Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

England's good PISA results: how much credit does Gove's GCSE reform truly deserve?

167 replies

ParentOfOne · 14/10/2026 18:25

England did reasonably well in the latest PISA results, much better than Scotland and Wales
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvgy6n0l4rdo

I'd be interested in comparing opinions on how much credit Gove's GCSE reform of 2013 deserves for this.

I don't like Gove (a Brexiter who famously said that all schools should be above average...) but I am open to admitting that I can disagree with someone on a topic but still agree on another.

It's not clear to me what the main difference between Gove's GCSE and the previous system was: did coursework use to count in the previous system, whereas he made the GCSE reliant only on the final examination? Has this made the results fairer and more reliable, to the extent that the test and the marking are the same across the country?

It's also not clear to me how the Welsh system differs. I remember many comments from Welsh politicians against teaching to the test and in favour of a more comprehensive approach, but I do not understand what it means in practice.

What was most striking for me was that the results were not driven by socio-economic factors, and that English students in deprived areas still did better than Welsh students in less deprived areas (based on the press - I haven't analysed the reports myself), so it's not a matter of London being richer and skewing the results.

Thoughts?

Students in green school uniforms sit at desks reading books during a classroom lesson. Pencil pots and study materials are visible on the tables, with a noticeboard and classroom displays in the background.

England up in reading, maths and science rankings as Scotland and Wales dip

The latest Pisa report also warned of a global decline in teenagers' reading skills.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvgy6n0l4rdo

OP posts:
Benvenuto · 19/10/2026 12:05

Genevieva · 19/10/2026 10:48

Again, you are making suppositions for which there is no data. No one is criticising your support for Sure Start, but despite efforts there is no evidence that it improved PISA outcomes. Ditto Letters and Sounds. Expensive as these reading programmes were (and that is a different thread that I almost certainly agree with you on) systematic synthetic phonics schemes measurably moved the dial in terms of pupil learning outcomes. They also reduced teacher planning workload. There are many many things I’m critical of Gove on, but on this, we have to recognise that he gave permission for real, positive change. Not a nod in the direction of the Rose Report that put the burden on teachers and made no difference to outcomes (L&S). There’s no evidence that any other minister from any party would have facilitated this. It was Gibb’s absolute belief and commitment that persuaded Gove and it was give that gave the go ahead. It’s a different funding pot from Sure Start and the fabric of school buildings, neither of which are relevant to PISA, but the funding for which would have been very welcome for me in my career.

But it’s too soon for the changes that you are claiming to have affected this data. The children being assessed were 15 last year. They would have been learning phonics 10-12 years ago when Letters and Sounds was still in use as it wasn’t withdrawn until 2022.

AlistairAppletonssexyscarf · 19/10/2026 13:55

User454545454546565 · 18/10/2026 14:40

@ParentOfOneContext is everything, surely. That's why I asked downthread, who cares about these rankings? They aren't a reflection of ability. They're a reflection of a government body's ability to engineer a system to produce the output desired by the government. With the raw material being children and teachers and their mental health. It's not a level playing field for children or teachers.

As a parent of a middle-class child who was forced to go to one of the schools you mention, and was unable to complete her time there through absolutely no fault of her own, I say these results are not accurate. Gove's reforms were incomplete and he gets no credit for partially reforming a very damaged system.

Half the kids in that school shouldn't have been there (as commented by the school's own Safeguarding lead), and the other half could have performed far better if they and their teachers were in conditions to do so.

This is happening in schools across the country, the Ofsted propaganda banners at the school gates fool only the very stupid among us, so why do people put any reliance at all on PISA or Ofsted? It is genuinely baffling to me.

Edited

As the parent of a child who should be about to get a good set of GSCEs, be thinking about A level options, and beyond that to university, but who is instead about to get no GSCEs at all, I can only echo this. We are driving our education system on a single metric and deeming it a success, when the crisis in absenteeism and mental health breakdown suggests it is failing in a way that may well damage our country more than any academic success can benefit it. I have no idea what my child will do next autumn; we are doing everything we can to identify the right post-16 path for them, with provision for retaking the crucial English and Maths, but the whole last five years has been hellish, and their trust in education is obviously very low.

My child couldn't access any provision that met their needs as it just doesn't exist where we live. They haven't been able to access anything but an online education for over three years and we had to fight for months to get that - with the LA continuing to refuse to provide additional measures set out in the ECHP. And there's a rich irony to getting emails from the school 'reminding' you that every session of school missed can have an effect on a child's achievement while they go without any education at all for months while the LA fights tooth and nail not to give your child even the very basic provision it has decided meets its legal obligation to provide a 'full time education'.

