Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

England's good PISA results: how much credit does Gove's GCSE reform truly deserve?

167 replies

ParentOfOne · 14/10/2026 18:25

England did reasonably well in the latest PISA results, much better than Scotland and Wales
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvgy6n0l4rdo

I'd be interested in comparing opinions on how much credit Gove's GCSE reform of 2013 deserves for this.

I don't like Gove (a Brexiter who famously said that all schools should be above average...) but I am open to admitting that I can disagree with someone on a topic but still agree on another.

It's not clear to me what the main difference between Gove's GCSE and the previous system was: did coursework use to count in the previous system, whereas he made the GCSE reliant only on the final examination? Has this made the results fairer and more reliable, to the extent that the test and the marking are the same across the country?

It's also not clear to me how the Welsh system differs. I remember many comments from Welsh politicians against teaching to the test and in favour of a more comprehensive approach, but I do not understand what it means in practice.

What was most striking for me was that the results were not driven by socio-economic factors, and that English students in deprived areas still did better than Welsh students in less deprived areas (based on the press - I haven't analysed the reports myself), so it's not a matter of London being richer and skewing the results.

Thoughts?

Students in green school uniforms sit at desks reading books during a classroom lesson. Pencil pots and study materials are visible on the tables, with a noticeboard and classroom displays in the background.

England up in reading, maths and science rankings as Scotland and Wales dip

The latest Pisa report also warned of a global decline in teenagers' reading skills.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvgy6n0l4rdo

OP posts:
ParentOfOne · 18/10/2026 14:52

@User454545454546565 Again, I view standardised tests as a necessary evil. Italy is a good example of what happens in the absence of fair standardised tests: their A-level equivalent is universally recognised as so useless and unreliable that universities ignore it and have come up with their own admission tests. Is that a better outcome? I think not

To me it's neither here nor there if a school achieves 60% of GCSEs between 5 and 9, and another 70%. But, if half the kids in a school fails to get a 4 in English and Maths, that's concerning.

In Italy there is no standardised testing and no way, other than word of mouth, to get any information on how one school is doing vs another. I am not convinced that's a better system.

Ofsted is a different matter. I view it as mostly useless. Holland Park School and Mossbourne were both outstanding. If schools with rampant emotional abuse can get an outstanding, the Ofsted rating isn't worth much more than toilet paper to me

OP posts:
User454545454546565 · 18/10/2026 15:10

If we want to standardise, how about 1 exam board rather than 4, or 5 whatever scam it is we currently have.

Own dc were largely educated in Italy and yes it has huge, huge shortcomings but I don't think the absence of GCSEs and regional variations in the maturità is one of them. There are regional cultural differences perhaps similar to the UK, Italy isn't really one single country and neither is the UK. So makes perfect sense to me for universities having their own admissions exam. I think that's an excellent and far better system. They'll decide what is and what isn't necessary for a student on their course. Instead of all this ridiculousness and pressure on 16 year olds stressed about "performing" in GCSEs. Poor kids.

ParentOfOne · 18/10/2026 15:22

@User454545454546565
If we want to standardise, how about 1 exam board rather than 4, or 5 whatever scam it is we currently have.

I don't disagree. When I asked a similar question on this forum, however, I was crucified because apparently this is not a priority and because I fail to appreciate all the complex historical reasons that led to a multitude of exam boards...

So makes perfect sense to me for universities having their own admissions exam. I think that's an excellent and far better system

Here I disagree. The Italian academics I met tell me that the change (ie universities no longer considering the Italian A-level equivalent - it wasn't like this 20 years ago) became necessary because their final exam has, over time, become meaningless and unrepresentative. A score of 85/100 in one school may actually be better than a 95/100 in another school.

England may have many problems but not this. An A star is an A star. No English university is left wondering: "mmm, is the A star in School 1 really comparable to an A star in School 2, or is School 1 a shit school which inflates it grades because the school does its own marking?"

