Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

England's good PISA results: how much credit does Gove's GCSE reform truly deserve?

167 replies

ParentOfOne · 14/10/2026 18:25

England did reasonably well in the latest PISA results, much better than Scotland and Wales
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvgy6n0l4rdo

I'd be interested in comparing opinions on how much credit Gove's GCSE reform of 2013 deserves for this.

I don't like Gove (a Brexiter who famously said that all schools should be above average...) but I am open to admitting that I can disagree with someone on a topic but still agree on another.

It's not clear to me what the main difference between Gove's GCSE and the previous system was: did coursework use to count in the previous system, whereas he made the GCSE reliant only on the final examination? Has this made the results fairer and more reliable, to the extent that the test and the marking are the same across the country?

It's also not clear to me how the Welsh system differs. I remember many comments from Welsh politicians against teaching to the test and in favour of a more comprehensive approach, but I do not understand what it means in practice.

What was most striking for me was that the results were not driven by socio-economic factors, and that English students in deprived areas still did better than Welsh students in less deprived areas (based on the press - I haven't analysed the reports myself), so it's not a matter of London being richer and skewing the results.

Thoughts?

Students in green school uniforms sit at desks reading books during a classroom lesson. Pencil pots and study materials are visible on the tables, with a noticeboard and classroom displays in the background.

England up in reading, maths and science rankings as Scotland and Wales dip

The latest Pisa report also warned of a global decline in teenagers' reading skills.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvgy6n0l4rdo

OP posts:
User454545454546565 · 17/10/2026 15:21

@OwlbookendI'd love there to be appreciative posts about teachers. My daughter massively appreciated 80% of her teachers. She did not appreciate the awful conditions they are required to work in, the idiotic rules and fixation on grades nor the uncomfortable fact that it was simply too dangerous for her to keep attending. She's now being "taught to the test" at home to scrape into Sixth Form.

Who cares what PISA/league tables say, if hundreds (at least) of kids across the country are being educationally short-changed like this.

ScrollingLeaves · 17/10/2026 16:57

Owlbookend · 17/10/2026 15:03

& i think increasing use of screens (by us all not just kids) is likely strongly linked to decreased reading for pleasure.
As a child in the 80s we had 1 TV with limited child friendly offerings on limited channels at limited times. There just wasnt the same variety of alternative entertainment to reading.

I dont know how we change that. I am as guilty? as anyone at constantly engaging in screen based entertainment.

You might be interested in this:
Radical with Amol Rajan
https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m002tpw0
The Reading Recession: Are We Making Ourselves Less Intelligent? (James Marriott)

BBC Radio 4 - Radical with Gabriel Gatehouse, The Reading Recession: Are We Making Ourselves Less Intelligent? (James Marriott)

Tracing the historical relationship between reading, intelligence and democracy.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m002tpw0

Araminta1004 · 17/10/2026 17:32

@User454545454546565 - yes I think you are probably right that the big increase in kids not in school (is it as much as 4 per cent now?) and the severe absent ones (over 2 per cent) is really quite an urgent issue to sort out now. However, I don’t think I want to live somewhere where school is compulsory so not sure what the solution is. All my children have friends, and we have close family friends, with kids out of school or there less than 50 per cent of the time. It is difficult.

ParentOfOne · 17/10/2026 18:11

@User454545454546565 I'd love there to be appreciative posts about teachers.

You may have misunderstood my point. That was never the topic of the thread. I am interested in the education reform and in how much it contributed to good results. The best, brightest, most motivated teachers can be almost powerless in a dysfunctional education system.

Take the difference between England and Wales. I very much doubt those differences are driven by Welsh teachers being lazier or worse or less dedicated than their English colleagues - it's the system that's different.

Who cares what PISA/league tables say, if hundreds (at least) of kids across the country are being educationally short-changed like this.

Well, if I were a Welsh parent, I would certainly start wondering why on Earth Welsh schools have been doing so much worse than English ones, to the point that English schools in deprived areas do well than Welsh schools in non-deprived ones. Would you not?