My child has two engaged, university-educated parents who believe in education and who worked with the school at every turn to keep them in education. They have two siblings who attend daily. But the relentless focus on specific attainment, the 100% or fail approach of tools like Sparx, the lack of flexibility, the pointless insistence on minor rules and punishment for breaking them even by mistake, and the lack of work that engaged what had previously been a curious and creative brain was too much.

Appuskidu · 19/10/2026 17:48

What ‘should’ have happened if Letters and Sounds was not deemed good enough anymore as a scheme, was that it should have been withdrawn, fixed and then made freely available again to all primary schools.

What Gove/Gibb did was to make publishers (and Ruth Miskin) extremely rich and force individual schools up and down the land to spend thousands and thousands of pounds of a non-existent budget on buying something new.

Genevieva · 19/10/2026 18:18

Benvenuto · 19/10/2026 12:05

But it’s too soon for the changes that you are claiming to have affected this data. The children being assessed were 15 last year. They would have been learning phonics 10-12 years ago when Letters and Sounds was still in use as it wasn’t withdrawn until 2022.

That isn't true. Children who started school in 2012 finished A Levels last academic year. They are in the 2023 PISA data. But synthetic phonics was not just rolled out to Reception in 2012. It was rolled out across EYFS and KS1, so that takes us back to about 2021. There was also a remediation support programme focussed on KS2 (Y3-6), the benefits of which were visible in PISA testing as early as 2016. Letters and Sounds is just a dilute version of synthetic phonics. It is completely compatible with it, so there was no need to withdraw it as such. It just wasn't enough by itself. I've no idea why you are trying to credit Letters and Sounds with PISA success when all the data is so clearly documented and shows that it was Gibb's systematics synthetic phonics rollout that made the difference. It is very well documented by PISA themselves.

ScrollingLeaves · 19/10/2026 21:50

User454545454546565 · 18/10/2026 23:16

Well, good for you cityliving99.

O levels were a very long time ago, pre-Gove. Things are extremely stressful for many 16yo now.

PISA might be good as far as it goes, if you're into league tables and want to feel better about the mess UK schools are in, but as I said upthread imo it's an incomplete assessment of both pupil ability and education system. Italy and any other European country you care to name would have wiped the floor with English kids in terms of MFL and oracy.

Also, depressingly, PISA shows that educational outcomes are "stagnating or declining" in many countries and it's showing that lack of reading is a problem. Countries (like Italy and Wales) with a firmer grasp of traditional book reading, standing in front of the class and speaking and way more foreign language content are going to have better language processing skills and be better and more interesting at communicating, generally. Who cares about PISA just get them off the bloody screens.

Italy and any other European country you care to name would have wiped the floor with English kids in terms of MFL and oracy.

Did you see all the English speaking French teenagers on the news about the school riots?

metellaestinatrio · 20/10/2026 06:05

cityliving99 · 18/10/2026 19:51

I wanted to do well in my O levels. I wanted top grades. I wasn’t stressed. It’s OK for the majority of students to want to perform to their best ability. Some stress is good. And English students were tested on exactly the same things as Italian students and the rest of the world- and way outperformed the Italian students.

I agree that people have got very dramatic about the “stress” caused by exams. GCSEs are taken at 16. At 16 young people can also get a job or join the army. They are not tiny children. It is good for children to experience a bit of stress, to work hard and to come through the other side.

When I was at school, we did end of year exams every year from Y7 upwards so we were used to being tested, to revising, to sometimes getting things wrong, to doing better in some subjects than others; as a result GCSEs were not a huge deal. Nowadays parents make such a fuss about how “stressed” their kids are about SATs and it’s totally unnecessary. SATs should be presented as a few tests done in a familiar environment which measure how the school is doing, not the child. Parents hype up the tests and then claim their little babies are too stressed by them.

ParentOfOne · 20/10/2026 06:58

@User454545454546565 Italy and any other European country you care to name would have wiped the floor with English kids in terms of MFL and oracy.

And you know this... how, exactly?

Dutch and Scandinavian kids are much better at MFL.
Spanish and Italians typically no.
I also stand by my previous point that MFLs are less important for English speaker (and I say this as someone who has lived abroad, is currently reading a novel in another language, and certainly appreciates how enriching it can be to speak other languages).

Oracy? Maybe, to the extent that Italian schools are much more based on oral assessments than written ones. But that has its pros and cons - oral tests to all the students is incredibly time-consuming, and contributes to the grades being unreliable and not comparable from school to school

OP posts:
User454545454546565 · 20/10/2026 09:56

@ParentOfOneI know this because it's hard to think of a European country that doesn't have minimum 1 but usually 2 hours of English a week at school from age 5-6, continuing uninterrupted till 16 and usually 18. Thousands of Welsh children are bilingual, which counts for nothing in England because we're too thick and lazy to learn Welsh because we'd rather deride minority languages as economically worthless and ignore the educational and cultural benefits.

