolutely nothing to do with the natural abilities of eg Italian/French/German/Polish children and everything to do with the national education policy.
I never said anything about the natural abilities! See above. And please do NOT put words in my mouth. Thank you.
112,000 sat Maths A level last year. 8,000 took Spanish. 2,224 sat German. 1,653 sat Chinese.
MFL at A level is the wrong metric to look at. England is somewhat unique in requiring early specialisation, so, unless you want to study languages at uni, it doesn't make sense to choose one at A level.
How many take MFL GCSEs is a better indicator. I don't have the exact stats, but I seem to remember it was something like 800,000 every year take maths, ca. 150,000 take French and ca 150,000 take Spanish. Note that many schools don't let you take both but force you to choose.
The main thing there was that a MFL used to be a requirement at GCSE, but Labour scrapped the requirement around 2004: many teachers lost their jobs, and recruiting has been difficult sicne then