How is that "excellent and far better?" I don't get it

OP posts:
User454545454546565 · 18/10/2026 15:38

I don't appreciate those complex historical reasons for having a silly number of exam boards either and it just leads to arguments about which board's GCSE is harder or somehow better. It's illogical to me, therefore I don't believe an A is always an A because you're comparing different things. And if there's no difference between them, then, again, let's just have the one.

If a university's setting its own standards, it doesn't matter if the high school grade was higher than someone else's. You all pass or fail the highest exam. Interviews are also important.

Excellent and better only in my opinion, obviously. Basically I don't have any faith in schools or the government, pay lip service to rankings and am just requiring my child to jump through hoops and tick boxes, till she gets to university and is old enough to really think for herself surrounded by literate young people and lecturers who have also learned to think for themselves and then they can discuss the merits of GCSEs and what they would do differently, and I can go and post on Travel threads.

FrippEnos · 18/10/2026 16:33

ParentOfOne
in England, the unions opposed Gove's reforms, most likely because he was a Tory more than because of the reform itself. He didn't get everything right, but his focus on making the curriculum more rigorous was a step in the right direction

Many teachers opposed gove's reforms because they excluded a large amount of the pupils.

As for being rigorous, other than being used as a buzzword, it was never fully defined.

Which would be a bonus given his lack of knowledge of averages and his history course that had to be rewritten by teachers so that it would work.

Papyrophile · 18/10/2026 17:33

I enjoyed the privilege of an independent school education from 1967-74, and yes, it was a privilege granted only to the very able high scoring 11+ pupils who lived in remote areas. We went to boarding school for free. I think we all went on to university too.

prh47bridge · 18/10/2026 18:11

@ParentOfOne - Several of your points show clearly that you are not approaching this with an open mind. I am certainly not going to discuss Mossbourne or any other specific school.

A brief explanation on curriculum - it is about giving schools and teachers discretion over choosing textbooks, determining course content and designing assessment policies. However, it does not operate in a vacuum. High performing systems combine local or school-level discretion with accountability mechanisms such as external exams. If you want more than that, I'm afraid you will have to take the time to read and understand the research as I have. I don't have time to give a more detailed explanation than this.

I will, however, say that, as per my previous posts, freedom over the curriculum is not a silver bullet on its own. It is one of a number of freedoms that are correlated with high performing school systems. Pointing at Wales and Italy to suggest that they somehow undermine the research is ridiculous - neither gives schools the full range of freedoms.

But you appear to believe you know far more than the researchers who have spent years conducting comparative studies of education systems to try and figure out what works.

ParentOfOne · 18/10/2026 18:18

@prh47bridge I am certainly not going to discuss Mossbourne

Of course you are not

But you appear to believe you know far more than the researchers who have spent years conducting comparative studies of education systems to try and figure out what works

Textbook strawman argument, whereby merely asking a couple of very banal and reasonable questions becomes, in your twisted interpretation, that I know far more than the researcher etc etc.

Your bad faith is shocking.
There is disagreeing, and there is twisting other people's words in bad faith.
I really wish this forum had a block function.

OP posts:
cityliving99 · 18/10/2026 19:51

User454545454546565 · 18/10/2026 15:10

If we want to standardise, how about 1 exam board rather than 4, or 5 whatever scam it is we currently have.

Own dc were largely educated in Italy and yes it has huge, huge shortcomings but I don't think the absence of GCSEs and regional variations in the maturità is one of them. There are regional cultural differences perhaps similar to the UK, Italy isn't really one single country and neither is the UK. So makes perfect sense to me for universities having their own admissions exam. I think that's an excellent and far better system. They'll decide what is and what isn't necessary for a student on their course. Instead of all this ridiculousness and pressure on 16 year olds stressed about "performing" in GCSEs. Poor kids.

I wanted to do well in my O levels. I wanted top grades. I wasn’t stressed. It’s OK for the majority of students to want to perform to their best ability. Some stress is good. And English students were tested on exactly the same things as Italian students and the rest of the world- and way outperformed the Italian students.