Like I said, I see standardised tests as a necessary evil. Like any metric, they can be manipulated. They can lead to teaching to the test. They can lead to dishonest headteachers "incentivising" students to enrol elsewhere. Etc etc etc

But... what's the alternative? That's the bit that detractors of standardised tests never manage to clarify

OP posts:
ParentOfOne · 17/10/2026 18:18

@Owlbookend It is somewhat depressing that a thread about the UK doing relatively well in international educational comparisons seems to result in digs at teaching unions and very little appreciation of the role of teaching professionals in achieving this.

See above. I am interested in what makes a system successful or dysfunctional. The best teachers are powerless in a dysfunctional system.

Also, I didn't "have a dig" at unions.
Rather, I presented well-documented, factual examples:

  • in England, the unions opposed Gove's reforms, most likely because he was a Tory more than because of the reform itself. He didn't get everything right, but his focus on making the curriculum more rigorous was a step in the right direction
  • in California, advancement placement high school classes in maths and science have been cancelled because it was "racist" that not enough black and Latino students were taking them
  • in New York, some standardised tests for teachers have been scrapped, because it was "racist" that white teachers were passing at a much higher rate than black ones
  • in Italy, the fierce opposition to standardised and centralised tests of all the unions, who deem it as anathema that any statistic on school results could ever be published and compared, have led to an A-level equivalent which is utterly useless, because it is marked by each school, not by an independent board. The result is that universities ignore it and have come up with their own standardised admission tests.
OP posts:
Araminta1004 · 17/10/2026 18:21

Across 4DC mine have all had good or fantastic teachers and very clear communication from their schools. However, all have been outstanding schools bar DS2’s primary that went down slightly in Ofsted grading, but no decline in attainment. The rating declined as the school couldn’t cope with a number of high SEND needs. The grammar schools they go to is a similar picture now. No schools are really set up properly to deal with the increase in mental health and SEND needs. Why would they be? There was no significant actual funding and will from Government to actually provide the full support to address these issues. And I am talking here about a generally higher attainment/privileged demographic (by national standards) so in the schools that are deprived it must be much worse.

Owlbookend · 17/10/2026 19:31

The examples of unions in the US/mainland Europe are irrelevant in the UK context. UK uniions criticising aspects of goverment education policy is just part of a free society (& certainly predates Gove's tenure). You are suggesting that the Gove reforms are what have led to this pattern of PISA findings in the UK. The teaching unions would probably disagree. Supporting evidence based teaching, phonics etc. doesn't necessarily mean that Gove's wider reforms are appropriate. For example, the direction of a specific type of literature texts, the demphasising of 14-16 vocational options etc. are viewed by many as problematic. I think they are unlikely to be important in the PISA outcomes.
The Wales England contrast is interesting, but it is difficult to determine which aspects of the English context are beneficial to outcomes (you have to look at differences accross key stages). Educational policy research is difficult because of the multitude of variables at play Isolating the specifics of what is important is incredibly challenging. Policy, implementation and practice are all important.

ParentOfOne · 17/10/2026 19:51

@Owlbookend The examples of unions in the US/mainland Europe are irrelevant in the UK context.

I disagree. They are relevant as cautionary tales of what can happen when ideology takes hold.
Those who oppose standardised tests should beware of what has happened in those countries, explain what alternative they propose, and explain how they think we can avoid what happened there.

UK uniions criticising aspects of goverment education policy is just part of a free society (& certainly predates Gove's tenure)

Of course. No one has said they shouldn't be allowed to

You are suggesting that the Gove reforms are what have led to this pattern of PISA findings in the UK.

I started the thread because I wanted to compare opinions. So far yes, it seems to me that Gove's reform, while far from perfect, did contribute to the good PISA scores by making the curriculum more rigorous

Supporting evidence based teaching, phonics etc. doesn't necessarily mean that Gove's wider reforms are appropriate. For example, the direction of a specific type of literature texts, the demphasising of 14-16 vocational options etc. are viewed by many as problematic

And I said something very similar. I said that, for me, one of the greatest flaws of the system is that those who fail to get a 4 at GCSE in English and Maths are abandoned by the system, which forces them to retake them till they are 18.