Disappointing cultural stereotyping there, PoO. It is absolutely nothing to do with the natural abilities of eg Italian/French/German/Polish children and everything to do with the national education policy.

112,000 sat Maths A level last year. 8,000 took Spanish. 2,224 sat German. 1,653 sat Chinese.

It's dismal.

ParentOfOne · 20/10/2026 15:10

@user149799568 With respect, it is most unclear to me what you are trying to say.

Are you trying to argue that PISA is flawed and that Welsh kids are actually much better at reading and maths that the flawed test would suggest? If so, why? I would gently remind you that pretty much no one in Wales is arguing this.

Are you maybe trying to say that, yes, Welsh kids do poorly at reading and maths, but they are brilliant in other areas, not reflected in the PISA tests? If so, then:

  1. what are these areas and why do you think that?
  2. Even if that's true, so what? Does being brilliant in other areas make it OK to do poorly in reading and maths? I don't understand. I genuinely don't

Thousands of Welsh children are bilingual, which counts for nothing in England

What should it count for? What do you think we should be doing about it, which we are not? Give them a medal? Pat them on the back? Tell them they need to achieve a lower standard in reading and maths than their English peers because... they speak another language??

Disappointing cultural stereotyping there, PoO.

?? What would be the stereotyping? It is quite factual that people in Nordic countries speak English much better than Italians and Spaniards. There are many reasons, other than the potential similarity between the languages; eg in Italy and Spain movies and TV shows are always dubbed, and the way Italians learn English is heavily influenced by the way they used to learn Latin and ancient Greek: lots of theoretical grammar, followed by lots of literature, with little practical applications.

It is absolutely nothing to do with the natural abilities of eg Italian/French/German/Polish children and everything to do with the national education policy.

I never said anything about the natural abilities! See above. And please do NOT put words in my mouth. Thank you.

112,000 sat Maths A level last year. 8,000 took Spanish. 2,224 sat German. 1,653 sat Chinese.

MFL at A level is the wrong metric to look at. England is somewhat unique in requiring early specialisation, so, unless you want to study languages at uni, it doesn't make sense to choose one at A level.

How many take MFL GCSEs is a better indicator. I don't have the exact stats, but I seem to remember it was something like 800,000 every year take maths, ca. 150,000 take French and ca 150,000 take Spanish. Note that many schools don't let you take both but force you to choose.
The main thing there was that a MFL used to be a requirement at GCSE, but Labour scrapped the requirement around 2004: many teachers lost their jobs, and recruiting has been difficult sicne then

OP posts:
User454545454546565 · 20/10/2026 15:36

Equally unclear to me what you're trying to say, Parent.

The first point I made, a few times now, is asking why PISA is important at all, given that it's incomplete. It looks at Maths, Science and reading. Yes those skills/knowledge areas are important but they aren't the full picture. They are not the full subject spectrum.

Children living in countries where other subjects eg MFL are prioritised, aren't necessarily educationally inferior to PISA high-performing countries. They have skills not recognised by PISA. The governments of those countries have made different choices.

So if you want to give Gove credit for pushing up England's Maths and Science performance on PISA, then perhaps that's fair enough.

I just don't understand why anyone would care about an incomplete educational ranking, or why anyone would look at the wider context, ie the deplorable state of British education, and give any UK government credit for anything.

Pearlstillsinging · 20/10/2026 15:45

ParentOfOne · 14/10/2026 19:42

@noblegiraffe Thank you, very interesting. I'll look up those references.

This may be a bit of a silly question, but how does an Education secretary change the national curriculum, and how does that link to the supposed autonomy of schools and exam boards? exam boards can change the curriculum only within certain parameters set by the Dep of Education?

@HilaryThorpe2 Money into LA? You mean local authorities? But, since then, there's been a huge shift, whereby the vast majority of secondary schools are now independent of local authorities. I forget the exact number, but I think ca 3/4 of English secondaries are academies. It seems a bit of a stretch to me to link today's success to something which happened 25-30 years ago, when so much has changed in the meanwhile

Local Authorities still have overall responsibility for the children in their area and Academies follow the NC in the vast majority of cases. LA staff are often called in to rescue struggling schools. As PP the approach to education of many academies contributes to the difficulties experienced by many children.

User454545454546565 · 20/10/2026 15:48

It's also not "factual" that people in Nordic countries speak English much better than Italians and Spaniards.

It's a fact that eg Germans and Poles have a far easier time learning and speaking English than eg Italians. Look at a Polish or German grammar book to understand why. Polish is arguably inaccessible to your average Brit unless they've had exposure to it as a child.