Araminta1004 · 18/10/2026 20:01

A lot of elite English unis /most competitive courses do now have their own admissions exams, UCAT, ESAT, LNAT, TARA etc etc - I have a year 13. Most of her friends are doing admissions tests of one sort.
And @noblegiraffe is right. A lot of this year group and the year below have mental health struggles. We know of 3 boys who have committed suicide in year 12 or 11 in just the last year and these weren’t kids where you thought they were massively struggling. In every case, it was a massive sudden shock.

ScrollingLeaves · 18/10/2026 21:28

Araminta1004 · 18/10/2026 20:01

A lot of elite English unis /most competitive courses do now have their own admissions exams, UCAT, ESAT, LNAT, TARA etc etc - I have a year 13. Most of her friends are doing admissions tests of one sort.
And @noblegiraffe is right. A lot of this year group and the year below have mental health struggles. We know of 3 boys who have committed suicide in year 12 or 11 in just the last year and these weren’t kids where you thought they were massively struggling. In every case, it was a massive sudden shock.

Gosh, how terrible about those poor boys. What were their circumstances that drove them to this, do you know?

User454545454546565 · 18/10/2026 23:16

Well, good for you cityliving99.

O levels were a very long time ago, pre-Gove. Things are extremely stressful for many 16yo now.

PISA might be good as far as it goes, if you're into league tables and want to feel better about the mess UK schools are in, but as I said upthread imo it's an incomplete assessment of both pupil ability and education system. Italy and any other European country you care to name would have wiped the floor with English kids in terms of MFL and oracy.

Also, depressingly, PISA shows that educational outcomes are "stagnating or declining" in many countries and it's showing that lack of reading is a problem. Countries (like Italy and Wales) with a firmer grasp of traditional book reading, standing in front of the class and speaking and way more foreign language content are going to have better language processing skills and be better and more interesting at communicating, generally. Who cares about PISA just get them off the bloody screens.

Genevieva · 19/10/2026 02:11

The foundations for PISA test scores come in primary school and that’s where Gove made a big difference. This was possible because he listened to people like Nick Gibb and Ruth Miskin on the value of synthetic Phonics and gave Gibb (schools minister) the go ahead to implement it across primary schools.

GCSE curricular changes varied between subjects but all involved more content. This has seen some schools starting the courses in Y9, which is a shame.

What worries me about the Labour education reform proposals is that they will make it difficult to measure progress. This means children have less idea of how well they are learning. Less able children will get less support. More able children won’t be able to demonstrate their attainment. Everyone will be worse off.

DeftGoldHedgehog · 19/10/2026 05:28

Tickingcrocodile · 14/10/2026 18:50

What's the point of doing well in the PISA tests if the results don't translate to a more successful and productive economy and society? I'm a teacher and parent of children who started school at the time of the curriculum reform and IMO the curriculum is a contributory factor to the poor mental health and behaviour of students. It would be better if we did less well in the PISA tests but students learned skills thay would help them succeed in the workplace and education would be properly accessible to all.

This. Schools and secondary education have become far worse, and are failing more children than ever, but have become better at ticking boxes.

Schools have led the way in forcing teenagers onto screens for homework. I saw a huge change of approach between DDs at two different schools, one starting in 2016 and one in 2020. I find the backlash against phones and screens now incredibly hypocritical.

DeftGoldHedgehog · 19/10/2026 05:32

Araminta1004 · 18/10/2026 20:01

A lot of elite English unis /most competitive courses do now have their own admissions exams, UCAT, ESAT, LNAT, TARA etc etc - I have a year 13. Most of her friends are doing admissions tests of one sort.
And @noblegiraffe is right. A lot of this year group and the year below have mental health struggles. We know of 3 boys who have committed suicide in year 12 or 11 in just the last year and these weren’t kids where you thought they were massively struggling. In every case, it was a massive sudden shock.

This is the year group who started secondary school in 2020.