I never said Gove's reform was perfect in its entirety. But it does seem to me that it contributed to the good PISA scores.

Wales went the opposite way and seems to have achieved the worst of both worlds: worse academic results, but, also, can we honestly say that Wales caters to its less academic teenagers better than England? I wouldn't be so sure

The Wales England contrast is interesting, but it is difficult to determine which aspects of the English context are beneficial to outcomes

yes. It's never one single factor. We can, however, say it's not about deprivation, because English schools in deprived areas do better than Welsh schools in non-deprived areas.
And we can also conclude that autonomy by itself, unlike what @prh47bridge said, doesn't mean much, since Welsh schools have had plenty of autonomy yet terrible results.

OP posts:
Owlbookend · 17/10/2026 20:49

Maybe I misinterpreted some of your views @ParentOfOne about UK unions. I do think the issues raised about the non-UK unions arent really relevant - but that is just something we disagree on. I'm sure we agree on some others. Anyhow, it is saturday evening so am going to leave educational policy debate now to fully focus on trash TV.

prh47bridge · 17/10/2026 22:07

ParentOfOne · 17/10/2026 19:51

@Owlbookend The examples of unions in the US/mainland Europe are irrelevant in the UK context.

I disagree. They are relevant as cautionary tales of what can happen when ideology takes hold.
Those who oppose standardised tests should beware of what has happened in those countries, explain what alternative they propose, and explain how they think we can avoid what happened there.

UK uniions criticising aspects of goverment education policy is just part of a free society (& certainly predates Gove's tenure)

Of course. No one has said they shouldn't be allowed to

You are suggesting that the Gove reforms are what have led to this pattern of PISA findings in the UK.

I started the thread because I wanted to compare opinions. So far yes, it seems to me that Gove's reform, while far from perfect, did contribute to the good PISA scores by making the curriculum more rigorous

Supporting evidence based teaching, phonics etc. doesn't necessarily mean that Gove's wider reforms are appropriate. For example, the direction of a specific type of literature texts, the demphasising of 14-16 vocational options etc. are viewed by many as problematic

And I said something very similar. I said that, for me, one of the greatest flaws of the system is that those who fail to get a 4 at GCSE in English and Maths are abandoned by the system, which forces them to retake them till they are 18.

I never said Gove's reform was perfect in its entirety. But it does seem to me that it contributed to the good PISA scores.

Wales went the opposite way and seems to have achieved the worst of both worlds: worse academic results, but, also, can we honestly say that Wales caters to its less academic teenagers better than England? I wouldn't be so sure

The Wales England contrast is interesting, but it is difficult to determine which aspects of the English context are beneficial to outcomes

yes. It's never one single factor. We can, however, say it's not about deprivation, because English schools in deprived areas do better than Welsh schools in non-deprived areas.
And we can also conclude that autonomy by itself, unlike what @prh47bridge said, doesn't mean much, since Welsh schools have had plenty of autonomy yet terrible results.

One example would not undermine all the research studies I've quoted (or the many I haven't quoted), any more than one heavy smoker living to 90 would undermine the idea that smoking causes lung cancer. In any event, whilst the Curriculum for Wales is less prescriptive than the national curriculum, Welsh schools have less freedom than academies in other important areas. They have less financial freedom, less flexibility over staff pay and very limited autonomy over term dates. These freedoms are all correlated with high performing education systems.

