@Owlbookend The examples of unions in the US/mainland Europe are irrelevant in the UK context.
I disagree. They are relevant as cautionary tales of what can happen when ideology takes hold.
Those who oppose standardised tests should beware of what has happened in those countries, explain what alternative they propose, and explain how they think we can avoid what happened there.
UK uniions criticising aspects of goverment education policy is just part of a free society (& certainly predates Gove's tenure)
Of course. No one has said they shouldn't be allowed to
You are suggesting that the Gove reforms are what have led to this pattern of PISA findings in the UK.
I started the thread because I wanted to compare opinions. So far yes, it seems to me that Gove's reform, while far from perfect, did contribute to the good PISA scores by making the curriculum more rigorous
Supporting evidence based teaching, phonics etc. doesn't necessarily mean that Gove's wider reforms are appropriate. For example, the direction of a specific type of literature texts, the demphasising of 14-16 vocational options etc. are viewed by many as problematic
And I said something very similar. I said that, for me, one of the greatest flaws of the system is that those who fail to get a 4 at GCSE in English and Maths are abandoned by the system, which forces them to retake them till they are 18.
I never said Gove's reform was perfect in its entirety. But it does seem to me that it contributed to the good PISA scores.
Wales went the opposite way and seems to have achieved the worst of both worlds: worse academic results, but, also, can we honestly say that Wales caters to its less academic teenagers better than England? I wouldn't be so sure
The Wales England contrast is interesting, but it is difficult to determine which aspects of the English context are beneficial to outcomes
yes. It's never one single factor. We can, however, say it's not about deprivation, because English schools in deprived areas do better than Welsh schools in non-deprived areas.
And we can also conclude that autonomy by itself, unlike what @prh47bridge said, doesn't mean much, since Welsh schools have had plenty of autonomy yet terrible results.