DeftGoldHedgehog · 19/10/2026 05:48

Araminta1004 · 18/10/2026 11:54

I think depends on the aim. It caters relatively well to the top 60-70 per cent and unlocks the possibility of higher education for more children, arguably, including poorer bright children. In my opinion, it is grammar school for the majority (in simple terms).
However, caters badly without extra funding for additional needs and deprivation not accompanied by inherent cleverness. So bit divisive.
You can’t just raise standards across the board with high expectations and demands of staff and kids. It needs a lot more than that.
However, in a complex service economy arguably the top 70 per cent matters the most and you can still find workable solutions for the remaining cohort?

It's not just the bottom 30% academically who are failed but those who are bright but have SEN and were not remotely deprived. Secondary schools give them a phobia of school and cause anxiety and depression.

PassTheCranberrySauce · 19/10/2026 06:35

DeftGoldHedgehog · 19/10/2026 05:48

It's not just the bottom 30% academically who are failed but those who are bright but have SEN and were not remotely deprived. Secondary schools give them a phobia of school and cause anxiety and depression.

Edited

I am a SENDCo and this isn’t true. Our ND children do brilliantly, on the whole.

It is true that a small minority of children cannot cope with the hustle and bustle of a big, busy environment. Some ND children also have time blindness, cannot ‘read’ teachers so think they’re ‘cross’, have HPA axis-dysfunction so are constantly in fight/flight/freeze/fawn mode, and many other associated difficulties. It takes them longer to settle than other children, but many do and are successful.

Phineyj · 19/10/2026 07:11

noblegiraffe · 14/10/2026 22:11

Well, that is certainly one view of Gove. He is definitely an effective politician, unlike many others.
He also is behind a lot of current problems in the education system even if educational outcomes have remained fairly stable while those around us have fallen. The RAAC crisis in schools, for example wouldn't have been such a problem if he hadn't cancelled the schools rebuilding programme. The teacher recruitment crisis and painting teachers as the enemy of education rather than the experts in delivering it has been deeply damaging to the profession.

And his support for Brexit was really damaging to the country. He lies as easily as he breathes.

I find it very hard to forgive him and his colleagues for cancelling Building Schools for the Future in 2010. It wasn't just the capital budget - the budget for ongoing repairs was cut drastically. 90% I was told by a bursar at the time.

It is a special sort of cognitive dissonance banging on about higher academic standards while people rush to put buckets under the leaks in the roof! The physical condition of many state school buildings is shockingly poor. Not just the obvious issues like RAAC but the lack of access, heating, cooling, inadequate toilets, poor grounds...

Benvenuto · 19/10/2026 07:16

Genevieva · 19/10/2026 02:11

The foundations for PISA test scores come in primary school and that’s where Gove made a big difference. This was possible because he listened to people like Nick Gibb and Ruth Miskin on the value of synthetic Phonics and gave Gibb (schools minister) the go ahead to implement it across primary schools.

GCSE curricular changes varied between subjects but all involved more content. This has seen some schools starting the courses in Y9, which is a shame.

What worries me about the Labour education reform proposals is that they will make it difficult to measure progress. This means children have less idea of how well they are learning. Less able children will get less support. More able children won’t be able to demonstrate their attainment. Everyone will be worse off.

Phonics predates Gove though - the Rose report was in 2006 and the original Letters and Sounds was issued under the Blair/Brown Government. Not all schools were implementing it as they should (as shown by earlier MN threads). The Coalition Government did bring in the Phonics Check but this was a further development of a pre-existing policy.

Against this has to be set the dismantling by the Coalition Government of Sure Start & support for SEN & the subsequent reducing school funding.

Appuskidu · 19/10/2026 07:40

Phineyj · 19/10/2026 07:11

I find it very hard to forgive him and his colleagues for cancelling Building Schools for the Future in 2010. It wasn't just the capital budget - the budget for ongoing repairs was cut drastically. 90% I was told by a bursar at the time.

It is a special sort of cognitive dissonance banging on about higher academic standards while people rush to put buckets under the leaks in the roof! The physical condition of many state school buildings is shockingly poor. Not just the obvious issues like RAAC but the lack of access, heating, cooling, inadequate toilets, poor grounds...