ParentOfOne · 17/10/2026 22:55

@prh47bridge Except it's not one school doing badly but a whole country (Wales). Also, like I said earlier, it remains unclear what autonomy means:

  • schools have the autonomy to choose a different exam board, but the differences are not huge. It's not like academies can choose to skip trigonometry or Shakespeare
  • multi-trust academies tend to be extremely prescriptive and to give their teachers little to no autonomy
  • flexibility over staff pay? Has anyone ever complained about academies paying more? The problem is that they are allowed to pay less!
  • term dates? really? Deciding whether to start half-term one week earlier is correlated with high performance? Now you're really clutching at straws...
OP posts:
prh47bridge · 17/10/2026 23:47

ParentOfOne · 17/10/2026 22:55

@prh47bridge Except it's not one school doing badly but a whole country (Wales). Also, like I said earlier, it remains unclear what autonomy means:

  • schools have the autonomy to choose a different exam board, but the differences are not huge. It's not like academies can choose to skip trigonometry or Shakespeare
  • multi-trust academies tend to be extremely prescriptive and to give their teachers little to no autonomy
  • flexibility over staff pay? Has anyone ever complained about academies paying more? The problem is that they are allowed to pay less!
  • term dates? really? Deciding whether to start half-term one week earlier is correlated with high performance? Now you're really clutching at straws...

You could try reading the research rather than accusing the researchers of being unclear about what autonomy means and and me of clutching at straws. The research is absolutely clear. Whether you like it or not and whether you believe it or not, these things are correlated with high performing school systems.

ParentOfOne · 18/10/2026 09:51

@prh47bridge I am not accusing the researchers of anything.
You linked some research.
I asked you a couple of very simple questions.
You chose not to answer them, but instead chose to attack me. Why?

Makes me wonder if you have read the research at all, to be honest, or if the research addresses my points at all.

OP posts:
Araminta1004 · 18/10/2026 11:16

Well Gove was there for a whole 4 years and did have an impact in his role of SOS for Education. And by all accounts, he did listen to evidence and experts. Apparently even in his 1 year stint in Justice, he did actually try and listen to experts.

And that is why it is all the more surprising that he was a Brexiteer which by definition is the anti thesis of expertism. And that is also why he is a divisive character.

Appuskidu · 18/10/2026 11:27

I also think that a lot of the reforms Gove introduced, made the curriculum dry, inflexible and irrelevant which has contributed to increasing numbers of children not wanting to go to school. I wonder what the stats on school refusal look like over the years?

prh47bridge · 18/10/2026 11:46

ParentOfOne · 18/10/2026 09:51

@prh47bridge I am not accusing the researchers of anything.
You linked some research.
I asked you a couple of very simple questions.
You chose not to answer them, but instead chose to attack me. Why?

Makes me wonder if you have read the research at all, to be honest, or if the research addresses my points at all.

I did not attack you. You suggested that one country disproved all the research, which it clearly does not. I pointed out that the research is clear about what autonomy means and that the idea that giving schools flexibility about term dates is correlated with high performing education systems comes from the research and is not clutching at straws. You asked about the research so I gave you links. I know exactly what the research says. If you want to attack it without bothering to read it, that is your prerogative but be prepared to be corrected.

noblegiraffe · 18/10/2026 11:46

Appuskidu · 18/10/2026 11:27

I also think that a lot of the reforms Gove introduced, made the curriculum dry, inflexible and irrelevant which has contributed to increasing numbers of children not wanting to go to school. I wonder what the stats on school refusal look like over the years?

Rocketed after Covid. Noticeably. What's interesting (to me) is that it's now hitting sixth form too, with multiple kids who can't attend form time or assemblies. Y13 were Y6/7 during Covid school closures and Y12 were Y5/6.

Araminta1004 · 18/10/2026 11:54

I think depends on the aim. It caters relatively well to the top 60-70 per cent and unlocks the possibility of higher education for more children, arguably, including poorer bright children. In my opinion, it is grammar school for the majority (in simple terms).
However, caters badly without extra funding for additional needs and deprivation not accompanied by inherent cleverness. So bit divisive.
You can’t just raise standards across the board with high expectations and demands of staff and kids. It needs a lot more than that.
However, in a complex service economy arguably the top 70 per cent matters the most and you can still find workable solutions for the remaining cohort?

ParentOfOne · 18/10/2026 11:58

@prh47bridge I do not have the time to read hundreds of pages of research at the moment. You seem to be familiar with it, so I asked you a few banal questions. Why have you dodged all of them???