Nordics have fewer natural barriers to English, they aren't "better" or more linguistically able than Italians, who find English pronunciation and intonation kind of impossible, in much the same way as English people can very rarely speak un-accented French or Italian.

ParentOfOne · 20/10/2026 16:05

@User454545454546565

The first point I made, a few times now, is asking why PISA is important at all, given that it's incomplete. It looks at Maths, Science and reading. Yes those skills/knowledge areas are important but they aren't the full picture. They are not the full subject spectrum

I am not aware of many people claiming that's the full picture. I most certainly do not claim that.
Still, I find PISA important because it tests areas which, as you recognise yourself, are important.

Children living in countries where other subjects eg MFL are prioritised, aren't necessarily educationally inferior to PISA high-performing countries.

And that's the part I don't agree with. That's why I asked you those questions above, which you have chosen not to answer.

You can say that other countries do better than England at MFL and in other areas not tested by PISA.
But you CANNOT say or imply that one offsets the other.

PISA tests the kind of reading and maths skills without which today's kids will become the functionally illiterate adults of tomorrow.
Are you claiming that struggling to read and comprehend a text, or struggling with basic maths, can be OK if someone speaks another language?????

They have skills not recognised by PISA. The governments of those countries have made different choices.

Please, do tell me which governments have made the explicit choice that MFLs are important while reading and maths are not.

It seems to me you struggle to appreciate that multiple things can be true at once:

  • England seems to have got the basics rights, and managing the keep scores steady, while most countries have been doing worse and worse, is remarkable
  • We should also be glad (for England, and sad for Wales) that English kids in deprived areas do better than Welsh kids in non-deprived areas
  • None of this means that English schools are perfect
  • None of this means Gove got everything right (he caused so much damage to the country with Brexit and his lies)
  • None of this means other subjects are taught correctly. I share your frustration at how MFLs are taught, and I think the way we study history is also rather useless and nonsensical
  • A country can do well at PISA and still have a terrible education system, which sucks in many areas not assessed by PISA
  • I struggle to see how a country could suck at PISA but still have an excellent education system, since PISA tests skills which are so fundamental

Nordics have fewer natural barriers to English, they aren't "better" or more linguistically able than Italians,

You continue with your strawman argument. You continue to reply to an argument (ability) I have never made. I pointed to other causes, like dubbing movies and a teaching of MFL heavily influenced by the teaching of dead languages, but you chose to ignore those points and focus on a point I never made.
For a better example, just compare how much better the Portuguese tend to speak English than the Spanish or the Italians. Those 3 languages all have a common root, yet Portugal is the one country among the 3 which dubs movies and TV the least

It's also not "factual" that people in Nordic countries speak English much better than Italians and Spaniards.

It kind of is, actually. My experience of visiting and recruiting from those countries may well be unrepresentative. But many studies confirm the point. Eg this ranking (which places Portugal among the top 6) https://www.ef.com/wwen/epi/

OP posts:
User454545454546565 · 20/10/2026 16:52

Sorry you lost me at the usual "you've chosen not to answer," Parent.

Lots of things you're not answering but like I said, who cares? Most people agree with you so that's great.

ParentOfOne · 20/10/2026 17:45

@user149799568 What would I have refused to answer? You asked why I think PISA tests are important, and I have explained it in great detail.
It's you who continue to fail to explain how or why better results in other areas (which are still to be proven) would offset poor PISA results.

OP posts:
Araminta1004 · 20/10/2026 18:46

England is more like some Asian countries now educationally. That is what the PISA results suggest. As a lot of Asian kids come to our unis and private schools, it all makes some sense to me. Question is will we grow like China and India? Yes or no?
I know, I know… very simplistic.
The theory of adding a foreign language to the curriculum from Reception was tested by some free schools. Eg Judith Kerr or La Fontaine in London about 15 years ago, 2 I can remember. I think both schools doing well but not sure how bilingual their kids really are or whether it is just another clever way of attracting middle class parents which turns out good results, typically.
I would love every child in England to learn an instrument and a foreign language over and above counting to ten and learning colours in French. Teachers mostly don’t have the skill but this is where tech can actually assist.

User454545454546565 · 20/10/2026 19:30

ParentOfOne · 20/10/2026 17:45

@user149799568 What would I have refused to answer? You asked why I think PISA tests are important, and I have explained it in great detail.
It's you who continue to fail to explain how or why better results in other areas (which are still to be proven) would offset poor PISA results.

I don't think PISA by itself is worth much. You do. That's great. We can agree to differ.

Nothing to do with offsetting. If there was a similar index solely for MFL performance globally then it would give us all another benchmark for the validity of education systems.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page