Edited

I completely agree with this. My last school was so poorly funded that everything was falling down-the windows were so draughty that no matter how much the heating was on, in the winter, it was always freezing. We couldn’t afford to put the heating on anyway by the end, though…

The ceiling tiles were broken, the lights flickered, the drawer runners were knackered, the toilets leaky, the WiFi was crap, the list goes on.

Yet which phonics scheme we had to spend thousands of pounds on, was all anyone could talk about. That wasn’t the priority to my mind-I was so cold I was teaching in my coat and gloves.

Genevieva · 19/10/2026 07:51

Benvenuto · 19/10/2026 07:16

Phonics predates Gove though - the Rose report was in 2006 and the original Letters and Sounds was issued under the Blair/Brown Government. Not all schools were implementing it as they should (as shown by earlier MN threads). The Coalition Government did bring in the Phonics Check but this was a further development of a pre-existing policy.

Against this has to be set the dismantling by the Coalition Government of Sure Start & support for SEN & the subsequent reducing school funding.

The Rose Report was important. it did not result in the universal introduction of a systematic synthetic phonics programme until Gove gave the go ahead to Gibb. There’s a world of difference between Letters and Sounds (2007) and what we have had for the past 14 years thanks to Gibb. This has undoubtedly had a positive impact on literacy that is likely to have fed into PISA data. This thread is about PISA, so not policies that are unlikely to have impacted it. As it happens, an old friend of mine’s mother was part of the Oxford research group behind Sure Start. While it aimed to boost GCSE grades for disadvantaged children and OPEN collaborated with PISA, there’s no evidence that Sure Start positively impacted PISA results.

Dinnerontheterrace · 19/10/2026 08:12

PassTheCranberrySauce · 19/10/2026 06:35

I am a SENDCo and this isn’t true. Our ND children do brilliantly, on the whole.

It is true that a small minority of children cannot cope with the hustle and bustle of a big, busy environment. Some ND children also have time blindness, cannot ‘read’ teachers so think they’re ‘cross’, have HPA axis-dysfunction so are constantly in fight/flight/freeze/fawn mode, and many other associated difficulties. It takes them longer to settle than other children, but many do and are successful.

Thank you. I have a dyslexic DD whose issue was spotted in year 9. She has gone on to do very well. I adore her teachers.

Benvenuto · 19/10/2026 09:33

Genevieva · 19/10/2026 07:51

The Rose Report was important. it did not result in the universal introduction of a systematic synthetic phonics programme until Gove gave the go ahead to Gibb. There’s a world of difference between Letters and Sounds (2007) and what we have had for the past 14 years thanks to Gibb. This has undoubtedly had a positive impact on literacy that is likely to have fed into PISA data. This thread is about PISA, so not policies that are unlikely to have impacted it. As it happens, an old friend of mine’s mother was part of the Oxford research group behind Sure Start. While it aimed to boost GCSE grades for disadvantaged children and OPEN collaborated with PISA, there’s no evidence that Sure Start positively impacted PISA results.

The Rose Report completely changed the direction of reading teaching by working out that the reosearch evidence was in favour of phonics. Before that it was a highly contested area between phonics & other approaches. The whole point of the phonics check was to ensure that schools were teaching phonics correctly - Nick Gibb does deserve credit for this as some schools weren’t but he was building on the direction of travel set by the previous Labour Government. Personally, I understand why the tests were important (my DC’s school had issues with phonics) but I also think that Gibb & Gove failed to address what happens after the check - there’s a real variation in what is offered after check re catch-up programmes & support for dyslexia is highly variable.

As for Letters and Sounds - many of the children sitting the PiSA tests will have learned to read with L&S as it was a common way to teach reading when the PISA cohort were learning. The strength & weakness of L&S is that it relies on teachers to create their own lesson plans and they had to source their own reading schemes. There were problems with this due to the resistance in adopting phonics (eg in my DC’s case the L&S sessions were great but the school was sending home old ORT books).