  • what does autonomy mean? Of whom from whom/what?
  • what does autonomy mean, if a school can choose a different exam board, but not the content required by each board, and the differences from board to board are, practically, very limited?
  • what does autonomy mean, if multi academy trusts tend to be extremely prescriptive about how and what they want their teachers to teach? You mean autonomy of multi-academy trusts from central government, but not of each school from its trust?
  • autonomy has meant that academies like Mossbourne are de facto unaccountable, even after formal investigations confirmed widespread practices of emotional abuse. Is this the kind of autonomy conducive to better results?
  • Autonomy has been a disaster in Wales and Italy. Are Wales and Italy the only two exceptions which prove the rule?

A person truly familiar with the research would have no issues answering these very reasonable questions.
A person who has not read any of the research and just googled the names would not be able to answer the questions.

@Appuskidu Quite possibly. But... what is the alternative? The systems in Wales, France, Italy etc were supposed to be less dry, less prescriptive, more engaging, etc. I'm not sure they have worked that well - quite the opposite, in fact.

I'd love to find a system that manages to combine rigour and fairness (which means marking centralised and done externally, not by the schools) with engaging, non-dry lessons!

@Araminta1004 It caters relatively well to the top 60-70 per cent [...] However, caters badly without extra funding for additional needs and deprivation not accompanied by inherent cleverness. So bit divisive

We disagree on many things but we can agree on this, I think. I did say that one of the flaws of the system is that it de facto abandons the 20-25ish % of kids who fail their GCSE, forcing them into a loop of resits till they are 18, but without offering them many true alternatives

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 18/10/2026 11:59

I think one of the potentially interesting things Gove did was get rid of contextual value added in the school league tables. He called it something like damning with a culture of low expectations - basically disadvantaged kids didn't do as well as non-disadvantaged kids, so they weren't expected to do as well as them, and round the cycle goes. Did it raise achievement for disadvantaged kids? PISA certainly seems to suggest that our disadvantaged kids are doing better than in other countries. But when it comes to things like Ofsted, it was clear that schools were being graded on intake as much as anything else.

It now looks like we might be swinging back the other way with Ofsted taking more account of school context.

noblegiraffe · 18/10/2026 12:02

ParentOfOne · 18/10/2026 11:58

@prh47bridge I do not have the time to read hundreds of pages of research at the moment. You seem to be familiar with it, so I asked you a few banal questions. Why have you dodged all of them???

  • what does autonomy mean? Of whom from whom/what?
  • what does autonomy mean, if a school can choose a different exam board, but not the content required by each board, and the differences from board to board are, practically, very limited?
  • what does autonomy mean, if multi academy trusts tend to be extremely prescriptive about how and what they want their teachers to teach? You mean autonomy of multi-academy trusts from central government, but not of each school from its trust?
  • autonomy has meant that academies like Mossbourne are de facto unaccountable, even after formal investigations confirmed widespread practices of emotional abuse. Is this the kind of autonomy conducive to better results?
  • Autonomy has been a disaster in Wales and Italy. Are Wales and Italy the only two exceptions which prove the rule?

A person truly familiar with the research would have no issues answering these very reasonable questions.
A person who has not read any of the research and just googled the names would not be able to answer the questions.

@Appuskidu Quite possibly. But... what is the alternative? The systems in Wales, France, Italy etc were supposed to be less dry, less prescriptive, more engaging, etc. I'm not sure they have worked that well - quite the opposite, in fact.

I'd love to find a system that manages to combine rigour and fairness (which means marking centralised and done externally, not by the schools) with engaging, non-dry lessons!

@Araminta1004 It caters relatively well to the top 60-70 per cent [...] However, caters badly without extra funding for additional needs and deprivation not accompanied by inherent cleverness. So bit divisive

We disagree on many things but we can agree on this, I think. I did say that one of the flaws of the system is that it de facto abandons the 20-25ish % of kids who fail their GCSE, forcing them into a loop of resits till they are 18, but without offering them many true alternatives

The resit doom loop is real but the suggestion that those kids have no options isn't true. When I teach low Y11 sets I usually spend some time with them on the local college website looking at level 1/2 courses in things like construction, or hairdressing or animal care. Generally they find something to apply for.