In contrast, Read Write Inc type programmes are much more prescriptive as they prescribe both lesson plans & books so it avoids these problems. However- as said earlier on this thread - it also ties schools into expensive programmes which is an issue re school budgets. I find the insistence on only using the books that match the programme interesting, as I don’t see why they can’t be more flexible as all the schemes are teaching the same content in a roughly similar order.

As for Sure Start etc, it will have had an impact as the PISA generation will still have been able to access many more support services to help with school readiness and to ensure that SEN support was put in place early. That’s very different to now when schools are being impacted with children not toilet trained & lacking support for SEN and it’s something that could potentially affect results in future not least because it impacts teaching time. Interestingly, there was a report on York making progress with toilet training by the Sure Start methods of informing & engaging with parents.

DeftGoldHedgehog · 19/10/2026 10:20

PassTheCranberrySauce · 19/10/2026 06:35

I am a SENDCo and this isn’t true. Our ND children do brilliantly, on the whole.

It is true that a small minority of children cannot cope with the hustle and bustle of a big, busy environment. Some ND children also have time blindness, cannot ‘read’ teachers so think they’re ‘cross’, have HPA axis-dysfunction so are constantly in fight/flight/freeze/fawn mode, and many other associated difficulties. It takes them longer to settle than other children, but many do and are successful.

That's great that your kids do so well. Unfortunately from personal and good friends' experiences and also spending a fair bit of time on the Not Fine in School group it's not the case for many kids up and down the country and they do not reach their potential at secondary school in the current system.

Genevieva · 19/10/2026 10:48

Benvenuto · 19/10/2026 09:33

The Rose Report completely changed the direction of reading teaching by working out that the reosearch evidence was in favour of phonics. Before that it was a highly contested area between phonics & other approaches. The whole point of the phonics check was to ensure that schools were teaching phonics correctly - Nick Gibb does deserve credit for this as some schools weren’t but he was building on the direction of travel set by the previous Labour Government. Personally, I understand why the tests were important (my DC’s school had issues with phonics) but I also think that Gibb & Gove failed to address what happens after the check - there’s a real variation in what is offered after check re catch-up programmes & support for dyslexia is highly variable.

As for Letters and Sounds - many of the children sitting the PiSA tests will have learned to read with L&S as it was a common way to teach reading when the PISA cohort were learning. The strength & weakness of L&S is that it relies on teachers to create their own lesson plans and they had to source their own reading schemes. There were problems with this due to the resistance in adopting phonics (eg in my DC’s case the L&S sessions were great but the school was sending home old ORT books).

In contrast, Read Write Inc type programmes are much more prescriptive as they prescribe both lesson plans & books so it avoids these problems. However- as said earlier on this thread - it also ties schools into expensive programmes which is an issue re school budgets. I find the insistence on only using the books that match the programme interesting, as I don’t see why they can’t be more flexible as all the schemes are teaching the same content in a roughly similar order.

As for Sure Start etc, it will have had an impact as the PISA generation will still have been able to access many more support services to help with school readiness and to ensure that SEN support was put in place early. That’s very different to now when schools are being impacted with children not toilet trained & lacking support for SEN and it’s something that could potentially affect results in future not least because it impacts teaching time. Interestingly, there was a report on York making progress with toilet training by the Sure Start methods of informing & engaging with parents.

Again, you are making suppositions for which there is no data. No one is criticising your support for Sure Start, but despite efforts there is no evidence that it improved PISA outcomes. Ditto Letters and Sounds. Expensive as these reading programmes were (and that is a different thread that I almost certainly agree with you on) systematic synthetic phonics schemes measurably moved the dial in terms of pupil learning outcomes. They also reduced teacher planning workload. There are many many things I’m critical of Gove on, but on this, we have to recognise that he gave permission for real, positive change. Not a nod in the direction of the Rose Report that put the burden on teachers and made no difference to outcomes (L&S). There’s no evidence that any other minister from any party would have facilitated this. It was Gibb’s absolute belief and commitment that persuaded Gove and it was give that gave the go ahead. It’s a different funding pot from Sure Start and the fabric of school buildings, neither of which are relevant to PISA, but the funding for which would have been very welcome for me in my career.