Obviously some areas that seem to be saturated with academic sixth forms are less well-served at the lower end.

ParentOfOne · 18/10/2026 12:11

@noblegiraffe - basically disadvantaged kids didn't do as well as non-disadvantaged kids, so they weren't expected to do as well as them, and round the cycle goes

I actually agree with this big time. I remember having big hopes on Birbalsingh when she became famous, because she said this very same thing. Then she took it too far, ego took over, and her Micaela school seems to be all about rote learning and cultish behaviour (like saying what you are thankful for at lunch or standing up with your arms crossed, which is utter bs).

On how much Ofsted should take context into account, I honestly don't know. On one hand, it is unfair to penalise a school simply because it is in a deprived area. On the other hand, I have seen a couple of schools which are rated outstanding yet ca. half its kids fail their GCSEs and, well, call me classist, but I wouldn't want my child to go there.

Also, thanks for the feedback on local colleges. I have never looked into those options so I am not sure about the offering. It's reassuring to hear that alternatives do exist

OP posts:
Araminta1004 · 18/10/2026 12:43

Birbalsingh is right in many ways though, including gratitude and respect for the privilege of education and a free society.
A lot of kids are completely lost at sea in a huge pool of disinformation and information overload from all sides. So a bit of certainty and respect goes along way for some kids. Even if it offends an adult who does not like authoritarianism.

ParentOfOne · 18/10/2026 12:59

@Araminta1004 Yes, it's all about balance. Like I said in my uber-long threads on the Mossbourne academy, I am all for discipline, but the rules need to be fair, not batshit crazy.

Some of these schools (Mossbourne, Ashcroft, Micaela etc) take it waaay too far, and their fans love the present the false dichotomy of authoritarianism vs chaos, as if there were no alternative in between. There is.

You can have a culture of no excuses and punish bad behaviour, without giving detentions to those who cycle to school, without organising seminars on "healthy fear", without sending hundreds of former students into therapy, without regularly shouting at them and isolating them in desks in the corridor with the explicit intent of humiliating them, without forcing them to stand up with their arms crossed (a cultish, bs behaviour they will need to unlearn quickly), without imposing the kind of dull, soul-crushing rote-learning which is the very opposite of critical thinking ( eg see www.mumsnet.com/talk/secondary/4661381-michaela-school-experiences?flipped=1&page=1 ).

I'd be so adventurous as to think that the best way to counter some of the extremist bs of the last 10-15 years, from all camps, (like 'racist' books burnt in Canada, the culture of white guilt in general, Iranian feminists disinvited from unis because accused of Islamophobia, the Independent writing that Rushdie's book should be burnt because offensive, the right linking everything to immigration, nationalist thugs attacking Mosques in the summer riots, etc etc etc) would be to foster debate and critical thinking, which you don't achieve by forcing a class to repeat the definition of "monotonous" 5 times.

OP posts:
User454545454546565 · 18/10/2026 14:40

@ParentOfOneContext is everything, surely. That's why I asked downthread, who cares about these rankings? They aren't a reflection of ability. They're a reflection of a government body's ability to engineer a system to produce the output desired by the government. With the raw material being children and teachers and their mental health. It's not a level playing field for children or teachers.

As a parent of a middle-class child who was forced to go to one of the schools you mention, and was unable to complete her time there through absolutely no fault of her own, I say these results are not accurate. Gove's reforms were incomplete and he gets no credit for partially reforming a very damaged system.

Half the kids in that school shouldn't have been there (as commented by the school's own Safeguarding lead), and the other half could have performed far better if they and their teachers were in conditions to do so.

This is happening in schools across the country, the Ofsted propaganda banners at the school gates fool only the very stupid among us, so why do people put any reliance at all on PISA or Ofsted? It is genuinely baffling to me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread